Skip to content

Guide · Technology, Privacy and AI

CASL, Advertising and Consumer Protection in Canada

CASL and consumer protection rules shape how businesses market and sell to Canadians. This guide explains CASL consent, identification and unsubscribe requirements and penalties, Competition Act advertising and drip pricing rules, provincial consumer contract law including the status of Ontario's 2023 Act, and Quebec's price display and advertising-to-children rules.

10 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • CASL requires consent, sender identification and an unsubscribe mechanism in every commercial electronic message.
  • Implied consent from a purchase lasts two years; from an inquiry, six months.
  • CASL penalties reach CAD 10 million per violation for organizations, and directors can be liable.
  • Quebec requires advertised prices to include the total amount payable, apart from sales taxes.
  • Ontario's Consumer Protection Act, 2023 is enacted but not yet in force; the 2002 Act still applies.

CASL and consumer protection: the essentials

CASL and consumer protection rules govern how businesses market to Canadians and the terms on which they sell to them. Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) is a federal statute that regulates commercial electronic messages, the installation of computer programs and the alteration of transmission data. Advertising is governed nationally by the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act, enforced by the Competition Bureau. Consumer contracts are regulated provincially, through statutes such as Ontario's Consumer Protection Act, 2002 and Quebec's Consumer Protection Act, which is among the most demanding consumer statutes in North America.

Marketing email on a smartphone illustrating CASL and consumer protection compliance in Canada
Email consent records, price displays and online contract terms are central to CASL and consumer protection compliance.

For businesses selling into Canada, these regimes overlap constantly. A promotional email must comply with CASL; the offer it advertises must not be misleading under the Competition Act; the price shown must meet drip pricing rules and, in Quebec, include the total amount payable; and the online contract that follows must meet provincial disclosure and cancellation rules. This page explains each regime, the penalties and the practical steps for a compliant marketing and sales process.

How CASL works

Under s. 6 of CASL, it is prohibited to send, or cause or permit to be sent, a commercial electronic message (CEM) to an electronic address unless the recipient has consented, expressly or impliedly, and the message contains prescribed identification information and an unsubscribe mechanism. A CEM is broadly any electronic message, such as email, text or direct social media message, one of whose purposes is to encourage participation in a commercial activity.

Consent

Express consent must be sought with prescribed information, including the purpose of the request and the identity of the person seeking consent, and cannot be bundled into general terms and conditions. Implied consent is available only in the circumstances listed in s. 10, including where there is an existing business relationship based on:

  • a purchase or lease of a product, goods, service or interest in land within the two-year period immediately before the message is sent; or
  • an inquiry or application made by the recipient within the six-month period immediately before the message is sent.

Other implied consent categories cover existing non-business relationships with registered charities and similar organizations, conspicuously published addresses where the message relates to the recipient's business role, and business cards and similar disclosures. Because implied consent expires, businesses need systems that track when each relationship started and whether express consent has since been obtained. Our insight on express and implied consent under CASL explains the categories.

Unsubscribe and identification

Every CEM must identify the sender, and the person on whose behalf it is sent, with contact information, and include an unsubscribe mechanism that is readily performed. Unsubscribe requests must be given effect without delay and in any event no later than 10 business days after they are sent (s. 11(3)).

Software and transmission data

CASL also prohibits installing a computer program on another person's computer system in the course of commercial activity without express consent (s. 8), subject to exceptions and deemed consent for certain programs such as cookies, and prohibits altering transmission data in an electronic message so that it is delivered to another destination without consent (s. 7).

CASL penalties and enforcement

The CRTC enforces CASL's messaging, software and transmission data provisions, while the Competition Bureau and the Privacy Commissioner enforce related amendments to their own statutes. Administrative monetary penalties can reach CAD 1 million per violation for an individual and CAD 10 million per violation for any other person (s. 20(4)). Officers, directors, agents and mandataries of a corporation that commits a violation are liable if they directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in it (s. 31), and an employer is vicariously liable for violations by its employees acting within the scope of their employment.

The private right of action originally included in CASL (ss. 47–51) never came into force and the provisions have been repealed. Enforcement therefore depends on the CRTC and the other regulators, but the absence of private claims under CASL does not prevent consumers from suing under other laws, such as provincial consumer protection or privacy statutes. Businesses that rely on a due diligence defence must be able to show the steps taken to comply, which makes consent records and documented processes essential.

RegimeWhat it coversMaximum exposure
CASLCommercial electronic messages, software installation, transmission dataAMPs up to CAD 1M (individuals) and CAD 10M (others) per violation
Competition Act, deceptive marketingFalse or misleading representations, drip pricing, performance claimsFor corporations, the greater of CAD 10M (CAD 15M subsequent) and 3x the benefit or 3% of worldwide revenues
Quebec Consumer Protection ActConsumer contracts, advertising, price display, advertising to childrenCivil remedies including punitive damages; penal offences
Ontario Consumer Protection Act, 2002Consumer agreements, internet and remote agreements, unfair practicesCivil remedies, cancellation rights and offences
Practical point

Keep proof of consent for every address you email. Under CASL the person sending a message bears the onus of proving consent, so records of when, how and for what purpose consent was obtained, and of the start date of each existing business relationship, are the core of any defence. Audit purchased or partner lists especially carefully.

Advertising and the Competition Act

The Competition Act prohibits materially false or misleading representations to the public, through both a criminal offence for knowing or reckless conduct and civil reviewable practices enforced by the Competition Bureau before the Competition Tribunal or the courts. Specific rules address performance claims, which must be based on adequate and proper testing, ordinary selling price claims, and environmental claims. Drip pricing is expressly covered: representing a price that is not attainable because of additional fixed obligatory charges or fees, other than government-imposed charges such as taxes, is deemed false or misleading (s. 74.01(1.1)).

For corporations, administrative monetary penalties for deceptive marketing can reach the greater of CAD 10 million (CAD 15 million for subsequent orders) and three times the benefit derived or, if that cannot be determined, 3% of annual worldwide gross revenues. Private parties may also seek leave from the Competition Tribunal to bring certain deceptive marketing applications. Our deceptive marketing and greenwashing page and insight on drip pricing compliance explain these rules.

Provincial consumer protection acts

Each province regulates consumer contracts. Common features include mandatory disclosure before an internet or remote agreement is concluded, delivery of a copy of the agreement, cooling-off and cancellation rights for certain contract types, rules on unilateral amendment, renewal and termination of ongoing contracts, prohibitions on unfair practices and remedies such as rescission and damages.

In Ontario, the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 remains the governing statute. The Legislature enacted the Consumer Protection Act, 2023 to replace it, with updated rules on contract changes, subscriptions and unfair practices, but according to the e-Laws consolidation the 2023 Act is not yet in force and will come into force on a day to be named by proclamation. Businesses should comply with the 2002 Act while preparing for the new one, for example by reviewing how their contracts handle amendments, renewals and cancellation, which are among the areas the new Act addresses. Our insights on provincial consumer protection reform and subscription contracts and auto-renewals track these changes.

Quebec consumer law and advertising to children

Quebec's Consumer Protection Act deserves particular attention because of its scope, its civil remedies, including punitive damages, and the frequency of consumer class actions in Quebec. Key rules include:

  • Price display: no merchant may charge a higher price than advertised, and the advertised price must include the total amount the consumer must pay for the goods or services, apart from Quebec sales tax and GST; more emphasis must be placed on the advertised price than on the amounts of which it is composed (s. 224).
  • Unilateral amendments: a stipulation allowing a merchant to amend a contract unilaterally is prohibited unless it also meets statutory conditions, including notice requirements and, for certain contracts, the consumer's right to refuse or cancel (s. 11.2).
  • Advertising to children: subject to the regulations, no person may make use of commercial advertising directed at persons under 13 years of age (s. 248). Whether an advertisement is directed at children depends on its context, including the nature and intended purpose of the goods, the manner of presentation and the time and place it is shown (s. 249).
  • Warranties and remedies: consumers have legal warranty rights, including recourse against manufacturers for latent defects (s. 53), and broad remedies when a merchant fails to fulfil statutory obligations (s. 272).

Quebec's Charter of the French Language adds requirements for French-language contracts, product information, websites and marketing directed at Quebec consumers. Our insight on French contracts of adhesion under Bill 96 explains those rules.

CASL and consumer protection for e-commerce and platforms

E-commerce businesses and digital platforms face CASL and consumer protection issues at every stage of the customer journey. Account sign-up flows must separate express CASL consent from acceptance of terms of service; transactional messages, such as receipts and delivery notices, are partly exempt from consent requirements but must not be loaded with promotional content that turns them into CEMs; and referral or "tell a friend" programmes must fit the narrow referral exemption or obtain consent.

Online sales also trigger provincial rules on distance contracts. Consumers generally must receive specified information before they are bound, be able to correct errors, receive a copy of the contract and, in some circumstances, cancel if disclosure obligations were not met. Subscription models need particular care: free trials converting to paid plans, automatic renewals, price increases and cancellation processes are all areas where consumer protection regulators and class action counsel focus. Marketplaces should also consider whether they are responsible for representations made by third-party sellers on their platforms and how fees are displayed to consumers.

Influencer and affiliate marketing is another pressure point. Endorsements must disclose material connections between the influencer and the brand, and performance or testimonial claims must be truthful and substantiated. Our insight on influencer marketing and online reviews explains the Competition Bureau's expectations.

Cross-border marketing and transactions

CASL applies to messages sent to or accessed from computer systems in Canada, so foreign businesses that email Canadian customers are covered even if they have no Canadian presence. Their consent practices, often designed for opt-out regimes elsewhere, may not meet Canada's opt-in model. Foreign merchants selling to Canadian consumers are also generally subject to the consumer protection law of the consumer's province, and Quebec consumers cannot be deprived of the protection of Quebec law by a choice-of-law clause in a consumer contract.

In acquisitions of consumer-facing businesses, CASL and consumer protection diligence should review consent records and their quality, complaint volumes, regulator correspondence, pricing practices, subscription terms, any class actions threatened or filed and the target's marketing vendor arrangements. A marketing database without reliable consent records may have limited value after closing if it cannot lawfully be used. Buyers should also confirm whether consents obtained by the target can be relied on by the buyer's group, since CASL consent is given to a particular person and may not extend automatically to affiliates or successors.

Building a compliant marketing and sales process

CASL and consumer protection obligations are easiest to meet when they are built into marketing and e-commerce systems rather than checked after the fact. A practical programme includes:

  1. Consent management: capture express consent with compliant wording, record the source and date of every consent and implied-consent relationship, and expire implied consent automatically.
  2. Message templates: include identification and a working unsubscribe mechanism in every CEM, and process unsubscribes within 10 business days.
  3. Price display: show all-in prices with mandatory fees included, and apply Quebec's total-price rule for Quebec consumers.
  4. Claims substantiation: test performance claims and substantiate environmental and comparative claims before publication.
  5. Contract design: provide pre-contract disclosure, copies and cancellation rights required by provincial law, and review renewal and amendment clauses.
  6. Children and sensitive audiences: screen campaigns for Quebec's under-13 rule and for privacy obligations relating to minors.
  7. Vendors and affiliates: require marketing partners, influencers and lead generators to comply, and audit them regularly against the same standards.
  8. Training and audit: train marketing teams and audit campaigns periodically.

Illustration: a hypothetical US subscription box company launches in Canada. Its welcome emails need CASL-compliant consent and unsubscribe mechanics; its website must display all-in prices without drip fees; its Quebec subscribers must see total prices and receive French-language terms; its auto-renewal and price-change clauses must meet provincial rules on ongoing contracts; and any advertising featuring toys must be checked against Quebec's prohibition on advertising directed at children under 13.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise businesses on CASL and consumer protection in Canada: consent and unsubscribe processes, CASL compliance audits and CRTC investigations, advertising and pricing reviews under the Competition Act, drip pricing and environmental claims, consumer contract terms and subscription models under Ontario, Quebec and other provincial laws, Quebec advertising to children and French-language requirements, and responses to regulator inquiries and consumer claims. Where proceedings require Canadian-licensed counsel, we work with them closely. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a campaign or contract, please contact us.

Frequently asked questions

How long does implied consent last under CASL?

Implied consent based on an existing business relationship lasts for two years after a purchase or lease, and six months after an inquiry or application, measured from the day before the message is sent. Other categories, such as conspicuously published business addresses, have their own conditions. Businesses should seek express consent before implied consent expires.

How quickly must unsubscribe requests be honoured?

Under s. 11(3) of CASL, the sender and the person on whose behalf a message was sent must give effect to an unsubscribe request without delay and in any event no later than 10 business days after it was sent. The unsubscribe mechanism must be readily performed, and the contact information in the message must remain valid for at least 60 days after it is sent.

Can consumers sue under CASL?

No. CASL originally included a private right of action in ss. 47 to 51, but those provisions never came into force and have been repealed. Enforcement rests with the CRTC and other regulators. Consumers may still bring claims under provincial consumer protection, privacy or other laws.

Is drip pricing illegal in Canada?

Yes. Under s. 74.01(1.1) of the Competition Act, representing a price that is not attainable because of additional fixed obligatory charges or fees is deemed false or misleading, unless the extra amounts are government-imposed charges such as taxes. Quebec's Consumer Protection Act separately requires advertised prices to include the total amount payable.

Can businesses advertise to children in Quebec?

Subject to the regulations, s. 248 of Quebec's Consumer Protection Act prohibits commercial advertising directed at persons under 13. Whether advertising is directed at children depends on context, including the nature and purpose of the goods, how the advertisement is presented and when and where it is shown.

Sources

  1. Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (S.C. 2010, c. 23)
  2. Competition Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. C-34)
  3. Consumer Protection Act, CQLR c. P-40.1 (Quebec)
  4. Consumer Protection Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 30, Sched. A (Ontario)
  5. Consumer Protection Act, 2023, S.O. 2023, c. 23, Sched. 1 (Ontario)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.