Guide · Employment, Labour and Pensions
Workplace Investigations and Human Rights in Canada
Canadian employers must prevent harassment and violence, accommodate employees to the point of undue hardship, and investigate complaints fairly. Workplace investigations are where those duties are tested: a flawed process can turn a manageable complaint into a tribunal claim or a lawsuit. This page explains the federal and provincial rules, the duty to accommodate, pay equity and how to run an investigation that holds up.
Key takeaways
- Ontario employers must investigate harassment complaints appropriately, and an inspector can order an impartial investigation at the employer's expense (OHSA s. 32.0.7).
- Federally regulated employers must follow the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations, including rules on choosing investigators.
- Human rights law requires accommodation to the point of undue hardship; Ontario applications must generally be made within one year.
- Federally regulated employers with 10 or more employees are subject to the Pay Equity Act.
- Quebec's Act respecting labour standards guarantees a work environment free from psychological harassment.
Why workplace investigations matter in Canada
Workplace investigations in Canada are not optional best practice: in most jurisdictions they are a legal duty. Occupational health and safety statutes require employers to have harassment and violence policies and to investigate complaints; human rights statutes make employers liable for discrimination and harassment by their staff unless they respond properly; and the common law treats a failure to address a poisoned work environment as a possible constructive dismissal. An investigation is also how an employer establishes the facts it needs to discipline, accommodate or exonerate.

The legal framework depends on the employer. Provincially regulated employers follow the health and safety and human rights statutes of their province, such as Ontario's Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) and Human Rights Code. Federally regulated employers follow Part II of the Canada Labour Code, the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations and the Canadian Human Rights Act. Unionized employers must also respect the collective agreement, and investigations of unionized employees often involve the union at interviews.
Done well, workplace investigations protect employees, limit liability and support defensible decisions. Done badly, they generate new claims: for bad-faith conduct in dismissal, for reprisal, for breach of privacy, or for failure to accommodate. The rest of this page explains the duties and then the practice.
Harassment and violence prevention duties
Ontario
The OHSA requires employers to prepare policies on workplace violence and workplace harassment and to develop and maintain programs to implement them.
The harassment program must set out how workers report incidents, how complaints will be investigated and dealt with, and how information will be kept confidential. Under s. 32.0.7, to protect a worker from workplace harassment, the employer must ensure that an investigation appropriate in the circumstances is conducted into incidents and complaints, and that the worker who complained and the alleged harasser are informed in writing of the results and any corrective action. An inspector may order the employer to have an investigation conducted, at the employer's expense, by an impartial person with knowledge, experience or qualifications the inspector specifies, and to obtain a written report.
Federally regulated employers
Federal employers must follow a detailed process under the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations. They must carry out a joint workplace assessment with the policy committee, workplace committee or health and safety representative, adopt a prevention policy, train employees within three months of hiring and at least every three years, and follow a structured resolution process when they receive a notice of an occurrence.
If the matter is not resolved by negotiation or conciliation, the principal party can require an investigation. The investigator must be chosen from a list jointly developed with the applicable partner, or agreed by the parties, or, failing agreement within 60 days, from among those identified by the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety as having the required knowledge, training and experience.
Quebec and other provinces
Quebec's Act respecting labour standards (s. 81.19) gives every employee a right to a work environment free from psychological harassment and requires employers to take reasonable action to prevent it and stop it, including by adopting a prevention and complaint-handling policy. Other provinces have comparable health and safety rules, with differences in definitions, required policy content and regulator powers. National employers should use one investigation protocol but adapt notices, timelines and reporting to each jurisdiction.
| Jurisdiction | Key source | Investigation requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario | OHSA ss. 32.0.1–32.0.7 | Investigation appropriate in the circumstances; written results to both parties; inspector may order third-party investigation |
| Federal | Canada Labour Code, Part II; SOR/2020-130 | Structured resolution process; investigation on request if unresolved; investigator selection rules |
| Quebec | Act respecting labour standards, s. 81.19 | Reasonable action to prevent and stop psychological harassment; written policy |
Human rights and the duty to accommodate
Every Canadian jurisdiction prohibits discrimination in employment. Ontario's Human Rights Code gives every person a right to equal treatment in employment without discrimination because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability (s. 5). Harassment on those grounds is also prohibited. The federal Canadian Human Rights Act applies similar protections to federally regulated employers.
The duty to accommodate requires employers to adjust rules, duties and workplaces so that employees with protected characteristics can participate, unless doing so would cause undue hardship. Under the Ontario Code, undue hardship is assessed by considering cost, outside sources of funding, if any, and health and safety requirements, if any (s. 11(2)). The duty is procedural as well as substantive: the employer must actively explore options, request appropriate medical or other information, and document what it considered. Employees must cooperate, and an employer is not obliged to provide the employee's preferred accommodation if another reasonable one exists.
Common accommodation situations include return to work after illness or injury, mental health conditions, childcare and eldercare obligations under family status, religious observance and drug or alcohol dependence in safety-sensitive roles. Each requires individual assessment. Blanket rules, such as a requirement that employees be "100% fit" before returning, are likely to be found discriminatory. When an accommodation complaint and a harassment complaint arise together, which is common, the two processes should be coordinated so that information gathered in one is used fairly in the other.
Keep a written accommodation file for each request: what the employee asked for, what information was requested and received, which options were considered and why the chosen one was reasonable. Tribunals often decide accommodation cases on whether the employer can show that process, not only on the outcome.
Human rights tribunal claims and remedies
In Ontario, a person who believes their Code rights have been infringed applies directly to the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario, generally within one year after the incident or the last in a series of incidents (s. 34). Under the federal Act, complaints go first to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, which may decline to deal with complaints about acts that occurred more than one year earlier, unless it extends the period. Other provinces use either a direct-access tribunal model or a commission screening model.
Tribunals can award compensation for lost wages and for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect, and they can order reinstatement and public interest remedies such as training, policy changes and monitoring. Employees can also include human rights claims in a wrongful dismissal action in court in some provinces. Reprisal against a person who complains or participates in an investigation is itself a breach of the human rights statutes and a frequent add-on claim.
Pay equity
Pay equity laws require equal pay for work of equal value between predominantly female and predominantly male job classes. The federal Pay Equity Act, in force since 31 August 2021, applies to federally regulated employers with 10 or more employees, which must establish a pay equity plan, with reasonable efforts to form a pay equity committee required for employers of 100 or more employees and for smaller employers with unionized employees, and post a final plan by the third anniversary of becoming subject to the Act. Ontario and Quebec have their own proactive pay equity statutes, and several provinces have adopted pay transparency laws governing job postings and pay reporting.
Running workplace investigations that hold up
Courts and tribunals do not expect perfection, but they expect fairness, thoroughness and impartiality. The following steps reflect what decision-makers in Canada look for when they review workplace investigations:
- Triage and interim measures. Assess the complaint quickly. Consider whether to separate the parties, adjust reporting lines or place the respondent on paid leave, without treating interim measures as discipline.
- Choose the investigator. Use someone impartial, with no reporting relationship to the parties and the right expertise. External investigators are advisable for senior respondents, complex allegations or where the internal team is implicated. Federal employers must follow the selection rules in the regulations.
- Define the mandate. Set out in writing the allegations to be investigated, the applicable policy, the standard of proof (balance of probabilities) and whether the investigator will make findings only or also recommendations.
- Give notice and a fair opportunity to respond. The respondent should know the substance of the allegations and have a real chance to answer them, including any new evidence that emerges.
- Interview and gather evidence. Interview the complainant, respondent and relevant witnesses, collect documents and electronic records lawfully, and keep careful notes.
- Assess credibility and make findings. Explain why evidence was accepted or rejected, considering consistency, corroboration and plausibility.
- Report and close. Inform the parties in writing of the results and any corrective action, as Ontario's OHSA requires, and protect confidentiality to the extent possible.
Privilege requires a deliberate choice. An investigation conducted by or for counsel to provide legal advice may be privileged, but privilege can be lost if the employer relies on the report to justify discipline in later proceedings. Many employers separate the fact-finding investigation from legal advice about what to do with the findings.
Illustration (hypothetical): a sales director in Toronto is accused by two team members of repeated demeaning comments about their religion. The company places him on paid leave, retains an external investigator with a written mandate, and gives him the particulars of each allegation. The investigator interviews nine witnesses, reviews chat messages and finds most allegations substantiated. The company informs both complainants and the director in writing of the results and ends his employment, relying on documented findings. If he sues, the company can show a process that was prompt, impartial and fair, which also reduces the risk of damages for bad-faith conduct in the manner of dismissal.
Allegations against senior leaders
Complaints about executives, directors or founders need governance as well as investigation. The board, or a committee of independent directors, should oversee the process rather than management reporting to the respondent. The investigator should report to that committee, and counsel advising the board should be separate from counsel for the individual. Public companies must also consider whether the allegations, or the investigation itself, require disclosure under securities law, and whether insurance notice obligations under directors' and officers' policies are triggered. Speed and confidentiality are harder to manage at this level, and leaks can damage both the company and the individuals involved, so access to information should be tightly controlled from the start.
Common mistakes in workplace investigations
Reviews of workplace investigations by courts, arbitrators and tribunals point to recurring errors. The most common is delay: complaints left for weeks while evidence fades and the complainant's trust erodes. Others include choosing an investigator who reports to one of the parties, failing to put the allegations to the respondent in enough detail to answer them, expanding the scope mid-stream without telling the parties, relying on rumour or uncorroborated hearsay, and drawing conclusions about legal liability rather than facts. Managers sometimes discipline before the investigation is finished, which makes the outcome look predetermined. Each of these mistakes can expose the employer to claims even when the underlying complaint was unfounded.
After the findings
Investigation findings are the start of the employer's decision, not the end. Discipline should be proportionate to the substantiated misconduct, consistent with how similar cases were treated, and, for unionized employees, compliant with the collective agreement. Where allegations are not substantiated, the employer should still consider whether workplace dynamics need attention, such as training, mediation or changes to reporting lines, and must protect the complainant from reprisal. Policies and programs should be reviewed after significant investigations to capture lessons learned, as Ontario's OHSA requires the harassment program to be reviewed as often as necessary and at least annually.
Workplace investigations, privacy and records
Investigations involve personal information, and privacy law applies. Federally regulated employers are subject to the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act for employee information, and British Columbia, Alberta and Quebec have private-sector privacy laws that cover employees. Employers should collect only what the investigation needs, secure the file, limit access to those who need it, and set a retention period. Searching employees' devices or accounts should be done under a clear policy and in a proportionate way.
Records are also evidence. Investigators' notes, interview summaries and drafts may be producible in litigation or tribunal proceedings, and inconsistent or careless notes undermine credibility. A short, factual report with clear reasons is generally better than a long document full of commentary.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise employers on harassment and violence prevention programs, human rights compliance and workplace investigations across Canada. We draft and update policies and investigation protocols, advise on interim measures and the choice of investigator, structure mandates to manage privilege, review investigation reports before decisions are made, and help employers respond to human rights applications and pay equity obligations. Where an independent investigation or tribunal representation is required, we coordinate with qualified external investigators and Canadian-licensed counsel. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a complaint or policy, contact us, or see our pages on employment law and the employment and labour overview.
Frequently asked questions
Is an employer in Canada required to investigate a harassment complaint?
In most jurisdictions, yes. Ontario's OHSA requires an investigation appropriate in the circumstances into incidents and complaints of workplace harassment, with written results to the parties. Federally regulated employers must follow the resolution process in the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations, which includes an investigation when the principal party requests it.
Who should conduct a workplace investigation?
Someone impartial, with no reporting relationship to the parties and with appropriate expertise. External investigators are advisable for senior respondents or complex allegations. Federally regulated employers must choose investigators according to the regulations, and an Ontario inspector can order an impartial third-party investigation at the employer's expense.
What is undue hardship in the duty to accommodate?
It is the point at which an employer is no longer required to accommodate. Under Ontario's Human Rights Code, it is assessed by considering cost, outside sources of funding and health and safety requirements. The threshold is high, and employers must show they actively explored options before concluding accommodation was impossible.
How long does an employee have to file a human rights claim in Ontario?
Generally one year after the incident, or after the last incident in a series, under s. 34 of the Human Rights Code. The Tribunal can accept late applications if the delay was incurred in good faith and no substantial prejudice results. Federal complaints go to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, which may decline complaints filed more than a year after the events.
Are workplace investigation reports privileged?
Sometimes. An investigation conducted by or for counsel for the purpose of legal advice may attract privilege, but privilege can be lost if the employer relies on the report to justify a decision in later proceedings. Many employers separate fact-finding from legal advice on the consequences to manage this risk.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.