Departing Employees and Trade Secret Theft
Departing employees are the leading cause of trade secret loss. Canadian employers rely on breach of confidence, fiduciary duties of senior staff, and reasonable confidentiality and non-solicitation clauses, backed by forensic evidence and fast injunctions, especially where non-competes are restricted.

Key takeaways
- Breach of confidence requires confidential information, communicated in confidence and misused to the claimant's detriment.
- Senior fiduciary employees cannot divert corporate opportunities, even after resigning.
- Ontario has prohibited most employee non-compete agreements since 25 October 2021.
- Springboard injunctions remove the head start gained from misusing confidential information.
- Forensic preservation of devices and logs at departure is often decisive.
Departing employees and trade secrets: the short answer
Departing employees are the most common source of trade secret loss in Canadian businesses. Canada has no general trade secrets statute; protection comes from the law of breach of confidence, fiduciary duties, contract, and in Quebec the Civil Code.
Under the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Cadbury Schweppes Inc. v. FBI Foods Ltd., [1999] 1 S.C.R. 142, a claimant must show that the information was confidential, that it was communicated in circumstances of confidence, and that it was misused to the claimant's detriment. Senior employees may also owe fiduciary duties that restrict them from taking corporate opportunities after they leave, following Canadian Aero Service Ltd. v. O'Malley, [1974] S.C.R. 592. Courts can grant injunctions, including "springboard" injunctions that remove the head start gained from misuse.

For employers, the practical question is how to protect information without relying on restrictive covenants that may be unenforceable, particularly in Ontario, which prohibits most non-compete agreements. This article explains the legal tools, how courts approach departing employees, what urgent relief is available, and how to design exit protocols and forensic preservation steps that make claims provable.
Breach of confidence: the core claim
Breach of confidence protects information that has the necessary quality of confidence, such as formulas, source code, pricing models, customer data, supplier terms and business plans. In Cadbury Schweppes, the Supreme Court confirmed the three elements of the claim and held that remedies are flexible, ranging from injunctions to compensation measured by the claimant's loss or the defendant's gain. The Court also recognized that equitable compensation should reflect the value of the confidential information and the extent to which the defendant could have obtained the same result legitimately.
Two points matter for employers. First, information is protected only if it is genuinely confidential; information in the public domain, or general skill and knowledge that employees acquire in their work, is not. Employees are entitled to take their general know-how to a new job. Second, the employer must be able to show what was taken and how it was used, which depends on evidence collected before and immediately after departure.
Fiduciary employees and corporate opportunities
Most employees owe only contractual and common-law duties of good faith and confidentiality. Senior employees, officers and key personnel may also be fiduciaries. In Canadian Aero Service Ltd. v. O'Malley, the Supreme Court held that senior officers who left and diverted a business opportunity they had been pursuing for their employer breached their fiduciary duties, even after resigning. Fiduciary employees cannot use their position to divert opportunities, and for a reasonable period after leaving they may be restricted from soliciting the employer's customers or taking opportunities they developed while employed.
Ordinary employees are in a different position. In RBC Dominion Securities Inc. v. Merrill Lynch Canada Inc., 2008 SCC 54, the Supreme Court held that departing non-fiduciary employees were liable for failing to give reasonable notice, but that, absent fiduciary duties or contractual restrictions, they could compete after leaving. The branch manager who orchestrated the mass departure, however, was held liable for breaching his own contractual duties to the employer. The case shows the difference that roles and contracts make.
Contracts: confidentiality, non-solicitation and non-competition
| Tool | Enforceability (general) | Drafting focus |
|---|---|---|
| Confidentiality clause | Generally enforceable for genuinely confidential information | Define categories, require return and deletion on exit, survive termination |
| Non-solicitation of customers | Enforceable if reasonable in time, scope and customers covered | Limit to customers the employee dealt with, for a short period |
| Non-solicitation of employees | Often enforceable if reasonable | Clear time limit; avoid overbreadth |
| Non-competition | Prohibited for most employees in Ontario since 25 October 2021; elsewhere enforceable only if reasonable and no lesser covenant suffices | Use only where justified; sale-of-business and executive exceptions in Ontario |
| Garden leave and notice | Depends on contract and employment standards | Paid notice periods keep the employee away from competitors and information |
Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 has prohibited employers from entering into non-compete agreements with employees since 25 October 2021, with exceptions for the sale of a business and for executives, as explained in the Ontario government's guide. In other provinces, courts enforce restrictive covenants only if they are reasonable and clearly drafted, and they generally will not rewrite an overbroad clause. Employers should therefore rely primarily on confidentiality and non-solicitation obligations, supported by good information security. See our page on employment law.
Springboard injunctions and urgent relief
When an employer discovers that a departing employee has taken information, speed matters. Canadian courts can grant interlocutory injunctions restraining use or disclosure of confidential information and solicitation of customers, where the employer shows a serious issue to be tried (or, for restrictive covenants, often a strong prima facie case), irreparable harm and that the balance of convenience favours relief. A "springboard" injunction aims to deprive the defendant of the head start it gained from misuse, for a period roughly equal to the advantage obtained. In serious cases, courts can grant Anton Piller orders to search for and preserve evidence without notice, and orders requiring forensic imaging of devices and accounts.
Courts expect evidence, not suspicion. Before seeking an injunction, collect forensic evidence of downloads, emails to personal accounts, USB use and cloud uploads in the period before departure, and set out precisely what information was taken and why it is confidential. Delay in moving undermines the claim of irreparable harm, and a court may refuse relief to an employer that waited weeks after learning of the problem.
Forensic preservation
Most trade secret cases are won or lost on digital evidence. When a key employee resigns, employers should:
- preserve the employee's laptop, phone and accounts before reissuing them, using a qualified forensic examiner;
- retain logs of email, file-sharing, cloud storage, printing and removable media activity;
- suspend routine deletion for relevant systems and issue a litigation hold if a dispute is likely;
- document the chain of custody for all devices and data; and
- avoid self-help searches of personal accounts or devices, which can create privacy and admissibility problems.
Privacy laws and, in some provinces, employee privacy statutes apply to monitoring and investigations, so the employer should act within its policies and the law. See our page on workplace investigations.
Know what you are protecting
Claims involving departing employees often fail because the employer cannot say precisely what its trade secrets are. A court will not protect a vague category such as "all business information". Employers should maintain an inventory of their most valuable confidential information, such as source code repositories, formulas, manufacturing parameters, pricing models, bid data and strategic plans, and apply access controls that match its value. Marking documents as confidential, limiting access on a need-to-know basis, logging downloads and training staff all serve two purposes: they reduce the risk of loss, and they provide evidence that the information was treated as confidential if a dispute arises.
Employers should also consider the practical difference between information that can be protected and general skill and knowledge. Departing employees will take their experience and contacts with them. The legal tools are most effective when they focus on specific, valuable information and on conduct during and immediately after departure, rather than trying to stop a competent employee from working in the industry.
Hiring employees from competitors
The same rules apply in reverse to businesses that recruit departing employees from competitors. A hiring company can be liable for inducing breach of contract, for knowing assistance in breach of fiduciary duty, or for using confidential information it knows or ought to know was taken. A careful onboarding process requires new hires to confirm in writing that they have not brought confidential material, keeps them away from projects where their former employer's information would be directly useful for an initial period, and gives managers a route to escalate concerns. Those steps also make it easier to defend a claim by showing good faith.
An exit protocol for departing employees
Illustration: a sales director with access to pricing models and key accounts resigns to join a competitor. A good exit protocol would include the following steps:
- Immediate access review: decide whether to place the employee on paid garden leave and restrict system access.
- Exit interview: remind the employee in writing of confidentiality and non-solicitation obligations and ask about the new role.
- Return and certification: recover devices, documents and data, and obtain a signed certification that all company information has been returned and deleted from personal devices and accounts.
- Customer communication: introduce a new account manager promptly and keep a record of customer contacts in the following months.
- Letter to the new employer: where appropriate, notify the new employer of the employee's obligations, which can also support an inducement claim if breaches continue.
- Monitoring: watch for unusual customer losses or competitor products that suggest misuse.
Remedies at trial
If a case against departing employees proceeds to trial, the court can award a permanent injunction, damages for the employer's losses, an accounting of the defendant's profits, or equitable compensation, and may order the return or destruction of confidential material. In Cadbury Schweppes, the Supreme Court emphasized that the remedy should fit the nature of the information and the wrong, so compensation may be limited where the defendant could have developed the same information independently within a short time. Punitive damages are reserved for high-handed or malicious conduct. Because trials are expensive and slow, most disputes resolve at the injunction stage through undertakings, forensic protocols and agreed non-solicitation periods.
Quebec and other remedies
In Quebec, trade secrets are protected under the Civil Code, which, in art. 2088, recognizes an employee's duty of loyalty and confidentiality during employment and for a reasonable time after it ends, and provides for damages for disclosure of trade secrets. Under art. 2089, non-competition clauses must be in writing and limited in time, territory and type of work.
Criminal law may also apply where information is obtained by fraud or computer intrusion. Hiring employers should adopt onboarding procedures that keep new hires from bringing former employers' confidential information, since they can be liable for inducing breach or receiving confidential information. See our pages on copyright and trade secrets and Quebec employment, and our insight on IP ownership between employees and contractors.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise employers and hiring companies on departing employees and trade secret protection. We draft confidentiality, non-solicitation and IP agreements, design information security and exit protocols, coordinate forensic investigations, and help clients seek or resist urgent injunctions alongside Canadian-licensed litigation counsel. We also advise hiring employers on onboarding safeguards. To discuss a resignation, a suspected misuse of information or a planned hire from a competitor, contact us. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can a departing employee take customer lists?
Not if the list is confidential information belonging to the employer. Employees may use general skill, knowledge and publicly available information, but copying confidential customer data, pricing or files can be a breach of confidence and of contract. Senior fiduciary employees face additional restrictions on soliciting customers.
Are non-compete clauses enforceable in Canada?
In Ontario, employers have been prohibited from entering into non-compete agreements with most employees since 25 October 2021, with exceptions for sales of businesses and executives. Elsewhere, courts enforce them only if reasonable and if a lesser restriction, such as non-solicitation, would not protect the employer.
What is a springboard injunction?
An injunction designed to remove the unfair head start a defendant gained by misusing confidential information, usually for a period corresponding to the advantage obtained. Courts require evidence of misuse and prompt action by the employer.
What should an employer do when a key employee resigns?
Preserve devices and logs through a forensic examiner, review recent downloads and transfers, remind the employee of obligations in writing, recover company property, obtain a certification of return and deletion, and act quickly if evidence of misuse appears.
Can the new employer be liable?
Yes. A hiring employer can be liable for inducing breach of contract or for using confidential information it knows or should know was taken. Hiring employers should instruct new staff not to bring former employers' information and monitor compliance.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


