Skip to content
Trade, Sanctions & Investigations

Customs Valuation and Transfer Pricing Adjustments

Customs valuation sets the value for duty on which Canadian duties, surtaxes and trade remedy duties are charged. For related-party imports, intercompany prices and year-end transfer pricing adjustments must satisfy s. 48 of the Customs Act and CBSA Memorandum D13-4-5, with corrections filed within 90 days.

Invoices and intercompany agreements under review, illustrating customs valuation and transfer pricing in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Transaction value under s. 48 is the primary method, subject to statutory conditions.
  • Related-party prices must be shown not to be influenced by the relationship, or to match a test value.
  • Assists and royalties paid as a condition of sale must be added to value for duty.
  • Net upward transfer pricing adjustments must be reported as corrections under s. 32.2.
  • Corrections are due within 90 days of reason to believe and are filed through CARM.
  • Surtaxes of up to 50% make valuation errors far more expensive.

Customs valuation basics

Customs valuation determines the "value for duty" on which Canadian customs duties, surtaxes and anti-dumping duties are calculated, and which forms part of the base for GST collected at the border. Under s. 48 of the Customs Act, the primary method is transaction value: the price paid or payable for goods sold for export to a purchaser in Canada, adjusted by adding certain amounts and deducting others. If transaction value cannot be used, the Act provides a hierarchy of alternative methods: the transaction value of identical goods, then of similar goods, then deductive value, computed value and finally a residual method.

For multinational groups, customs valuation intersects with income tax transfer pricing. The same intercompany price is examined by the Canada Revenue Agency for tax and by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) for customs, and the two authorities apply different rules and have different incentives: for tax, a higher import price reduces Canadian taxable income; for customs, it increases duties.

Invoices and intercompany agreements under review, illustrating customs valuation and transfer pricing in Canada
Customs valuation for related-party imports must reconcile intercompany pricing with the Customs Act.

With surtaxes of up to 50 per cent on some US goods and heightened enforcement, customs valuation errors can now be very costly. This insight explains transaction value between related parties, assists and royalties, post-importation transfer pricing adjustments, corrections in CARM and CBSA verification. It is general information, not legal advice.

Transaction value and its conditions

Transaction value is available only if conditions in s. 48(1) are met: there are no restrictions on the purchaser's use or disposition of the goods (other than those imposed by law, limiting resale geography, or not substantially affecting value); the sale or price is not subject to a condition or consideration that cannot be valued; no part of the proceeds of resale accrues to the vendor unless it can be added; and the parties are not related or, if they are, the relationship did not influence the price or the price closely approximates a "test value" (s. 48(1)(d)).

A "sale for export to Canada" is also required. In multi-tier supply chains, identifying the relevant sale can be complex, for example where a foreign distributor buys from a manufacturer and resells to a Canadian importer, or where goods are drop-shipped. The relevant sale is the one that causes the goods to be exported to Canada, and the importer should be able to document it.

"Related persons" are defined in s. 45(3) of the Customs Act and include companies under common control and parent-subsidiary relationships. According to CBSA Memorandum D13-4-5 (December 2021), an importer using transaction value for related-party purchases must be able to demonstrate either that the relationship did not influence the price, by evidence of the circumstances surrounding the sale, or that the price closely approximates a test value, such as the transaction value of identical or similar goods sold to unrelated buyers or a deductive or computed value.

The CBSA expects the importer to conduct a self-examination before using transaction value and to keep on file the information justifying its conclusion and the calculation of the transfer price.

The CBSA accepts that a transfer price established for tax purposes may be a starting point, if supported by a transfer pricing agreement or documentation with relevant information about the circumstances of the sale. But a tax transfer pricing study does not automatically prove that the price is acceptable for customs valuation, because the methods and comparables differ.

IssueTax transfer pricing (ITA s. 247)Customs valuation (Customs Act s. 48)
StandardArm's length principleRelationship did not influence the price, or test value
Unit of analysisOften company-wide or segment profitabilityPrice of the specific imported goods
Year-end adjustmentsCommon to reach target marginMust be reported to the CBSA as value corrections
RegulatorCanada Revenue AgencyCanada Border Services Agency

Assists, royalties and other additions

Section 48(5) requires the price paid or payable to be adjusted by adding amounts not already included, such as:

  • commissions and brokerage incurred by the purchaser, other than buying commissions;
  • packing costs and containers;
  • "assists": the value of goods and services supplied free or at reduced cost by the purchaser for use in producing the goods, such as moulds, tooling, materials and engineering or design work done outside Canada;
  • royalties and licence fees, including for patents, trademarks and copyrights, that the purchaser must pay, directly or indirectly, as a condition of the sale of the goods for export to Canada, excluding charges for the right to reproduce the goods in Canada;
  • proceeds of subsequent resale that accrue to the vendor; and
  • transportation, loading and insurance costs to the place of direct shipment to Canada.

Royalties are a frequent issue in related-party structures. In Canada (Deputy Minister of National Revenue) v. Mattel Canada Inc., 2001 SCC 36, the Supreme Court held that royalties paid by the Canadian importer to third-party licensors were not dutiable because they were not a condition of the sale of the goods for export: the vendor could not refuse to sell if the royalties were unpaid. Where the licensor and vendor are related, or the licence agreement gives the licensor control over the sale, the analysis may differ.

Practical point

Map every intercompany payment that relates to imported goods, including royalties, service fees, tooling charges and year-end adjustments, and decide for each whether it must be added to value for duty. Payments recorded in accounts outside the purchasing function are a common source of undeclared value.

Post-importation transfer pricing adjustments

Many groups adjust intercompany prices after year end to reach a target operating margin for tax purposes. Memorandum D13-4-5 explains how these adjustments affect customs valuation. Corrections to declared value must be submitted when the net total of upward and downward transfer price adjustments for a fiscal period is identified, because that is when the importer has reason to believe the declarations are incorrect.

If the net result is an upward adjustment, the importer must submit a correction under s. 32.2 of the Customs Act whether or not the goods are dutiable. If the net result is downward, a correction is required only if it would be revenue neutral, and a refund request under s. 74 for dutiable goods is voluntary.

Section 32.2(2) imposes a 90-day deadline to correct a declaration of value for duty once there is reason to believe it is incorrect. Late or missing corrections can lead to penalties under the Administrative Monetary Penalty System, interest and, where the CBSA finds a pattern, broader verification. Coordination between tax and customs teams at year end is therefore essential.

CARM and the mechanics of corrections

The CBSA Assessment and Revenue Management (CARM) system is now the platform for commercial accounting, adjustments and payments. Corrections to value for duty, refund requests and adjustments for surtaxes are submitted through CARM, following the procedures in CBSA memoranda on adjusting commercial accounting declarations. Importers should ensure that their CARM client portal access, delegations to customs brokers and financial security are in order, and that their brokers understand how to process transfer pricing adjustments, which often affect many transactions at once.

Valuation under surtaxes and trade remedies

Customs valuation has taken on new weight because surtaxes on US goods and anti-dumping and countervailing duties are calculated on value. An undervalued import underpays not only the regular duty but also surtax at up to 50 per cent. Conversely, some groups are tempted to reduce intercompany prices for goods subject to surtax, which can create tax transfer pricing exposure and CBSA scrutiny of whether the relationship influenced the price. Changes to intercompany pricing in response to tariffs should be documented with a clear commercial rationale and consistent tax and customs analysis. See our insight on tariff remission and Canadian countermeasures.

CBSA verification priorities and audits

The CBSA publishes trade compliance verification priorities that identify products and issues selected for review, and valuation, including related-party pricing and undeclared assists and royalties, is a recurring focus. Verifications typically begin with a request for information on pricing policies, intercompany agreements, transfer pricing documentation, accounting records and payments to related parties. Findings lead to re-determinations of value for duty under s. 59, which the importer can challenge by requesting a re-determination within 90 days under s. 60, then appealing to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal under s. 67 and, on questions of law, to the Federal Court of Appeal under s. 68.

Coordinating tax and customs positions

Because the CRA and the CBSA can take inconsistent positions on the same price, groups should coordinate. Practical measures include drafting intercompany agreements that address customs valuation expressly, preparing a customs valuation memo alongside the tax transfer pricing documentation, modelling the customs effect of any planned adjustment, and considering CBSA rulings on valuation questions. Where the CRA reassesses a transfer price upward, the customs consequences should be evaluated immediately. For the tax side, see our page on transfer pricing and our insight on transfer pricing audits.

When transaction value is not available

If the conditions for transaction value are not met, for example because the relationship influenced the price and no test value is available, the importer must move down the statutory hierarchy. The transaction value of identical or similar goods sold to unrelated buyers in Canada is used if available.

Deductive value starts from the price at which the goods, or identical or similar goods, are resold in Canada and deducts profit, general expenses, transportation and duties. Computed value builds up the cost of production, profit and general expenses in the exporting country. The residual method applies the other methods with flexibility. Each step requires data that related-party importers may not readily have, so it is better to plan for transaction value than to discover in an audit that it was unavailable.

Key questions for management

  • Which imports are purchased from related parties, and how is the price set?
  • Do we have documentation showing the relationship did not influence the price, or a test value?
  • Are royalties, service fees, tooling and design costs reviewed for dutiability?
  • How are year-end transfer pricing adjustments reported to the CBSA, and by whom?
  • Are corrections filed within 90 days of reason to believe?
  • How would a 25 or 50 per cent surtax change the cost of a valuation error?

How TRW & Co helps

We advise importers and multinational groups on customs valuation in Canada, including related-party pricing, assists and royalties, post-importation transfer pricing adjustments and CBSA verifications. Our work includes reviewing intercompany agreements and payment flows, preparing customs valuation memoranda, designing year-end adjustment procedures with tax and finance teams, filing corrections and refund requests, and challenging re-determinations before the CBSA and the CITT. Where licensed customs brokers are involved, we coordinate with them. See our tariffs, CUSMA and customs page or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can a related-party price be used as the value for duty?

Yes, if the importer can show that the relationship did not influence the price, based on the circumstances of the sale, or that the price closely approximates a test value under s. 48(3) of the Customs Act. The importer should keep documentation supporting that conclusion, as CBSA Memorandum D13-4-5 explains.

Do year-end transfer pricing adjustments affect customs duties?

Yes. According to Memorandum D13-4-5, when the net total of upward and downward adjustments for a fiscal period is identified, an upward net adjustment must be reported as a correction under s. 32.2, whether or not the goods are dutiable. A downward net adjustment requires a correction only if revenue neutral, and refunds are voluntary.

Are royalties dutiable?

Royalties and licence fees are added to value for duty when the purchaser must pay them, directly or indirectly, as a condition of the sale of the goods for export to Canada, excluding charges for the right to reproduce the goods in Canada. Mattel, 2001 SCC 36, held third-party royalties that were not a condition of sale were not dutiable.

What is an assist?

An assist is a good or service supplied by the purchaser, free or at reduced cost, for use in producing the imported goods, such as moulds, tooling, materials or engineering and design work done outside Canada. Its value must be added to the price paid or payable.

How do I challenge a CBSA valuation decision?

Request a re-determination within 90 days of the notice under s. 60 of the Customs Act, then appeal to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal under s. 67 within 90 days of the decision, and on questions of law to the Federal Court of Appeal under s. 68.

Sources

  1. Customs Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (2nd Supp.), ss. 32.2, 45, 48, 60, 67, 68 (Justice Laws)
  2. CBSA Memorandum D13-4-5: Transaction Value Method for Related Persons
  3. CBSA Customs Notice 25-19: United States Surtax Remission Order (2025)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.