Skip to content

Guide · Intellectual Property

IP Litigation

IP litigation in Canada usually runs in the Federal Court, where a single judgment covers the whole country. This guide explains forum choice, patent infringement and impeachment, trademark and copyright claims, interim injunctions, remedies such as springboard profits and statutory damages, and how to keep a case efficient.

9 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • Only the Federal Court can invalidate a patent or expunge a registration against everyone.
  • PM(NOC) actions must start within 45 days and trigger a 24-month stay.
  • Interlocutory injunctions require clear evidence of irreparable harm.
  • Patentees can recover springboard profits, as confirmed in Nova Chemicals, 2022 SCC 43.
  • Copyright owners may elect statutory damages of CAD 500 to CAD 20,000 per work for commercial infringement.

IP litigation in Canada: the short answer

IP litigation in Canada is concentrated in the Federal Court, a national court whose judgments are enforceable in every province and territory. Patent, trademark, copyright and industrial design disputes can also be heard by provincial superior courts, but only the Federal Court can invalidate a patent or expunge a registration with effect against everyone. Cases move through a structured, case-managed process with documentary and oral discovery, expert evidence and a trial before a judge alone. There are no juries in Canadian IP cases.

IP litigation in Canada: counsel preparing a Federal Court patent infringement action
IP litigation in Canada: Federal Court actions, injunctions, damages and anti-counterfeiting measures.

For rights holders, the main strategic questions are where to sue, whether interim relief is realistic, which monetary remedy to elect and how validity counterclaims will change the case. For defendants, they are how to respond to a demand, whether to attack validity, and how to manage exposure while the case proceeds.

RightMain forumKey statutory hooksTime limit or look-back
PatentFederal Court (or provincial superior court for infringement)Patent Act ss. 54, 55, 60No remedy for acts more than six years before the action (s. 55.01)
TrademarkFederal Court or provincial superior court; Federal Court for expungementTrademarks Act ss. 19, 20, 22, 7, 53.2, 57Provincial limitation rules generally apply
CopyrightFederal Court or provincial superior courtCopyright Act ss. 34, 35, 38.1Generally three years from the act or from when the owner knew or ought to have known (s. 43.1)
Confidential informationProvincial superior courtBreach of confidence; contract; Civil Code in QuebecProvincial limitation statutes

Choosing the forum for IP litigation

Section 20(1) of the Federal Courts Act gives the Federal Court exclusive original jurisdiction over conflicting applications and over proceedings to impeach or annul a patent or certificate of supplementary protection, or to have an entry in the copyright, trademark or industrial design registers made, expunged or varied. Section 20(2) gives it concurrent jurisdiction in other cases where a remedy is sought under an Act of Parliament relating to these rights. Section 57 of the Trademarks Act confirms the Federal Court's exclusive jurisdiction to strike out or amend register entries.

Provincial superior courts have jurisdiction over infringement claims under s. 54 of the Patent Act and over common-law and contractual claims. They are sometimes preferred where the dispute is mainly contractual, such as a licence or employment dispute, or where interim relief in one province is the priority. But a provincial judgment that a patent is invalid binds only the parties.

Why most cases go to the Federal Court

  • One judgment and one injunction for the whole country.
  • Judges and prothonotaries (associate judges) with deep IP experience.
  • Active case management, including specialized practice for PM(NOC) actions.
  • Bilingual proceedings, which matters where witnesses or documents are in French.

The Federal Court cannot, however, hear purely contractual claims between private parties that are not grounded in federal law. A claim for unpaid royalties under a licence, for example, usually belongs in a provincial court unless it is closely tied to an infringement claim.

Patent infringement and impeachment

Patent IP litigation turns on claim construction. Canadian courts construe claims purposively, from the perspective of a person skilled in the art, before considering infringement or validity. The patentee must prove that the defendant's product or process takes every essential element of at least one claim. The defendant usually counterclaims for invalidity on grounds such as anticipation, obviousness, insufficiency, overbreadth or lack of utility; since AstraZeneca Canada Inc. v. Apotex Inc., 2017 SCC 36, utility requires only a single use demonstrated or soundly predicted at the filing date.

Section 60 of the Patent Act allows any interested person, or the Attorney General, to ask the Federal Court to declare a patent or any claim invalid. Section 60(2) also allows a person with reasonable cause to believe that a process or article might be alleged to infringe to seek a declaration of non-infringement, subject to conditions.

Pharmaceutical actions under the PM(NOC) Regulations

A large share of Canadian patent litigation involves pharmaceuticals. Under the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations, an innovator has 45 days after being served with a generic's notice of allegation to bring an action under s. 6(1). That triggers a 24-month bar on the generic's market authorization under s. 7(1)(d). These are full actions on infringement and validity, and the court manages them tightly so that trial occurs within the stay period. See our patents page for the regulatory background.

Defences beyond invalidity

Defendants also rely on prior use, experimental and regulatory use exceptions, licence, exhaustion through authorized sales and the six-year look-back in s. 55.01. A defendant that receives a demand letter should also check whether it complies with the requirements made under s. 76.2 for written demands.

Trademark IP litigation typically combines claims for infringement under ss. 19 and 20 of the Trademarks Act, depreciation of goodwill under s. 22, and passing off under s. 7(b) and at common law. The central issue is usually confusion, assessed from the first impression of the casual consumer somewhat in a hurry. Defendants often counterclaim for expungement on grounds such as non-distinctiveness, abandonment or bad faith.

Copyright claims require proof that copyright subsists, that the plaintiff owns it and that the defendant reproduced a substantial part of the work or did another act reserved to the owner. A certificate of registration is evidence of subsistence and ownership under s. 53(2) of the Copyright Act. Defences include fair dealing, the specific technology exceptions and licence.

Counterfeits and the border

The Combating Counterfeit Products Act added civil and criminal measures against counterfeit goods. Owners of registered trademarks and copyright can file a request for assistance with the Canada Border Services Agency; under the Trademarks Act this is done under s. 51.04. Border officers can then detain suspect shipments and share information with the owner, who must start proceedings within a short time to keep the goods detained. Owners should keep requests current and supply product identification guides to make detentions more likely.

Industrial designs and confidential information

Industrial design registrations protect the visual features of a finished article, and infringement claims follow a similar path in the Federal Court. Disputes over confidential information and trade secrets, by contrast, are usually heard in provincial courts because they rest on contract, equity or, in Quebec, the Civil Code. They often involve former employees or business partners and move quickly, with early motions for injunctions and for the return of documents. Where a former employee has also copied code or documents, a combined claim for copyright infringement and breach of confidence can be advantageous.

Interim relief and preserving evidence

Interlocutory injunctions are available in IP litigation but are harder to obtain in Canada than many foreign clients expect. Courts apply the three-part test from RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 S.C.R. 311: a serious issue to be tried, irreparable harm that cannot be compensated in damages, and a balance of convenience favouring the order. The Federal Court has historically required clear, non-speculative evidence of irreparable harm, which is often difficult in patent cases where damages can be calculated. Trademark and confidentiality cases involving loss of control over reputation or secrets are sometimes stronger candidates.

Other tools include interim preservation orders, Norwich orders to obtain information from third parties such as platforms, and, in exceptional cases, Anton Piller orders permitting a search of the defendant's premises to preserve evidence. Each demands strong evidence and full disclosure by the moving party. A party that obtains an order without notice to the other side must disclose all material facts, including those that hurt its case, or risk having the order set aside with costs.

Practical point

If you want an injunction, move quickly and prepare your irreparable harm evidence before you sue. Delay in bringing the motion is one of the most common reasons Canadian courts refuse interim relief, and a weak record on harm is difficult to fix later.

Summary judgment and early resolution

Not every case needs a full trial. The Federal Court Rules allow motions for summary judgment and summary trial where the issues can be fairly decided on a written record, which can suit straightforward trademark or copyright disputes. Mediation and dispute resolution conferences led by a judge or associate judge are also available and frequently produce settlements, including licences, coexistence agreements and phased exits from infringing products.

Remedies in IP litigation

A successful plaintiff in IP litigation may obtain a permanent injunction, delivery up or destruction of infringing goods, and either damages or an accounting of the defendant's profits. The choice between damages and profits is an equitable election made after liability is decided, often following a reference on quantum.

In Nova Chemicals Corp. v. Dow Chemical Co., 2022 SCC 43, the Supreme Court upheld an accounting of profits and confirmed that a patentee can recover "springboard" profits that the infringer earned after the patent expired because the infringement gave it a head start. The Court also addressed the role of non-infringing alternatives, holding that the infringer's argument failed on the facts.

Statutory and punitive damages

In copyright cases, the owner may elect statutory damages under s. 38.1 instead of damages and profits: CAD 500 to CAD 20,000 per work for commercial infringements, and CAD 100 to CAD 5,000 for all non-commercial infringements. Under s. 53.2 of the Trademarks Act, the court may award punitive damages and order destruction of goods. Costs are generally awarded to the successful party in Canada, which raises the stakes for both sides and encourages early, realistic settlement discussions.

Running an IP litigation file efficiently

Well-run IP litigation in Canada starts before the claim is issued. A rights holder should confirm title and any licences, check that maintenance and renewal fees were paid, gather evidence of infringement and damages, and consider whether a demand letter will help or simply invite a declaratory action. A defendant should preserve documents, map the claims or marks against its product, look for prior art or prior use, and consider design-around options that limit exposure.

  1. Pleadings: claim and counterclaim, often with particulars of invalidity.
  2. Discovery: production of relevant documents and examinations of party representatives.
  3. Experts: independent experts on claim construction, validity and damages, bound by a code of conduct.
  4. Trial: before a single judge, often bifurcated between liability and quantum.
  5. Appeal: to the Federal Court of Appeal, and with leave to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Parallel proceedings in other countries are common. Coordinating claim positions, expert evidence and settlement strategy across jurisdictions avoids inconsistent positions that the other side can exploit. Alternative dispute resolution, including mediation and arbitration of licence disputes, is also available, although the validity of a patent as against the world can only be decided by the Federal Court.

Budgeting deserves attention early. Patent cases with several experts and a damages reference are significant investments, and the loser usually contributes to the winner's legal costs. Insurance policies, litigation funding and contingency arrangements with counsel are all options to consider. For licensing disputes that are mainly commercial, a contractual dispute resolution clause providing for arbitration may give confidentiality and speed, although arbitral awards bind only the parties.

Foreign rights holders and cross-border issues

Many plaintiffs in Canadian IP litigation are foreign companies. A few features of the Canadian system surprise them. First, a foreign corporation without assets in Canada may be ordered to post security for the defendant's costs. Second, documentary discovery is broad: parties must produce relevant documents, including documents held by affiliates where they are within the party's control, and witnesses are examined under oath before trial. Third, because costs follow the event, an unsuccessful foreign plaintiff can face a meaningful adverse costs award.

Evidence and judgments also cross borders. Canadian courts can issue letters of request to obtain evidence abroad, and a Canadian money judgment can usually be recognized in other common-law jurisdictions. Foreign judgments are enforced in Canada through provincial recognition rules, but foreign patent rulings do not decide Canadian validity or infringement, because each patent is national and Canadian law on claim construction and obviousness differs in important respects. Prosecution histories, expert reports and admissions made in foreign proceedings can, however, be used in Canada, so positions taken abroad must be consistent with the Canadian case.

Online and platform enforcement

For online infringement, Canadian courts have granted orders requiring third parties to help identify anonymous infringers or to disable access to infringing services. Copyright owners can also use the notice-and-notice regime, which requires internet intermediaries to forward notices of claimed infringement. These tools complement, rather than replace, a claim against the person actually responsible.

How TRW & Co helps

We help rights holders and defendants plan and manage IP litigation in Canada. That includes pre-action assessments, demand letters and responses, coordinating litigation counsel called to the relevant bar, expert selection, settlement and licensing strategy, and aligning Canadian proceedings with litigation elsewhere. We also advise on border measures against counterfeits and on disputes over trademarks, copyright and confidential information. For broader litigation strategy, see our commercial litigation page. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a dispute, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Should I sue for patent infringement in the Federal Court or a provincial court?

Most patentees choose the Federal Court because its judgments and injunctions apply across Canada and its judges hear many IP cases. Provincial superior courts can hear infringement claims under s. 54 of the Patent Act and are useful for mainly contractual disputes, but only the Federal Court can declare a patent invalid against everyone.

How long does IP litigation take in Canada?

It varies with complexity. PM(NOC) actions are managed so that trial occurs within the 24-month stay. Other patent actions often take longer, especially if liability and damages are tried separately. Trademark and copyright cases can sometimes be resolved faster through summary proceedings or motions for summary judgment.

Can I get an injunction quickly against an infringer?

Interim injunctions are available but demanding. The moving party must show a serious issue, irreparable harm and a favourable balance of convenience, and courts expect concrete evidence of harm that damages cannot repair. Moving promptly and preparing evidence in advance improves the chances.

What monetary remedies are available?

Successful plaintiffs may elect damages or an accounting of the defendant's profits, which can include springboard profits. Copyright owners can instead choose statutory damages under s. 38.1. Punitive damages are available in serious cases, and the successful party usually recovers part of its legal costs.

What can I do about counterfeit goods entering Canada?

Owners of registered trademarks and copyright can file a request for assistance with the Canada Border Services Agency. Officers may then detain suspected counterfeits and share information, and the owner must promptly start court proceedings to keep the goods detained. Product identification guides help officers spot fakes.

Sources

  1. Federal Courts Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. F-7), s. 20
  2. Patent Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. P-4)
  3. Trademarks Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. T-13)
  4. Copyright Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. C-42)
  5. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Nova Chemicals Corp. v. Dow Chemical Co., 2022 SCC 43

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.