US Tariffs on Canadian Goods: Legal Bases and Exemptions
US tariffs on Canadian goods now rest on Section 232 national security measures and, since mid-2026, Section 338 discrimination duties of up to 50 per cent. The Supreme Court held in February 2026 that IEEPA does not authorize tariffs, opening refund claims. Exporters need product-level mapping, origin evidence and clear contracts.

Key takeaways
- The Supreme Court held on 20 February 2026 that IEEPA does not authorize tariffs.
- Section 232 measures cover steel, aluminum, autos and parts and other sectors.
- Section 338 proclamations in July 2026 imposed 50% duties on listed Canadian products.
- Finance Canada reported a US 50% tariff on CAD 27.6 billion of goods from 22 August 2026.
- Stacking rules and CUSMA treatment differ by measure and must be checked per product.
- IEEPA refunds belong to the US importer of record, so contracts decide who benefits.
US tariffs on Canadian goods: the legal landscape in 2026
US tariffs on Canadian goods in 2026 rest on a patchwork of US statutes, each with its own procedure, scope and exemptions. Since early 2025, the United States has used national security tariffs under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, emergency tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), and, from mid-2026, discrimination-based tariffs under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930. In February 2026, the US Supreme Court held that IEEPA does not authorize tariffs at all, which removed one legal basis and opened the door to refund claims, but did not end the tariff campaign against Canadian products.
For Canadian exporters, US importers of Canadian goods and investors, the legal basis matters. It determines which products are covered, whether goods that qualify under CUSMA are exempt, whether duties "stack" on top of each other, how long they last and whether they can be challenged or refunded.

This insight explains the main authorities, the Supreme Court's ruling in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, CUSMA-origin exemptions, stacking, refunds and planning steps. It is general information, not legal advice on US law; where US counsel is required, we coordinate with them.
Section 232: national security tariffs
Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 allows the President to adjust imports of articles that the Commerce Department finds are being imported in quantities or circumstances that threaten to impair US national security. It has been the most durable basis for US tariffs on Canadian goods because it rests on an express delegation of trade power and courts have been deferential to it. Since 2025, Section 232 measures have applied to steel and aluminum and their derivatives, automobiles and automotive parts, and other sectors such as softwood lumber and timber products and copper, with rates and product coverage changing through successive proclamations.
Section 232 measures typically include detailed product lists by HTSUS classification, rules for derivative products based on metal content, and, for autos, mechanisms that reduce duties based on US content. Exporters must therefore track not only the headline rate but also the classification and content rules that determine how much duty actually applies to a given shipment.
IEEPA tariffs and the Supreme Court ruling
In early 2025, the President declared national emergencies relating to drug trafficking and trade deficits and imposed tariffs under IEEPA. As the Supreme Court's syllabus records, the drug-trafficking tariffs imposed a 25 per cent duty on most Canadian and Mexican imports, and separate "reciprocal" tariffs applied to imports from many trading partners. Goods qualifying for CUSMA preference were exempted from the Canada-specific IEEPA tariffs for much of that period, which made CUSMA origin a decisive factor.
On 20 February 2026, in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump (together with Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, Inc.), the Supreme Court held that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. The Court affirmed the Federal Circuit's judgment in favour of the importers in V.O.S. Selections and vacated the district court judgment in Learning Resources for lack of jurisdiction, consistent with the Court of International Trade's role in tariff cases. The decision rests on the constitutional allocation of the taxing power to Congress and the absence of clear statutory authorization in IEEPA.
| US authority | Trigger | Status for Canadian goods (as of the sources reviewed) |
|---|---|---|
| Section 232, Trade Expansion Act of 1962 | Commerce finding of threat to national security | In use for steel, aluminum, autos and parts and other sectors; coverage changes by proclamation |
| IEEPA | National emergency declaration | Held not to authorize tariffs (Supreme Court, 20 February 2026) |
| Section 338, Tariff Act of 1930 | Finding that a country discriminates against US commerce | Used from 2026 against certain Canadian products at 50 per cent |
| Section 301, Trade Act of 1974 | Unfair trade practices investigation by USTR | Available tool; requires investigation and findings |
| Section 122, Trade Act of 1974 | Balance-of-payments problems | Available tool with limits on rate and duration |
Section 338: discrimination-based tariffs
Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 allows the President to impose additional duties on products of a country that discriminates against US commerce, up to a stated maximum. It had rarely been used before 2026.
In July 2026, the President signed several proclamations imposing additional duties on Canadian products under Section 338. The proclamation concerning alcoholic beverages, signed on 20 July 2026, imposed an additional 50 per cent ad valorem duty, described as the maximum the statute allows, on listed Canadian products, citing provincial and territorial removal of US alcohol from shelves since March 2025. It excluded goods subject to Section 232 duties and certain civil aircraft articles. Related proclamations addressed other Canadian measures, including in relation to dairy and motor vehicles.
According to Finance Canada's release of 25 August 2026, the United States imposed a 50 per cent tariff on CAD 27.6 billion of Canadian goods effective 22 August 2026, referring to Section 338 and Section 232 measures, and Canada responded with matching countermeasures effective 8 September 2026. See our insight on Canadian countermeasures and tariff remission.
For each product you export to the United States, record the HTSUS classification, the applicable US measures, whether CUSMA preference is claimed and supported, and any exclusions. Coverage under Section 232 and Section 338 is defined by product lists and exclusions that change frequently, so a quarterly review is the minimum.
CUSMA-origin exemptions
US tariff actions against Canada have repeatedly treated goods that qualify for CUSMA preferential treatment differently. The IEEPA tariffs on Canada exempted CUSMA-qualifying goods for much of 2025, prompting many exporters to start claiming CUSMA preference for products that previously entered duty-free under normal US rates. Section 232 measures have generally applied regardless of origin, although the automotive measures have adjusted duties based on US content. Whether CUSMA treatment affects a particular Section 338 measure depends on the text and annexes of the proclamation concerned.
For any business assessing US tariffs on Canadian goods, the lesson is that origin documentation has strategic value even when an exemption is not currently available. See our insight on CUSMA rules of origin.
Stacking rules
When several tariff measures could apply to the same goods, the proclamations and executive orders specify whether duties are cumulative. US measures have included non-stacking rules under which, for example, goods subject to Section 232 duties on autos or metals are not also subject to certain other additional duties. The Section 338 alcohol proclamation excluded goods subject to Section 232 duties, so the two do not stack on those articles. Ordinary most-favoured-nation duties, anti-dumping and countervailing duties continue to apply in addition. Importers must apply the correct HTSUS Chapter 99 provisions to reflect these rules, and errors are a common source of overpayment or penalty exposure.
Refunds after the IEEPA ruling
Because the Supreme Court held that IEEPA does not authorize tariffs, importers that paid IEEPA duties have sought refunds. In the US system, the importer of record, not the foreign exporter, pays duties and is the party entitled to seek refunds, through US Customs and Border Protection procedures such as post-summary corrections and protests, or through litigation before the Court of International Trade, depending on the liquidation status of the entries. The procedures and deadlines are technical and are governed by US law.
Canadian companies that acted as non-resident importers of record, or US subsidiaries of Canadian groups, may have direct refund rights. Canadian exporters that sold on delivered-duty-paid terms or agreed price adjustments to absorb tariffs should review their contracts to determine whether refunds received by US customers must be shared. These questions are increasingly arising in commercial disputes.
Sector snapshots
The effect of US tariffs on Canadian goods varies sharply by sector:
- Steel and aluminum. Section 232 duties apply to primary metals and a long list of derivative products, with duty calculated on metal content for many derivatives. Canadian producers face both US duties and Canadian safeguard and surtax measures on imports.
- Autos and parts. Section 232 auto measures interact with CUSMA rules of origin and US-content adjustments, which makes content tracing essential for parts suppliers.
- Forest products. Softwood lumber faces long-standing anti-dumping and countervailing duties in addition to national security measures, so total duty rates can be high.
- Food, beverages and consumer goods. Section 338 measures in 2026 targeted specific consumer categories, including alcoholic beverages and dairy-related products.
Compliance and penalty risk for US importers
Higher duties increase the incentive, and the scrutiny, around classification, valuation and origin. US Customs and Border Protection can impose penalties for negligent or fraudulent misstatements, and the US Department of Justice has used the False Claims Act against customs fraud. Canadian exporters whose invoices and origin certifications are relied on by US importers should expect indemnity requests and audits from customers. Accurate commercial invoices, consistent product descriptions and well-supported origin documentation reduce the risk that US tariffs on Canadian goods become a source of penalty exposure as well as cost.
Challenging US tariffs
Legal challenges to US tariffs proceed mainly in the US Court of International Trade, with appeals to the Federal Circuit. Challenges to Section 232 measures have historically faced deferential review, while the IEEPA litigation shows that tariffs lacking clear statutory authority can be struck down. At the international level, Canada can pursue state-to-state dispute settlement under CUSMA Chapter 31 or at the WTO, although these processes are slow and depend on compliance. Canadian investors have no investor-state remedy against the United States under CUSMA; see our insight on investor-state arbitration.
Planning for US tariffs on Canadian goods
- Map each export product to the US measures that apply, confirm its HTSUS classification and record the date of each change in coverage.
- Support CUSMA origin claims with full documentation, even where no exemption currently applies.
- Review Incoterms and pricing clauses to allocate tariff costs and refunds clearly; see tariff risk in purchase agreements.
- Consider whether to act as non-resident importer of record, weighing control of refunds against compliance obligations.
- Assess supply chain and market diversification, including Canada's other trade agreements and the time needed to qualify new customers and suppliers.
- Monitor the CUSMA joint review and negotiations on sectoral tariffs.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise Canadian exporters, US importers of Canadian products and investors on the legal bases of current US tariff measures and their business consequences. Our work includes mapping products to Section 232, Section 338 and other measures, supporting CUSMA origin claims, reviewing contracts for tariff and refund allocation, and assessing refund opportunities after the IEEPA ruling with US customs counsel and licensed customs brokers. We also help clients plan for Canadian countermeasures and remission. See our tariffs, CUSMA and customs page or our United States desk page, or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What did the US Supreme Court decide about IEEPA tariffs?
In Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, decided 20 February 2026 with Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, the Court held that IEEPA does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. The ruling affected the 2025 drug-trafficking and reciprocal tariffs but not tariffs imposed under other statutes such as Section 232.
What is Section 338?
Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 allows additional duties on products of a country found to discriminate against US commerce. In July 2026, the President used it to impose 50 per cent duties on certain Canadian products, citing measures such as provincial removal of US alcohol from store shelves.
Are CUSMA-qualifying goods exempt from US tariffs?
It depends on the measure. CUSMA-qualifying goods were exempt from the Canada-specific IEEPA tariffs for much of 2025, but Section 232 measures generally apply regardless of origin, with US-content adjustments for autos. Each Section 338 proclamation must be read for its own scope and exclusions.
Can Canadian exporters get IEEPA tariff refunds?
Refunds are claimed by the US importer of record through US procedures. A Canadian company that was the non-resident importer of record may claim directly. Otherwise, whether an exporter benefits depends on its contracts with US customers, such as price adjustment or tariff-sharing clauses.
Do US tariffs stack on top of each other?
Not always. Proclamations include rules on overlap; for example, the Section 338 alcohol proclamation excluded goods subject to Section 232 duties. Normal duties and trade remedy duties still apply. Correct HTSUS Chapter 99 reporting is essential.
Sources
- Supreme Court of the United States: Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, No. 24-1287 (20 February 2026)
- The White House: Imposing additional duties to offset Canadian discrimination against the commerce of the United States (July 2026)
- Finance Canada: Canada announces targeted countermeasures (25 August 2026)
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


