Skip to content

Guide · Disputes and Litigation

Commercial Litigation in Canada: Courts, Remedies and Strategy

Commercial litigation in Canada rewards early preparation. Limitation periods are short, documentary production is broad, losing parties usually pay part of the winner's costs, and the Supreme Court has recently tightened the duties of good faith in contracts and the consequences of destroying evidence. This page explains the courts, the main causes of action, urgent remedies, summary judgment and enforcement.

10 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • Contractual discretion and termination rights must be exercised in good faith (Callow, 2020 SCC 45; Wastech, 2021 SCC 7).
  • The oppression remedy, such as s. 241 CBCA, protects shareholders' and creditors' reasonable expectations.
  • Ontario's basic limitation period is two years from discovery, and the ultimate period is 15 years.
  • Summary judgment is available where there is no genuine issue requiring a trial (Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7).
  • Courts presume that evidence destroyed or hidden by a party was unfavourable to it (SS&C, 2026 SCC 29).

Commercial litigation in Canada: an overview

Commercial litigation in Canada takes place mostly in the provincial superior courts, such as the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, the Supreme Court of British Columbia, the Court of King's Bench of Alberta and the Superior Court of Québec. These courts have inherent jurisdiction over contract, tort, corporate and restitution claims, and they supervise insolvency proceedings. Appeals go to each province's court of appeal and, with leave, to the Supreme Court of Canada. The Federal Court hears claims within federal jurisdiction, such as intellectual property infringement and claims against the federal Crown.

Litigation team preparing evidence binders for commercial litigation before an Ontario court
Canadian commercial cases are won on documents, which makes preservation and production central from the first day.

Procedure is set by each province's rules of court. A typical action in a common-law province moves through pleadings, documentary production, oral examinations for discovery, mediation in some jurisdictions, pre-trial conferences and trial before a judge alone. Juries are rare in commercial cases. Most actions settle; those that go to trial can take several years. Costs usually follow the event, so the unsuccessful party typically pays a portion of the winner's legal costs, and formal offers to settle can shift that exposure.

Quebec follows a different civil procedure under its Code of Civil Procedure, with a case protocol agreed at the outset and stricter limits on pre-trial examinations. Commercial litigation in Quebec also applies the Civil Code's rules on contracts, good faith and prescription.

Before proceedings start

The months before a claim is issued often decide how commercial litigation unfolds. A business that anticipates a dispute should preserve documents, review notice and dispute resolution clauses, comply with any contractual escalation or mediation steps, and calculate limitation periods. Demand letters should be accurate and measured, because they will be exhibits later. Where the counterparty is insolvent or near insolvency, the strategy may shift to securing assets, asserting set-off rights or participating in a restructuring rather than suing. And where the contract contains an arbitration clause, a court action will usually be stayed, so the choice of forum is not open.

Contract and shareholder disputes

Good faith in contractual performance

Canadian contract law imposes duties of good faith that parties cannot simply draft around. In C.M. Callow Inc. v. Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45, the Supreme Court held that even an unrestricted right to terminate on notice must be exercised honestly, and that a party breaches the duty of honest performance by knowingly misleading its counterparty about matters directly linked to performance. In Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7, it held that contractual discretion must be exercised reasonably, in a manner connected to the purposes for which it was granted.

In Quebec, Ponce v. Société d'investissements Rhéaume ltée, 2023 SCC 25 applied the Civil Code's duty of good faith to company presidents who concealed information from their counterparties.

These decisions mean that termination for convenience, discretionary pricing or allocation clauses and "sole discretion" approvals are not unlimited. Commercial parties should keep a record of the business reasons for exercising discretion and avoid misleading statements while a termination is being planned.

Sale of goods and exclusion clauses

Exclusion and limitation of liability clauses are generally enforced between sophisticated parties, but courts read them carefully. In Earthco Soil Mixtures Inc. v. Pine Valley Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 20, the Supreme Court clarified what is required for a contract to exclude the conditions implied by Ontario's Sale of Goods Act. Drafting matters: an exclusion clause should name the implied conditions it is intended to displace.

Shareholder disputes and the oppression remedy

Shareholder disputes in private companies commonly involve deadlock, exclusion of a minority shareholder from management, dilution, unpaid dividends or disputed buy-outs.

The oppression remedy, found in s. 241 of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) and in the provincial corporate statutes, allows a court to remedy conduct that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or that unfairly disregards the interests of, any security holder, creditor, director or officer. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the Supreme Court framed the inquiry around the reasonable expectations of the stakeholder and whether the conduct complained of breached them. Courts have broad remedial powers, including ordering a buy-out at fair value, setting aside transactions and appointing a receiver. Shareholder agreements with clear dispute resolution, valuation and shotgun clauses reduce the scope for this kind of commercial litigation.

Injunctions and urgent relief

Commercial disputes often begin with an urgent motion. Canadian courts can grant interlocutory injunctions to preserve the status quo pending trial, for example to enforce confidentiality obligations, restrain a breach of a restrictive covenant, or prevent termination of a critical supply contract. The applicant generally must show a serious issue to be tried, that it will suffer irreparable harm if relief is refused, and that the balance of convenience favours an order; for mandatory injunctions, which require a party to act, a strong prima facie case is required. The applicant usually must give an undertaking to pay damages if the injunction turns out to have been wrongly granted.

Two extraordinary remedies are available on strict conditions. A Mareva injunction freezes a defendant's assets where there is a strong case and a real risk that assets will be dissipated to defeat a judgment. An Anton Piller order permits the search of premises and seizure of evidence without notice where there is a real possibility the evidence will be destroyed. Both require full and frank disclosure by the applicant, and courts can set them aside, with damages, if that duty is breached.

Practical point

Urgent motions are decided on affidavit evidence prepared in days. Keep contracts, correspondence and key business records organized so that a sworn record can be assembled quickly, and identify in advance who in the business can give first-hand evidence about the relationship in dispute.

The Commercial List and summary judgment

In Toronto, the Superior Court of Justice operates a Commercial List for specialized commercial matters, including proceedings under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act and the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, receiverships, oppression applications, plans of arrangement and other corporate disputes. Matters on the Commercial List are case-managed by judges with commercial experience, and many proceed by application on a written record with cross-examinations rather than by a full trial. Other provinces have comparable commercial practices, and their courts have embraced case management for complex disputes.

Summary judgment allows a court to decide a case without a full trial where there is no genuine issue requiring one. In Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7, decided on 23 January 2014, the Supreme Court called for a culture shift toward proportionate, timely and affordable procedures, and held that summary judgment should be granted where the judge can make the necessary findings of fact and apply the law to them on the motion record, using the expanded fact-finding powers in Ontario's rules where needed. Summary judgment and partial summary judgment are now regular tools in commercial litigation, although courts are cautious about deciding parts of a case where the remaining issues will need a trial anyway.

Experts and trial

Complex commercial cases usually turn on expert evidence about damages, valuation, accounting, industry practice or technical issues. Experts owe their primary duty to the court, must be independent and must sign an acknowledgment of that duty under the rules in most provinces. Their reports are disclosed in advance, and courts scrutinize assumptions closely. Engaging experts early, and separating consulting experts from testifying experts, helps shape the theory of the case and the documentary record. Trials in commercial cases are heard by a judge alone, and the reasons for judgment, which explain the court's findings, are the basis for any appeal.

Appeals

Appeals from final orders of superior courts go to the provincial court of appeal as of right in most cases, and interlocutory orders may require leave. Appellate courts review questions of law for correctness and findings of fact or mixed fact and law for palpable and overriding error, so the trial record largely determines what can be argued on appeal. Further appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada requires leave, which is granted only for issues of public importance.

Limitation periods and commercial litigation risk

Limitation periods are one of the most common reasons claims fail. Under Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002, a claim must be commenced within two years of the day it was discovered (s. 4), meaning the day the claimant knew or ought reasonably to have known of the injury, its cause, the defendant's involvement and that a proceeding would be appropriate. An ultimate limitation of 15 years from the act or omission applies regardless of discovery (s. 15). In Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32, the Supreme Court held that investors' claims against a company operating a Ponzi scheme were not statute-barred, illustrating how discoverability is applied to complex facts.

Other provinces have their own statutes with different periods and exceptions, and in Quebec, art. 2925 of the Civil Code provides that an action to enforce a personal right is generally prescribed by three years. Contracts may shorten or extend limitation periods in some circumstances, and certain statutory claims have their own deadlines. A second claim for relief already decided is barred by res judicata; in Patrick Street Holdings Ltd. v. 11368 NL Inc., 2026 SCC 15, the Supreme Court held that a party could not bring a second claim to sale proceeds whose division had already been decided.

JurisdictionBasic periodUltimate or long-stop periodSource
Ontario2 years from discovery15 years from the act or omissionLimitations Act, 2002, ss. 4 and 15
Quebec3 years for personal rights (general rule)Varies by claimCivil Code of Québec, art. 2925
Other provincesGenerally 2 years from discoveryVariesProvincial limitations statutes

Evidence, privilege and enforcement

Parties to Canadian commercial litigation must produce all relevant documents in their possession, control or power, whether helpful or harmful, subject to privilege and proportionality. Electronic documents, chat messages and personal devices used for business are included. In SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, decided on 31 July 2026, the Supreme Court held that where a party intentionally destroys, changes, hides or fails to keep relevant evidence to influence the outcome of a lawsuit, courts must presume that the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to that party, and have discretion over the remedy. A litigation hold should be issued as soon as a dispute is reasonably anticipated.

Solicitor-client privilege and litigation privilege are strongly protected. Communications with in-house counsel are privileged only when they seek or give legal advice, not business advice, so legal and business discussions should be kept distinct. Common-interest privilege can protect information shared with parties who share a legal interest, such as co-defendants or parties to a transaction.

A judgment is only as good as its enforcement. Canadian judgments can be enforced through garnishment, seizure and sale of property, and examinations in aid of execution, and judgments from one province can be registered or enforced in another. Foreign money judgments are generally enforceable by action if the foreign court had a real and substantial connection to the dispute and no defence such as fraud, breach of natural justice or public policy applies. Defendants should also consider the risk of having to post security or face asset-preservation orders.

Illustration (hypothetical): a European manufacturer terminates a ten-year Canadian distribution agreement on 90 days' notice, relying on a termination-for-convenience clause, while telling the distributor for months that the relationship would be renewed. The distributor sues in Ontario. Even if the clause permits termination, the distributor may claim damages for breach of the duty of honest performance under Callow, measured by what it lost by being misled, such as the opportunity to find another supplier. The manufacturer's internal emails about the termination plan will be producible, and any deleted messages could support a spoliation presumption.

Foreign parties and forum clauses

For international businesses, commercial litigation in Canada often starts with a jurisdiction fight. Canadian courts assume jurisdiction over a foreign defendant only where there is a real and substantial connection between the claim and the province, and they will generally enforce a valid forum selection clause unless the plaintiff shows strong reasons not to. A foreign defendant that wants to contest jurisdiction must take care not to attorn by taking steps on the merits first. Contracts with Canadian counterparties should therefore specify governing law and forum clearly, address service of process and consider arbitration where enforcement abroad matters.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise Canadian and international businesses on commercial litigation risk and strategy. We assess contract and shareholder claims early, review termination and discretion decisions against the duties of good faith, plan urgent relief, manage litigation holds and document collection, analyze limitation periods across provinces, and develop settlement and enforcement strategy. Court appearances require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work alongside counsel of record and the client's in-house team. This page is general information, not advice on any dispute. To discuss a commercial dispute, contact us, or see our disputes overview, our international arbitration page and our insight on interlocutory injunctions.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a duty of good faith in Canadian contracts?

Yes. Parties must perform contracts honestly and exercise contractual discretion reasonably and in line with its purpose. In Callow, 2020 SCC 45, the Supreme Court held that even an unrestricted termination right must be exercised without actively misleading the other party, and in Wastech, 2021 SCC 7, it addressed the reasonable exercise of discretion.

What is the Commercial List?

It is a specialized part of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Toronto that hears complex commercial matters, including CCAA and bankruptcy proceedings, receiverships, oppression applications and plans of arrangement. Cases are case-managed by judges experienced in commercial law, and many proceed on written records rather than full trials.

When can a commercial case be decided by summary judgment?

When there is no genuine issue requiring a trial. In Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7, the Supreme Court held that summary judgment is appropriate where the judge can make the necessary findings of fact and apply the law on the motion record, and encouraged proportionate procedures in civil litigation.

How long does a business have to start a claim in Ontario?

Generally two years from the day the claim was discovered, under s. 4 of the Limitations Act, 2002, and in any event no later than 15 years after the act or omission (s. 15). Other provinces have different statutes, and Quebec's general prescription period for personal rights is three years.

What happens if a party deletes relevant emails before litigation?

If the destruction was intentional and aimed at influencing litigation, it is spoliation. Following SS&C Technologies v. BNY Mellon, 2026 SCC 29, courts must presume the missing evidence was unfavourable to the party responsible and can choose an appropriate remedy, so prompt litigation holds are essential.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Canada: C.M. Callow Inc. v. Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45 (Case in Brief)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada: Wastech Services Ltd. v. GVS&DD, 2021 SCC 7 (Case in Brief)
  3. Ontario: Limitations Act, 2002
  4. Canada Business Corporations Act, s. 241
  5. Supreme Court of Canada: SS&C Technologies v. BNY Mellon, 2026 SCC 29 (Case in Brief)
  6. Supreme Court of Canada: Hryniak v. Mauldin (docket 34641)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.