Skip to content
Intellectual Property

Non-Traditional Trademarks: Colour, Sound, Shape and Scent

Non traditional trademarks such as colours, shapes, sounds and scents have been registrable in Canada since June 2019. Most require evidence of acquired distinctiveness at filing, none can be registered if dictated primarily by a utilitarian function, and each must be represented precisely.

Coloured product packaging and a bottle shape illustrating non traditional trademarks in Canada

Key takeaways

  • The Trademarks Act's definition of sign includes colour, shape, sound, scent, taste, texture, holograms and moving images.
  • Single colours, shapes, packaging, sounds, scents, tastes and textures require evidence of distinctiveness under s. 32(1).
  • Marks whose features are dictated primarily by a utilitarian function are not registrable.
  • Registrations are restricted to the goods, services and territory where distinctiveness is proven.
  • Narrow, precise descriptions make non-traditional marks easier to register and enforce.

Non traditional trademarks in Canada: the short answer

Non traditional trademarks, such as colours, sounds, three-dimensional shapes, scents, tastes, textures, holograms, moving images and the positioning of a sign, can be registered in Canada. Since the amendments to the Trademarks Act that came into force on 17 June 2019, the definition of "sign" in s. 2 expressly includes each of them.

Registration is harder than for word marks, however. Under s. 32(1), applicants must file evidence that the mark is distinctive at the filing date if it consists exclusively of a single colour or a combination of colours without delineated contours, or exclusively or primarily of a three-dimensional shape of the goods or their packaging, a mode of packaging, a sound, a scent, a taste or a texture. And under s. 12(2), no mark is registrable if its features are dictated primarily by a utilitarian function.

Coloured product packaging and a bottle shape illustrating non traditional trademarks in Canada
Colours, shapes, sounds and scents can be registered, but usually only with evidence of acquired distinctiveness.

For fashion, consumer goods, food and beverage and technology businesses, non traditional trademarks can protect the features customers actually recognize: a product's distinctive colour, the shape of a bottle, a start-up chime or a store's trade dress. This article explains the legal tests, the evidence the Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) expects, how to represent these marks in an application, and how they are enforced.

What signs can be registered

Section 2 of the Act defines a "sign" to include "a word, a personal name, a design, a letter, a numeral, a colour, a figurative element, a three-dimensional shape, a hologram, a moving image, a mode of packaging goods, a sound, a scent, a taste, a texture and the positioning of a sign". A trademark is a sign or combination of signs used or proposed to be used to distinguish one person's goods or services from others'. The list is inclusive, but each type raises different practical issues.

Type of markEvidence of distinctiveness required under s. 32(1)?Main challenges
Single colour or colour combination without delineated contoursYes (s. 32(1)(c))Consumers rarely see colour alone as a brand; colour depletion arguments
Colour applied to a defined shape or designOnly if the examiner considers it not inherently distinctivePrecise description of the colour and its placement
Three-dimensional shape of goods or packagingYes, if exclusively or primarily the shape (s. 32(1)(d)(i))Utilitarian function; consumers see shapes as product features
Mode of packagingYes (s. 32(1)(d)(ii))Common packaging forms in the trade
SoundYes (s. 32(1)(d)(iii))Representation; showing consumers recognize the sound as a brand
Scent, taste, textureYes (s. 32(1)(d)(iv)-(vi))Representation; functionality (a scent that is the product)
Hologram, moving image, positioningDepends on preliminary view of inherent distinctiveness (s. 32(1)(b))Clear description of the sign and its placement

Inherent and acquired distinctiveness

Section 32(1)(b) also requires evidence whenever the Registrar's preliminary view is that a mark is not inherently distinctive. In practice, many non traditional trademarks will attract that view, because consumers are generally not accustomed to treating colours, shapes or sounds alone as indicators of source. The applicant must then prove that the mark had acquired distinctiveness at the filing date in Canada, and under s. 32(2) the registration will be restricted to the goods or services, and the territorial area in Canada, for which distinctiveness is shown.

Evidence that works

Evidence of acquired distinctiveness usually needs to show that consumers recognize the sign itself, not just the product or the word mark used with it. Useful evidence includes:

  • long and consistent use of the sign in Canada, with sales and market share figures;
  • "look for" advertising that draws consumers' attention to the colour, shape or sound as the brand;
  • media coverage and third-party references identifying the sign with the owner;
  • properly designed consumer surveys of the relevant Canadian public; and
  • evidence that competitors avoid the sign or have been required to change it.

Evidence focused on the word mark, or showing the sign only alongside a dominant word mark, is less persuasive. Applicants should plan marketing so that it builds and documents recognition of the non traditional element itself.

Utilitarian function and functionality

Section 12(2) bars registration of any trademark whose features are dictated primarily by a utilitarian function in relation to the goods or services. A shape that makes a product work better, a colour that signals a technical property, or a sound that is the natural result of a mechanism cannot be monopolized as a trademark, however well known it is. The policy is to keep functional features in the domain of patents, which are time-limited, rather than trademarks, which can last indefinitely. The Act also provides that registration does not prevent others from using any utilitarian feature embodied in the trademark.

The functionality bar is a frequent battleground for shape marks. Owners should be careful about advertising that emphasizes the technical benefits of the claimed shape, and about relying on expired patents that describe the same feature, since that evidence can support a functionality objection.

Representing non traditional trademarks in an application

An application must define the mark precisely. The Trademarks Regulations require a representation of the trademark and, for certain types, a description. For a colour mark, the application should identify the colour, ideally by reference to a recognized colour system, and the area of the goods or packaging on which it appears. Three-dimensional marks are represented through drawings or photographs showing the shape from relevant angles, with a description.

Sound marks are filed with an audio file and a description, and moving images, holograms and positioning marks need images and descriptions sufficient to identify the sign. Scents, tastes and textures can only be described in words, which makes them hard to define and enforce. Examiners may raise objections where a description is ambiguous, so applicants should test the description against the question of whether a competitor could tell, from the register alone, what it must avoid.

Practical point

Draft the description as narrowly as the brand allows. A precise description of a colour on a specific part of a product is easier to register and to enforce than a claim to a colour for a whole class of goods. Use dotted lines to show unclaimed product features in shape and positioning marks.

Fashion and consumer goods examples

Non traditional trademarks are most valuable in sectors where trade dress drives purchasing decisions. Illustrations of the kinds of features brand owners try to protect include:

  • Fashion: a distinctive colour on a specific part of a shoe or garment, a recognizable stitching pattern or a signature closure, protected through colour, positioning or shape marks.
  • Food and beverage: bottle shapes, packaging configurations and distinctive colour schemes on packaging.
  • Consumer electronics: start-up sounds, product shapes and moving-image logos.
  • Retail and hospitality: store layouts and trade dress, which can be protected through registrations and through the common law of passing off.

Not every feature can be registered. Shapes that are standard in a category, colours that indicate product type (such as a flavour) and features with a technical function are unlikely to succeed. Owners should combine registrations with unregistered rights, which protect trade dress through passing off where the owner can prove goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, and, for new shapes, with industrial design registrations; see our insight on industrial design protection.

Non traditional trademarks across borders

Brand owners usually protect the same feature in several countries, and approaches differ. Some jurisdictions are more willing than others to accept colour or shape marks, and representation rules vary, particularly for scents and sounds. Evidence of distinctiveness is also territorial: recognition of a colour in Europe or the United States does not prove distinctiveness in Canada, although spill-over reputation through Canadian travellers, online sales and media can help. Because s. 32(2) restricts registration to the territory in Canada where distinctiveness is shown, a brand that is well known in one region but not nationally may obtain only a regionally limited registration.

Applicants claiming priority from a foreign application should check that the foreign representation and description meet Canadian requirements. A colour mark described by a foreign colour code, for example, may need clarification of where the colour is applied. The safest approach is to prepare a Canadian application with its own description, informed by but not copied from foreign filings.

Building an evidence programme from launch

Because most non traditional trademarks need evidence of acquired distinctiveness, the work starts long before filing. A practical programme might include: keeping dated samples of products and packaging showing the feature; tracking Canadian sales and advertising spend for products bearing it; running marketing that tells consumers to "look for" the colour or shape; collecting unsolicited media and social media references; and commissioning periodic recognition research. When the evidence is strong enough, the applicant files with an affidavit that tells a coherent story about how Canadian consumers came to see the feature as a brand.

Enforcing non traditional trademarks

Registered non traditional trademarks are enforced like other marks, through infringement, confusion and depreciation of goodwill claims under the Trademarks Act and passing off at common law. Enforcement raises particular questions about scope: whether a competitor's similar but not identical colour, shape or sound is confusing, and whether consumers would see it as a brand at all. Opposition proceedings are a key battleground, since competitors often oppose applications for non traditional marks on grounds of non-distinctiveness and utilitarian function. See our insights on trademark oppositions and anti-counterfeiting and border measures.

Building a strategy for non traditional trademarks

A practical strategy combines several steps. Identify the non-word features customers actually use to recognize the brand. Decide which can be registered now, which need a few years of evidence-building, and which are better protected by industrial design or copyright. Begin collecting evidence of recognition from launch, including dated advertising and sales data for Canada. File narrowly described applications, and consider separate applications for different combinations of features. Finally, police use by competitors consistently, since tolerance of similar features can undermine distinctiveness and make it harder to rely on the feature as a brand in later disputes. See our page on trademarks and brands and our retail and consumer sector page.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise brand owners on non traditional trademarks in Canada. We help identify protectable features, design evidence programmes for acquired distinctiveness, prepare applications with registered trademark agents, respond to examiner objections on distinctiveness and functionality, and enforce or defend marks in oppositions and litigation alongside Canadian-licensed counsel. We also coordinate trademark, design and copyright protection for products and packaging. To discuss a colour, shape or other brand feature, contact us. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Can a colour be registered as a trademark in Canada?

Yes. A colour or colour combination is a sign under the Trademarks Act. If the mark consists exclusively of colour without delineated contours, the applicant must file evidence that it was distinctive at the filing date. Colour applied to a defined shape or position is often easier to register.

Can a product shape be a trademark?

Yes, but the applicant must show acquired distinctiveness if the mark consists exclusively or primarily of the shape of the goods or packaging, and the shape cannot be registered if its features are dictated primarily by a utilitarian function. Industrial design registration may be an alternative.

How are sound marks filed?

Sound marks are filed with an audio file and a description of the sound. Because the Act requires evidence of distinctiveness for marks consisting exclusively or primarily of sounds, applicants should be ready to show that Canadian consumers recognize the sound as identifying their goods or services.

What evidence proves acquired distinctiveness?

Evidence that Canadian consumers recognize the sign itself as a brand: long and consistent use, sales figures, look-for advertising focused on the feature, media references, properly designed surveys and evidence that competitors avoid the feature. Evidence centred on an accompanying word mark is less persuasive.

When did Canada start registering non-traditional marks?

The amended Trademarks Act, which expressly lists colours, shapes, sounds, scents, tastes, textures, holograms, moving images and positioning as signs, came into force on 17 June 2019. Some non-traditional marks, such as sounds, were accepted under earlier practice in limited cases.

Sources

  1. Trademarks Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. T-13
  2. Trademarks Regulations, SOR/2018-227
  3. CIPO, Trademarks

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.