Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Equity Awards on Termination: Forfeiture Clauses for RSUs and Options

Equity and bonus plans almost always say that unvested awards are forfeited when employment ends. Whether those forfeiture clauses actually remove an employee's entitlement during the reasonable notice period is a separate question, which the Supreme Court answered in Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition with a demanding two-step test.

Equity award agreement with highlighted forfeiture clauses on termination

Key takeaways

  • Damages for wrongful dismissal include incentive compensation that would have vested or been earned during the notice period.
  • Forfeiture clauses must clearly and unambiguously remove that entitlement.
  • Language tied to 'active employment' or the 'date of termination' may not suffice.
  • Courts also ask whether the terms were brought to the employee's attention.
  • Clauses that would breach employment standards minimums are unenforceable.
  • Consistent plan, award and employment agreement terms are the best protection.

Why forfeiture clauses are contested

Employees dismissed without cause, and without an enforceable termination clause, are entitled to damages equal to what they would have earned during the reasonable notice period. That includes salary and benefits, and it can include bonuses, restricted share units (RSUs), performance share units, stock options and other incentives that would have been paid or vested during that period. Incentive plans usually contain forfeiture clauses stating that unvested awards lapse on termination. The question in litigation is whether those forfeiture clauses displace the employee's common law right to damages for awards that would have vested during the notice period.

Equity award agreement with highlighted forfeiture clauses on termination
Forfeiture clauses in equity plans must be clear and properly communicated to limit damages on termination.

The amounts at stake can be large. For executives and technology employees, unvested equity can exceed a year's salary. A plan that seemed to forfeit everything on termination may, if its forfeiture clauses fail, leave the employer liable for the value of awards vesting over a long notice period.

Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition

In Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, a senior employee was constructively dismissed about a year before the company was sold. A long-term incentive plan provided for a payment on a sale, but stated that the employee had to be a full-time employee at the time of the sale, and that the plan did not form part of any damages calculation. The Supreme Court held that the employee was entitled to the payment as damages because the sale occurred within his 15-month reasonable notice period.

The Court set out a two-step approach. First, would the employee have been entitled to the bonus or benefit as part of their compensation during the reasonable notice period? Second, do the terms of the employment contract or plan unambiguously take away or limit that common law right? The Court emphasized that language requiring the employee to be "full-time" or "active" at the time of payment, or excluding entitlement "upon termination", does not necessarily cover termination without reasonable notice.

A clause must clearly cover that situation. The Court also noted, without deciding, that a forfeiture clause may need to be brought to the employee's attention to be enforceable, particularly where it is in a plan document the employee may not have seen.

Drafting approachLikely effect after Matthews
"Must be actively employed on the vesting date"Often insufficient; does not address the notice period
"Forfeited on termination for any reason"Uncertain; may not cover wrongful termination without reasonable notice
Express exclusion of any period of reasonable notice, pay in lieu or damages, with statutory minimums preservedStronger, if brought to the employee's attention
Clause that removes statutory entitlementsUnenforceable; may taint the plan's termination provisions

Appellate guidance since Matthews

Appellate courts have applied Matthews in a range of cases, with outcomes turning on the wording and on how the terms were communicated. In Battiston v. Microsoft Canada Inc., 2021 ONCA 727, the Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld a forfeiture clause in a stock award agreement where the employee had been sent the plan terms and accepted them each year as a condition of receiving awards, even though he did not read them. The court treated the clause as clear and as having been brought to his attention through the annual acceptance process. In other decisions, courts have refused to enforce clauses that relied on vague "active employment" language or that were buried in plan documents never provided to the employee.

The trend is that well-drafted forfeiture clauses, communicated through a process the employee must engage with, are enforceable, while generic clauses in documents the employee never saw are not.

Drafting enforceable forfeiture clauses

  1. State that unvested awards are forfeited on the "termination date", defined as the date the employee receives notice of termination or the last day of active work, whichever is earlier, and expressly not extended by any period of reasonable notice, pay in lieu of notice or damages.
  2. Preserve statutory minimums: during any statutory notice period under employment standards legislation, awards that the statute treats as wages or benefits should continue to vest or be compensated.
  3. Address each termination scenario: without cause, for cause, resignation, retirement, death and disability.
  4. Use consistent language across the plan, the award agreement and the employment agreement.
  5. Require employees to accept award terms through a process that records acceptance, and provide the full plan.
  6. Highlight the forfeiture terms in plain language in award communications.
Practical point

Statutory minimums matter. Under Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 and similar statutes, a forfeiture clause that denies an employee awards or incentive amounts that would count as wages during the employment standards notice period can be unenforceable for that reason alone, and may be used to attack termination provisions elsewhere. Carve out statutory entitlements expressly.

Short-term bonuses

The same principles apply to annual bonuses. Where a bonus is an integral part of compensation, as it usually is for senior employees, an employee dismissed without notice may be entitled to the bonus that would have been earned during the notice period, including pro-rated amounts, unless the plan clearly excludes it. Discretionary bonuses are not necessarily excluded: where bonuses have been paid regularly and form part of expected compensation, courts may treat them as part of damages even if the plan reserves discretion, unless the discretion is genuinely exercised in a way that would have resulted in no payment.

Stock options

For stock options, the question is whether options would have vested during the notice period and, if so, what damages follow. Courts may award the value of options that would have vested and could have been exercised, often measured by the in-the-money value at a relevant date. Plans typically provide a short post-termination exercise window for vested options; whether that window starts at the termination date or at the end of the notice period is a frequent dispute. Tax consequences also differ between options actually exercised and damages paid in lieu, which are generally employment income.

If forfeiture clauses fail

If a court finds that forfeiture clauses do not displace the common law right, damages are calculated on the basis of what would have vested or been paid during the reasonable notice period, sometimes with adjustments for contingencies such as performance conditions. Where performance conditions apply, courts estimate the likely outcome, often by reference to actual results for other participants. Valuing equity in a private company can require expert evidence. Employers should therefore consider the potential incentive exposure when calculating offers on termination, and document how any settlement value for awards was determined.

Leaves, disability and retirement

Plans should also address awards held by employees on leave. Employment standards legislation protects employees on statutory leaves, including pregnancy and parental leave, from losing benefits that continue to accrue, and human rights law prohibits disadvantaging employees because of disability. A clause that forfeits awards because an employee is on a protected leave, or treats the start of long-term disability as a termination, risks both statutory and human rights claims. Retirement provisions that accelerate or continue vesting for retirees should define retirement objectively, since age-based distinctions must be justified.

Change of control and forfeiture clauses

Corporate transactions often determine whether awards vest. Many plans provide for acceleration on a change of control combined with a qualifying termination, the double-trigger approach. If an employee is terminated shortly before a transaction, Matthews shows that the employee may claim the value of acceleration that would have occurred during the notice period. Buyers and sellers should identify employees terminated in the period before closing and assess this exposure. Forfeiture clauses should expressly address terminations in anticipation of a transaction, although such clauses will still be read strictly.

Releases and settlements

Because incentive entitlements are uncertain, they are often resolved in settlement. Release agreements should identify the awards being cancelled or settled, state any amounts paid in respect of them, and address tax withholding. Where awards are cancelled in exchange for a cash payment, the payment is generally employment income or a retiring allowance depending on its character, and the employer should withhold accordingly. Settlements should also deal with any shares already acquired under the plans, including repurchase rights in private companies.

Cross-border plans

Many Canadian employees participate in plans of a US or other foreign parent governed by foreign law. A governing law clause may not prevent a Canadian court from applying Canadian employment law to damages for wrongful dismissal, which is a claim against the Canadian employer. Foreign plans should be reviewed for Canadian employees and, where necessary, supplemented with Canadian addenda that address forfeiture, statutory minimums and Quebec requirements, including French-language documentation where required.

Quebec

In Quebec, an employee cannot renounce in advance the right to compensation for insufficient notice, so forfeiture clauses that purport to eliminate compensation for incentives during the notice period may be treated restrictively. Quebec courts apply the Civil Code's rules on contracts of adhesion and abusive clauses to plan documents. Employers should obtain Quebec advice on plan terms for Quebec-based participants.

Communicating plan terms

Because enforceability may depend on whether the forfeiture terms were brought to the employee's attention, the grant process matters as much as the drafting. Best practice is to deliver the plan and award agreement with each grant, require the employee to accept electronically before the award becomes effective, and include a short summary of what happens on termination in plain language. Keeping records of acceptance, including timestamps and the version of the documents accepted, allows the employer to prove the process years later. Where awards are granted automatically without any acceptance step, employers should consider adding one for future grants.

Changes to plan terms should be communicated just as carefully. A plan amendment that tightens forfeiture rules for existing awards may require employee consent or fresh consideration, and an amendment adopted without notice is unlikely to bind employees who never saw it.

Practical steps for employers

  • Audit existing plans and award agreements against Matthews and recent appellate decisions.
  • Amend plans for future grants and consider whether existing awards can be amended with consent.
  • Implement an electronic acceptance process for each grant.
  • Align employment agreement termination clauses with plan terms.
  • Model incentive exposure when planning terminations and preparing offers.
  • Train HR teams to explain award treatment consistently in termination meetings and letters.
  • Review Canadian addenda to foreign parent plans whenever the parent amends its global plan.

How TRW & Co helps

We review and draft forfeiture clauses in equity, bonus and long-term incentive plans, prepare Canadian addenda to foreign plans, advise on terminations involving significant incentives, and act in disputes over unvested awards. Our employment law and tax teams work together. See also our insights on employee stock options and reasonable notice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your plans.

Frequently asked questions

Are RSUs forfeited when an employee is dismissed?

Only if the plan clearly and unambiguously removes the employee's right to awards that would have vested during the reasonable notice period, under Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition, 2020 SCC 26. Generic 'active employment' language may not be enough, and statutory minimums must be preserved.

What did Matthews decide?

The Supreme Court held that an employee constructively dismissed was entitled to a long-term incentive payment triggered during his reasonable notice period. It set a two-step test: whether the employee would have been entitled during the notice period, and whether plan terms unambiguously remove that right.

Can forfeiture clauses ever be enforced?

Yes. In Battiston v. Microsoft Canada, 2021 ONCA 727, the Court of Appeal for Ontario enforced a forfeiture clause where the employee had accepted the award terms each year, even without reading them. Clear wording and a process that brings terms to the employee's attention are key.

Do bonuses count during the notice period?

Often yes, where bonuses are an integral part of compensation. Unless the plan clearly excludes entitlement during the notice period, employees may recover bonuses that would have been earned, sometimes pro-rated, even under nominally discretionary plans.

What about employment standards minimums?

Forfeiture clauses must not deny amounts that employment standards legislation treats as wages or benefits during the statutory notice period. Clauses that do can be unenforceable and may undermine other termination provisions.

Sources

  1. Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26
  2. Employment Standards Act, 2000 (Ontario)
  3. Civil Code of Québec

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.