Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Defending Human Rights Tribunal Claims

Human rights tribunal claims are often decided on procedure before anyone tests the merits. This guide compares the Ontario, British Columbia and federal systems and explains limitation periods, deferral and dismissal requests, mediation, the remedies tribunals can order, damages exposure and the preparation that allows employers to defend efficiently.

Employer and applicant at a human rights tribunal mediation session in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Ontario and BC applications go directly to the tribunal; federal complaints go first to the Commission.
  • A one-year limitation period applies, with discretion to accept late filings.
  • Tribunals can defer, or dismiss where another proceeding dealt with the substance (Figliola, 2011 SCC 52).
  • Federal pain-and-suffering damages are capped at CAD 20,000; Ontario and BC have no cap.
  • HRTO decisions are reviewable only if patently unreasonable.

How human rights tribunal claims start

A human rights tribunal claim against an employer usually begins with an application or complaint alleging discrimination or harassment on a protected ground, most often disability, sex, race, age, family status or reprisal. The procedure depends on which statute applies. Provincially regulated employers answer to their provincial human rights code and tribunal; federally regulated employers, such as banks, airlines and telecommunications companies, answer to the Canadian Human Rights Act (CHRA). The routes differ in ways that shape defence strategy from the first response.

Employer and applicant at a human rights tribunal mediation session in Canada
A human rights tribunal application is often won or lost on procedure: timing, deferral and early dismissal requests.
FeatureOntario (HRTO)British Columbia (BCHRT)Federal (CHRC and CHRT)
Who files whereApplication directly to the Human Rights Tribunal of OntarioComplaint directly to the BC Human Rights TribunalComplaint to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, which may refer it to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal
Time limitOne year after the incident or last in a series (Code s. 34(1)), extendable for good-faith delay without substantial prejudiceOne year after the contravention or last instance of a continuing one (Code s. 22), with discretion to accept late complaintsCommission may decline complaints more than one year old (CHRA s. 41(1)(e))
DeferralCode s. 45 and the Tribunal's rulesCode s. 25, where another proceeding can deal with the substanceCommission may require other procedures to be exhausted (s. 41(1)(a)-(b))
Early dismissalCode s. 45.1 (substance appropriately dealt with elsewhere) and summary hearing procedures under the rulesCode s. 27(1), including "no reasonable prospect" of successCommission screening under ss. 41 and 44
General damagesNo statutory cap; compensation for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect (s. 45.2)No statutory cap; compensation for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect (s. 37)Up to CAD 20,000 for pain and suffering, plus up to CAD 20,000 for wilful or reckless conduct (s. 53(2)(e), (3))

Ontario and British Columbia are "direct access" systems: the tribunal receives the application and manages it from start to finish. Under the federal model, the Canadian Human Rights Commission screens complaints and only some reach the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. Other provinces mostly follow the commission model.

Timelines and the first response

The one-year limitation period is the first defence to examine. Under s. 34(1) of the Ontario Human Rights Code, an application must be filed within one year of the incident or, for a series of incidents, the last one in the series; the HRTO can accept late applications if the delay was incurred in good faith and causes no substantial prejudice.

British Columbia's Human Rights Code s. 22 has a similar rule, and the BC Tribunal can accept a late complaint where that is in the public interest and no substantial prejudice results. Applicants often plead older events as part of a "series" or "continuing contravention"; the response should test whether the later events are genuinely of the same character.

The employer's response is due within a short period after the application is served, and extensions are not automatic. A good response:

  • answers each allegation specifically, rather than generally denying discrimination;
  • sets out the legitimate, non-discriminatory reasons for each decision, supported by documents;
  • raises timeliness, jurisdiction and any other proceeding (grievance, civil action, workers' compensation) at the outset;
  • identifies witnesses and preserves their records, including messages on personal devices where relevant.

Deferral and dismissal requests at the human rights tribunal

Much of the work in a human rights tribunal file happens before any hearing on the merits. Three procedural tools matter most.

Deferral

Where another proceeding, such as a union grievance or a wrongful dismissal action, covers the same facts, the tribunal can defer the human rights application until that proceeding ends (Ontario Code s. 45; BC Code s. 25). Deferral avoids duplication and inconsistent findings, but it is discretionary and the tribunal will consider whether the other forum can actually address the human rights issues.

Dismissal because another proceeding dealt with the substance

Once another proceeding has concluded, s. 45.1 of the Ontario Code allows the HRTO to dismiss an application if that proceeding "appropriately dealt with the substance" of it; BC Code s. 27(1)(f) is to similar effect. In British Columbia (Workers' Compensation Board) v. Figliola, 2011 SCC 52, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the BC provision reflects finality principles: the question is whether there was concurrent jurisdiction to decide human rights issues, whether the previous decision decided the same issue, and whether the complainant had an opportunity to know the case and be heard, not whether the tribunal would have decided differently.

Summary dismissal

BC Code s. 27(1)(c) allows dismissal without a hearing where there is "no reasonable prospect" that the complaint will succeed, and the HRTO's rules provide a summary hearing process for applications with no reasonable prospect of success. These motions work best where the documents clearly establish a non-discriminatory explanation and the applicant's allegations, even if true, would not amount to discrimination.

The federal screening stage

Federally regulated employers face a different first battle. A complaint under the CHRA goes to the Canadian Human Rights Commission, which must deal with it unless one of the grounds in s. 41(1) applies: the complainant ought first to exhaust grievance or review procedures reasonably available; another federal procedure is more appropriate; the complaint is outside the Commission's jurisdiction; it is trivial, frivolous, vexatious or made in bad faith; or it is out of time.

The employer's early submissions to the Commission on these points, and later on the investigator's report, are the main opportunity to stop a complaint before it is referred to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. Those submissions should be treated as advocacy documents, supported by evidence, rather than as administrative correspondence.

Unionized employers in every jurisdiction should also consider whether the grievance and arbitration process is the proper forum. Labour arbitrators can apply human rights legislation, and a grievance already filed on the same facts is frequently the basis for a deferral or a later dismissal request.

Practical point

When a dismissed employee files both a civil action and a human rights application, decide early which forum you want to decide the human rights issues. A coordinated strategy, using deferral in one forum and a comprehensive defence in the other, usually produces one decision instead of two and limits total cost.

Mediation and settlement

Every major tribunal offers mediation, and most applications that do not end on a preliminary issue settle. Settlement terms commonly include a payment characterized as general damages for injury to dignity, a neutral reference, a mutual release, confidentiality and, sometimes, training or policy commitments. Several points deserve attention:

  • Tax and payroll treatment. General damages for injury to dignity are treated differently from amounts that replace lost wages, so the allocation should be considered carefully and documented.
  • Releases. The release should cover the human rights application, any civil claim and statutory complaints on the same facts.
  • Enforcement. In Ontario, a signed settlement is binding and a party can return to the HRTO if it is breached (Code s. 45.9); in British Columbia, s. 30 of the Code allows a party to apply to the BC Supreme Court to enforce the settlement. Terms must therefore be capable of performance.
  • Public-interest remedies. Tribunals take an interest in non-monetary terms, and employers can sometimes resolve a file on better financial terms by agreeing to sensible policy improvements.

Human rights tribunal remedies and exposure

If the case proceeds to a hearing and discrimination is found, remedies can be broad. Under s. 45.2 of the Ontario Code, the HRTO may order monetary compensation, including for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect; restitution other than money; and orders directing a party to do anything the Tribunal considers necessary to promote compliance with the Code. Those public-interest orders can require policy changes, training, monitoring or, in some cases, reinstatement. BC's s. 37 gives similar powers.

Federally, the CHRA caps compensation for pain and suffering at CAD 20,000 and adds up to CAD 20,000 in special compensation where the discrimination was wilful or reckless, in addition to lost wages and other remedies. Provincially, there is no statutory cap on general damages, and awards for injury to dignity have trended upward. Lost income can extend well beyond the common law notice period if the tribunal finds that discrimination caused the job loss and the applicant mitigated reasonably.

Costs are another difference from court. Human rights tribunals in Ontario and British Columbia generally do not award legal costs to the successful party, so an employer that wins on the merits will usually bear its own legal fees. That reality, and the management time a multi-day hearing consumes, explains why so many cases resolve at mediation even where the employer's position is strong. It also makes early, well-supported dismissal and deferral requests valuable.

Review is narrow. In Ontario, s. 45.8 of the Code makes HRTO decisions final, subject to reconsideration by the Tribunal itself, and provides that they may be set aside on judicial review only if "patently unreasonable". That deferential standard means the hearing itself is usually the only real opportunity to win on the facts.

Procedural defences and preparation

Strong defences are built long before any application arrives. Employers that defend these claims efficiently usually have:

  1. Accommodation files showing the request, the medical or other information obtained, the options considered and why any were rejected, which is the evidence needed for an undue hardship defence.
  2. Investigation reports prepared under a clear policy, with a decision on privilege made at the start (see our privilege insight).
  3. Contemporaneous reasons for terminations and discipline that are consistent with what the employer later says to the tribunal.
  4. Anti-reprisal controls, because a reprisal finding can succeed even where the underlying discrimination claim fails.

Illustration: a hypothetical Ontario retailer terminates an assistant manager for performance two months after she returns from a medical leave. She files an HRTO application and starts a wrongful dismissal action. The employer asks the HRTO to defer, defends the civil action on the merits, and settles both at a mediation once its documents, which show performance concerns raised before the leave, have been exchanged. The timeline of documented concerns, not the employer's stated intent, did most of the work.

For related obligations, see our guides on accommodation and undue hardship and return to work after injury.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise employers on human rights tribunal claims as part of our workplace investigations and human rights practice. Our work includes assessing new applications for timeliness and jurisdiction, preparing responses, bringing deferral, dismissal and summary hearing requests, coordinating parallel grievances and civil actions, preparing for mediation and negotiating settlements, and reviewing policies and accommodation processes to reduce future claims. Where a hearing or court proceeding requires a Canadian-licensed lawyer, we work with local counsel. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a file, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an employee have to file a human rights claim?

In Ontario and British Columbia, generally one year from the incident or the last incident in a series or continuing contravention, with discretion to accept late filings in limited circumstances. Federally, the Canadian Human Rights Commission may decline complaints filed more than one year after the last act or omission, although it can allow a longer period.

Can an employer stop a human rights case while a lawsuit proceeds?

The tribunal can defer an application where another proceeding, such as a civil action or grievance, can deal with the substance (Ontario Code s. 45; BC Code s. 25). Deferral is discretionary. After the other proceeding ends, the tribunal can dismiss the application if that proceeding appropriately dealt with its substance.

Are human rights damages capped?

Federally, the Canadian Human Rights Act caps pain and suffering compensation at CAD 20,000 and special compensation for wilful or reckless discrimination at a further CAD 20,000. Ontario and British Columbia have no statutory cap on compensation for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect, and lost wages are assessed separately.

Can a human rights tribunal order reinstatement?

Yes. Provincial tribunals can make orders directing a party to do anything necessary to promote compliance with the Code, and the federal tribunal has similar powers. Reinstatement is uncommon where the relationship has broken down, but it is available, as are policy, training and monitoring orders.

Can an HRTO decision be appealed?

There is no appeal. Under s. 45.8 of the Ontario Human Rights Code, decisions are final, subject to reconsideration by the HRTO and judicial review in the Divisional Court, where they can be set aside only if patently unreasonable. The hearing record is therefore critical.

Sources

  1. Human Rights Code, R.S.O. 1990, c. H.19, ss. 34, 45–45.9
  2. Human Rights Code, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 210, ss. 22, 25, 27, 37
  3. Canadian Human Rights Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. H-6, ss. 41, 53
  4. British Columbia (Workers' Compensation Board) v. Figliola, 2011 SCC 52

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.