Skip to content
Corporate & M&A

Not-for-Profit Corporations: ONCA and CNCA Compliance

Not for profit corporations in Ontario and under federal law face detailed statutory rules on by-laws, member rights, special resolutions and audits. Ontario's three-year ONCA transition ended in October 2024. This guide compares the ONCA and CNCA, explains public benefit and soliciting status, and sets out directors' duties and the charity overlay.

Board meeting reviewing by-laws for not for profit corporations under the ONCA and CNCA

Key takeaways

  • Ontario's ONCA has applied since 19 October 2021; non-conforming documents were deemed amended in October 2024.
  • Special resolutions under both statutes need at least two-thirds of the votes cast.
  • More than CAD 10,000 in donations or grants can trigger public benefit or soliciting status.
  • Audit exemptions depend on revenue and require member resolutions renewed each year.
  • Charity registration with the CRA is a separate layer with its own obligations.

How governance of not for profit corporations works in Ontario and federally

Not for profit corporations in Canada are governed by the statute under which they were incorporated or continued. In Ontario that is the Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010 (ONCA), in force since 19 October 2021. Federally it is the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act (CNCA). Both statutes give members real rights, require articles and by-laws that conform to the Act, and scale audit and governance obligations to whether the organization relies on public money. Charitable status is a separate layer, granted by the Canada Revenue Agency, with its own rules.

Board meeting reviewing by-laws for not for profit corporations under the ONCA and CNCA
Not for profit corporations under the ONCA and CNCA must align their articles, by-laws, membership structure and financial review with the statute.

For boards and executive directors, the practical questions are recurring: are our by-laws compliant, who are our members and what can they do, when do we need a special resolution, do we need an audit, and what extra obligations apply because we are a charity or receive public funding? This note answers those questions for both statutes and highlights where they differ.

ONCA transition: what changed in 2024

When the ONCA came into force, existing Ontario non-share corporations formerly governed by the Corporations Act became subject to it automatically. Section 207 gave them a three-year transition period: provisions in letters patent, supplementary letters patent, by-laws or special resolutions that did not conform to the ONCA remained valid until the third anniversary of the section's coming into force, after which they were deemed amended to the extent necessary to conform. That anniversary passed in October 2024.

In practice, Ontario not for profit corporations that never updated their documents now operate under by-laws that are partly overridden by statute. That creates uncertainty about quorum, voting, membership classes and director terms. Boards should confirm that their articles and by-laws have been reviewed and, where necessary, restated. Some provisions that were previously in by-laws, such as certain membership class rights, must now be in the articles to remain effective after articles of amendment are filed.

Membership classes and member rights

Members are to not for profit corporations what shareholders are to business corporations, and both statutes give them significant powers. Members elect directors, approve by-law amendments, appoint the auditor or approve exemptions from audit, and vote on fundamental changes. Key points:

  • Classes. Both Acts allow multiple classes of members, with or without voting rights. Under the ONCA and CNCA, certain amendments that affect a class trigger a separate class vote, even for non-voting classes.
  • Proposals and requisitions. Members can submit proposals for meetings and requisition meetings, subject to statutory thresholds.
  • Records. Members have rights to access specified corporate records and financial statements.
  • Remedies. Members and other complainants can apply for oppression and compliance remedies.

Organizations that want governance concentrated in a board sometimes create a single voting member class composed of the directors (a "board-equals-members" model). That is permitted but has consequences: the directors then hold both roles, and non-voting classes still retain statutory rights on amendments that affect them.

Whatever model is chosen, membership criteria, admission procedures, fees, termination and discipline should be set out clearly. Expelling a member without following the by-laws, or without basic procedural fairness, is a frequent source of litigation.

Special resolutions and fundamental changes

Both statutes require a special resolution of members, passed by at least two-thirds of the votes cast, for fundamental changes, including amendments to articles, changes to membership classes and conditions, amalgamations, continuances, sales of all or substantially all property, and dissolution. Under the ONCA, a special resolution can also be passed by written consent of every voting member. The CNCA defines a special resolution simply as a resolution passed by "not less than two thirds of the votes cast".

IssueONCA (Ontario)CNCA (federal)
Public money category"Public benefit corporation": charities, and non-charities receiving more than CAD 10,000 in a financial year in donations from non-insiders or government grants"Soliciting corporation": more than CAD 10,000 in the last financial year in donations from non-insiders, government grants, or gifts from soliciting entities
Special resolutionTwo-thirds of votes cast at a meeting, or written consent of all voting membersTwo-thirds of votes cast
Audit exemptionPublic benefit corporations with revenue of CAD 100,000 or less; other corporations with revenue of CAD 500,000 or less (80% extraordinary resolution)"Designated" corporations: soliciting with gross revenue of CAD 50,000 or less; non-soliciting of CAD 1,000,000 or less
Review engagement instead of auditPublic benefit corporations with revenue over CAD 100,000 and under CAD 500,000; other corporations over CAD 500,000 (80% extraordinary resolution)Soliciting corporations with gross revenue of CAD 250,000 or less (special resolution)
Board compositionAt least three directors; public benefit corporations limit employee-directorsSoliciting corporations need at least three directors, two of whom are not officers or employees

Thresholds are prescribed by statute or regulation and can change; boards should check the current text of the ONCA and the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Regulations before relying on an exemption.

Audit, review and the public benefit or soliciting tests

Under s. 76 of the ONCA, members of a public benefit corporation may, by extraordinary resolution (at least 80% of the votes cast at a special meeting, or the consent of all voting members), choose a review engagement instead of an audit where annual revenue is more than CAD 100,000 and less than CAD 500,000, or dispense with both where revenue is CAD 100,000 or less. Members of other ONCA corporations may choose a review engagement where revenue exceeds CAD 500,000 or dispense with both where revenue is CAD 500,000 or less. Each resolution is valid only until the next annual meeting.

Under the CNCA, a corporation becomes a soliciting corporation if, in its last financial year, it received more than CAD 10,000 in donations requested from non-insiders, government grants, or gifts from other soliciting entities. Soliciting status lasts until the third annual meeting after it is triggered. Designated corporations, essentially small ones, may waive the public accountant requirement, and soliciting corporations with gross annual revenue up to CAD 250,000 may elect a review engagement by special resolution. Above those levels, an audit is required.

Practical point

Track government grants and donations by financial year. A single large grant can make an Ontario corporation a public benefit corporation, or a federal corporation a soliciting corporation, and change its audit and board composition obligations from the next annual meeting.

Running member meetings properly

Many governance disputes in not for profit corporations begin at a members' meeting: a contested election, a challenged by-law amendment, or a dispute over who is entitled to vote. Both statutes set out rules on notice, record dates, quorum, proxies and voting methods, and by-laws fill in details within the limits the Act allows. Several practical steps reduce the risk of a successful challenge:

  • Keep an accurate members' register. Membership renewals, lapses and class changes should be recorded consistently, because the register determines who receives notice and who can vote.
  • Follow the notice rules exactly. Notice periods, content requirements and delivery methods in the Act and by-laws must be met; special business, such as a by-law change, must be described in enough detail for members to decide.
  • Plan electronic participation. Hybrid and virtual meetings are common, but the by-laws and the Act must permit the method used, and voting technology must allow members to participate and vote as the rules require.
  • Use a neutral chair and scrutineers for contested votes, and keep detailed minutes.

Members who believe a meeting was improperly called or conducted can apply to court for compliance or oppression remedies, which can set aside elections or resolutions. Careful process is far cheaper than litigation.

Director duties in not for profit corporations

Directors and officers of not for profit corporations owe the same core duties as their business-corporation counterparts: to act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the corporation, and to exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in comparable circumstances. Both statutes provide due diligence defences, including good-faith reliance on financial statements and professional reports. Directors also face statutory liability, for example for unpaid wages and, under tax legislation, for unremitted source deductions, subject to due diligence defences.

Conflicts of interest need particular attention in community organizations where directors are often suppliers, donors or employees. Both statutes require disclosure of interests in material contracts and abstention from voting, and charities face additional restrictions on paying directors. Directors' and officers' insurance and indemnification by-laws are standard protections.

The overlay of charity registration

Incorporation as a not-for-profit and registration as a charity are different things. A corporation incorporated under the ONCA or CNCA becomes a registered charity only if the Canada Revenue Agency registers it under the Income Tax Act. Registration brings the ability to issue official donation receipts, and with it obligations: exclusively charitable purposes, an annual information return, the disbursement quota, limits on political and business activities, and rules on gifts to non-qualified donees. Charitable purposes must also be reflected in the articles.

Charities incorporated in Ontario face an additional layer: the Public Guardian and Trustee oversees charitable property, and Ontario's charities legislation regulates matters such as director remuneration. Organizations considering charitable status should align their articles with CRA requirements before applying. Our note on the disbursement quota for registered charities covers the spending rules.

Choosing and changing jurisdiction

Organizations that operate across Canada often choose the CNCA; those focused on Ontario often choose the ONCA. A corporation can continue from one statute to another with a special resolution and articles of continuance, and an amalgamation can combine organizations with similar purposes. Charities should check with the CRA how a continuance or amalgamation will affect registration, because a new legal entity may need to apply for its own registration. Our corporations and commercial structuring page and our note on amalgamations and reorganizations explain the process for business corporations, much of which applies by analogy.

Illustration: a federal association with 2,000 members receives a CAD 50,000 government grant in its 2026 financial year. From its next annual meeting it is a soliciting corporation, so it must have at least three directors, two of whom are not officers or employees, and, with revenue above CAD 250,000, it must have an audit rather than a review engagement.

How TRW & Co helps not-for-profits

We advise not for profit corporations and their boards on ONCA and CNCA compliance: restating articles and by-laws, designing membership structures, planning special and extraordinary resolutions, audit and review exemptions, director duties and conflict policies, continuances and amalgamations, and coordination with charity registration. We work with Ontario or other provincial counsel where a filing requires it. This note is general information, not legal advice. To discuss your organization, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Do Ontario not-for-profits still need to update their by-laws?

If they have not already, yes. The ONCA's three-year transition ended in October 2024, and non-conforming provisions are now deemed amended to conform with the Act. Organizations relying on old by-laws face uncertainty about quorum, voting and membership classes, so a review and restatement is advisable.

What is a public benefit corporation under the ONCA?

It is a charitable corporation, or a non-charitable corporation that receives more than CAD 10,000 (or another prescribed amount) in a financial year in donations or gifts from persons other than its members, directors, officers or employees, or in grants or similar assistance from government. Public benefit corporations face stricter audit and board rules.

When is a federal not-for-profit a soliciting corporation?

Under the CNCA and its regulations, when it received more than CAD 10,000 in its last financial year in requested donations from non-insiders, government grants, or gifts from other soliciting entities. The status lasts until the third annual meeting of members after it is triggered and brings stricter board and audit requirements.

Can a not-for-profit avoid an audit?

Smaller organizations can. Under the ONCA, members may pass an 80% extraordinary resolution to dispense with an audit or use a review engagement within revenue thresholds. Under the CNCA, designated corporations may waive the requirement and smaller soliciting corporations may elect a review engagement. Resolutions must be renewed each year.

Is a not-for-profit corporation automatically a charity?

No. Incorporation creates a not-for-profit corporation; charitable registration is granted separately by the Canada Revenue Agency under the Income Tax Act. A registered charity can issue official donation receipts but must meet additional requirements, including exclusively charitable purposes, annual returns and the disbursement quota.

Sources

  1. Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010, S.O. 2010, c. 15
  2. Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act, S.C. 2009, c. 23
  3. Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Regulations (SOR/2011-223)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.