Drafting Earnout Provisions in Canadian Acquisitions
Earnout provisions bridge valuation gaps by tying part of the price to post-closing performance, but they are a frequent source of disputes. This guide covers metrics, buyer covenants, the Wastech good faith duty, accounting disputes, acceleration events and Canadian tax treatment.

Key takeaways
- Pick a metric the buyer cannot easily manipulate and attach a worked example.
- Wastech, 2021 SCC 7, requires contractual discretion to be exercised reasonably and for its purposes.
- Separate accounting disputes for an expert from interpretation disputes for arbitration.
- Negotiate acceleration, set-off and subordination before signing, not after a dispute.
- CRA's cost recovery method in IT-426R depends on strict conditions, including Canadian residence.
Why earnout provisions matter in Canadian deals
Earnout provisions make part of the purchase price depend on how the acquired business performs after closing. They bridge a valuation gap: the seller believes the business will grow, the buyer is not prepared to pay for growth that has not happened yet, and both agree that a portion of the price will be paid only if agreed targets are met. In Canadian private M&A, earnouts are common in technology, life sciences, professional services and founder-led businesses where future revenue is uncertain.

They also generate disputes. Once the buyer controls the business, it controls the decisions that drive the metric: pricing, staffing, integration and capital spending. A seller who receives nothing under an earnout will often argue that the buyer ran the business to avoid paying. Good drafting cannot remove that tension, but it can define the rules clearly enough that disputes are rare and, when they arise, are resolved quickly.
Choosing the metric
The metric is the heart of the clause. Each option carries a different mix of objectivity and manipulation risk.
| Metric | Advantages | Risks |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | Easy to measure; less affected by buyer's cost allocations | Can reward unprofitable growth; revenue recognition policies matter |
| Gross margin | Captures pricing discipline | Depends on cost of goods definitions |
| EBITDA | Aligns with how buyers value the business | Vulnerable to overhead allocations, integration costs and accounting changes |
| Milestones | Binary and objective (regulatory approval, product launch, customer contract) | All-or-nothing outcomes; definitions of "achieved" must be precise |
| Customer retention | Useful in services and software | Requires agreed definitions of "customer" and "retained" |
Whatever the metric, the agreement should specify the accounting principles (usually the target's historical practices, consistently applied, with a fallback to Canadian accounting standards), list the adjustments that will be made, and attach a worked example. A sample calculation using historical figures is one of the most effective tools for preventing later disagreement, because it shows the parties' shared understanding of each line item.
Earnout provisions should also address the measurement period (often one to three years), whether payments are cumulative or annual, whether there is a catch-up if a later period makes up for an earlier shortfall, and whether the payment is linear between a floor and a cap or stepped.
Buyer operating covenants
Sellers negotiate covenants that constrain how the buyer runs the business during the earnout period. Typical requests include an obligation to operate the business in the ordinary course, to maintain it as a separate unit with its own books, to fund a minimum budget, to retain key employees and not to divert customers or opportunities to other group companies.
Buyers resist these covenants because they limit integration and the ability to respond to market change. The common compromise is a covenant not to take action with the primary purpose of reducing or avoiding the earnout, combined with a short list of specific restrictions. Buyers often add an express statement that they may operate the business in their sole discretion subject only to those listed covenants. As the next section explains, that statement does not end the analysis under Canadian law.
Earnout provisions and the Wastech duty of good faith
In Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7, the Supreme Court of Canada held that where a contract gives one party discretion, that discretion must be exercised in good faith, meaning reasonably and consistently with the purposes for which it was granted. The case concerned a waste-hauling contract in which Metro had discretion to allocate waste among disposal sites; Metro's choice reduced Wastech's returns, and the Court found no breach because Metro used its discretion for purposes connected to the contract.
The principle applies directly to earnout provisions. A buyer that has discretion over pricing, product launches or sales effort must not exercise it for a purpose unconnected with the reasons the discretion was granted, such as the sole purpose of defeating the earnout. Wastech also confirms that the duty cannot be excluded by the parties, although the scope of the discretion they grant can be defined. For drafters this means two things:
- Define the purposes of the buyer's discretion explicitly, for example integration, cost efficiency and compliance, so that legitimate business decisions are easier to defend.
- Do not rely on "sole discretion" language to shut out a good faith claim; build objective covenants and carve-outs instead.
In Quebec, the Civil Code imposes good faith throughout the life of a contract, and the analysis of a buyer's conduct under earnout provisions will draw on those principles as well as on the contract's terms.
Accounting disputes and expert determination
Most earnout disputes are about numbers. A well-drafted clause sets out a timetable: the buyer delivers an earnout statement within a set period after the measurement period ends; the seller has access to books and personnel and a period to deliver a notice of disagreement; the parties negotiate; and unresolved items go to an independent accountant.
The role of that accountant needs careful definition. An expert determination, in which the accountant acts as an expert and not as an arbitrator, is typically limited to the disputed items, must choose within the range of the parties' positions, and is final and binding absent manifest error. Questions of contractual interpretation (for example, whether the buyer breached an operating covenant or acted in bad faith) are better left to arbitration or the courts. Clauses should say which questions go where, to avoid parallel proceedings arguing over jurisdiction.
Attach a worked example to the agreement and require the buyer to keep separate management accounts for the acquired business during the earnout period. Many earnout disputes turn on ambiguous adjustments and missing data rather than deliberate manipulation, and both problems can be prevented at the drafting stage.
Acceleration events, set-off and security
Sellers commonly ask that the maximum earnout become payable immediately on certain events: a sale of the business or the buyer, a material breach of the operating covenants, the buyer's insolvency, or the termination of the founders without cause. Buyers respond by limiting acceleration to a sale of substantially all of the acquired business and by excluding internal reorganizations.
Two further protections are frequently negotiated:
- Set-off. Buyers want the right to set off indemnity claims against earnout payments. Sellers try to limit set-off to finally determined claims, or to require payment into escrow pending resolution.
- Security and ranking. Earnout obligations are unsecured unless the parties agree otherwise. Where the buyer is leveraged, the senior lender will insist that earnout payments be subordinated and blocked on a default. Sellers should review the intercreditor or subordination terms before signing.
Illustration: an EBITDA earnout gone wrong
Illustration (hypothetical): A Canadian buyer acquires a software company for CAD 40 million at closing plus up to CAD 15 million over two years if annual EBITDA exceeds CAD 6 million. The agreement says EBITDA is calculated "in accordance with the Company's past practices", with no worked example. After closing, the buyer moves the target's sales team onto the group's payroll and charges a management fee for shared services. Reported EBITDA drops to CAD 5.2 million and no payment is made.
The seller disputes the management fee and the reallocation of sales costs. Because the agreement did not say whether group charges are excluded, the parties argue for months over whether an accountant or an arbitrator should decide. Two drafting choices would have avoided most of the dispute: a list of excluded adjustments (group overhead, integration costs, transaction expenses and changes in accounting policy) and a clear split between accounting questions for the expert and covenant questions for arbitration.
Earnout provisions tied to continued employment
Founders frequently stay with the business after closing, and buyers sometimes condition earnout payments on the founder remaining employed. That link has consequences. If payment depends on continued employment rather than on the value of the shares sold, the payment may be characterized as remuneration for services, with the result that it is taxed as employment income and subject to payroll withholding rather than treated as proceeds of disposition.
A forfeiture on termination can also be challenged where the employer terminates without cause, particularly if the employment contract or applicable employment standards legislation entitles the employee to amounts during a notice period. Drafters should decide deliberately whether the earnout is price or compensation, and keep retention incentives in a separate employment or bonus agreement where possible.
- State expressly that earnout payments are additional purchase price for the shares or assets.
- Avoid conditions that turn solely on continued employment; use a separate retention plan instead.
- Address what happens to the earnout if the founder is terminated without cause or resigns for good reason.
Tax treatment of earnout provisions
Earnouts create tax uncertainty because the seller does not know the final proceeds of disposition at closing. Paragraph 12(1)(g) of the Income Tax Act (ITA) includes in income amounts received that are "dependent on the use of or production from property", which could in principle treat earnout payments as income rather than capital.
The Canada Revenue Agency's archived Interpretation Bulletin IT-426R sets out an administrative "cost recovery method" for shares sold under an earnout. Under it, earnout amounts first reduce the adjusted cost base of the shares, and only amounts in excess of cost are reported as capital gains when they become determinable. The bulletin conditions this treatment on, among other things, an arm's length sale, capital property, an earnout relating to goodwill that cannot reasonably be valued at closing, an earnout ending no later than five years after the end of the corporation's taxation year in which the shares were sold, a vendor resident in Canada, and a request filed with the return for the year of sale. Non-resident vendors cannot use the method.
A reverse earnout, where the maximum price is stated in the agreement and reduced if targets are missed, is an alternative that some sellers prefer, because the price is fixed and later reductions are treated as adjustments. Its tax treatment, including the timing of any reduction, should be confirmed with tax advisers for the specific facts. Earnout payments to non-resident sellers also raise withholding and section 116 questions that should be built into the payment mechanics.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise buyers and sellers on earnout provisions in Canadian acquisitions: choosing and defining the metric, negotiating operating covenants and acceleration events, drafting the expert determination process and coordinating tax structuring with accounting advisers. When disputes arise, we review earnout statements, assess good faith arguments under Wastech and represent clients in negotiation, expert determination and arbitration, working with Canadian counsel where a provincial licence is required. See also our pages on mergers and acquisitions, corporate and international tax and commercial litigation, and our insight on locked box and closing accounts. To discuss a transaction, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Can a buyer exclude the duty of good faith from an earnout?
No. In Wastech, 2021 SCC 7, the Supreme Court held that the duty to exercise contractual discretion in good faith cannot be contracted out of, although the parties can define the scope and purposes of the discretion. Buyers should rely on clear covenants and stated purposes rather than broad sole discretion language.
Which metric produces the fewest earnout disputes?
Objective milestones such as a regulatory approval or a signed customer contract produce fewer disputes than financial metrics, but create all-or-nothing outcomes. Revenue is generally less contentious than EBITDA because it is less affected by cost allocations. Whatever the metric, a worked example attached to the agreement reduces disagreement.
Who decides an earnout accounting dispute?
Most agreements send disputed calculations to an independent accountant acting as an expert, not an arbitrator. The expert decides only the disputed items within the parties' ranges. Allegations of covenant breach or bad faith usually go to arbitration or court, and the clause should say so.
Can non-resident sellers use the cost recovery method?
No. CRA's archived IT-426R limits the administrative cost recovery method to vendors resident in Canada, among other conditions. Non-resident sellers must consider other approaches, and payments to them can raise withholding and section 116 issues that should be reflected in the payment mechanics.
What happens to an earnout if the buyer sells the business?
Only what the agreement says. Sellers often negotiate acceleration of the maximum payment on a sale of the acquired business, while buyers prefer the earnout to continue as an obligation of the purchaser. Without a clause, the seller's rights depend on the covenants and assignment provisions.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


