Skip to content

Guide · Disputes and Litigation

Securities Litigation and Regulatory Enforcement in Canada

Securities litigation in Canada combines statutory secondary market class actions, provincial regulatory enforcement and shareholder disputes. This guide explains the leave test and liability caps under Part XXIII.1 of the Ontario Securities Act, the 2025 Lundin Mining decision on material change, OSC and AMF enforcement powers and practical steps for issuers and investors.

10 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • Secondary market claims under s. 138.3 OSA need no proof of reliance but require leave of the court.
  • Leave requires good faith and a reasonable possibility of success at trial, a real evidentiary screen.
  • An issuer's liability limit is the greater of 5% of market capitalization and CAD 1 million.
  • Lundin Mining, 2025 SCC 39, reads 'material change' broadly, widening timely disclosure exposure.
  • The Capital Markets Tribunal can impose penalties of up to CAD 5 million per failure to comply.

Securities litigation in Canada at a glance

Securities litigation in Canada covers three overlapping arenas: civil claims by investors, most often brought as class actions; enforcement proceedings by provincial securities regulators; and corporate disputes in which shareholders invoke the oppression remedy or challenge a transaction. Each arena has its own decision-maker, burden of proof and remedies, but they frequently arise from the same facts. A single disclosure problem can lead to a regulator's investigation, a proposed class action in two or three provinces and a shareholder dispute over the board's response, all at once.

Trading screens and court filings illustrating securities litigation and regulatory enforcement in Canada
A disclosure problem at a reporting issuer can trigger parallel class actions, regulatory investigations and shareholder disputes.

Canada has no national securities regulator. Each province and territory has its own securities statute and commission, coordinated through the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) and national instruments. In practice the Ontario Securities Act (OSA) sets the pattern for most secondary market litigation, while Quebec's Securities Act and the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) follow a parallel but distinct path. This page explains the main causes of action, the enforcement toolkit, the leading Supreme Court of Canada decisions and how issuers, directors and investors can prepare.

The stakes are significant. Issuers face damages claims measured against market capitalization, directors face personal exposure, and regulators can impose administrative penalties, trading bans and disgorgement orders. Securities litigation also tends to move quickly at the outset: the leave motion, the certification motion and the regulator's first requests for information often arrive within months of the triggering event.

Secondary market liability under Part XXIII.1

Before 2005, investors who bought shares in the secondary market had to prove that they relied on a misrepresentation, which made class actions difficult to certify. Part XXIII.1 of the OSA, and equivalent provisions in the other provinces, removed that obstacle. Section 138.3 OSA gives a statutory right of action, without proof of reliance, against a responsible issuer and certain related defendants where a document or public oral statement contains a misrepresentation, or where the issuer fails to make timely disclosure of a material change.

Who can be sued

Depending on the type of disclosure, the potential defendants include the responsible issuer, its directors and officers who authorized, permitted or acquiesced in the release, "influential persons" such as control persons, and experts whose reports were included with their consent. The statute gives defendants other than the issuer a due diligence defence where they conducted a reasonable investigation and had no reasonable grounds to believe that the document contained a misrepresentation.

The leave requirement

No action under s. 138.3 can begin without leave of the court. Under s. 138.8(1), the court grants leave only if the action is brought in good faith and there is a reasonable possibility that it will be resolved at trial in favour of the plaintiff. In Theratechnologies inc. v. 121851 Canada inc., 2015 SCC 18, the Supreme Court of Canada described this as a real screening mechanism: the plaintiff must offer a plausible analysis of the legislation and credible evidence, not just pleaded allegations. The parties file affidavits and may cross-examine, so the leave motion is often the decisive event in securities litigation.

Liability limits and proportionate liability

Damages under Part XXIII.1 are capped. For a responsible issuer, the "liability limit" is the greater of 5% of its market capitalization and CAD 1 million. For a director or officer, it is the greater of CAD 25,000 and 50% of the individual's total compensation from the issuer and its affiliates. Liability is generally proportionate to each defendant's responsibility, but the caps and proportionate liability fall away for a defendant other than the issuer who knowingly authorized, permitted or acquiesced in the misrepresentation (s. 138.7(2) and s. 138.6(2)).

Limitation period

Section 138.14 sets a short limitation period. For a misrepresentation in a document, the action must be commenced no later than the earlier of three years after the document was first released and six months after a news release disclosing that leave has been granted in Ontario or under comparable legislation elsewhere. Because leave must be obtained first, plaintiffs typically issue a statement of claim and bring the leave motion together, and limitation arguments are common.

Primary market and offering memorandum claims

Investors who buy in a distribution have separate statutory rights. Under s. 130 OSA, a purchaser under a prospectus containing a misrepresentation has a right of action for damages, again without proof of reliance, against the issuer or selling security holder, the underwriters, the directors and those who signed the prospectus. Section 130.1 OSA provides a similar right where an offering memorandum used in an exempt distribution contains a misrepresentation. These claims do not require leave, but they carry their own defences, including the due diligence defence for underwriters and directors, and their own limitation periods.

Common law claims, such as negligent misrepresentation, remain available alongside the statutory causes of action. They require proof of reliance, which makes them harder to certify as class actions, but they can matter for individual institutional investors with documented reliance and for claims against parties outside the statutory list of defendants.

Practical point

The leave motion is fought on evidence. Issuers should preserve disclosure committee minutes, drafts of the impugned documents, analyst communications and board materials as soon as a claim is threatened. A well-documented disclosure process is often the best answer to the "reasonable possibility" test and to the due diligence defence for individual directors and officers.

Material change and the Lundin Mining decision

Many securities litigation cases turn on whether an event was a "material change" that required immediate disclosure by news release and material change report, or merely a "material fact" that could wait for periodic disclosure. In Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39, decided on 28 November 2025, the Supreme Court of Canada held that "change in the business, operations or capital" should be read broadly and allowed an investor's secondary market claim to proceed. The decision makes it harder for issuers to treat operational events, such as a pit-wall instability at a mine, as outside the timely-disclosure obligation.

For issuers, the practical consequence is that disclosure committees should test significant operational developments against the material change definition, document the reasons for their conclusion and revisit that conclusion as facts develop. Our analysis of the case is in Lundin Mining and the meaning of material change, and our guidance on disclosure systems is on the continuous disclosure compliance page.

Securities class actions and procedure

Most secondary market claims proceed as class actions. In Ontario, the Class Proceedings Act, 1992, as amended in 2020, requires the court to be satisfied that a class proceeding is the preferable procedure, which now includes findings that it is superior to all reasonably available alternatives and that common issues predominate over individual issues (s. 5(1.1)). In Quebec, authorization under art. 575 of the Code of Civil Procedure applies, and the Quebec Securities Act has its own leave requirement for secondary market claims, which the Supreme Court in Theratechnologies held to be more demanding than the general authorization test.

Securities litigation increasingly crosses provincial and national borders. Issuers listed in Canada and the United States may face parallel claims in both countries, and Canadian claims are often filed in Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia at the same time. Coordinating carriage, leave motions and settlement approval across jurisdictions is a large part of the work. See our pages on class actions and multi-jurisdictional class actions.

StageWhat happensKey rule
Claim issuedStatement of claim pleading s. 138.3 and common law claimss. 138.14 OSA limitation periods
Leave motionAffidavits, cross-examinations, expert evidence on materialityGood faith and reasonable possibility of success, s. 138.8
Certification or authorizationCourt decides whether the case proceeds as a class actionOntario CPA s. 5; Quebec art. 575 C.C.P.
Discovery and trialDocuments, examinations, damages modellingStatutory damages formula and liability limits, ss. 138.5–138.7
SettlementCourt approval requiredNo discontinuance or settlement without approval, s. 138.10

Regulatory enforcement: OSC, AMF and other commissions

Securities regulators investigate insider trading, tipping, market manipulation, misleading disclosure, illegal distributions and registrant misconduct. In Ontario, the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) investigates and prosecutes, while contested public interest proceedings are heard by the Capital Markets Tribunal. Under s. 127 OSA, the Tribunal may make orders in the public interest, including cease trade orders, removal of exemptions, director and officer bans, an administrative penalty of up to CAD 5 million for each failure to comply with Ontario securities law, and disgorgement of amounts obtained through non-compliance.

Quasi-criminal prosecutions are also available. Under s. 122 OSA, making a misleading statement in a filed document or contravening Ontario securities law can lead, on conviction, to a fine of up to CAD 10 million, imprisonment of up to five years less a day, or both. Insider trading and market manipulation are also Criminal Code offences in the most serious cases.

Regulators coordinate closely. Reciprocal orders allow one commission to adopt another's sanctions, and the Supreme Court in Sharp v. Autorité des marchés financiers, 2023 SCC 29, confirmed that a Quebec tribunal had jurisdiction over individuals outside Quebec whose manipulation scheme had a sufficient connection to the province. Public interest orders and their limits are discussed in our insight on public interest orders in securities enforcement.

Responding to an investigation

  • Clarify whether the request is a voluntary inquiry, a compelled interview or a summons under an investigation order, and what confidentiality obligations apply.
  • Issue a litigation hold immediately and identify custodians, devices and messaging apps.
  • Assess whether an internal investigation is needed and structure it to protect solicitor-client and litigation privilege.
  • Consider the interaction with any class action: documents produced to a regulator, and admissions in a settlement, can surface in civil proceedings.
  • Evaluate early whether cooperation or a settlement agreement is in the issuer's interest and how it will be disclosed to the market.

Oppression remedy and M&A litigation

Not all securities litigation is about disclosure. Shareholders, creditors and other stakeholders may seek relief under the oppression remedy in s. 241 of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) or its provincial equivalents where the corporation's conduct is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial to or unfairly disregards their interests. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the Supreme Court held that the question is whether the claimant had a reasonable expectation that was violated by unfair conduct, and that directors owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation while considering the interests of affected stakeholders.

In public M&A, litigation often takes place on compressed timetables. Typical disputes include challenges to plans of arrangement at the fairness hearing, applications to the securities commissions about defensive tactics or the conduct of a take-over bid, and claims about related party transactions and minority approval. Our public M&A and take-over bids page covers the transactional rules, and our insight on the oppression remedy explains the remedy in more depth.

Defending and preparing for securities litigation

Good preparation reduces both the likelihood and the cost of securities litigation. For reporting issuers, the main levers are disclosure governance, insurance and crisis readiness.

  1. Disclosure governance. Maintain a written disclosure policy, an active disclosure committee and a record of materiality decisions, particularly for operational setbacks, guidance changes and regulatory developments.
  2. Insurance. Review directors' and officers' liability insurance for entity securities coverage, investigation costs, retentions and the allocation between insured and uninsured defendants.
  3. Crisis response. Prepare a playbook for a sudden adverse event: who decides whether to halt trading, who drafts the news release and who speaks to analysts.
  4. Evidence. Preserve documents early and manage internal communications carefully once a dispute is foreseeable.
  5. Coordination. Align positions taken with regulators, in civil proceedings and in public statements, since each can be used in the others.

Investors and institutional shareholders face a different set of questions: whether to participate in a class action or opt out, how to preserve trading records, whether to bring an individual claim and how to approach a regulator with information. In each case the timing rules in the securities statutes and the limitation rules described above are central to securities litigation strategy.

Illustration: a hypothetical TSX-listed miner announces a production shortfall and its share price falls 30%. Within weeks, plaintiffs' counsel file proposed class actions in Ontario and Quebec alleging the company knew of ground instability months earlier. The issuer must respond to leave motions in both provinces, manage a parallel request for information from the OSC and decide whether its earlier quarterly disclosure was adequate. After Lundin Mining, the question whether the instability was a "change in operations" will be argued on detailed technical evidence.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise issuers, directors, officers, underwriters and investors on Canadian securities litigation and regulatory enforcement. Our work includes assessing exposure after a disclosure event, preparing for leave and certification motions, coordinating multi-jurisdictional class actions, responding to OSC, AMF and other commission investigations, conducting privileged internal investigations, and advising on oppression and M&A disputes. Where a matter must be argued before a Canadian court or tribunal, we work with Canadian-licensed litigation counsel and coordinate strategy across proceedings. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a specific situation, please contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Do investors have to prove reliance in a Canadian secondary market claim?

No. The statutory right of action in s. 138.3 of the Ontario Securities Act, and its equivalents in other provinces, does not require proof that the investor relied on the misrepresentation. In exchange, the plaintiff must obtain leave of the court, damages are calculated under a statutory formula, and liability is capped for most defendants unless they knowingly took part in the misrepresentation.

What is the leave test for a securities class action in Ontario?

Under s. 138.8(1) OSA, the court grants leave only if the action is brought in good faith and there is a reasonable possibility that it will be resolved at trial in favour of the plaintiff. The Supreme Court of Canada in Theratechnologies, 2015 SCC 18, held that the test is a meaningful screen requiring credible evidence and a plausible legal analysis, not just allegations.

How long do investors have to sue for a misrepresentation?

For a misrepresentation in a document, s. 138.14 OSA requires the action to be commenced by the earlier of three years after the document was first released and six months after a news release disclosing that leave has been granted. Similar periods apply to oral statements and failures to make timely disclosure, so investors and issuers should track dates carefully.

What sanctions can the OSC seek in an enforcement case?

In public interest proceedings before the Capital Markets Tribunal, orders can include trading bans, removal of exemptions, director and officer bans, administrative penalties of up to CAD 5 million for each failure to comply with Ontario securities law, and disgorgement. Separately, prosecutions under s. 122 OSA can lead to fines of up to CAD 10 million and imprisonment.

Can directors be personally liable in securities litigation?

Yes. Directors and officers who authorized, permitted or acquiesced in a misrepresentation can be named in a secondary market action. Their liability is normally capped at the greater of CAD 25,000 and 50% of their compensation, and they can rely on a due diligence defence, but the cap does not apply if they acted knowingly.

Sources

  1. Securities Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. S.5 (Ontario e-Laws)
  2. Theratechnologies inc. v. 121851 Canada inc., 2015 SCC 18
  3. Supreme Court of Canada: Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39 (Case in Brief)
  4. Canada Business Corporations Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. C-44)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.