Freedom of Information Requests and Confidential Business Information
Freedom of information requests can expose bids, filings and pricing that businesses give to governments. Canadian access laws protect confidential commercial information and give third parties notice and objection rights, but the deadlines are short and the burden of proof sits with the business.

Key takeaways
- Section 20(1) ATIA requires withholding trade secrets and confidential commercial information supplied by third parties.
- Third parties have 20 days to make representations and 20 days to apply to the Federal Court.
- Merck Frosst (2012 SCC 3) places the burden on the objecting business and requires a reasonable expectation of probable harm.
- Quebec requires written notice to third persons within 20 days of a request.
- Protection depends on how information is marked, explained and treated when first supplied.
Freedom of information requests: what businesses need to know
Freedom of information requests allow anyone, including competitors, journalists and activists, to ask governments for records they hold, and those records often include information that businesses supplied. Bids, regulatory filings, inspection reports, grant applications, contract pricing and clinical data can all be requested. Canadian access statutes protect confidential commercial information through mandatory third-party exemptions, and they give businesses a right to notice and to object before disclosure. Those rights are short-lived: under the federal Access to Information Act (ATIA), a third party has 20 days to make representations and 20 days to go to court after a decision to disclose.

The practical lesson is that protection is won or lost long before a request arrives. How information is marked, explained and treated when it is submitted largely determines whether it can be withheld later. This guide explains the federal regime, the main provincial differences including Quebec, and the steps businesses should take when they supply information and when they receive a notice.
The federal third-party information exemption
Section 20(1) ATIA requires the head of a government institution to refuse to disclose records containing:
- (a) trade secrets of a third party;
- (b) financial, commercial, scientific or technical information that is confidential, supplied to a government institution by a third party, and treated consistently in a confidential manner by the third party;
- (b.1) certain information supplied in confidence for emergency management plans about the vulnerability of the third party's buildings, networks or systems;
- (c) information whose disclosure could reasonably be expected to result in material financial loss or gain to, or prejudice the competitive position of, a third party; and
- (d) information whose disclosure could reasonably be expected to interfere with contractual or other negotiations of a third party.
The exemption is mandatory: if it applies, the institution must withhold. But it is subject to limits. Section 20(2) prevents the exemption from being used to withhold the results of product or environmental testing carried out by or for a government institution, with exceptions, and s. 20(6) allows disclosure of some information in the public interest relating to health, safety or environmental protection where that interest clearly outweighs the harm to the third party.
The Supreme Court's guidance in Merck Frosst
In Merck Frosst Canada Ltd. v. Canada (Health), 2012 SCC 3 (judgment of 3 February 2012, SCC docket 33320), the Supreme Court of Canada set out how these exemptions work in practice. The third party objecting to disclosure bears the burden of showing, on a balance of probabilities, that an exemption applies. For the harm-based exemptions in s. 20(1)(c) and (d), the standard is a reasonable expectation of probable harm: more than possible or speculative, but not proof that harm is more likely than not.
The Court also held that institutions must give notice where there is reason to believe a record might contain exempt information, and that information already publicly available is not confidential. The decision remains the leading authority on third-party objections to freedom of information requests.
Notice, representations and timelines
The ATIA gives third parties procedural rights, but on tight timelines.
| Step | Provision | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Institution notifies third party of request and intention to disclose | s. 27(1) | Every reasonable effort within 30 days after the request is received |
| Third party makes written representations | s. 28(1)(a) | Within 20 days after notice is given |
| Institution decides whether to disclose and notifies | s. 28(1)(b) | Within 30 days after notice is given |
| Third party applies to the Federal Court for review | s. 44(1) | Within 20 days after notice of the decision |
A third party can waive notice or consent to disclosure (s. 27(2)). If the third party does nothing, the institution can release the records once the time for review has passed. Notices are often sent to a generic corporate address or to the individual who submitted the original filing years earlier, so businesses need a reliable internal route for these letters.
Treat every third-party notice as litigation with a 20-day limitation period. Assign an owner the day it arrives, collect the original submission and evidence of how it was kept confidential, and prepare line-by-line objections tied to each paragraph of s. 20(1). Generic claims that "all of this is commercially sensitive" rarely succeed.
Challenging a disclosure decision in court
A third party that receives notice of a decision to disclose can apply to the Federal Court under s. 44(1) ATIA within 20 days. The institution should not release the contested record while a timely review application is pending, and the requester is notified and may take part as a party (s. 44(2)-(3)). The Court reviews whether the exemption applies, and the third party must prove it with evidence: affidavits explaining what the information is, why it is confidential, how it has been protected, and what specific harm disclosure would cause. Confidential evidence can be filed under protective arrangements. The usual outcome is an order confirming or overturning the decision to disclose particular passages.
Partial wins are common. Courts often order disclosure of most of a document with specific pricing, technical details or personal information redacted. That makes it worth objecting precisely rather than broadly, and offering redactions that the institution can accept without litigation.
Freedom of information requests in the provinces and Quebec
Every province has its own access statute for provincial ministries, agencies and often municipalities, universities and hospitals. The structure is similar to the federal Act, but the tests differ in important ways.
- Ontario: the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA) and its municipal counterpart protect third-party information through a three-part test: the information must be a trade secret or scientific, technical, commercial, financial or labour relations information; supplied in confidence, implicitly or explicitly; and its disclosure must be reasonably expected to cause one of the listed harms. All three parts must be met.
- Quebec: under ss. 23 and 24 of the Act respecting access to documents held by public bodies and the protection of personal information, a public body may not release industrial secrets or confidential industrial, financial, commercial, scientific, technical or union information supplied by a third person and ordinarily treated as confidential, or information whose release would likely hamper negotiations, cause losses or substantially reduce the third person's competitive margin, without consent. Under ss. 25 and 49, the public body must give written notice within 20 days of the request and an opportunity to submit written observations.
- Other provinces: British Columbia, Alberta and others use variations of the three-part test, with their own review bodies (information and privacy commissioners) and appeal routes.
Unlike the federal system, where the Federal Court decides third-party objections, many provincial regimes route disputes first through an information and privacy commissioner, whose orders can then be judicially reviewed. Timelines and evidentiary standards differ, so a national business should keep a short guide to each regime it deals with regularly. Municipal records deserve particular attention: development applications, property tax appeals and municipal contracts are frequent subjects of freedom of information requests, and municipal access statutes often have their own notice rules and shorter internal timelines.
Vexatious requests and business requesters
Businesses also use freedom of information requests themselves, to learn about competitors' approvals, government procurement or enforcement policy. Requesters should know that the ATIA allows an institution, with the Information Commissioner's written approval, to decline to act on a request that is vexatious, made in bad faith or otherwise an abuse of the right of access (s. 6.1). Several provinces have similar powers. Requests that are clearly targeted, explain their scope and avoid repetition are processed faster and are less likely to be refused.
Federal institutions also proactively publish some information under Part 2 of the ATIA, such as contracts and grants above certain values. Businesses that contract with government should assume that headline information about their contracts will become public and focus protection efforts on the detail that truly matters.
Freedom of information requests in regulated sectors
Some industries face freedom of information requests far more often than others. Pharmaceutical and medical device companies file extensive data with Health Canada; energy, mining and infrastructure proponents file environmental studies and Indigenous consultation records with federal and provincial regulators; and defence and technology suppliers submit detailed technical proposals in procurements. In each case, a portion of the material is already destined for publication under program rules, and the rest may be requested.
Sector rules can change the analysis. Some statutes contain their own confidentiality provisions that override or supplement access laws, and some regulators publish summaries of decisions or clinical information under specific policies. Businesses should map the confidentiality rules of each regulator they deal with, decide what they are prepared to see published, and prepare redacted versions in advance where a public version is likely to be required. That preparation also makes responses to freedom of information requests faster and more credible, because the business has already explained which passages are sensitive and why.
Protecting information when it is supplied
The best defence to freedom of information requests is built at the time of submission. Practical steps include:
- Mark and segregate. Label confidential pages and put the most sensitive information in separate schedules that can be withheld without redacting the whole document.
- Explain confidentiality. Include a short cover statement explaining why the information is confidential, how it is protected internally and what harm disclosure would cause.
- Keep it confidential in practice. Consistent internal treatment is part of the test. Information shared freely with partners or posted in investor materials will be hard to protect.
- Negotiate contract terms. Government contracts usually acknowledge access legislation; negotiate notice and cooperation clauses, while recognizing that a contract cannot override the statute.
- Keep a register. Track what was supplied, to which institution, and who the contact is, so notices can be answered quickly.
For public procurement specifically, see our page on infrastructure, P3 and procurement. For life sciences companies, whose regulatory submissions are frequent targets, see life sciences and health.
How TRW & Co helps
We help businesses protect confidential information supplied to Canadian governments and respond to freedom of information requests. We prepare confidentiality statements for regulatory filings and bids, respond to third-party notices with targeted representations, and support judicial review applications and commissioner proceedings, working with locally licensed counsel where a court filing requires it. We also help companies make well-framed requests of their own. Our work connects with our appellate and public law practice and our privacy team; see also our insight on software as a medical device for regulatory submissions. To discuss a notice, contact us. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can a competitor obtain my company's government filings?
They can request them. Whether the records are released depends on the exemptions in the applicable access statute. Trade secrets and confidential commercial, financial, scientific or technical information supplied in confidence are protected, as is information whose release could cause material financial loss or competitive harm, but the business must prove the exemption applies.
How long do I have to respond to a third-party notice?
Under the federal Access to Information Act, a third party has 20 days after notice is given to make written representations. If the institution then decides to disclose, the third party has 20 days after notice of that decision to apply to the Federal Court for review. Provincial deadlines vary.
What is the test for harm under the federal Act?
In Merck Frosst Canada Ltd. v. Canada (Health), 2012 SCC 3, the Supreme Court held that the objecting third party must show, on a balance of probabilities, a reasonable expectation of probable harm: more than speculative, but not proof that harm is more likely than not.
Does a confidentiality clause in a government contract prevent disclosure?
Not on its own. Access statutes override contracts, although a confidentiality clause can help show that information was supplied in confidence. Businesses should also negotiate notice and cooperation clauses so that they learn of requests promptly.
How does Quebec protect third-party information?
Quebec's access statute prohibits public bodies from releasing industrial secrets and confidential commercial and technical information supplied by a third person, or information whose release would cause listed harms, without consent. The public body must notify the third person in writing within 20 days of the request and allow written observations.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


