Directors' Duties in the Zone of Insolvency in Canada
Canadian directors in the zone of insolvency still owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation, not to creditors, but their exposure grows sharply. Oppression claims, dividend and compensation liability under the CBCA and BIA, and personal liability for wages and unremitted taxes all come into play. Careful, documented decision-making is the best protection.

Key takeaways
- Peoples (2004 SCC 68) and BCE (2008 SCC 69): the fiduciary duty stays owed to the corporation.
- CBCA s. 122(1.1) lets directors consider creditors, employees, pensioners and others.
- BIA s. 101 can make directors liable for dividends and excessive pay in the year before bankruptcy.
- Directors face personal liability for wages and unremitted source deductions and GST/HST.
- CCAA D&O charges are unavailable if adequate insurance can be obtained at reasonable cost.
What directors owe in the zone of insolvency
In Canada, directors of a company in the zone of insolvency still owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation, not to its creditors. The Supreme Court of Canada settled that point in Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, and confirmed it in BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69.

There is no Canadian equivalent of a US-style shift of fiduciary duties to creditors when a company nears insolvency. But that does not mean creditors can be ignored. As financial distress deepens, the best interests of the corporation increasingly depend on preserving value for creditors, creditors gain access to the oppression remedy, and a cluster of statutory provisions makes directors personally liable for specific payments and unremitted amounts. The practical result is that directors in the zone of insolvency must act with more care, not less.
This note explains the fiduciary and care duties under the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) and provincial equivalents, the oppression remedy, liability for dividends and redemptions under the CBCA and s. 101 of the BIA, statutory wage and tax exposure, the protection available through directors' and officers' (D&O) charges and insurance, and how to document decisions.
The fiduciary duty and the duty of care
Section 122(1) of the CBCA requires directors and officers to act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the corporation (the fiduciary duty), and to exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in comparable circumstances (the duty of care). Since 2019, s. 122(1.1) has stated expressly that, in considering the corporation's best interests, directors may consider the interests of shareholders, employees, retirees and pensioners, creditors, consumers and governments, as well as the environment and the corporation's long-term interests.
In Peoples, the Court held that the fiduciary duty does not change when a corporation is in the "nebulous" vicinity of insolvency; the duty remains owed to the corporation. Creditors can, however, sue for breach of the duty of care, which is not owed to the corporation alone in the same way, and the Court noted that directors who act in good faith on a reasonable business judgment are protected. BCE added that directors must treat affected stakeholders fairly, consistent with their reasonable expectations, and that there is no rule that shareholder interests always prevail.
Oppression risk for directors
The oppression remedy in s. 241 of the CBCA lets a "complainant" seek relief where the corporation's conduct, or the way directors exercise their powers, is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial to or unfairly disregards the interests of any security holder, creditor, director or officer. Creditors are not automatically complainants, but courts may grant them standing, and creditors in distressed situations often do obtain it, particularly where directors stripped assets, preferred related parties or took steps that defeated reasonable creditor expectations. Remedies can include orders against directors personally where they benefited or acted in bad faith.
Typical fact patterns that attract oppression claims in the zone of insolvency include transfers of valuable assets to affiliates, payments to shareholders or insiders while trade creditors go unpaid, granting security to related lenders for old debt, and abandoning a business in a way that leaves creditors with an empty shell.
Dividend, redemption and compensation liability
Two overlapping regimes target distributions when a company is insolvent.
- CBCA. A corporation may not pay a dividend if there are reasonable grounds to believe it is, or would after payment be, unable to pay its liabilities as they come due, or that the realizable value of its assets would be less than its liabilities and stated capital (s. 42). Similar solvency tests apply to share purchases and redemptions (ss. 34–36). Directors who vote for or consent to such payments are jointly and severally liable to restore the amounts (s. 118(2)).
- BIA s. 101. If a bankrupt corporation paid a dividend or redeemed or purchased shares in the year before the initial bankruptcy event, the court may give judgment to the trustee against the directors if the transaction occurred while the corporation was insolvent or rendered it insolvent, unless the directors had reasonable grounds to believe otherwise (s. 101(2)). Since the 2019 amendments, the same applies to termination pay, severance pay, incentive benefits or other benefits paid to directors, officers or managers that were conspicuously above fair market value and outside the ordinary course (s. 101(2.01)).
| Exposure | Source | Defence or limit |
|---|---|---|
| Dividends, redemptions while insolvent | CBCA ss. 42, 118(2); BIA s. 101(2) | Reasonable grounds to believe solvency; reliance on financial statements |
| Excessive executive compensation before bankruptcy | BIA s. 101(2.01) | Reasonable grounds; ordinary course; fair value |
| Unpaid wages | CBCA s. 119 (up to six months' wages); provincial statutes | Conditions precedent; timing limits |
| Unremitted source deductions | ITA s. 227.1 | Due diligence; two-year limitation after ceasing to be director |
| Unremitted GST/HST | Excise Tax Act s. 323 | Due diligence; two-year limitation |
| Oppression | CBCA s. 241 | Fair treatment of reasonable expectations; business judgment |
Statutory wage and tax exposure
Directors are personally liable to employees for up to six months' wages under s. 119 of the CBCA, subject to conditions such as the corporation having been sued or having entered insolvency proceedings, and provincial corporate and employment statutes contain parallel rules (Ontario's, for example, also covers vacation pay). Directors are also liable for unremitted employee source deductions under s. 227.1 of the ITA and for unremitted GST/HST under s. 323 of the Excise Tax Act, subject to a due diligence defence: directors who exercised the degree of care, diligence and skill a reasonably prudent person would have exercised to prevent the failure are not liable. Courts focus on whether directors took positive steps to prevent the failure, not merely whether they tried to cure it afterwards.
These exposures explain why directors of distressed companies insist on current remittances and why many resign before a filing. Resignation does not end liability for amounts that arose while they were in office, and the limitation periods run from the date they ceased to be directors.
Insiders, related lenders and new security
Many distressed companies are financed in part by their own shareholders or affiliates. When the business weakens, those insiders often offer more money, but on terms that improve their position: new security for old advances, guarantees from subsidiaries, priority over trade creditors or repayment of existing shareholder loans. Directors who are also lenders, or who were appointed by them, face a conflict, and decisions of this kind attract scrutiny in any later insolvency.
The risks are concrete. Granting security for existing debt to a non-arm's-length creditor within 12 months before a bankruptcy can be attacked as a preference under s. 95 of the BIA, without proof of intent, if it has the effect of preferring that creditor. Transfers to related parties for less than fair value within five years can be reversed as transfers at undervalue under s. 96 if the company was insolvent or intended to defeat creditors. Provincial fraudulent conveyance and preference statutes add further remedies, and the oppression remedy can reach the same conduct with more flexible relief.
A safer approach is to treat insider financing like any other related-party transaction: have independent directors negotiate it, obtain a fairness view or market check, limit any new security to genuinely new money, and record why the financing is better for the corporation than the alternatives. In a CCAA proceeding, insider DIP financing is possible but will be reviewed closely by the monitor and the court, and related-party purchases of assets face the additional tests in s. 36(4) of the CCAA. Directors should also remember that being on both sides of a transaction may disentitle them to the business judgment rule's protection if the process was not fair.
D&O charges and insurance
When a company files under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, the court may grant a charge over the company's property to indemnify directors and officers for obligations incurred after the filing (s. 11.51). The court may not make the order if adequate insurance is available at reasonable cost, and the charge cannot cover liabilities from gross negligence or wilful misconduct. D&O charges are sized by reference to post-filing wage, vacation and remittance exposures, and they rank alongside the administration and DIP charges.
Before a filing, directors should review the company's D&O insurance: limits, exclusions for insolvency or creditor claims, the order of payments among insureds, and whether "Side A" cover protects individuals if the company cannot indemnify. Run-off cover should be arranged if the company is sold or wound up, and directors should keep copies of the policy and indemnity agreements personally in case the company's records later become inaccessible.
When a company enters the zone of insolvency, put remittances on a weekly reporting cycle to the board, and record in the minutes each time the board confirms that source deductions, GST/HST and wages are current. That record is the core of any due diligence defence later.
Documenting decisions in the zone of insolvency
Good process is the best defence. Directors acting in the zone of insolvency should:
- meet more often, with complete and timely financial information, including 13-week cash-flow forecasts;
- retain independent financial and legal advisers, and record their advice;
- form a special committee of independent directors where insiders are conflicted, for example in transactions with shareholders or related lenders;
- consider all realistic alternatives (refinancing, sale, out-of-court workout, CCAA or BIA proposal) and record why the chosen path serves the corporation's best interests;
- avoid preferential payments to related parties and new security for old debt without advice on preference and transfer-at-undervalue risk;
- monitor remittances and wage payments closely; and
- confirm D&O insurance and indemnities before taking major decisions.
Directors who follow a careful, documented process are generally protected by the business judgment rule even if the outcome is poor. Those who act without information, prefer insiders or ignore creditor interests face the oppression remedy, statutory liability and, in bankruptcy, reviewable transaction claims. See our notes on transfers at undervalue and preferences and forbearance agreements.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise boards, special committees, individual directors and officers of distressed Canadian companies. Our work includes advice on duties and options in the zone of insolvency, special committee processes, remittance and wage exposure, D&O insurance and indemnities, CCAA and BIA filing strategy, and defence of oppression and reviewable transaction claims. We work with financial advisers, insolvency trustees and Canadian litigation counsel where needed. See our pages on corporate governance and CCAA restructuring. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss your board's position, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Do directors owe fiduciary duties to creditors when a company is near insolvency?
No. In Peoples Department Stores v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the fiduciary duty remains owed to the corporation even in the vicinity of insolvency. BCE, 2008 SCC 69, confirmed this. Creditors can still pursue oppression claims, rely on the duty of care and use statutory remedies, so their interests matter in practice.
Can directors be liable for dividends paid before a bankruptcy?
Yes. Under the CBCA, directors who authorize a dividend that fails the solvency tests in s. 42 must restore the amount. Under s. 101 of the BIA, a trustee can obtain judgment against directors for dividends or share redemptions in the year before the initial bankruptcy event if the company was insolvent, unless the directors had reasonable grounds to believe it was solvent.
What is the due diligence defence for unremitted taxes?
Under s. 227.1 of the Income Tax Act and s. 323 of the Excise Tax Act, a director is not liable if they exercised the care, diligence and skill a reasonably prudent person would have exercised in comparable circumstances to prevent the failure to remit. Courts focus on positive steps taken before the failure, not efforts to cure it later.
What protects directors during a CCAA proceeding?
The court may grant a directors' and officers' charge under s. 11.51 of the CCAA to indemnify them for post-filing obligations, unless adequate insurance is available at reasonable cost. The charge does not cover gross negligence or wilful misconduct. Directors should also review D&O insurance, indemnities and run-off cover.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


