Skip to content
Banking, Finance & Fintech

Equipment Finance and Leasing in Canada

Equipment finance in Canada turns on a few legal questions: whether a lease is a true lease or a security lease, whether the lessor has registered, and what happens if the lessee becomes insolvent. This note covers the PPSA treatment of leases, rolling stock and fleet issues, residual value, GST/HST and lessor remedies.

Construction equipment yard with machines held under equipment finance leases in Canada

Key takeaways

  • PPSAs treat security leases as security interests and deem leases over one year to be within the Act.
  • Re Giffen shows an unperfected lessor can lose leased equipment to the lessee's trustee in bankruptcy.
  • Register before delivery to obtain purchase-money priority; Ontario allows 15 days for non-inventory PMSIs.
  • Rolling stock documents can be deposited with the Registrar General of Canada under s. 105 of the Canada Transportation Act.
  • CCAA s. 34 stops lessors terminating leases only because of the filing or pre-filing arrears.

Equipment finance in Canada: the basic choices

Equipment finance in Canada covers loans and leases that fund the acquisition of machinery, vehicles, technology, rolling stock, aircraft and other movable assets. Financiers include banks, captive finance companies of equipment manufacturers, independent lessors and private credit funds. The legal framework is mostly provincial: each common law province has a Personal Property Security Act (PPSA), Quebec applies the Civil Code of Québec, and specialized federal regimes govern railway rolling stock and, through the Cape Town Convention, aircraft. Tax law, including GST/HST and capital cost allowance, shapes how deals are priced. Consumer protection statutes add disclosure and cancellation rules where the lessee is an individual, so the same equipment finance product may need two sets of documents.

Construction equipment yard with machines held under equipment finance leases in Canada
Equipment can be financed by a secured loan, a conditional sale, a financing lease or a true operating lease, each with different PPSA and tax results.

The first decision in any equipment finance deal is the form. A secured loan or conditional sale gives the borrower ownership (or ownership on payment) with the financier holding a security interest. A lease keeps title with the lessor and gives the lessee a right to use the equipment for a term. Leases are further divided into "security leases" (sometimes called financing or capital leases), which in substance secure payment of the purchase price, and "true leases" (operating leases), where the lessor takes real residual value risk.

True leases versus security leases under the PPSA

The PPSAs apply to every transaction that in substance creates a security interest, regardless of form or of who holds title. A lease that secures payment or performance of an obligation is therefore a security interest, and the lessor is a secured party. Courts look at the economics: a nominal or bargain purchase option at the end of the term, a lease term covering most of the equipment's useful life, the lessee bearing all risk of loss and maintenance, and a lessee guarantee of residual value all point to a security lease.

True leases are also caught in part. In Ontario, s. 2(c) of the Personal Property Security Act applies the Act to a lease of goods for a term of more than one year even though it does not secure payment. The western PPSAs, including British Columbia's, contain a similar deemed security interest for a "lease for a term of more than one year", defined to include indefinite leases and short leases that the lessee may renew or that are held for more than a year. Those leases must be perfected, usually by registration, even if the lessor owns the equipment outright.

FormWho owns the equipmentPPSA treatmentTypical tax result for the user
Secured loanBorrowerSecurity interest; register to perfectBorrower claims capital cost allowance; interest deductible
Conditional saleBuyer on full paymentSecurity interest (often a purchase-money security interest)Buyer generally treated as owner for tax
Security (financing) leaseLessor in form; lessee in substanceSecurity interest; purchase-money priority availableDepends on terms; may be treated as a sale
True lease over one yearLessorDeemed security interest for perfection and priorityLessee deducts rent; lessor claims capital cost allowance (subject to leasing property rules)
True lease of one year or lessLessorGenerally outside the PPSALessee deducts rent

Registering lessor interests

The consequence of not registering can be total loss. In Re Giffen, [1998] 1 S.C.R. 91, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a lessor's unperfected security interest in a leased car was ineffective against the lessee's trustee in bankruptcy under the British Columbia PPSA, so the trustee, not the lessor, was entitled to the proceeds of sale. The lessor's ownership did not save it. The same reasoning applies to unperfected leases for more than one year in other PPSA provinces, and to security leases everywhere.

Good practice for equipment finance registrations includes:

  • registering before the lessee takes possession, so that purchase-money security interest (PMSI) priority is available. In Ontario, a non-inventory PMSI has priority if perfected before or within 15 days after the debtor obtains possession;
  • registering in the province where the equipment is located and, for mobile equipment used in several provinces (trucks, construction equipment), in the province where the lessee is located;
  • including serial numbers where the PPSA or its regulations require them, especially for motor vehicles, trailers and certain other serial-numbered goods;
  • registering against the lessee's exact legal name and updating after amalgamations or name changes; and
  • for leases to consumers, waiting until the agreement is signed, since registration before signing is restricted for consumer goods.

In Quebec, leases with a term of more than one year, instalment sales and sales with a right of redemption must be published in the Register of Personal and Movable Real Rights to be set up against third parties. A lessor that fails to publish within the required time may lose its rights against the lessee's creditors and a trustee.

Practical point

Treat every lease of more than one year as if it were a loan for registration purposes. Register before delivery, use serial numbers where relevant, check the lessee's location and name, and diarize renewals. The cost of a registration is trivial compared with losing title to a trustee.

Rail, fleet and specialized assets

Rolling stock. Railway rolling stock is subject to a federal deposit regime. Under s. 105 of the Canada Transportation Act, a lease, conditional sale, mortgage, hypothec or security agreement relating to rolling stock may be deposited with the Registrar General of Canada. Once deposited, the document need not be registered under any other law respecting real or personal property and is valid against all persons. Rail lessors and lenders typically deposit with the Registrar General and, for prudence, also consider PPSA registrations.

Fleets. Truck, trailer and car fleets are financed through master leases, often with schedules for each unit. Serial number registrations, provincial vehicle registration and insurance requirements, and the lessee's ability to sublease to drivers or affiliates all need attention.

Aircraft and engines. Airframes, aircraft engines and helicopters above specified thresholds are governed by the Cape Town Convention and Aircraft Protocol, which Canada has implemented. Interests are registered in the International Registry, and special insolvency rules apply.

Technology and software. Leases of IT equipment often bundle services and licences. The licence component may not be "goods" for PPSA purposes, and the lessor may need separate rights over software.

Vendor programs and portfolio financing

Manufacturers and dealers often offer equipment finance at the point of sale through vendor programs run by a captive finance company or a partner bank. The program agreement allocates credit risk, recourse to the vendor, remarketing obligations and responsibility for consumer disclosure. Lessors in turn fund their books by selling or pledging lease receivables in securitizations or warehouse facilities, which requires clean chains of title, PPSA registrations in the lessor's name with assignments recorded, and servicing arrangements that survive the lessor's insolvency. Equipment finance portfolios that are documented inconsistently are harder and more expensive to fund.

Residual value risk and GST/HST on leases

Residual risk is what distinguishes true lease equipment finance from lending. In a true lease, the lessor's return depends partly on the residual value of the equipment at lease end. Lessors manage this through conservative residual assumptions, manufacturer buy-back or remarketing agreements, return condition provisions, excess usage charges and, in some markets, residual value insurance. Lessees should understand that return condition clauses can impose significant costs, and that an end-of-term purchase option at fair market value is priced at the lessor's discretion unless a method is specified.

For indirect tax, a lease of tangible personal property is generally a taxable supply for GST/HST purposes, with tax charged on each lease payment at the rate applicable in the province where the equipment is delivered or made available, plus provincial sales tax in British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, and Quebec sales tax in Quebec.

Interest on a secured loan, by contrast, is generally an exempt financial service, while GST/HST is paid on the purchase price of the equipment. The difference affects cash flow for lessees that cannot fully recover input tax credits, such as financial institutions and some public sector bodies. For income tax, the leasing property rules and the specified leasing property rules in the Income Tax Act and its regulations can limit a lessor's capital cost allowance, so lessors model their tax position carefully before quoting a rate to the lessee.

Lessor remedies on default and insolvency

On default, a lessor or secured lender typically has the right to terminate the lease or accelerate the loan, repossess the equipment and sell or re-lease it. For security leases, Part V of the PPSA governs: the secured party must give notice before disposition, act in a commercially reasonable manner and account for any surplus. For true leases, the lessor's remedies depend mainly on contract and the common law, because the PPSA enforcement provisions are aimed chiefly at security interests that secure payment. In Quebec, a lessor enforcing against a lessee must follow Civil Code rules, including prior notice in some cases.

Insolvency changes the picture. Under s. 34 of the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), no person may terminate or amend an agreement, or accelerate payment, by reason only that CCAA proceedings have commenced or the company is insolvent, and a lessor may not terminate a lease only because pre-filing rent was not paid. The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act contains parallel rules for proposals. Lessors can, however, insist on payment for post-filing use of leased property. The debtor may also disclaim an agreement with court or monitor approval, after which the lessor can recover its equipment and claim its damages as an unsecured creditor.

Illustration (hypothetical): a manufacturer leases CNC machines for five years with a USD 1 purchase option. That is a security lease. The lessor registers a financing statement before delivery, gaining PMSI priority over the manufacturer's bank. When the manufacturer files under the CCAA, the lessor cannot terminate the lease because of the filing, but receives payments for post-filing use. When the plan proposes to keep the machines, the lessor negotiates its treatment as a secured creditor.

How TRW & Co helps with equipment finance

We advise lessors, lenders, manufacturers and lessees on equipment finance across Canada. That includes structuring loans, conditional sales and leases, master lease and vendor program documentation, PPSA, Quebec RDPRM and rolling stock registrations, tax-driven lease structures with Canadian tax advisers, and enforcement and insolvency strategy. Where a registration, opinion or court filing requires a Canadian-licensed lawyer or notary, we work with licensed counsel. Our structured finance and enforcement work covers related issues; see also our notes on PPSA security interests and aircraft finance. To discuss a transaction, contact us. This note is general information, not legal or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

Does a lessor need to register a true lease?

Often, yes. Ontario's PPSA applies to leases of goods for more than one year even if they do not secure payment, and the western PPSAs deem such leases to be security interests. An unregistered lessor can lose priority to other creditors and, as Re Giffen showed, to the lessee's trustee in bankruptcy.

What makes a lease a security lease?

Courts look at substance: a nominal purchase option, a term close to the equipment's useful life, the lessee bearing risk of loss and maintenance, and residual value guarantees by the lessee all suggest the lease secures payment of a price. A security lease is treated as a security interest under the PPSA.

How are railway cars financed in Canada?

Leases, conditional sales, mortgages and security agreements relating to rolling stock can be deposited with the Registrar General of Canada under s. 105 of the Canada Transportation Act. Once deposited, the document need not be registered under other property laws and is valid against all persons.

Is GST/HST charged on equipment leases?

Generally yes. A lease of tangible personal property is a taxable supply, so GST/HST, and provincial sales tax where applicable, is charged on each lease payment. Interest on a secured loan is generally an exempt financial service, but tax is paid on the equipment's purchase price instead.

Can a lessor terminate a lease when the lessee files under the CCAA?

Not because of the filing alone. Section 34 of the CCAA prevents termination, amendment or acceleration by reason only of the proceedings or insolvency, and prevents lease termination only for pre-filing rent arrears. Lessors can require payment for post-filing use, and the debtor may disclaim the lease with approval.

Sources

  1. Personal Property Security Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.10 (Ontario)
  2. Personal Property Security Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 359 (British Columbia)
  3. Re Giffen, [1998] 1 S.C.R. 91
  4. Canada Transportation Act, s. 105 (rolling stock)
  5. Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, s. 34

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.