Skip to content

Overview

Commercial Disputes in Canada: Litigation and Arbitration

Business disputes in Canada are resolved in a court system that combines federal and provincial courts, specialized commercial lists, an active class action bar and arbitration-friendly statutes. This guide explains how commercial litigation, class actions, international arbitration, securities claims, appeals, product liability and construction disputes work, and what the Supreme Court of Canada has recently changed.

11 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • Most commercial disputes in Canada are heard by provincial superior courts; the Federal Court handles federal matters such as IP and admiralty.
  • In Ontario, the basic limitation period is two years from discovery, with an ultimate limit of 15 years.
  • Ontario class actions must show common issues predominate and the class action is superior (Class Proceedings Act, s. 5(1.1)).
  • International commercial arbitration in every province follows the UNCITRAL Model Law and the New York Convention.
  • Since 2026 SCC 29, courts must presume that destroyed or hidden evidence was unfavourable to the party responsible.

How business disputes in Canada are resolved

Business disputes in Canada are resolved mainly in the provincial superior courts, which have general jurisdiction over contract, tort, corporate, insolvency and most commercial claims. Each province also has a court of appeal, and the Supreme Court of Canada hears appeals from all of them, with leave, on matters of public importance. The Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal have jurisdiction over specified federal matters, including intellectual property, admiralty, judicial review of federal decision-makers and claims against the federal Crown. Tribunals decide many regulatory disputes, from competition and securities matters to labour and human rights.

Courtroom and case documents prepared for business disputes in Canada before a superior court
Choosing the right forum, court or arbitration, is often the first strategic decision in a Canadian dispute.

Canada has two legal traditions. Nine provinces and the territories use the common law, with procedure set by each province's rules of court. Quebec uses the civil law for private matters, under the Civil Code of Québec and the Code of Civil Procedure, and its courts operate in French and English. Disputes in Canada that cross provincial or national borders must therefore address which court has jurisdiction, which law applies and how a judgment will be enforced elsewhere.

Litigation is document-heavy and slower than many clients expect, but it is also predictable: courts follow precedent, judges are appointed rather than elected, juries are rare in commercial cases and costs generally follow the event, so the losing party usually pays part of the winner's legal costs. That costs rule shapes settlement behaviour in a way that differs from the United States.

Mediation, arbitration and other alternatives

Not all disputes in Canada end up in court. Commercial contracts often require negotiation and mediation before proceedings, and some provinces make mediation mandatory in certain civil actions. Arbitration is common in construction, energy, technology and cross-border supply contracts, and in shareholder agreements of private companies, because it offers confidentiality, choice of decision-maker and easier international enforcement. Expert determination is used for accounting, valuation and purchase price disputes. Choosing among these mechanisms when the contract is drafted, rather than when the dispute arises, is one of the most valuable decisions a business can make.

Type of disputeUsual forumOur practice page
Contract, shareholder and commercial claimsProvincial superior courts; commercial listsCommercial litigation
Consumer, competition, privacy and securities class claimsSuperior courts under provincial class statutes; Federal Court for some federal claimsClass actions
Cross-border commercial and investment disputesArbitral tribunals seated in Canada or abroad; courts for set-aside and enforcementInternational arbitration
Misrepresentation claims by investors; regulatory enforcementSuperior courts; securities commissions and tribunalsSecurities litigation
Appeals, judicial review and constitutional challengesCourts of appeal; Divisional Court; Federal Court; SCCAppellate and public law
Defective products, recalls and mass tortsSuperior courts, often as class actionsProduct liability
Construction claims, liens and adjudicationStatutory adjudication; superior courts; arbitrationConstruction and infrastructure disputes

Commercial litigation and limitation periods

Our commercial litigation page covers contract and shareholder disputes, injunctions, summary judgment and enforcement. In Toronto, complex commercial matters, including insolvency proceedings, corporate oppression claims and many shareholder disputes, can be heard on the Commercial List of the Superior Court of Justice, which offers judicial case management by judges experienced in commercial law. Other provinces have comparable commercial practice arrangements.

Limitation periods are short and strictly enforced. Under Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002, a claim must generally be started within two years of the day it was discovered (s. 4), and in any event within 15 years of the act or omission on which it is based (s. 15). Other provinces use similar but not identical regimes, and Quebec's Civil Code generally provides a three-year prescription period for personal rights. Contractual limitation clauses are permitted in some circumstances. Diarizing limitation dates from the first sign of a claim is the most basic risk control in Canadian litigation.

Injunctions and the oppression remedy

Canadian courts can grant urgent interim relief. To obtain an interlocutory injunction, an applicant generally must show a serious issue to be tried, irreparable harm if relief is refused and that the balance of convenience favours relief, with a stronger case required for mandatory orders. Freezing orders (Mareva injunctions) and civil search orders (Anton Piller orders) are available in cases of fraud and risk of dissipation or destruction of evidence, on strict conditions.

Shareholder disputes often rely on the statutory oppression remedy, such as s. 241 of the Canada Business Corporations Act, which lets courts remedy conduct that is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial to or unfairly disregards the interests of security holders, creditors, directors or officers. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the Supreme Court explained that the remedy protects the reasonable expectations of stakeholders.

Costs, funding and enforcement

The cost of disputes in Canada depends heavily on how they are funded. Contingency fee arrangements are permitted in the common-law provinces, subject to provincial rules, and third-party litigation funding is increasingly used, particularly in class actions, where courts review funding agreements to protect class members. Defendants can seek security for costs from plaintiffs resident outside the province in some circumstances. Once a judgment is obtained, enforcement tools include garnishment, seizure and sale, examinations in aid of execution and, where assets are in another province or abroad, registration or recognition proceedings in that jurisdiction. Thinking about enforcement at the outset, including where the defendant's assets are, often changes the litigation plan.

Courts have also tightened evidentiary obligations. In SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, decided on 31 July 2026, the Supreme Court held that once spoliation is established, meaning a party intentionally destroyed, changed, hid or failed to keep relevant evidence to influence the outcome of litigation, courts must presume that the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to that party, and have discretion to choose the remedy. Litigation holds issued promptly when a dispute is anticipated are now more important than ever.

Class actions and securities claims

Every province has class proceedings legislation, and Canada has an active class action practice covering consumer protection, competition, privacy and data breach, securities, product liability and employment claims.

Our class actions page explains certification and defence strategy. Ontario's Class Proceedings Act, 1992 was amended in 2020 so that a class proceeding must be superior to all reasonably available means of determining class members' entitlement and common issues must predominate over individual issues (s. 5(1.1)), and so that actions are dismissed for delay if key steps are not taken by the first anniversary of commencement (s. 29.1). In Quebec, authorization under art. 575 of the Code of Civil Procedure remains a comparatively low threshold.

The Supreme Court's decisions continue to shape the field. In Pioneer Corp. v. Godfrey, 2019 SCC 42, it allowed indirect and "umbrella" purchasers to pursue price-fixing claims under s. 36 of the Competition Act. In Sanis Health Inc. v. British Columbia, 2024 SCC 40, it upheld a British Columbia statute allowing the province to bring an opioid class action on behalf of other Canadian governments.

Securities misrepresentation claims under the secondary market liability provisions of provincial securities acts require leave of the court before they proceed. In Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39, the Supreme Court gave a broad reading to "material change" and allowed an investor's claim for failure to make timely disclosure to proceed. Our securities litigation page covers these claims and regulatory enforcement.

Defending a class action is a long exercise. Certification is the main battleground, and defendants often challenge the class definition, the commonality of issues and whether a class action is the preferable or superior procedure. Settlements require court approval, and class counsel fees are reviewed by the court. National classes and overlapping actions in several provinces raise coordination issues that should be addressed early.

International arbitration in Canada

Canada is a reliable seat for arbitration. Every province has adopted the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration for international disputes, and Canada applies the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. Ontario's International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 gives the Model Law and the Convention force of law in Ontario and sets a limitation period for enforcement of the later of 31 December 2018 and ten years after the award or the conclusion of set-aside proceedings. Courts limit their intervention to the grounds in the Model Law, and set-aside applications must be made within three months of receipt of the award.

Domestic arbitration statutes allow more court involvement. Under Ontario's Arbitration Act, 1991, for example, a party may appeal on a question of law with leave if the arbitration agreement does not deal with appeals (s. 45), and appeals or set-aside applications must be started within 30 days (s. 47). Arbitration clauses in standard-form contracts can also be challenged: in Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16, the Supreme Court held an arbitration clause in a driver contract unconscionable and invalid. Our international arbitration page covers seats, set-aside, enforcement and investor-state disputes.

Investor-state arbitration is also relevant for foreign investors in Canada and Canadian investors abroad. According to Global Affairs Canada, CUSMA does not provide investor-state dispute settlement between Canada and the United States, apart from a transition period for legacy investments, so US investors must rely on other protections. Canada's other investment treaties and trade agreements contain their own mechanisms, and treaty coverage should be checked when structuring an investment.

Appeals, public law and regulatory disputes

Businesses challenge government decisions through judicial review, statutory appeals and constitutional litigation. Since Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65, courts presume that administrative decisions are reviewed for reasonableness, while statutory appeals are reviewed on appellate standards. In TransAlta Generation Partnership v. Alberta, 2024 SCC 37, released with a companion case, the Court applied that framework to the review of regulations. Division-of-powers disputes, such as whether a business falls under federal or provincial labour law, continue to reach the Supreme Court. Our appellate and public law page covers appeals, judicial review and Crown liability.

Recent Supreme Court decisionWhy it matters for business disputes in Canada
SS&C Technologies v. BNY Mellon, 2026 SCC 29Spoliation triggers a presumption that missing evidence was unfavourable
Lundin Mining v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39Broad reading of "material change" in secondary market claims
Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27Limits on jurisdiction over foreign defendants
Sanis Health v. British Columbia, 2024 SCC 40Province may sue on behalf of other governments in opioid litigation
TransAlta v. Alberta, 2024 SCC 37Standard of review for challenges to regulations
Uber Technologies v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16Unconscionable arbitration clauses are unenforceable

Product liability and construction disputes

Product liability claims in Canada are mostly based on negligence, including failure to warn and design defects, and on contract and consumer protection statutes. Strict liability of the US kind is generally not part of the common law, although Quebec's Civil Code imposes extensive manufacturer liability for safety defects. Claims frequently proceed as class actions, and recalls are governed by federal statutes such as the Canada Consumer Product Safety Act and by sector-specific regulators.

Our product liability page explains defence and recall strategy, including how to coordinate a recall with regulators and insurers while preserving defences in later litigation. Under art. 1468 of the Civil Code of Québec, for example, the manufacturer of a movable thing must make reparation for injury caused to a third person by a safety defect in it, and distributors and suppliers can share that liability. Companies selling into Quebec should take this into account in warnings, labelling and recall planning.

Construction disputes follow their own statutory track. Ontario's Construction Act requires an owner to pay a proper invoice within 28 days after receiving it, unless it gives a notice of non-payment (s. 6.4), and provides for interim adjudication of payment disputes, holdbacks and liens. Other provinces have adopted or are adopting prompt payment and adjudication regimes. Large infrastructure projects add procurement, P3 and arbitration issues. Our construction and infrastructure disputes page covers liens, adjudication, delay and defect claims.

Practical point

When a dispute is foreseeable, act on three things immediately: issue a litigation hold covering emails, chat messages and devices; calculate the limitation period under every potentially applicable law; and check the contract for notice, dispute resolution and forum clauses. Each of these can decide the outcome before the merits are reached.

Managing disputes in Canada from abroad

Foreign companies involved in disputes in Canada face particular questions. Canadian courts take jurisdiction over a foreign defendant only where there is a real and substantial connection to the province, and in Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, the Supreme Court held that Ontario courts had no jurisdiction over foreign defendants where the only connection to Ontario was a credit card service based there. Foreign judgments can generally be enforced in Canada through a fresh action, without retrying the merits, if the foreign court had a real and substantial connection to the dispute and no defence such as fraud or a breach of natural justice applies.

Document production in Canadian litigation is broad, and parties must disclose relevant documents whether or not they help their case, subject to privilege. Solicitor-client and litigation privilege are strongly protected, but communications with in-house counsel are privileged only when they involve legal, not business, advice. Foreign parties should also expect examinations for discovery of a corporate representative, mandatory mediation in some cities and provinces, and costs exposure if they lose.

Illustration (hypothetical): a US supplier is sued in Ontario by a Canadian distributor after terminating a distribution agreement governed by New York law with a New York forum clause. The supplier's first steps are to move to stay the Ontario action in favour of the agreed forum, to preserve evidence, and to assess whether any Ontario statute, such as franchise legislation, overrides the clause. The outcome of that preliminary motion often determines whether the dispute is litigated at all.

Most disputes in Canada settle, often after examinations for discovery or mediation. Settlement agreements should address releases, confidentiality, tax treatment of payments and, in class actions, court approval. Formal offers to settle under the rules of court can shift costs consequences if the other party fails to beat the offer at trial, so they are a useful tactical tool for both plaintiffs and defendants.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise Canadian and international businesses on disputes in Canada at every stage. We assess claims and defences early, manage litigation holds and limitation risk, develop forum and jurisdiction strategy, coordinate class action and securities defence, advise on arbitration clauses, seats and enforcement, and help clients through regulatory investigations and judicial review. Appearances before Canadian courts and tribunals require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work alongside the counsel of record in those proceedings. Litigation outcomes depend on facts and evidence, and this page is general information rather than advice on any dispute. To discuss a dispute or a contract's dispute resolution provisions, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to sue in Canada?

It depends on the province and the claim. In Ontario, the Limitations Act, 2002 generally requires a claim to be started within two years from the day it was discovered, and no later than 15 years after the act or omission. Quebec generally uses a three-year prescription period for personal rights. Contracts and specific statutes can change these periods.

Does the loser pay legal costs in Canadian litigation?

Generally yes. Canadian courts usually order the unsuccessful party to pay part of the successful party's legal costs, typically on a partial indemnity scale, with higher awards possible in some cases. This differs from the US approach and affects settlement strategy, especially for foreign parties weighing the cost of defending a claim.

Are arbitration awards enforceable in Canada?

Yes. Every province has adopted the UNCITRAL Model Law for international commercial arbitration, and Canada applies the New York Convention. Courts may refuse enforcement only on the limited grounds the Convention and Model Law allow, such as incapacity, lack of notice, excess of jurisdiction or public policy.

What happens if a party destroys evidence in Canadian litigation?

In SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, the Supreme Court held that once spoliation is established, courts must presume the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to the party responsible, and they have discretion to fashion an appropriate remedy.

Can a foreign company be sued in a Canadian court?

Yes, if there is a real and substantial connection between the claim and the province. Recent decisions, including Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, show that weak connections are not enough. Forum selection and arbitration clauses can also lead a Canadian court to stay an action in favour of another forum.

Sources

  1. Ontario: Limitations Act, 2002
  2. Ontario: Class Proceedings Act, 1992
  3. Ontario: International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017
  4. Supreme Court of Canada: SS&C Technologies v. BNY Mellon, 2026 SCC 29 (Case in Brief)
  5. Supreme Court of Canada: Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39 (Case in Brief)
  6. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.