Guide · Disputes and Litigation
Construction and Infrastructure Disputes in Canada
Construction disputes in Canada now start with statutory payment deadlines and fast-track adjudication, not just lawsuits. This guide explains Ontario and federal prompt payment rules, how adjudication works, lien and holdback deadlines, delay and escalation claims, P3 project disputes and how expert evidence and records decide outcomes.
Key takeaways
- Ontario owners must pay a proper invoice within 28 days unless they give a timely notice of non-payment.
- Ontario adjudicators generally decide within 30 days, and determinations bind until a court or arbitrator rules.
- Judicial review of an Ontario adjudication needs leave of the Divisional Court, sought within 35 days.
- Ontario contractor liens generally expire 60 days after substantial performance is published or the contract ends.
- Federal projects follow a separate prompt payment statute in force since December 2023.
Construction disputes in Canada: an overview
Construction disputes in Canada are shaped by three features that set them apart from other commercial litigation. First, statutory prompt payment and adjudication regimes now require owners and contractors to pay on fixed timetables and give parties a fast, interim way to resolve payment disputes. Second, lien legislation gives contractors, subcontractors and suppliers security against the land, but only if strict deadlines are met. Third, large projects, including public-private partnerships (P3s), use layered contracts with their own dispute resolution ladders, often ending in arbitration. Delay, disruption, change orders, price escalation and defects then supply most of the substance.

Construction is mainly a matter of provincial law, so the rules differ by province. Ontario's Construction Act is the most developed model and is used as the reference point on this page. Federal construction projects have their own regime under the Federal Prompt Payment for Construction Work Act. Several other provinces have adopted or are adopting prompt payment and adjudication legislation with different timelines, so the governing statute must always be confirmed for the project's location and owner.
Prompt payment and adjudication
Ontario
Under s. 6.4 of the Ontario Construction Act, an owner must pay the amount payable under a proper invoice no later than 28 days after receiving it, unless it gives a notice of non-payment disputing all or part of the invoice within the statutory time. A contractor that receives full payment must then pay each subcontractor whose work was included in the invoice within seven days (s. 6.5), and similar cascading obligations apply further down the chain. A party that does not pay must either give a timely notice of non-payment or face interest and adjudication.
Part II.1 allows a party to a contract or subcontract to refer a dispute on a prescribed matter, or any matter the parties agree on, to adjudication (s. 13.5). The prescribed matters, set out by regulation, focus on payment-related disagreements such as the value of work performed and amounts owing under the contract. The adjudicator must generally make a determination within 30 days after receiving the required documents (s. 13.13). Key features of adjudication in Ontario include:
- the determination is binding on the parties until a court, an arbitrator under the Arbitration Act, 1991 or a written agreement decides the matter otherwise (s. 13.15);
- the paying party must pay the amount determined no later than 15 days after the determination is communicated (s. 13.19(2));
- judicial review of a determination is available only with leave of the Divisional Court, and the motion for leave must be filed within 35 days after the determination is communicated (s. 13.18); and
- amendments in force on 1 January 2026 adjusted parts of the adjudication and holdback regime, including annual release of holdback on longer contracts.
Federal projects
For construction work on federal real property and federal immovables, the Federal Prompt Payment for Construction Work Act, in force since December 2023, requires the federal owner to pay a contractor's proper invoice no later than the 28th day after receiving it, unless it gives notice of non-payment by the 21st day (s. 9). The contractor must pay its subcontractors for work covered by the invoice by the 35th day (s. 10), with later deadlines further down the chain. Disputes can be referred to adjudication under the federal regime, with procedures set out in the federal dispute resolution regulations (SOR/2023-271).
| Step | Ontario Construction Act | Federal Prompt Payment Act |
|---|---|---|
| Owner pays proper invoice | 28 days after receipt (s. 6.4) | 28th day after receipt (s. 9(2)) |
| Owner's notice of non-payment | Within the statutory window before payment is due | By the 21st day (s. 9(3)) |
| Contractor pays subcontractors | 7 days after receiving payment (s. 6.5) | 35th day after owner received invoice (s. 10(1)) |
| Adjudicator's determination | Generally 30 days after documents (s. 13.13) | Under the federal dispute resolution regulations |
| Effect | Interim binding (s. 13.15) | Interim binding |
In construction disputes the first deadline is often the notice of non-payment, not the lawsuit. Owners and contractors should set up invoice review processes that can identify disputed amounts and issue compliant notices on time; a missed notice can turn a genuine dispute about quality or quantity into an obligation to pay now and argue later.
Construction liens and holdback
Lien rights give unpaid contractors, subcontractors and suppliers security against the owner's interest in the land, and holdback rules require payers to retain part of each payment to protect those further down the chain. In Ontario, "holdback" is 10% of the value of services or materials supplied under a contract or subcontract. Deadlines are strict:
- a contractor's lien for work up to substantial performance generally expires at the end of the 60-day period after the earlier of publication of the certificate or declaration of substantial performance and the date the contract is completed, abandoned or terminated (s. 31(2));
- a lien is preserved by registration on title (or, for certain premises, by notice) within that period; and
- a preserved lien expires unless it is perfected, usually by starting an action and registering a certificate of action, within 90 days after the last day on which it could have been preserved (s. 36(2)).
Lien actions are often consolidated with breach of contract claims, and owners commonly post security to vacate liens from title so that financing and sales can proceed. Lenders, purchasers and landlords must factor lien exposure into closing conditions. Other provinces use different periods and procedures, so a contractor working across provinces needs a jurisdiction-specific lien calendar. Our construction law page covers project-side lien and holdback planning.
Delay, disruption and change claims
Most high-value construction disputes concern time and money: who bears the cost of delay, acceleration, disruption, changed conditions and price escalation. Canadian courts and arbitrators begin with the contract, so notice provisions, change order procedures, force majeure clauses and limitations of liability usually decide the outcome. Standard forms such as the CCDC suite are widely used in the private sector, often heavily amended by supplementary conditions.
Recurring issues include:
- Notice compliance: whether a contractor gave timely written notice of a delay or claim, and whether strict compliance is required or has been waived by conduct.
- Critical path and concurrency: proving that an owner-caused event delayed completion, and allocating time and cost where owner and contractor delays overlap.
- Global claims: whether a contractor can claim total cost overruns without linking each cost to a specific cause.
- Escalation and supply shocks: whether tariffs, commodity price spikes or supply-chain failures fall within force majeure, change-in-law or escalation clauses. Recent US tariffs and Canadian counter-tariffs on steel and aluminum make this a live issue on many projects.
- Good faith: how the duty of honest performance and the good-faith exercise of contractual discretion affect owners' decisions on change orders and terminations.
Our insight on price escalation and delay claims discusses these issues in more detail, and our insight on construction adjudication explains how interim adjudication fits alongside longer proceedings.
P3 and major infrastructure disputes
Large infrastructure projects, including transit, hospitals, highways and energy facilities, are frequently procured as P3s. A project agreement between the public authority and a special-purpose project company sits on top of a design-build contract, an operations and maintenance agreement, lenders' direct agreements and interface agreements. Disputes on these projects tend to be complex and multi-party, and the project agreement usually prescribes a staged process: negotiation between representatives, referral to an independent certifier or expert for technical questions, and then arbitration or litigation.
Distinctive issues on P3 projects include relief and compensation events, the pass-through of public authority claims to the design-builder, lenders' step-in rights and the effect of insolvency of a consortium member. Public owners are also subject to procurement law and, in some cases, to judicial review of procurement decisions. These construction disputes often run for years, so early decisions about forum, experts and document management matter. Our pages on infrastructure, P3 and procurement and international arbitration cover the related transactional and arbitral rules.
Defects, warranties and limitation periods
Not all construction disputes arise during the build. Defect claims often surface years after completion, when water ingress, cladding failures, structural movement or mechanical deficiencies appear. These claims raise distinct questions about who is responsible and when the clock started to run.
Owners typically have contractual warranty rights, commonly a one-year warranty period in standard-form contracts, after which claims proceed in contract or negligence. Designers and consultants are usually sued in negligence and for breach of their engagement terms, and their contracts often cap liability by reference to fees or insurance limits. Subcontractors and suppliers may be brought in by third-party claims, which makes contribution and indemnity rights important.
Limitation periods are critical. In Ontario, the Limitations Act, 2002 sets a basic two-year period from the day the claim was discovered and an ultimate 15-year period from the act or omission on which the claim is based. Discoverability arguments are common in latent defect cases because the cause of a failure may not be apparent when damage first appears. Other provinces have their own limitation statutes, and in Quebec the Civil Code contains specific rules on the liability of contractors and architects for the loss of a work, so the applicable regime must be checked for each project.
Practical steps for owners include inspecting thoroughly before warranty periods expire, documenting deficiencies in writing, giving contractual notices promptly and obtaining early technical advice on cause, which often determines both liability and the limitation analysis. Where several parties may share responsibility, notices should go to each of them, and their insurers, without waiting for the investigation to finish.
Insurance, bonds and insolvency on projects
Many construction disputes are ultimately funded by insurers or sureties, so their positions shape strategy. Builders' risk and wrap-up liability policies respond to physical loss and third-party claims on the project; professional liability insurance responds to design errors; and performance bonds and labour and material payment bonds protect owners and subcontractors when a contractor fails. Each instrument has notice requirements and conditions that must be met on time, and coverage disputes frequently run in parallel with the underlying claim.
Insolvency of a contractor or subcontractor changes the dynamics of construction disputes quickly. Lien rights, holdback, trust provisions in provincial construction statutes and bond claims become the main sources of recovery, while the owner must decide whether to terminate, complete the work with a replacement contractor and pursue the surety. Where a project company or contractor enters formal proceedings under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act or the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the stay of proceedings can freeze litigation and adjudication, and claims must be pursued through the insolvency process. Our insight on surety bonds and construction insurance covers these issues in more depth.
Bid disputes are a related category. Unsuccessful bidders on public projects may challenge the conduct of a tender in court, typically alleging that the owner breached the implied duty to treat bidders fairly and equally or accepted a non-compliant bid. Federal procurement complaints can also go to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal where the procurement is covered by trade agreements. Owners reduce this risk through clear evaluation criteria, careful compliance review and well-drafted privilege and limitation clauses in the tender documents.
Expert evidence and managing construction disputes
Construction disputes are won or lost on records and expert evidence. Delay analysts, quantum experts, engineers and building scientists will reconstruct what happened, so contemporaneous documents such as schedules and updates, daily reports, meeting minutes, change order logs, correspondence and photographs carry great weight. Canadian courts require experts to be impartial and to acknowledge their duty to the court, and arbitral tribunals apply similar expectations.
Illustration: a hypothetical mechanical subcontractor on an Ontario hospital project issues a proper invoice that includes disputed extra work. The general contractor, unpaid by the owner for that portion, must give its own notice of non-payment on time and decide whether to refer the dispute to adjudication. Meanwhile, the subcontractor's lien deadline runs from the date substantial performance is certified. Within a few weeks, both parties need to choose between adjudication, lien preservation and negotiation, and the record they build will later frame any arbitration or trial.
A sensible dispute management plan for construction disputes includes:
- a calendar of contractual and statutory deadlines, including notices of non-payment, lien expiry, claim notices and limitation periods;
- consistent document management across the owner, contractor and subcontractor teams;
- early retention of independent schedule and quantum experts where a significant claim is likely;
- a clear view of the dispute resolution ladder in each contract, including any conditions precedent to arbitration; and
- regular review of insurance and surety positions, including performance and labour and material payment bonds.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise owners, contractors, subcontractors, lenders and investors on Canadian construction disputes, including prompt payment and adjudication strategy, lien and holdback issues, delay, disruption and escalation claims, P3 project agreement disputes and construction arbitrations. We help clients build the documentary and expert record early and coordinate with Canadian-licensed counsel for lien actions, court proceedings and adjudications that require local representation. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a project or claim, please contact us.
Frequently asked questions
How quickly must an owner pay a contractor in Ontario?
Under s. 6.4 of the Ontario Construction Act, an owner must pay the amount payable under a proper invoice no later than 28 days after receiving it, unless it gives a notice of non-payment within the statutory time. A contractor that is paid must then pay subcontractors whose work was included in the invoice within seven days.
Is an adjudicator's decision final?
No. In Ontario, an adjudicator's determination is binding on an interim basis until the matter is decided by a court, by arbitration under the Arbitration Act, 1991, or by written agreement of the parties. The paying party must still pay within 15 days, and judicial review requires leave of the Divisional Court sought within 35 days.
When does a construction lien expire in Ontario?
A contractor's lien for work supplied up to substantial performance generally expires 60 days after the earlier of publication of the certificate or declaration of substantial performance and the completion, abandonment or termination of the contract. A preserved lien must then be perfected, usually by starting an action, within 90 days after the last day it could have been preserved.
Do federal construction projects follow provincial prompt payment rules?
Not for construction work on federal real property. The Federal Prompt Payment for Construction Work Act sets its own regime: the federal owner pays within 28 days of a proper invoice unless it gives notice of non-payment by day 21, contractors pay subcontractors by day 35, and disputes can go to federal adjudication.
How are P3 construction disputes usually resolved?
P3 project agreements usually set out a staged dispute resolution process, starting with negotiation, moving to an independent certifier or expert determination for technical matters and ending in arbitration or court proceedings. The design-build contract and lenders' agreements contain linked provisions, so disputes often involve several parties and must be coordinated across contracts.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.