Skip to content
Competition & Foreign Investment

Competition Class Actions Under Section 36

Competition class actions in Canada rest on s. 36 of the Competition Act, which lets people harmed by criminal conduct such as price-fixing sue for damages. Indirect and umbrella purchasers can claim, discoverability applies to the two-year limitation, and provincial certification rules shape outcomes. This note explains the framework and new areas of exposure.

Courtroom documents for competition class actions under section 36 in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Section 36 allows damages for loss from conduct contrary to Part VI, without a conviction.
  • A conviction record is proof of the conduct absent contrary evidence (s. 36(2)).
  • Indirect purchasers may sue if they can show a credible pass-through methodology.
  • Pioneer v. Godfrey, 2019 SCC 42: umbrella purchasers can claim and discoverability applies.
  • Drip pricing and no-poach offences open new avenues for class claims.

How competition class actions work in Canada

Competition class actions in Canada are built on s. 36 of the Competition Act. It gives any person who has suffered loss or damage as a result of conduct contrary to the criminal provisions in Part VI of the Act, or as a result of a failure to comply with an order of the Competition Tribunal or a court under the Act, a right to sue for the loss proved, plus investigation and litigation costs.

Courtroom documents for competition class actions under section 36 in Canada
Competition class actions in Canada rely on s. 36 of the Competition Act and provincial class proceedings statutes.

Part VI includes price-fixing, market allocation and output restriction under s. 45, wage-fixing and no-poach agreements under s. 45(1.1), bid-rigging under s. 47 and criminal false or misleading representations under s. 52, including drip pricing. Provincial class proceedings legislation then allows these claims to be brought on behalf of large groups of purchasers.

Competition class actions have become a major source of exposure for businesses accused of cartel conduct, often running in parallel with proceedings in the United States and elsewhere. This note explains the elements of a s. 36 claim, indirect and umbrella purchaser claims, certification, limitation periods and the interaction with parallel foreign cases.

Elements of a section 36 claim

A plaintiff must prove that the defendant engaged in conduct contrary to a provision of Part VI, that the plaintiff suffered loss or damage, and that the loss resulted from that conduct. A criminal conviction is not required. Where there has been a conviction, the record of the criminal proceedings is, absent evidence to the contrary, proof that the person engaged in the conduct (s. 36(2)). Guilty pleas by cartel members in Canada or abroad therefore often trigger follow-on class actions. The Federal Court is a court of competent jurisdiction (s. 36(3)), but most cases proceed in provincial superior courts, particularly in Ontario, British Columbia and Quebec, which have established class action regimes.

Damages under s. 36 are compensatory: the loss proved, plus any additional amount the court allows up to the full cost of investigation and proceedings. There are no punitive damages under s. 36 itself, although plaintiffs often plead parallel common-law claims, such as civil conspiracy and unjust enrichment, which can support other remedies.

IssueRuleSource
Cause of actionLoss from conduct contrary to Part VI or breach of a Tribunal or court orders. 36(1)
Effect of convictionRecord of proceedings is proof of conduct, absent contrary evidences. 36(2)
Limitation period2 years from the conduct or final disposition of criminal proceedings, whichever is laters. 36(4)
Certification (Ontario)Includes superiority and predominance of common issuesClass Proceedings Act, 1992, s. 5(1.1)
Authorization (Quebec)Four conditions in art. 575 C.C.P.Code of Civil Procedure, art. 575

Indirect and umbrella purchasers

Canadian law allows indirect purchasers to sue. In a trilogy of 2013 decisions, including Pro-Sys Consultants Ltd. v. Microsoft Corporation, 2013 SCC 57, the Supreme Court of Canada held that indirect purchasers, who bought products containing the overcharged input from intermediaries rather than from the cartelists, may claim, provided they can show a credible methodology for proving that the overcharge was passed through to them. Defendants cannot rely on a "passing on" defence against direct purchasers. In practice, class definitions often include direct and indirect purchasers together, and expert evidence on pass-through is central at certification.

Umbrella purchasers, who bought from non-cartel firms that raised their own prices under the cartel's "umbrella", may also claim under s. 36. The Supreme Court so held in Pioneer Corp. v. Godfrey, 2019 SCC 42, which also confirmed that the discoverability principle applies to the two-year limitation in s. 36(4)(a)(i). That decision significantly widened potential class membership and extended the time for bringing claims where cartel conduct was concealed.

Practical point

When a cartel investigation or foreign guilty plea becomes public, assume Canadian competition class actions will follow, potentially including indirect and umbrella purchasers. Preserve documents, assess Canadian sales and pass-through, and coordinate defence strategy across jurisdictions from the outset.

Certification of competition class actions

Each province sets its own certification test. In Ontario, the Class Proceedings Act, 1992, as amended in 2020, requires among other things that a class proceeding be the preferable procedure, and adds that it is superior to all reasonably available means of determining the claims and that common issues predominate over individual issues (s. 5(1.1)). The court must also dismiss an action for delay if key steps are not taken by the first anniversary of its commencement, unless the parties agree or the court orders otherwise (s. 29.1).

In Quebec, authorization under art. 575 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires that the claims raise identical, similar or related issues; that the facts alleged appear to justify the conclusions sought; that the class composition makes joinder or mandates impracticable; and that the representative is adequate. Quebec's threshold is generally viewed as lower.

At certification, plaintiffs typically rely on expert evidence proposing a methodology to establish class-wide loss, including pass-through for indirect purchasers. Courts examine whether the methodology is plausible and grounded in available data, without deciding the merits. Defendants often respond with their own experts, and the battle of experts at certification can determine whether the case proceeds as a class action at all, which in turn drives settlement value.

Limitation periods

Section 36(4) requires an action to be brought within two years from the day the conduct was engaged in or the day criminal proceedings were finally disposed of, whichever is later. Because the discoverability principle applies following Godfrey, time does not run against plaintiffs who could not reasonably have discovered the conduct, which is common in secret cartels. Plaintiffs also often plead common-law claims subject to provincial limitation statutes, such as Ontario's basic two-year period from discovery and 15-year ultimate period. Defendants should analyse when the conduct became public and when each claim was discoverable.

New areas: drip pricing, deceptive marketing and labour

Beyond traditional cartels, recent statutory changes create new bases for competition class actions. Drip pricing is now deemed false or misleading in both the civil and criminal provisions (ss. 74.01(1.1) and 52(1.3)); where the criminal standard of knowing or reckless conduct is met, s. 36 can support damages claims by consumers who paid undisclosed mandatory fees. Wage-fixing and no-poach agreements, criminal since June 2023, can found claims by affected employees. Bid-rigging claims by public bodies are another category. In each, plaintiffs must still prove conduct contrary to Part VI, which in deceptive marketing cases means meeting the criminal mental element, not just the civil standard.

Defending competition class actions

Defendants in competition class actions have several lines of defence. At the pleadings stage, they may challenge whether the facts alleged disclose conduct contrary to Part VI, particularly in cases built on parallel pricing without evidence of an agreement. At certification, they may contest the plaintiffs' expert methodology, arguing that it cannot reliably show class-wide loss or pass-through to indirect purchasers given the complexity of distribution chains, or that individual issues will overwhelm common ones. Jurisdictional challenges arise where foreign defendants have limited connection to Canada. On the merits, the issues are whether an agreement existed, its scope and duration, and the size of any overcharge.

Insurance and indemnity questions matter early. Many directors' and officers' policies and commercial liability policies exclude antitrust or cartel claims, or cover only defence costs. Contribution and indemnity claims among co-defendants can also affect settlement dynamics. Companies that receive immunity or leniency from the Competition Bureau remain exposed to civil claims; cooperation with the Bureau does not provide civil immunity, though it may affect settlement timing and terms.

Document strategy should be set from the outset. Materials produced to the Bureau or foreign regulators may be sought by plaintiffs, subject to privilege and confidentiality protections, and courts manage access case by case. A coordinated approach across regulatory investigations and civil proceedings reduces the risk of inconsistent positions.

Settlements and distribution

Most competition class actions settle, often in stages as individual defendants reach agreements. Canadian courts must approve each settlement as fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class, and must approve class counsel fees. Settlements commonly include releases of all class members' claims against the settling defendant, bar orders preventing contribution claims by non-settling defendants, and cooperation obligations. Distribution of settlement funds can be complex where the class includes direct, indirect and umbrella purchasers; courts approve distribution protocols that allocate funds among these groups and sometimes provide for charitable distribution of residual amounts where individual distribution is impractical.

Coordination with US and other foreign cases

Most international cartels generate litigation in several countries. Canadian actions often follow US class actions and government investigations, and plaintiffs may seek access to documents produced abroad. Settlements are frequently negotiated globally, with separate Canadian settlement classes approved by Canadian courts, which must find the settlement fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class. Defendants should coordinate positions on pass-through, damages methodology and privilege across jurisdictions, and be mindful that admissions in one country may be used in another. Our note on private access to the Competition Tribunal explains the separate route for reviewable conduct.

Checklist for businesses facing competition class actions

  1. Identify all Canadian sales of the affected products, directly and through distributors, for the whole relevant period.
  2. Map the full distribution chain to assess indirect purchaser, umbrella purchaser and pass-through issues.
  3. Determine when the alleged conduct became public and assess limitation defences under s. 36(4) and provincial statutes.
  4. Review insurance coverage, notice requirements and indemnity rights early.
  5. Coordinate closely with counsel handling regulatory investigations and foreign proceedings.
  6. Assess jurisdiction in each province where claims are filed, and consider whether proceedings can be consolidated or stayed.
  7. Evaluate early settlement opportunities, including cooperation terms, bar orders and global coordination.

For potential plaintiffs, including large commercial purchasers, the checklist is the mirror image: preserve purchase records, monitor guilty pleas and investigations in Canada and abroad, and decide whether to participate in a class or opt out and pursue an individual claim, which can be worthwhile where purchases are large and documented.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise defendants, plaintiffs' advisers, in-house teams and insurers on competition class actions in Canada. Our work includes risk assessment after investigations or foreign pleas, certification and pass-through strategy with economists, limitation analysis, coordination with foreign proceedings and settlement design. We work with Canadian class action counsel in each province where appearances are required. See our pages on class actions and cartels and criminal enforcement, and our note on drip pricing. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a matter, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Who can sue under section 36 of the Competition Act?

Any person who has suffered loss or damage as a result of conduct contrary to Part VI (such as price-fixing, bid-rigging, wage-fixing or criminal misleading advertising) or a failure to comply with a Tribunal or court order. Direct, indirect and umbrella purchasers can claim, subject to proof of loss.

Is a criminal conviction required for a section 36 claim?

No. The plaintiff can prove the conduct in the civil action. If there was a conviction, the record of the criminal proceedings is proof of the conduct absent evidence to the contrary under s. 36(2), which is why guilty pleas often lead to follow-on class actions.

What is the limitation period?

Two years from the day the conduct occurred or the day criminal proceedings were finally disposed of, whichever is later, under s. 36(4). In Pioneer Corp. v. Godfrey, 2019 SCC 42, the Supreme Court held that discoverability applies, so time does not run until the claim was reasonably discoverable.

Can consumers bring class actions for drip pricing?

Potentially. Drip pricing is deemed false or misleading under both the civil and criminal provisions. A s. 36 damages claim requires conduct contrary to Part VI, so plaintiffs must establish the elements of the criminal provision in s. 52, including knowing or reckless conduct, in addition to loss.

Sources

  1. Competition Act, s. 36 and Part VI
  2. Class Proceedings Act, 1992, S.O. 1992, c. 6
  3. Code of Civil Procedure (Quebec), art. 575

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.