Reverse Vesting Orders in Canada: Tests and Limits
Reverse vesting orders let a buyer acquire an insolvent company's shares while unwanted liabilities are moved to a residual entity. Canadian courts approve them when a conventional asset sale would lose licences or other value, applying the Harte Gold questions and the s. 36 CCAA factors. Appellate courts have confirmed jurisdiction but not lowered the bar.

Key takeaways
- Reverse vesting orders keep licences, permits and contracts inside the purchased company.
- Harte Gold, 2022 ONSC 653, asks about necessity, economic result, no stakeholder worse off and value.
- The s. 36(3) CCAA sale factors still apply, adapted to the RVO context.
- BC's Court of Appeal confirmed RVO jurisdiction in receiverships; SCC denied leave in 2025.
- Releases and preserved tax attributes are the most frequent grounds for objection.
What reverse vesting orders do
Reverse vesting orders (RVOs) turn the usual insolvency sale upside down. In a conventional sale, the buyer acquires the debtor's good assets and the court "vests" them in the buyer free of claims, leaving liabilities behind in the insolvent company. In an RVO transaction, the buyer acquires the shares of the debtor company itself, and the court vests the unwanted assets, contracts and liabilities out of the company into a new entity, often called "ResidualCo", which is then bankrupted or wound up. The purchaser ends up owning a clean company that keeps its licences, permits, contracts, tax attributes and corporate identity.

Canadian courts first approved reverse vesting orders in contested proceedings around 2020, and they have since become common in CCAA cases involving mining, cannabis, energy and real estate, where non-transferable permits or licences are the main source of value. No statute expressly authorizes them. Courts rely on their general discretion under s. 11 of the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), guided by the sale approval factors in s. 36, and in receiverships on the court's powers under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA). This note explains the tests courts apply, the main areas of objection and the appellate decisions that confirm and limit the tool.
The Harte Gold analysis
The leading Ontario decision is Harte Gold Corp. (Re), 2022 ONSC 653, in which the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) approved a reverse vesting order for a mining company whose permits could not easily be transferred. The court described RVOs as an unusual remedy that should not become the norm and framed the inquiry around a set of questions that later courts have adopted:
- Why is the RVO structure necessary in this case?
- Does it produce an economic result at least as favourable as any other viable alternative?
- Is any stakeholder worse off under the RVO than it would have been under any other viable alternative?
- Does the consideration paid for the debtor's business reflect the importance and value of the licences and permits, or other intangible assets, preserved by the structure?
The court also confirmed that the s. 36(3) factors for approving a sale outside the ordinary course remain relevant, adapted to the RVO context: whether the process leading to the transaction was reasonable, whether the monitor approved it, whether creditors were consulted, the effects on creditors and other parties, and whether the consideration is fair and reasonable taking into account market value.
| Question | What the applicant must show | Typical evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Necessity | A conventional asset sale would lose value or is not feasible | Evidence that permits, licences or tax attributes cannot be transferred, or only with long delay |
| Economic result | At least as good as any viable alternative | SISP results, monitor's comparison with liquidation and asset sale |
| No stakeholder worse off | Each excluded creditor fares no worse than under alternatives | Recovery analysis for creditors left with ResidualCo |
| Value of preserved assets | Price reflects the licences and attributes kept | Valuation and bid comparisons |
| Fair process (s. 36(3)) | Reasonable process, monitor support, consultation | Monitor's report and marketing record |
Necessity and the "no worse off" test in practice
Necessity is usually the easiest question when the debtor holds regulatory approvals that cannot be assigned: mining permits, cannabis licences, telecommunications or energy authorizations, or long-term contracts with change-of-control or anti-assignment provisions that the counterparty will not waive. It is harder when the main benefit is preserving tax losses or avoiding transfer taxes. Courts have been more sceptical where the RVO appears designed mainly to deliver a tax advantage to the purchaser or to defeat a specific creditor.
The "no worse off" test focuses on creditors whose claims are moved into ResidualCo. Their position is compared with the realistic alternative, typically a conventional asset sale or a bankruptcy, not with an ideal outcome. Where the purchaser pays cash that flows to creditors through ResidualCo, or assumes specific liabilities, the analysis is usually straightforward. Where some creditors' claims are left behind while comparable creditors' claims are assumed by the purchaser, the applicant must justify the distinction.
Releases, licences and tax attributes
RVO transactions often include releases in favour of the purchaser, the debtor, its directors and officers, the monitor and sometimes the sponsor. Courts apply the same principles used for third-party releases in CCAA plans: the release must be connected to the restructuring, necessary for it, fair and reasonable, and supported by consideration or contribution from the released parties. Broad releases that extinguish claims unrelated to the transaction are a common target of objections.
Preservation of tax attributes is the most sensitive economic issue. Tax losses and other attributes may survive inside the purchased company, subject to the acquisition-of-control rules in the Income Tax Act that restrict the use of losses after a change of control. Courts have accepted that preserving such attributes may be part of the value of an RVO, but they expect the price to reflect it and the process to show that the structure is not merely a vehicle for tax planning at creditors' expense.
Objections by creditors and the Crown
The parties that most often oppose reverse vesting orders are:
- Excluded creditors who argue that the structure strips them of their debtor while comparable creditors are paid or assumed.
- Contract counterparties whose change-of-control or assignment rights are effectively overridden because the company stays the same.
- Shareholders whose shares are cancelled without a plan vote, although equity in an insolvent company typically has no economic value.
- Governments and regulators, particularly provinces concerned about loss of land or property transfer tax, environmental obligations or regulatory control over who holds a licence.
Regulators retain their own approval powers. An RVO does not oblige a regulator to accept a new owner of a licence, and many RVOs are conditional on regulatory approval of the change of control. Environmental obligations attached to licensed sites also usually remain with the operating company the purchaser acquires, which is one reason RVOs are used in resource cases: the buyer is taking on the permits and the obligations together.
Build the RVO case from the start of the sale process. Market the business with both an asset sale and a share-based RVO option, ask bidders to price both, and have the monitor document why the RVO produces a better or equal result for every creditor class. That record is what persuades a court that the structure is necessary.
ResidualCo mechanics and the treatment of excluded claims
The residual company is where the excluded liabilities go, so its design determines whether excluded creditors receive anything at all. Typical RVO orders add ResidualCo as an applicant in the CCAA proceeding, vest the excluded assets and liabilities in it, transfer any cash consideration or a funded "administration reserve" to it, and authorize the monitor to administer claims and later assign ResidualCo into bankruptcy. The bankruptcy trustee then distributes whatever ResidualCo holds according to the BIA scheme of priorities.
Courts look closely at how much value reaches ResidualCo. If the purchaser pays most of its consideration by credit bid, ResidualCo may hold little beyond the excluded assets, and unsecured creditors may recover nothing, which can still satisfy the "no worse off" test if a bankruptcy or asset sale would have produced the same outcome. Where some unsecured creditors, such as key suppliers or employees, have their claims assumed by the purchaser while others are left in ResidualCo, the applicant needs a commercial justification, usually that the assumed creditors are needed to keep the business operating.
Employees deserve particular care. Employees who stay with the purchased company keep their employment, but employees whose contracts are excluded will look to ResidualCo and, where eligible, to the Wage Earner Protection Program. Pension plans, collective agreements and environmental orders tied to the business usually remain with the purchased company, which buyers must price into their bids. Bidders should model these retained obligations alongside the purchase price, because a court comparing alternatives will count assumed liabilities as part of the value delivered to stakeholders.
Appellate decisions on reverse vesting orders
Appellate courts have confirmed that reverse vesting orders are available while emphasizing that they remain discretionary and fact-driven.
- Quebec. In Arrangement relatif à Nemaska Lithium inc., 2020 QCCA 1488, the Court of Appeal of Quebec refused leave to appeal an RVO in a CCAA proceeding. The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed an application for leave to appeal on 29 April 2021 (SCC file 39464).
- British Columbia, receiverships. In Peakhill Capital Inc., the Supreme Court of British Columbia granted an RVO in a BIA receivership (2023 BCSC 1476), and the Court of Appeal for British Columbia dismissed the Province's appeal in 2024 BCCA 246, holding that the court has jurisdiction under the BIA to grant an RVO in a receivership. The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the Province's leave application on 1 May 2025 (SCC file 41483).
These decisions settle jurisdiction in CCAA and receivership proceedings, but they do not lower the bar. Each RVO still has to satisfy the necessity, no-worse-off and fair-process inquiry on its own record, and courts at first instance have refused or modified RVOs where the evidence fell short.
Using reverse vesting orders well: a checklist
- Identify the specific licences, permits, contracts or attributes that cannot be moved by an asset sale, and gather evidence from regulators or counterparties.
- Run a fair, monitor-supervised sale process that lets bidders propose both conventional and RVO structures.
- Prepare a recovery comparison for each creditor group under the RVO and the realistic alternatives.
- Limit releases to parties and claims connected with the restructuring, supported by contribution.
- Engage early with provincial authorities on transfer taxes, environmental obligations and licence transfer approvals.
- Decide how ResidualCo will be administered, funded and wound up, including any distribution to excluded creditors.
- Give notice broadly and serve affected counterparties, shareholders and government bodies.
Reverse vesting orders work best as a solution to a specific transfer problem, not as a default structure. Applicants who treat them that way, and who show their work, have generally obtained approval. Our notes on sale and investment solicitation processes and mining insolvency discuss related issues.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise purchasers, lenders, debtors, monitors' counsel teams and objecting stakeholders on reverse vesting orders in CCAA and receivership proceedings. We structure RVO transactions, prepare evidence on necessity and recoveries, negotiate releases and ResidualCo mechanics, and engage with regulators and tax authorities on licence transfers and attributes. We also act for creditors and counterparties seeking to limit or oppose an RVO. Where court appearances require Canadian-licensed counsel or a licensed insolvency trustee, we work with them. See our pages on CCAA restructuring and distressed M&A. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss an RVO, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Are reverse vesting orders authorized by statute?
No statute expressly provides for them. Courts grant them under the broad discretion in s. 11 of the CCAA, informed by the sale approval factors in s. 36, and in receiverships under the court's BIA powers. The Court of Appeal for British Columbia held in 2024 BCCA 246 that a court has jurisdiction under the BIA to grant an RVO in a receivership, and the SCC dismissed leave in 2025.
What must an applicant prove to obtain an RVO?
Following Harte Gold, 2022 ONSC 653, the applicant should show why the RVO structure is necessary, that it produces an economic result at least as favourable as any viable alternative, that no stakeholder is worse off than under other viable alternatives, and that the price reflects the value of the licences and permits preserved, along with a fair process under s. 36(3).
Can an RVO preserve tax losses?
Tax attributes can remain in the purchased company, subject to the Income Tax Act's acquisition-of-control rules. Courts have accepted that preserved attributes may contribute to value, but they expect the price to reflect them and are more sceptical where the main purpose of the structure appears to be a tax advantage for the buyer rather than preserving non-transferable assets.
Who usually objects to reverse vesting orders?
Creditors whose claims are left in the residual company, counterparties whose change-of-control rights are bypassed, shareholders whose shares are cancelled and provincial governments concerned about transfer taxes or regulatory control. Regulators keep their own approval powers over licence holders, so many RVOs are conditional on regulatory consent.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


