Skip to content
Restructuring & Insolvency

Sale and Investment Solicitation Processes in Canada

A sale and investment solicitation process is how Canadian courts market a distressed business in a CCAA proceeding, proposal or receivership. This note explains the usual two-phase structure, stalking horse protections, credit bidding, pre-packaged sales, the Soundair principles and s. 36 CCAA approval, and why unsuccessful bidders rarely succeed in challenges.

Data room and bid timeline for a sale and investment solicitation process in a Canadian restructuring

Key takeaways

  • Most SISPs use a non-binding LOI phase followed by binding bids with deposits.
  • Stalking horse break fees and expense reimbursements are approved if reasonable and not chilling.
  • Secured creditors may credit bid, subject to security review and priority payables.
  • Section 36(3) CCAA codifies fairness factors similar to the Soundair principles.
  • Related-party sales need good faith marketing and superior consideration under s. 36(4).

What a sale and investment solicitation process is

A sale and investment solicitation process (SISP) is the court-approved procedure used in Canadian restructurings and receiverships to market a distressed business, gather offers and select a transaction. It is called a "sale and investment" process because bidders may propose to buy assets, buy shares, recapitalize the company or sponsor a plan. A SISP is usually approved early in a CCAA proceeding or receivership, run by the debtor or receiver with a financial adviser under the monitor's supervision, and ends with a motion for an approval and vesting order. Getting the design right at the start is what protects the final transaction from challenge.

Data room and bid timeline for a sale and investment solicitation process in a Canadian restructuring
A sale and investment solicitation process moves from court approval of the procedures through bidding phases to an approval and vesting order.

No statute prescribes the structure of a SISP. Courts approve the procedures under their general powers and then approve the resulting transaction under s. 36 of the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), s. 65.13 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) for proposals, or the court's authority over a receiver's sale. The principles developed in receivership cases, especially the Soundair principles from the Court of Appeal for Ontario's 1991 decision in Royal Bank of Canada v. Soundair Corp., continue to guide how courts assess whether a process was fair.

Phases, bid deadlines and participation

Most Canadian SISPs follow a two-phase structure:

  1. Phase 1: non-binding letters of intent. The financial adviser contacts a broad list of strategic and financial buyers, provides a teaser and, after a confidentiality agreement, a virtual data room. Interested parties submit non-binding letters of intent by a deadline, often four to eight weeks after launch, describing price, structure and conditions.
  2. Phase 2: binding bids. Qualified Phase 1 bidders receive further diligence access and a form of purchase agreement. They submit binding offers with deposits, typically 10% of the purchase price, by a second deadline. The debtor or receiver, with the monitor, evaluates bids against published criteria and may run an auction among the best qualified bids.

The procedures define who may participate, what makes a bid "qualified", how bids are compared, the conduct of any auction and the timeline to the approval motion. They also state the debtor's or receiver's reserved rights, such as extending deadlines, waiving technical defects and rejecting bids that do not meet the criteria. Clear rules protect the process; a vague procedure invites post-auction disputes.

StageTypical timingKey outputs
SISP approval motionAt or shortly after the comeback hearingApproved procedures, stalking horse protections, milestones
Phase 1 marketingSeveral weeksConfidentiality agreements, data room, non-binding LOIs
Phase 2 diligence and bidsSeveral further weeksBinding bids, deposits, marked purchase agreements
Auction (if any)Days after the bid deadlineSuccessful and back-up bids
Approval and vesting orderFollowing selectionCourt approval under s. 36 CCAA or equivalent; vesting of assets

Stalking horse bids and bid protections

A stalking horse is a binding bid signed before the process starts, which sets a floor price and gives other bidders a template. In exchange for exposing its offer to an auction, the stalking horse bidder typically receives bid protections: a break fee and an expense reimbursement payable if it is outbid, a minimum overbid increment for competing bids, and matching rights. Canadian courts approve these protections when they are reasonable in amount, necessary to induce the stalking horse to commit, and do not chill competing bids. The monitor's opinion on reasonableness, usually supported by comparable precedents, is central.

Stalking horse bids are often submitted by existing secured lenders or DIP lenders as credit bids. That is legitimate, but it heightens scrutiny of the process, because the insider bidder has information advantages and a strong position. Courts and monitors respond by requiring that the lender's diligence materials be shared, that its credit bid be capped at the secured debt actually owed and valid, and that other bidders have time to make a meaningful offer.

Credit bidding and pre-packaged sales

Secured creditors may generally credit bid the debt owed to them in a sale and investment solicitation process, subject to the validity and enforceability of their security, which the monitor typically reviews through an independent security opinion. A credit bid must still cover priority claims and court-ordered charges that rank ahead, so credit bids are usually combined with cash for those amounts and assumption of certain liabilities.

A "pre-packaged" sale is negotiated before filing, and the proceeding is used mainly to obtain an approval and vesting order quickly, sometimes with an abbreviated or post-filing market check. Courts have approved pre-packaged sales where pre-filing marketing was adequate and the monitor supports the result, but they look carefully at whether creditors received a fair opportunity to see alternatives. The more truncated the process, the more evidence the applicant needs that the price is fair and that a full SISP would not have produced a better result.

Soundair principles and section 36 CCAA approval

The Soundair principles ask whether the seller made sufficient effort to obtain the best price and did not act improvidently, whether the interests of all parties were considered, whether the process was conducted with efficacy and integrity, and whether there was unfairness in the working out of the process. Section 36(3) of the CCAA codifies similar factors for sales outside the ordinary course:

  • whether the process leading to the sale was reasonable in the circumstances;
  • whether the monitor approved the process;
  • whether the monitor filed a report that the sale would be more beneficial to creditors than a sale under a bankruptcy;
  • the extent to which creditors were consulted;
  • the effects of the sale on creditors and other interested parties; and
  • whether the consideration is reasonable and fair, taking into account market value.

Additional safeguards apply to sales to related persons, such as directors, officers or controlling shareholders. The court may approve such a sale only if good faith efforts were made to sell to unrelated persons and the consideration is superior to any other offer received in the process (s. 36(4)–(5)). The court may order the sale free and clear of security, but must then give the affected creditor a charge over the proceeds or other assets (s. 36(6)). A sale also requires the court to be satisfied that certain employee and pension amounts that a plan would have to pay can and will be paid (s. 36(7)).

Practical point

Courts defer to a well-run process. In Callidus, 2020 SCC 10, the Supreme Court of Canada emphasized substantial deference to the supervising CCAA judge. The best way to earn that deference is a record that shows broad marketing, equal information, monitor oversight and a reasoned choice among bids.

The sale and investment solicitation process in receiverships and cross-border cases

In a court-appointed receivership, the receiver runs the marketing process and seeks approval of the procedures and the final sale from the court. There is no plan or creditor vote, so the court's review of the process is the main protection for stakeholders, and the Soundair principles apply directly. Receivers often have less time and less operational support than a CCAA debtor, which makes stalking horse bids and short, focused marketing periods more common. Even so, the receiver must show that the market was properly canvassed and that the chosen offer is the best available.

In cross-border cases, a single sale and investment solicitation process is often run in the main proceeding and recognized in the other country. A US Chapter 11 sale under s. 363 of the Bankruptcy Code and a Canadian approval and vesting order may both be needed where assets sit on both sides of the border. Coordinating bid deadlines, auction rules and hearing dates avoids conflicting orders, and court-to-court protocols can provide for joint hearings. Canadian courts recognizing a foreign sale order will still want evidence that Canadian creditors were treated fairly and that Canadian regulatory approvals, such as Competition Act or Investment Canada Act clearances, have been addressed.

Purchasers also need to plan for Canadian-specific closing items: transfer of permits and licences, provincial land registration, employment and pension issues and, where an asset sale would lose non-transferable rights, the option of a reverse vesting structure.

Challenges by unsuccessful bidders

Disappointed bidders sometimes oppose approval, alleging that the auction was unfair, that their bid was wrongly disqualified or that the winning bid received special treatment. Courts generally give unsuccessful bidders limited standing: the process exists to maximize value for stakeholders, not to protect bidders' expectations, and a bidder that agreed to the procedures is bound by them. Courts are reluctant to reopen a completed process because a higher offer arrives late, since that would undermine the integrity of future auctions, unless the new offer is so much higher that accepting the result would be improvident.

Creditors, on the other hand, have full standing and may challenge the process or result as unfair or improvident. Their objections tend to focus on insider bids, inadequate marketing time, excessive bid protections or a preferred bidder's access to management. Raising concerns early, at the hearing that approves the procedures, is far more effective than waiting for the approval motion. A creditor that stays silent while the procedures are approved and the market is canvassed will find it hard to persuade a court that the same procedures were unfair once a winning bid has been selected, particularly if other bidders relied on the approved rules when they decided whether to participate.

Designing a sale and investment solicitation process: checklist

  1. Choose a financial adviser with sector reach and agree its fee structure, including any success fee, for court approval.
  2. Set timelines that match the liquidity runway and DIP milestones without truncating marketing.
  3. Define qualified bids, deposit requirements and evaluation criteria in plain terms.
  4. Decide whether a stalking horse is needed and size bid protections with the monitor's input.
  5. Allow both asset and share structures, including reverse vesting order options where licences matter.
  6. Establish rules for credit bids, insider participation and information sharing.
  7. Plan regulatory approvals, including competition and foreign investment clearances, into the closing timeline.
  8. Document every step so the monitor can report on fairness at the approval hearing.

Our notes on reverse vesting orders and DIP financing cover two of the issues that most often shape a SISP.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise debtors, purchasers, stalking horse bidders, secured lenders and investors on sale and investment solicitation processes in CCAA proceedings, proposals and receiverships. Our work includes drafting SISP procedures and bid protections, structuring credit bids and share or asset purchases, diligence and purchase agreements in distressed timelines, and supporting or opposing approval and vesting orders. We coordinate with monitors, receivers and Canadian litigation counsel where those roles are required. See our pages on distressed M&A and receiverships and enforcement. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a sale process, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Is a sale and investment solicitation process required by statute?

No statute requires a particular process. Courts approve SISP procedures under their general supervisory powers, and later approve the resulting transaction under s. 36 of the CCAA, s. 65.13 of the BIA for proposals, or the court's authority over a receiver's sale. In practice, a court-approved process is the norm because it gives the final sale credibility.

What are the Soundair principles?

They come from the Court of Appeal for Ontario's 1991 decision in Royal Bank of Canada v. Soundair Corp. The court asks whether sufficient effort was made to get the best price without acting improvidently, whether all parties' interests were considered, whether the process had efficacy and integrity, and whether there was unfairness in how it was carried out.

Can a secured lender credit bid in a SISP?

Generally yes, if its security is valid and enforceable, which the monitor usually confirms through an independent review. The credit bid must also provide for amounts ranking ahead, such as court-ordered charges and statutory priorities, typically in cash. Courts watch closely for information advantages when lenders bid.

Can an unsuccessful bidder overturn a sale approval?

Rarely. Courts give unsuccessful bidders limited standing, because the process protects stakeholders' recoveries rather than bidders' expectations, and bidders that participated are bound by the procedures. Courts are reluctant to reopen a completed process for a late, higher offer unless accepting the original result would be improvident.

Sources

  1. Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, s. 36
  2. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, s. 65.13
  3. SCC Case in Brief: 9354-9186 Québec inc. v. Callidus Capital Corp., 2020 SCC 10

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.