Skip to content
Energy, Mining & Environment

Environmental Offences: Director and Officer Liability

Environmental offences can lead to personal fines and even imprisonment for directors and officers in Canada. CEPA imposes a positive duty of reasonable care, the Fisheries Act makes participating directors parties to corporate offences, and Quebec presumes director liability. This guide explains the exposure, the penalties and how to build a due diligence system that holds up.

Boardroom reviewing an environmental compliance report, illustrating environmental offences and director liability

Key takeaways

  • CEPA s. 280.1 requires directors and officers to take all reasonable care to ensure compliance.
  • Directors who direct, authorize, assent to or acquiesce in offences are parties under CEPA and the Fisheries Act.
  • Individuals face fines from CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million or up to three years on indictment.
  • Quebec’s Environment Quality Act presumes director and officer liability unless due diligence is shown.
  • A documented, board-monitored compliance system is the core of the due diligence defence.

Can directors and officers be personally liable for environmental offences?

Yes. Canadian environmental statutes expose directors and officers to personal prosecution in two ways. First, most statutes make a director or officer a party to an offence committed by the corporation if they directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in it. Second, some statutes impose a positive duty on directors and officers to take all reasonable care to ensure that the corporation complies. Penalties for individuals include fines with statutory minimums and, for some environmental offences, imprisonment. The main protection is due diligence: proving that reasonable systems were in place and actually working. For boards and senior executives in resources, manufacturing, chemicals, transportation and real estate, that makes compliance systems a personal as well as corporate priority.

Boardroom reviewing an environmental compliance report, illustrating environmental offences and director liability
Environmental offences can lead to personal fines and imprisonment for directors and officers, subject to a due diligence defence.

This note covers the federal Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999 (CEPA) and the Fisheries Act, outlines provincial regimes including Quebec's, and sets out what a defensible due diligence system looks like. It reflects statutes current to 19 October 2026 and is general information, not legal advice.

Director and officer liability under CEPA

Under s. 280(1) of CEPA, if a corporation commits an offence, any director, officer, agent or mandatary who directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in the commission of the offence is a party to and guilty of the offence, and is liable to the penalty provided for an individual, whether or not the corporation has been prosecuted or convicted. Section 280.1(1) adds a positive duty: every director and officer must take all reasonable care to ensure that the corporation complies with the Act and regulations and with orders, directions, prohibitions and requirements imposed by the Minister, enforcement officers and the Environmental Protection Tribunal.

The positive duty matters. A director who simply did not know about a problem cannot rely on ignorance if reasonable care would have revealed it. The duty is not one of perfection, but it requires boards to put in place, and to monitor, systems that are designed to prevent and detect contraventions.

Penalties for individuals

For the most serious category of CEPA offences under s. 272(1), an individual faces, on indictment, a fine of CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million or up to three years' imprisonment, or both, for a first offence, and CAD 30,000 to CAD 2 million for a second or subsequent offence. On summary conviction, a first offence carries a fine of CAD 5,000 to CAD 300,000 or up to six months' imprisonment, or both. Corporations face much higher ranges, for example CAD 500,000 to CAD 6 million on indictment for a first offence by a corporation that is not a small revenue corporation (s. 272(3)).

The Fisheries Act

The Fisheries Act is one of the most frequently prosecuted federal environmental statutes because it prohibits activities that result in the death of fish (s. 34.4(1)) or the harmful alteration, disruption or destruction of fish habitat (s. 35(1)), and prohibits deposits of deleterious substances in water frequented by fish. Section 78.2 makes any officer, director or agent who directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in a corporate offence a party to it, whether or not the corporation is prosecuted. Section 78.6 provides the defence that the person exercised all due diligence or reasonably and honestly believed in facts that would have made the conduct innocent.

Fines track the CEPA structure. For contraventions of s. 34.4(1) or 35(1), s. 40(1) provides that an individual faces, on indictment, CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million for a first offence and CAD 30,000 to CAD 2 million, or imprisonment of up to three years, or both, for a subsequent offence. Corporations other than small revenue corporations face CAD 500,000 to CAD 6 million on indictment for a first offence. Our note on Fisheries Act authorizations explains how to obtain approvals that avoid these offences.

Environmental offences compared

StatuteDirector and officer provisionIndividual penalty (first offence, indictment)Defence
CEPAParty liability (s. 280(1)) and duty of reasonable care (s. 280.1)CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million, or up to 3 years, or bothDue diligence (s. 283), subject to exceptions
Fisheries ActParty liability (s. 78.2)CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million (s. 40(1))Due diligence or mistake of fact (s. 78.6)
Quebec Environment Quality ActPresumption of director and officer liability, rebuttable by due diligenceStatutory minimum and maximum fines; imprisonment for serious offencesDue diligence
Ontario Environmental Protection ActPositive duty on directors and officers to take all reasonable care to prevent certain dischargesDaily fines and imprisonment for serious contraventionsDue diligence

Provincial regimes, including Quebec

Every province has environmental legislation with its own offences and director provisions. Section 194(1) of Ontario's Environmental Protection Act provides that every director or officer has a duty to take all reasonable care to prevent the corporation from discharging, or causing or permitting the discharge of, a contaminant in contravention of the Act, and the Ontario Water Resources Act contains a parallel duty. These provisions impose duties on directors and officers to take all reasonable care to prevent the corporation from causing or permitting unlawful discharges, and they have been the basis for personal prosecutions and orders. Alberta's Environmental Protection and Enhancement Act and British Columbia's Environmental Management Act contain party liability provisions and significant fines, and both allow administrative penalties as an alternative to prosecution.

Quebec's Environment Quality Act was overhauled in 2017 and contains one of the strictest regimes. It sets statutory minimum and maximum fines by offence category, with higher amounts for corporations and repeat offences, and it includes a presumption that directors and officers of a corporation that commits an offence have themselves committed it unless they establish due diligence. Quebec also uses administrative monetary penalties extensively. Companies operating in Quebec should treat the presumption as a reason to document board oversight of environmental compliance carefully.

Orders directed at directors and officers

Beyond prosecution, environmental regulators can issue orders requiring cleanup, investigation or remediation. Some statutes allow orders to be directed to persons who had management or control of a property or undertaking, which in certain circumstances can include directors and officers personally. Enforcement officers may also issue directions requiring immediate action after a release. Failure to comply with such orders or directions is itself an offence, and CEPA's s. 280.1 duty expressly extends to ensuring compliance with orders and directions of enforcement officers.

When inspectors arrive: handling investigations

Many prosecutions for environmental offences begin with a routine inspection or a spill report. Inspectors and enforcement officers have broad powers to enter premises, take samples, examine records and require information, and statements made during an inspection can later be used as evidence. Companies should have a protocol that identifies who will accompany inspectors, how documents and samples are tracked, when legal counsel is called and how employees are briefed on their rights and obligations. The distinction between a regulatory inspection and a penal investigation matters, because Charter protections become more significant once the predominant purpose of the inquiry is to determine penal liability.

Mandatory reporting obligations add another layer. Federal and provincial statutes require prompt reporting of spills and releases, and failure to report can itself be an offence. A good response plan ensures that reports are accurate and timely, that remediation begins immediately and that the company's own investigation is conducted in a way that preserves privilege where appropriate. Directors should receive prompt notice of significant incidents so that they can show they were informed and responsive.

Administrative penalties

Regulators increasingly use administrative monetary penalties instead of, or before, prosecution. Federal environmental statutes have an administrative penalty regime, and provinces such as Quebec, Ontario, Alberta and British Columbia also use penalties. These are imposed without a trial and with a lower standard of proof, though they can be reviewed. Repeated penalties can be an aggravating factor if a prosecution follows, and they are a signal to boards that compliance systems need attention.

Sentencing principles

Courts sentencing environmental offences consider the harm or risk of harm, the offender's culpability, any previous convictions, profit or savings from non-compliance and the need for deterrence. CEPA and the Fisheries Act list aggravating factors such as damage to the environment, deliberate or reckless conduct, concealment and failure to take preventive measures, and they allow courts to make creative orders, including directing payment to environmental funds, requiring publication of the conviction, ordering environmental audits and imposing compliance conditions. Fines paid under the federal statutes are generally directed to the Environmental Damages Fund.

For individuals, a conviction can carry reputational consequences beyond the penalty, including effects on eligibility to serve on other boards and on securities regulators' assessments. Indemnification and insurance are relevant but limited: corporate statutes restrict indemnification where the individual did not act honestly and in good faith, and directors' and officers' insurance policies typically exclude fines and penalties or deliberate misconduct.

Building a due diligence system

The due diligence defence requires proof, on a balance of probabilities, that the accused took all reasonable steps to avoid the particular event. For directors, courts have looked at whether a system was in place to prevent environmental harm, whether the board ensured it was operating, whether officers reported regularly and whether the board responded promptly to problems. Key elements include:

  • a board-approved environmental policy and allocation of responsibility to a named senior officer;
  • an environmental management system with risk assessment, procedures, training and emergency response;
  • regular reporting to the board, including incidents, near misses, regulatory communications and audit findings;
  • independent audits and follow-up of corrective actions;
  • adequate budgets and authority for environmental staff;
  • documentation showing that the board asked questions and acted on the answers.
Practical point

Minutes matter. In prosecutions, board minutes and reports are often the best evidence of reasonable care. Make sure environmental compliance appears as a regular agenda item, that significant issues are minuted with the actions taken and that follow-up is tracked to completion.

Environmental offences in transactions

Environmental offences and orders also matter in M&A and financing. Buyers should review enforcement history, outstanding orders, regulatory correspondence and the target's compliance systems, and consider specific indemnities for pre-closing contraventions. New directors appointed after closing inherit the duty of reasonable care from day one, so integration plans should include an early review of environmental compliance. Our pages on environmental and climate law and corporate governance discuss board oversight more broadly, and our note on mine closure covers long-tail liabilities in the mining sector.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise boards, executives and companies on environmental offences and director and officer exposure in Canada. We review and design compliance and reporting systems, prepare boards for oversight of environmental risk, respond to inspections, orders and investigations, and assess environmental liabilities in transactions. Where a matter requires a lawyer licensed in a particular province, such as for a court appearance, we work with local counsel. To discuss your organization's position, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the duty of directors under CEPA?

Section 280.1(1) of CEPA requires every director and officer of a corporation to take all reasonable care to ensure that the corporation complies with the Act, its regulations and orders, directions and requirements of the Minister, enforcement officers and the Tribunal. It is a positive duty, so lack of knowledge is not a defence if reasonable care would have revealed the problem.

Can a director be convicted if the company is not prosecuted?

Yes. Both CEPA s. 280(1) and Fisheries Act s. 78.2 provide that a director or officer who directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in a corporate offence is a party to it, whether or not the corporation has been prosecuted or convicted.

What penalties do individuals face for federal environmental offences?

For the most serious CEPA offences and for Fisheries Act fish and habitat offences, an individual convicted on indictment faces a first-offence fine of CAD 15,000 to CAD 1 million, and CEPA also allows imprisonment of up to three years. Fines double for subsequent offences, and summary conviction ranges are lower.

What is the due diligence defence?

It allows an accused to avoid conviction by proving, on a balance of probabilities, that they took all reasonable steps to prevent the offence. For directors, courts look at whether a compliance system existed, whether the board ensured it worked, whether officers reported regularly and whether problems were addressed promptly.

Will directors’ insurance cover environmental fines?

Usually not fully. Directors’ and officers’ policies often exclude fines and penalties and deliberate misconduct, though they may cover defence costs. Corporate indemnification is limited where the director did not act honestly and in good faith. Directors should review their coverage and indemnity agreements.

Sources

  1. Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999 (S.C. 1999, c. 33) — ss. 272, 280, 280.1, 283
  2. Fisheries Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. F-14) — ss. 34.4, 35, 40, 78.2, 78.6
  3. Environmental Protection Act (Ontario), R.S.O. 1990, c. E.19

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.