Skip to content

Guide · Energy, Mining and Environment

Indigenous Law and Consultation

Indigenous law shapes approvals, financing and risk for every major project in Canada. This guide explains section 35 rights, the Crown's duty to consult and accommodate, Aboriginal title and treaties, the federal UNDRIP Act, impact benefit agreements and the rise of Indigenous equity ownership, with the leading Supreme Court decisions.

10 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • The duty to consult is triggered when Crown conduct may adversely affect asserted or established rights.
  • Procedural aspects of consultation are often delegated to proponents, but the duty remains the Crown's.
  • Aboriginal title confers the right to decide how land is used, per Tsilhqot'in, 2014 SCC 44.
  • The federal UNDRIP Act requires measures to align federal laws with the Declaration.
  • Indigenous equity ownership, backed by loan guarantees, is now common in energy and infrastructure.

Indigenous law and consultation in brief

Indigenous law shapes nearly every resource, energy and infrastructure project in Canada. Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 recognizes and affirms the existing Aboriginal and treaty rights of the Indigenous peoples of Canada, who include First Nations, Inuit and Métis. From that constitutional foundation, the courts have developed the Crown's duty to consult and, where appropriate, accommodate Indigenous peoples when government decisions might adversely affect their rights. Modern treaties and land claim agreements, Aboriginal title, the federal United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act and provincial equivalents add further layers.

Indigenous law in Canada: community leaders and project proponents meeting to discuss consultation and partnership
Indigenous law in Canada: section 35 rights, the duty to consult, UNDRIP legislation, benefit agreements and equity partnerships.

For businesses, Indigenous law is not only a compliance question. Projects with strong Indigenous partnerships move through approvals faster, attract financing more readily and face less litigation risk. Indigenous nations and their development corporations are also significant investors, landowners and business partners in their own right. This page explains the legal framework and the commercial arrangements that have become standard practice.

ConceptKey authorityWhat it means for business
Duty to consult and accommodateHaida Nation v. British Columbia (Minister of Forests), 2004 SCC 73Triggered by Crown conduct that may adversely affect asserted or established rights; procedural aspects often delegated to proponents
Aboriginal titleTsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014 SCC 44Title confers the right to use and benefit from land; infringement must be justified, and consent is the safest course
Regulators and consultationClyde River, 2017 SCC 40; Chippewas of the Thames, 2017 SCC 41A regulator's process can fulfil the Crown's duty if adequate
Legislation and consultationMikisew Cree First Nation, 2018 SCC 40No judicially enforceable duty to consult in the law-making process
UNDRIP ActS.C. 2021, c. 14 (royal assent 21 June 2021)Ottawa must take measures to align federal laws with the Declaration and implement an action plan

The duty to consult and accommodate

In Haida Nation, the Supreme Court held that the duty to consult arises when the Crown has real or constructive knowledge of the potential existence of an Aboriginal right or title and contemplates conduct that might adversely affect it. The depth of consultation required varies with the strength of the claim and the seriousness of the potential impact. At the low end, the Crown may need only to give notice, disclose information and discuss issues. At the high end, it may need to provide opportunities for submissions, formal participation in decision-making and written reasons showing how concerns were considered.

The duty belongs to the Crown and cannot be delegated in its entirety, but procedural aspects of consultation are routinely delegated to project proponents. In practice, proponents share project information, fund community participation, carry out traditional land use studies, meet communities, and propose mitigation and accommodation measures. Governments then assess whether the overall process was adequate before making their decisions. Proponents should agree with the Crown, in writing where possible, which procedural steps have been delegated, so that gaps do not emerge late in the approval process and expose the decision to challenge.

Consultation through regulatory processes

In Clyde River (Hamlet) v. Petroleum Geo-Services Inc., 2017 SCC 40, and Chippewas of the Thames First Nation v. Enbridge Pipelines Inc., 2017 SCC 41, the Supreme Court confirmed that the Crown can rely on a regulatory body's process to fulfil the duty to consult, if the process is adequate and the regulator has the necessary powers. In Clyde River, the consultation for seismic testing in Nunavut was inadequate and the authorization was quashed. In Chippewas of the Thames, the National Energy Board's process for a pipeline modification was adequate. These cases explain why proponents now treat regulatory hearings as an integral part of consultation.

Legislation and policy

In Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada (Governor General in Council), 2018 SCC 40, the Court held that the law-making process does not attract a judicially enforceable duty to consult, although the honour of the Crown continues to apply. However, decisions made under legislation, such as permits and approvals, remain subject to the duty.

Aboriginal title, treaties and the honour of the Crown

Aboriginal title is a collective right to land based on sufficient, continuous and exclusive occupation before the assertion of European sovereignty. In Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014 SCC 44, the Supreme Court made the first declaration of Aboriginal title in Canada and held that title confers the right to decide how the land will be used and to enjoy its economic benefits. Governments seeking to infringe title must have the consent of the title holders or justify the infringement. Once title is established, projects approved without consent may be cancelled if their continuation would be unjustifiable.

Treaties, both historic and modern, define rights over large parts of Canada. Modern land claim agreements, especially in the North and in British Columbia, create detailed regimes for land ownership, resource revenue sharing, environmental review and impact and benefit agreements. In Ontario (Attorney General) v. Restoule, 2024 SCC 27, the Supreme Court held that the Crown breached its treaty promise to increase annuities under the Robinson Treaties and must negotiate or determine compensation. In Quebec (Attorney General) v. Pekuakamiulnuatsh Takuhikan, 2024 SCC 39, the Court held that Quebec breached its obligations of good faith and the honour of the Crown in implementing agreements to fund an Indigenous police force. Both decisions underline that the Crown's promises to Indigenous peoples are enforceable and must be performed diligently.

Métis rights

Métis communities hold section 35 rights, and the duty to consult applies to them. In Saskatchewan (Environment) v. Métis Nation–Saskatchewan, 2025 SCC 4, the Supreme Court held that a Métis challenge to uranium exploration permits on duty-to-consult grounds could proceed and was not an abuse of process. Proponents should therefore identify Métis rights-holders, as well as First Nations, in their consultation planning.

UNDRIP legislation

The federal United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act received royal assent on 21 June 2021. Section 5 requires the Government of Canada, in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples, to take all measures necessary to ensure that federal laws are consistent with the Declaration. Section 6 requires an action plan to achieve the Declaration's objectives, and s. 7 requires annual reports to Parliament. British Columbia enacted its own Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act in 2019, which authorizes agreements with Indigenous governing bodies, including consent-based decision-making agreements.

The Declaration includes the principle of free, prior and informed consent. Canadian law has not converted that principle into a general veto over projects, but it increasingly influences how governments and companies approach engagement. In Reference re An Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, youth and families, 2024 SCC 5, the Supreme Court upheld federal legislation that affirmed Indigenous jurisdiction over child and family services and referred to the Declaration as an interpretive aid. Businesses should expect the Declaration to be invoked in regulatory proceedings and litigation, and should design engagement processes that can withstand scrutiny against it.

Impact benefit agreements

Impact benefit agreements (IBAs), sometimes called community benefit or relationship agreements, are contracts between project proponents and Indigenous communities. They are not required by statute in most jurisdictions, although some modern treaties and northern regimes require them. They have nonetheless become standard practice for mines, pipelines, LNG facilities, transmission lines and renewable projects.

  • Benefits: payments, revenue or profit sharing, scholarships and community funds.
  • Employment and contracting: hiring and training targets, set-asides or preferences for community businesses.
  • Environmental participation: monitoring roles, environmental committees and cultural protection measures.
  • Support and consent: the community's support for permits and commitments not to oppose the project, subject to the proponent's performance.
  • Governance: implementation committees, dispute resolution and review clauses.

Well-drafted IBAs anticipate change: project expansions, changes in ownership, closure and the possibility of disputes. They should also address confidentiality, the effect of the agreement on the Crown's consultation obligations and the treatment of the agreement in financing. Our impact benefit agreements insight covers negotiation in more detail.

Practical point

Do not treat an IBA as a substitute for Crown consultation. The Crown still decides whether its duty has been met, and a community can challenge a permit even if an agreement exists. Coordinate the IBA, the consultation record and the regulatory timetable so that each supports the others.

Indigenous equity ownership and loan guarantees

Indigenous equity ownership has become one of the most important trends in Canadian infrastructure and energy. Communities increasingly take equity stakes, often between a minority interest and majority ownership, in pipelines, transmission lines, power plants and LNG facilities. Federal and provincial loan guarantee programmes support these investments by allowing communities to borrow at lower cost. The federal government operates a national loan guarantee programme through the Canada Indigenous Loan Guarantee Corporation, and Alberta, Ontario and other provinces run their own programmes, such as the Alberta Indigenous Opportunities Corporation.

Equity partnerships raise distinctive legal issues: governance and veto rights, distribution waterfalls and debt service, construction and cost overrun risk, put and call rights, tax considerations for First Nations entities, and the interaction with the communities' own governance and trust structures. In the 2025 Canada–Alberta memorandum of understanding, both governments committed to use their loan guarantee bodies to help backstop Indigenous co-ownership of a proposed bitumen pipeline. Our Indigenous equity insight explains typical structures.

Indigenous law in project planning

Practical application of Indigenous law starts at the concept stage. Proponents should identify all rights-holders, including First Nations, Métis and Inuit, assess the likely depth of consultation, and plan engagement before applications are filed. Early capacity funding, information sharing and joint studies build trust. Consultation records must be detailed and well organized, because they will be the main evidence if a decision is challenged in court.

Indigenous governments also exercise their own jurisdiction. Self-governing First Nations and modern treaty nations have law-making powers, and many communities have their own assessment and consent processes. Respecting these processes is often a condition of community support. Our environmental and climate law page explains the assessment processes that run alongside consultation.

Litigation risk

When consultation is inadequate, Indigenous parties can seek judicial review of approvals, injunctions and declarations. Courts can quash approvals and order further consultation, which can delay projects by years. Proponents can reduce this risk through early engagement, meaningful accommodation and agreements, and by ensuring that decision-makers have a complete record. Companies should also be aware that Aboriginal title claims and treaty claims can affect land tenure, including in some cases privately held land.

Indigenous law in transactions and financing

Indigenous law issues appear in due diligence for almost every resource and infrastructure acquisition. Buyers should review existing agreements with Indigenous communities, including whether they require consent to an assignment or change of control, whether benefits continue after a sale, and whether any disputes or grievances are outstanding. A project whose community agreements cannot be transferred, or whose partners have not been informed of a sale, may face opposition at exactly the moment the buyer needs regulatory approvals.

Lenders take a similar view. Project finance lenders assess the consultation record, the status of IBAs and equity partnerships, and the risk that litigation could delay or stop the project. Credit agreements may include covenants to maintain community agreements and to report on disputes. Equity partners that are Indigenous development corporations will often have their own financing and governance constraints, which should be reflected in shareholder or partnership agreements from the outset.

Procurement and employment commitments

Government procurement policies and community agreements increasingly require Indigenous participation in contracting and employment. Federal procurement includes a target for contracts with Indigenous businesses, and many provincial infrastructure procurements score Indigenous participation plans. Companies should verify the eligibility of Indigenous business partners, avoid "shell" arrangements that do not deliver real participation, and track their commitments, because failure to deliver can breach contracts and damage relationships. Indigenous law and good commercial practice point in the same direction: commitments must be real and measurable.

Governance and the Charter

Business partners of Indigenous governments should understand how those governments operate. Many First Nations act through band councils under the Indian Act, while others are self-governing under modern agreements or their own constitutions. In Dickson v. Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation, 2024 SCC 10, the Supreme Court held that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies to a self-governing First Nation's laws, while s. 25 of the Charter protects certain Indigenous rights from being undermined. For commercial partners, the key questions are who has authority to sign, what internal approvals are required and how community members are consulted on major decisions.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise proponents, investors, lenders and Indigenous nations and their development corporations on Indigenous law in Canada. Our work includes consultation strategy and records, impact benefit and relationship agreements, equity partnerships and loan guarantee financings, joint ventures, and approvals strategy for energy, mining and infrastructure projects. We coordinate with counsel licensed in the relevant jurisdiction and with advisers who specialize in community engagement. See also our energy, mining and environment overview. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a project or partnership, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Does a company have a duty to consult Indigenous peoples?

Legally, the duty belongs to the Crown, not private companies. However, governments routinely delegate procedural aspects of consultation to proponents, and a project approval can be quashed if consultation was inadequate. In practice, companies carry out much of the engagement and should document it carefully.

Does UNDRIP give Indigenous communities a veto over projects?

The federal UNDRIP Act requires the government to align federal laws with the Declaration, which includes free, prior and informed consent. Canadian courts have not treated that principle as a general veto, but it increasingly shapes engagement, regulatory processes and litigation, and consent remains the safest course where Aboriginal title is established.

What is an impact benefit agreement?

It is a contract between a project proponent and an Indigenous community that typically provides financial benefits, employment and contracting opportunities and environmental participation in exchange for the community's support. IBAs are standard practice for major projects, although they do not replace the Crown's duty to consult.

How do Indigenous communities finance equity in major projects?

Often through loans supported by federal or provincial loan guarantee programmes, such as those administered by the Canada Indigenous Loan Guarantee Corporation and the Alberta Indigenous Opportunities Corporation. Guarantees lower borrowing costs, and the equity is typically repaid from project distributions.

Can private land be affected by Aboriginal title claims?

Aboriginal title claims are usually made against Crown land, but claims can extend to areas that include privately held land, and courts have been asked to consider the effect of title on private interests. Businesses acquiring land in areas subject to claims should assess the risk as part of due diligence.

Sources

  1. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (S.C. 2021, c. 14)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Ontario (Attorney General) v. Restoule, 2024 SCC 27
  3. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Quebec (AG) v. Pekuakamiulnuatsh Takuhikan, 2024 SCC 39
  4. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Saskatchewan (Environment) v. Métis Nation–Saskatchewan, 2025 SCC 4
  5. Canada–Alberta Memorandum of Understanding backgrounder (27 November 2025)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.