Skip to content
Technology, Privacy & AI

CASL Consent Rules: Express vs Implied Consent

CASL consent decides whether a commercial email or text can lawfully be sent. Express consent lasts until withdrawn, while implied consent is limited to listed situations and often expires after six months or two years. The sender must prove it, so records matter as much as forms.

Email inbox with opt-in checkbox illustrating CASL consent rules for commercial messages in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Commercial electronic messages need express or implied consent, sender identification and an unsubscribe mechanism.
  • Implied consent from a purchase lasts two years; from an inquiry, only six months.
  • Unsubscribe requests must take effect within 10 business days, with contact details valid for 60 days.
  • The sender bears the onus of proving consent under s. 13 CASL.
  • Maximum penalties are CAD 1 million for individuals and CAD 10 million for organizations per violation.

CASL consent: the short answer

CASL consent is the starting point for every commercial email, text or direct message sent to or from Canada. Under s. 6 of Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), a commercial electronic message (CEM) may only be sent if the recipient has consented, expressly or by implication, and the message identifies the sender and includes a working unsubscribe mechanism. Express consent lasts until withdrawn. Implied consent exists only in the situations the Act lists, and several of them expire. The sender carries the burden of proving consent under s. 13.

Email inbox with opt-in checkbox illustrating CASL consent rules for commercial messages in Canada
Every commercial message needs a consent basis, sender identification and an unsubscribe link.

The stakes are real. Under s. 20(4), the maximum administrative monetary penalty for a violation is CAD 1 million for an individual and CAD 10 million for any other person. Under s. 31, directors and officers can be liable for corporate violations they directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in, and under s. 32 employers are liable for violations by employees acting within the scope of their employment. This guide covers the consent rules most marketing and legal teams need to get right.

What counts as a commercial electronic message

Under s. 1(2), a CEM is an electronic message that, having regard to its content, hyperlinks or contact information, it would be reasonable to conclude has as one of its purposes to encourage participation in a commercial activity. That includes offers, advertisements and promotions, and messages that promote a person's public image as someone who does business. The test looks at any purpose, not the main one, so a service email that ends with a promotional banner is a CEM. Under s. 1(3), an email asking for consent to send CEMs is itself a CEM, which is why a cold "may we add you to our list?" email sent without an existing consent basis contravenes the Act.

Section 10(1) CASL requires a person seeking express consent to set out "clearly and simply" the purpose for which consent is sought, prescribed information identifying the person seeking consent (and anyone on whose behalf it is sought), and any other prescribed information. The CRTC's Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations fill in the details. A request for consent must include:

  • the name of the person seeking consent and of any person on whose behalf it is sought, with a statement of which is which;
  • a mailing address, plus a telephone number, email address or web address; and
  • a statement that the person can withdraw consent.

Express consent can be obtained orally or in writing, but the sender must be able to prove it. In practice, that means an action the recipient takes themselves, such as ticking an unchecked box or typing an email address into a field that explains what they are signing up for. Bundling marketing consent into acceptance of general terms and conditions makes the purpose harder to show as clear and simple, and makes proof weaker.

Consent obtained by third parties

Section 10(2) allows consent to be sought on behalf of a person whose identity is not known, for example when a lead-generation partner collects consent for "our partners". The regulations then require that the original collector be identified in later messages and that the unsubscribe mechanism allow withdrawal from the collector and every authorized user. These arrangements need careful contracts and data flows.

Section 10(9) sets out the only situations in which consent is implied. They are narrower than many marketers assume.

Basis for implied consentRequirementTime limit
Existing business relationship: purchase, lease or barterRecipient bought, leased or bartered a product, service or interest in land from the senderTwo years before the message
Existing business relationship: business, investment or gaming opportunityRecipient accepted an opportunity offered by the senderTwo years
Existing business relationship: written contractContract on another matter is current or expiredTwo years after expiry
Existing business relationship: inquiry or applicationRecipient asked about or applied for a product, service or opportunitySix months
Existing non-business relationshipDonations, volunteering or membership with a charity, political or membership organization, club or associationGenerally two years
Conspicuous publicationAddress published without a "no unsolicited messages" statement; message relevant to the person's business roleNone stated
Disclosure to the senderRecipient gave the address without objecting; message relevant to business roleNone stated

The time limits are measured back from the day the message is sent, which means implied consent runs out quietly. A customer who bought once in 2024 and never again can no longer be emailed on that basis in 2027. Well-run programs record the date and type of each transaction or inquiry and convert implied consent to express consent while the window is open.

Conspicuous publication is narrower than it looks

Finding an email address on a website does not by itself create CASL consent. Under s. 10(9)(b), the address must have been published by or on behalf of the person, without a statement that they do not want unsolicited messages, and the message must relate to the person's business, role, functions or duties. A pitch for a payroll product to a published HR contact may qualify; a consumer promotion sent to the same address would not.

Exemptions: B2B, referrals and other excluded messages

Some messages are outside s. 6 entirely, or need no consent even though identification and unsubscribe rules still apply. The Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations made by the Governor in Council are the key source.

  • Business-to-business: s. 3(a)(ii) excludes messages sent by an employee, representative, consultant or franchisee of one organization to their counterpart at another organization, where the organizations have a relationship and the message concerns the activities of the receiving organization.
  • Internal messages: s. 3(a)(i) excludes messages within an organization about its activities.
  • Solicited messages: s. 3(b) covers messages sent in response to a request, inquiry or complaint.
  • Legal notices and enforcement: s. 3(c) covers messages sent to satisfy or give notice of a legal obligation, or to enforce a right.
  • Referrals: s. 4(1) exempts from the consent requirement the first message sent after a referral by someone with a qualifying relationship with both sender and recipient, provided the message names the referrer and says it follows a referral.
  • Charities and political messages: fundraising messages from registered charities and certain political messages are excluded.

Section 6(6) of the Act also lists messages that need no consent but must still identify the sender and include an unsubscribe mechanism, such as quotes requested by the recipient and factual information about an ongoing subscription or product the recipient uses.

Unsubscribe mechanics and withdrawal of CASL consent

Every CEM must contain an unsubscribe mechanism that meets s. 11(1). It must let the recipient opt out at no cost, using the same electronic means by which the message was sent or, if impractical, another electronic means, and it must specify an electronic address or web link where the request can be sent. The contact information must remain valid for at least 60 days after the message is sent (s. 6(3)).

Under s. 11(3), an unsubscribe request must be given effect without delay and in any event no later than 10 business days after it is sent, without further action by the recipient. That rules out unsubscribe flows that require logging in, confirming by return email or calling a number. The recipient may opt out of all CEMs or of a specified class, so preference centres are permitted as long as a "stop everything" option is easy to find.

Practical point

Treat withdrawal of CASL consent as a data event that must reach every system that sends messages, including affiliates, agencies and email service providers. Most enforcement problems arise not from the original consent but from suppression lists that are not synchronized across platforms.

Cross-border senders and CASL consent

CASL reaches foreign businesses. Under s. 12(1), a person contravenes s. 6 only if a computer system located in Canada is used to send or access the message. A message sent from a server in the United States and opened by a recipient in Toronto is therefore covered. Foreign companies with Canadian customers should apply CASL consent standards to Canadian contacts even when their home-country rules, such as an opt-out regime, are looser.

The reverse also applies in a limited way. The regulations exclude messages that a sender reasonably believes will be accessed in a listed foreign state, provided the message conforms to that state's law on substantially similar conduct. That exclusion helps Canadian businesses marketing abroad, but it does not help foreign senders targeting Canada. Where a global email platform serves several markets, the simplest approach is often to tag contacts by jurisdiction at collection and apply the strictest applicable consent rule to each segment.

Group structures raise a related issue. Consent given to one company does not automatically extend to its affiliates. If a parent company wants to market products of several subsidiaries to the same list, the consent request should name each entity or describe them so that the recipient understands who will contact them. Mergers and acquisitions add a further layer: a buyer of a business acquires its customer relationships, but the buyer should confirm through diligence that the seller's consent records exist and support the messages the buyer plans to send.

Record-keeping and proving CASL consent

Because s. 13 places the onus of proving consent on the person relying on it, CASL consent is ultimately a records problem. For each contact, a compliant system should be able to show:

  1. the basis of consent (express, or the specific type of implied consent);
  2. the date, time and channel of collection, and the form or script shown;
  3. for implied consent, the date of the transaction, contract or inquiry that starts the clock;
  4. any third-party collector and the contractual authorization to use its consent; and
  5. every unsubscribe request and the date it took effect.

Due diligence is a defence to a violation under s. 33, and a documented compliance program, staff training and periodic audits are the best evidence of it. Note that the private right of action in ss. 47 to 51 was repealed before it ever came into force, so enforcement in practice comes from the CRTC, the Competition Bureau and the Privacy Commissioner, each within its own mandate.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise businesses on CASL consent programs, from the wording of opt-in forms to the data architecture that records consent and processes unsubscribes. We review email, SMS and app-messaging campaigns, lead-generation and affiliate contracts, and referral programs, and we help companies respond to CRTC inquiries. Our CASL work sits alongside our advice on CASL and consumer protection and privacy and data protection, and we coordinate with retail and consumer clients' marketing teams. See also our insights on subscription contracts and loyalty programs. To review your program, contact us. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

How long does implied consent last under CASL?

It depends on the basis. An existing business relationship from a purchase, lease, barter, accepted opportunity or written contract supports implied consent for two years. An inquiry or application supports it for six months. Conspicuous publication and disclosure of an address have no fixed time limit but require the message to be relevant to the recipient's business role.

Does CASL apply to business-to-business emails?

Yes, but the regulations exclude messages sent by an employee or representative of one organization to someone at another organization where the two have a relationship and the message concerns the recipient organization's activities. Cold B2B outreach without such a relationship needs consent, often relying on conspicuous publication.

Can a pre-checked box give express consent?

Relying on one is risky. CASL places the onus of proving consent on the sender, and the purpose of the request must be set out clearly and simply. A box that the recipient actively ticks, with a clear description of the messages they will receive, is far easier to prove than a default setting the person never changed.

How quickly must an unsubscribe request be processed?

Without delay and no later than 10 business days after the request is sent, with no further action required by the recipient. The unsubscribe mechanism must be free, use the same electronic means where practicable, and the contact information in the message must remain valid for at least 60 days.

Can individuals sue for CASL violations?

Not under CASL itself. The private right of action in sections 47 to 51 was repealed before it ever came into force. Enforcement comes from the CRTC through administrative monetary penalties and undertakings, with the Competition Bureau and the Privacy Commissioner responsible for related provisions in their own statutes.

Sources

  1. Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (S.C. 2010, c. 23)
  2. Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations (CRTC), SOR/2012-36
  3. Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations, SOR/2013-221

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.