Skip to content
Banking, Finance & Fintech

PPSA Security Interests: Attachment, Perfection and Priority

PPSA security interests protect lenders only if they attach, are perfected in the right province and keep their priority. This note explains attachment, perfection by registration, possession and control, purchase-money priority, serial numbers, conflict-of-laws rules for multi-province debtors and the errors that most often cost lenders their security.

Lender reviewing a personal property registry search to confirm PPSA security interests and priority

Key takeaways

  • PPSAs apply to any transaction that in substance creates security, plus some account transfers and long leases.
  • Attachment requires value, rights in the collateral and a signed agreement or possession or control.
  • Unperfected interests are subordinate to perfected ones and ineffective against a bankruptcy trustee.
  • Ontario gives non-inventory PMSIs priority if perfected within 15 days after the debtor gets possession.
  • Intangibles are governed by the law of the debtor's location; Quebec uses movable hypothecs instead.

How PPSA security interests work

In every Canadian province and territory except Quebec, security over personal property is governed by a Personal Property Security Act (PPSA). PPSA security interests arise from any transaction that in substance secures payment or performance of an obligation, whatever its form: a general security agreement, a chattel mortgage, a conditional sale, a pledge, a floating charge or a lease that secures payment. Each PPSA is provincial, so a lender must look at the statute of the province whose law governs the collateral. The Acts are similar but not identical, and the differences matter in practice.

Lender reviewing a personal property registry search to confirm PPSA security interests and priority
Attachment makes a security interest enforceable; perfection protects it against third parties; priority rules decide who is paid first.

Three concepts structure the analysis. Attachment makes PPSA security interests enforceable against the debtor and is a precondition to enforceability against third parties. Perfection, usually by registration, possession or control, protects the secured party against competing creditors, purchasers and a trustee in bankruptcy. Priority rules decide the order in which competing interests in the same collateral are paid. This note uses the Ontario Personal Property Security Act (OPPSA) for section references and flags where the western PPSAs differ.

The PPSA applies to more than secured loans. In Ontario, s. 2 also brings in transfers of accounts and chattel paper, even if they do not secure an obligation, and leases of goods for a term of more than one year, even if they are true leases. Factoring and receivables purchase programs and long-term equipment leases therefore need PPSA registrations even where no one thinks of them as security.

Attachment

Under s. 11 OPPSA, a security interest is not enforceable against a third party unless it has attached. It attaches when value is given, the debtor has rights in the collateral (or the power to transfer rights in it), and either the debtor has signed a security agreement containing a description of the collateral sufficient to identify it, or the collateral is in the secured party's possession or control. These steps can occur in any order.

Descriptions matter. A general security agreement typically describes "all present and after-acquired personal property", which is sufficient for most purposes. For consumer goods and some specific categories, a more specific description is required. Lenders that take security over particular assets, such as a single piece of equipment, should still describe them clearly in both the agreement and the registration.

Perfecting PPSA security interests: registration, possession and control

A security interest is perfected under s. 19 OPPSA when it has attached and all steps required for perfection have been completed, regardless of order. The main methods are:

MethodCollateralOntario provisionKey point
Registration of a financing statementAny type of collateralss. 23 and 45Registration can precede the security agreement, except for consumer goods
PossessionGoods, instruments, negotiable documents of title, money, certificated securitiess. 22Possession by the secured party or a bailee on its behalf, not the debtor
ControlInvestment property (securities, securities accounts)s. 22.1Control agreement with the securities intermediary or issuer; priority over registration
Temporary perfectionProceeds, goods released for limited purposesss. 24 and 25Short periods; registration needed to continue perfection

Registration is the default. A financing statement is filed in the provincial personal property registry against the debtor's exact legal name, with a collateral classification and, in some cases, a general collateral description. In Ontario, the registration period is chosen at the time of filing and must be renewed before expiry. Unperfected PPSA security interests are subordinate to perfected interests and to the interests of persons who seize the collateral or acquire it for value, and under s. 20 OPPSA they are ineffective against a trustee in bankruptcy or another person representing the debtor's creditors. Combined with the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), that means an unregistered lender in a bankruptcy usually becomes an unsecured creditor.

Serial numbers

For serial-numbered goods, especially motor vehicles, trailers, aircraft that are not covered by the Cape Town regime, and some equipment, the PPSAs have special rules. In the western provinces, serial-numbered goods held as consumer goods or as equipment must generally be described by serial number for the registration to be effective against certain third parties. In Ontario, the regulations require a vehicle identification number for motor vehicles in specified cases. A one-character error can defeat the registration against buyers and other secured parties who search by serial number.

Priority rules and purchase-money security interests

The residual priority rule in s. 30(1) OPPSA is "first to register": between security interests perfected by registration, priority goes by order of registration, regardless of the order of perfection or attachment. A lender that registers before it lends can therefore protect its future priority. Where one interest is perfected by registration and another otherwise, the earlier of registration or perfection generally governs.

The most important exception is the purchase-money security interest (PMSI), which secures credit used to acquire the collateral, such as a vendor's retained title or a lender financing the purchase price. Under s. 33 OPPSA:

  • Inventory: a PMSI has priority over a prior general security interest if it was perfected when the debtor obtained possession of the inventory, and before then the PMSI holder gave written notice to every secured party that had previously registered a financing statement covering the same type of inventory, inventory generally or accounts.
  • Other collateral (such as equipment): a PMSI has priority if it was perfected before or within 15 days after the debtor obtained possession. The western PPSAs use similar but not identical periods.

Other special rules give priority to buyers of goods in the ordinary course of business, to holders of investment property with control, to certain holders of chattel paper and instruments, and to statutory liens and deemed trusts created by federal or provincial legislation. Those non-consensual claims, such as Crown deemed trusts for source deductions, can outrank a perfected security interest and are a major focus for asset-based lenders.

Practical point

Search before you lend, register before you advance, and search again after registering to confirm the registration appears exactly as filed. Diary renewal dates, track changes in the debtor's name and jurisdiction, and file amendments within the statutory grace periods. Most lost priority disputes start with a registration that was correct on day one but not maintained.

Conflict of laws for multi-province debtors

Because each province has its own PPSA, the first question in any multi-province financing is which province's law governs perfection and priority. The general rule is that the law of the place where tangible collateral is situated governs. For intangibles (including accounts receivable), mobile goods normally used in more than one jurisdiction, and certain other collateral, s. 7 OPPSA applies the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor is located when the security interest attaches.

Ontario's location rule in s. 7(3) places a corporation or limited partnership incorporated or organized under the law of a province in that province, and a federally incorporated corporation in the province of its registered office or head office as set out in its constating documents. An individual is located at his or her principal residence. The western PPSAs use comparable but not identical location tests, including in some provinces a chief executive office test. A borrower with assets across Canada will therefore need registrations in the province of its location and in each province where tangible collateral is kept, and lenders should re-check location after any amalgamation or continuance.

Quebec

Quebec has no PPSA. Security over movable property is created by a movable hypothec under the Civil Code of Québec (C.C.Q.) and published in the Register of Personal and Movable Real Rights (RDPRM). The concepts and terminology differ: a hypothec must be granted in writing for a specific sum, a hypothec on a universality of property is common, and enforcement follows the Civil Code's prior notice and hypothecary rights regime. Lenders to borrowers with Quebec assets need Quebec-specific documents.

Enforcing PPSA security interests

Perfection and priority only matter if the security can be enforced. Part V of each PPSA sets out the secured party's remedies on default: taking possession, collecting receivables directly from account debtors, selling or leasing the collateral, or retaining it in satisfaction of the debt (foreclosure) after notice. Before a sale, the secured party must generally give the debtor and other interested parties notice, and every step must be commercially reasonable. Debtors and subordinate creditors can redeem the collateral or reinstate the agreement within the statutory windows.

Federal insolvency law adds another layer. Under s. 244 of the BIA, a secured creditor that intends to enforce on all or substantially all of the inventory, accounts receivable or other property of an insolvent business debtor must send a prescribed notice and generally cannot enforce until ten days after sending it, unless the debtor consents. Many lenders therefore enforce PPSA security interests through a court-appointed receiver, which gives them a stay of competing proceedings and court approval of the sale process.

Common perfection errors lenders make

  1. Wrong debtor name. Registering against a trade name, an abbreviation or a name with a typing error. Most registries search by exact name, so a seriously misleading error is fatal.
  2. Missed jurisdictions. Registering only where the borrower has its head office, not where it is located for PPSA purposes or where inventory and equipment are kept.
  3. Lapsed registrations. Failing to renew before expiry, which can lose priority to intervening creditors.
  4. Change of name or location. Not amending after an amalgamation, name change, continuance or transfer of collateral, within the grace periods the PPSAs allow.
  5. Investment property. Relying on registration over pledged shares or securities accounts when a competing creditor has control.
  6. PMSI notices. Failing to give inventory PMSI notice to prior registered secured parties before delivery.
  7. Serial numbers. Omitting or mistyping a serial number for vehicles and serial-numbered equipment.

Illustration (hypothetical): a lender takes a general security agreement from a federally incorporated distributor with its registered office in Ontario and warehouses in Alberta and British Columbia. It registers in Ontario for receivables and intangibles, and in Alberta and British Columbia for inventory and equipment located there. When the borrower amalgamates with an affiliate, the lender files amendments in all three registries under the new name within the grace period, preserving its priority against later creditors.

How TRW & Co helps with PPSA security interests

We advise lenders, borrowers and investors on PPSA security interests across the common-law provinces. That includes structuring security packages, preparing security agreements and control agreements, running PPSA and other searches, reviewing registrations and priority positions, and advising on enforcement. Where a registration, opinion or Quebec hypothec requires a Canadian-licensed lawyer or Quebec notary, we coordinate with licensed counsel. Our lending and acquisition finance and receiverships and enforcement work covers related issues; see also our notes on asset-based lending and equipment finance. To discuss a transaction, contact us. This note is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between attachment and perfection?

Attachment makes a security interest enforceable against the debtor; it requires value, the debtor's rights in the collateral and a signed security agreement or possession or control. Perfection is the extra step, usually registration, that protects the secured party against competing creditors, buyers and a trustee in bankruptcy.

Does registration before the loan protect priority?

Yes. Under the residual first-to-register rule in s. 30(1) of the Ontario PPSA, priority between security interests perfected by registration follows the order of registration, regardless of when they attached or were perfected. Lenders commonly register a financing statement before advancing funds.

How does a purchase-money security interest get priority?

For equipment and other non-inventory collateral in Ontario, the PMSI must be perfected before or within 15 days after the debtor obtains possession. For inventory, it must be perfected when the debtor obtains possession and written notice must be given beforehand to prior registered secured parties covering inventory or accounts.

Which province's PPSA applies to receivables?

Receivables are intangibles, so the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor is located when the security interest attaches governs. In Ontario, a provincially incorporated corporation is located in its province of incorporation and a federal corporation where its registered office or head office is located.

How is security taken in Quebec?

Quebec has no PPSA. Security over movable property is created by a movable hypothec under the Civil Code of Québec and published in the Register of Personal and Movable Real Rights. Hypothecs must be granted for a specific sum, and enforcement follows the Civil Code's hypothecary rights regime.

Sources

  1. Personal Property Security Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.10 (Ontario)
  2. Personal Property Security Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 359 (British Columbia)
  3. Civil Code of Québec (movable hypothecs)
  4. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.