Group Benefits Plans: Legal Risks and Pharmacare
Group benefits plans for health, dental, life and disability coverage are a large part of total compensation in Canada. Designing and changing them raises employment, human rights and contract issues, and federal programs such as the Pharmacare Act and the Canadian Dental Care Plan are changing how employer plans interact with public coverage.

Key takeaways
- Group benefits plans are contractual promises; changes can raise constructive dismissal issues.
- Employment standards require benefits to continue during statutory notice and protected leaves.
- Age-based distinctions after 65 are permitted in some jurisdictions but are under scrutiny.
- Retiree benefit reductions depend on the documents and communications promising them.
- Disability coverage gaps after termination are a major source of employer liability.
- The Pharmacare Act, S.C. 2024, c. 24, began a first phase of public coverage for contraception and diabetes medications.
Why group benefits plans carry legal risk
Group benefits plans are usually insured or administrative-services-only arrangements in which an insurer or administrator provides health, dental, vision, life, accidental death and disability coverage under a contract with the employer. Employees are typically not parties to the insurance contract, but their entitlement to benefits is part of their employment contract. That dual structure creates risk: the employer can promise more in employment documents than the insurance policy delivers, and the employer bears the gap.

Most disputes arise at moments of change: termination, disability, leave, retirement, age 65, plan redesign and corporate transactions. The rules come from employment standards legislation, human rights law, insurance law, the common law of employment and, for retirees, the documents and communications through which benefits were promised.
Benefits during notice and leaves
Employment standards statutes require employers to continue benefit plan contributions during the statutory notice period. In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act, 2000 requires continuation of benefits during the statutory notice period and continued participation in benefit plans during pregnancy, parental and other protected leaves. Termination clauses that do not preserve benefits during the statutory period are unenforceable. At common law, damages for wrongful dismissal include the value of benefits during the reasonable notice period, and if an employee becomes disabled or dies during that period without coverage, the employer may be liable for the benefits that would have been paid.
| Situation | Key risk | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|
| Termination without cause | Uninsured disability or death during the notice period | Continue coverage where possible, or price the risk into the package |
| Employee on disability leave | Coverage ends on termination; insurer disputes | Coordinate with insurer before any termination decision |
| Employee turns 65 | Age discrimination claims if benefits end | Review jurisdiction-specific rules and plan design |
| Retiree benefit changes | Claims that benefits were promised for life | Review historical documents and communications |
| Plan redesign | Constructive dismissal or bargaining issues | Notice, consultation, consideration, bargaining |
Insurers often allow continuation of coverage for a limited period after termination, and some permit conversion of life coverage to individual policies. Employers should check what continuation is available before termination and avoid promising coverage the insurer will not provide. Where coverage cannot be continued, a lump-sum payment in lieu of benefits, calculated on a reasonable basis, is a common alternative in settlements.
Disability benefits
Long-term disability coverage is the most valuable and contentious benefit. Where an employee becomes disabled while covered, the insurer generally remains responsible for benefits even after employment ends, subject to policy terms. But if coverage was terminated early, for example because the employer stopped coverage at the end of the statutory notice period rather than the common law period, and the employee becomes disabled in the gap, the employer can be liable for the lost benefits. Employers should also avoid terminating employees on disability leave without assessing accommodation obligations and the effect on coverage. Our insight on workplace accommodation explains those duties.
Post-65 benefits and age
Human rights legislation in several provinces historically allowed benefit plans to distinguish on the basis of age for employees 65 and older, reflecting traditional retirement ages and insurer pricing. As mandatory retirement was abolished, these exceptions have been challenged, and tribunals have scrutinized whether ending or reducing benefits at 65 is justified. Employers should review the rules in each jurisdiction and consider offering at least some coverage to employees working past 65, with adjustments justified by cost data. Life and disability coverage commonly reduces or ends at 65 or 70 under insurer terms, which should be clearly disclosed.
Read the insurance policy, not just the benefits booklet. Booklets summarize coverage and often say that the policy governs, but courts may hold employers to booklet language if the policy is never provided to employees. Make sure the booklet, the employment contract and the policy say the same thing about eligibility, age limits and termination of coverage.
Retiree benefits
Many employers that offered post-retirement health benefits have reduced or eliminated them as costs rose. Whether they can do so depends on what was promised. If plan documents, collective agreements or communications promised benefits "for life" without reserving a right to amend, retirees may have enforceable rights. If documents consistently reserved the right to change or terminate benefits, the employer will usually be able to make changes prospectively. Courts examine the full history of documents, including enrollment materials and retirement letters. In unionized settings, retiree benefits may be vested under collective agreements in force at retirement.
Changing group benefits plans
For active employees, significant reductions in benefits can amount to a fundamental change to the employment contract. Employers can reduce risk by reserving the right to change benefits in employment contracts, giving reasonable notice of changes, offering consideration and, where employees are unionized, bargaining. Moving from a traditional plan to a flexible or health spending account model is usually lawful if done with notice and if the overall value is maintained. Changes that disproportionately affect protected groups, such as employees with disabilities or older employees, should be assessed for human rights implications.
Pharmacare and public coverage
The federal Pharmacare Act, S.C. 2024, c. 24, received royal assent in October 2024, as Health Canada announced. It sets out principles for national pharmacare and supports a first phase of universal, single-payer coverage for contraception and diabetes medications, delivered through agreements with provinces and territories. Coverage depends on those agreements, so availability differs by jurisdiction and over time. Where public coverage is available, employer plans may become secondary payers for those drugs, which can affect plan costs and design.
The Canadian Dental Care Plan provides federal dental coverage for eligible residents without access to dental insurance, subject to income thresholds. Employees with access to employer dental coverage are generally not eligible, which means employer plans remain the primary source of dental coverage for most employees. Employers should monitor how these programs evolve, since future phases could affect the interaction between public and private coverage.
Insurer contract terms
- Actively at work. Coverage may not start or increase until the employee is actively at work.
- Eligibility. Minimum hours, waiting periods and classes of employees.
- Termination of coverage. Typically ends on termination of employment or at a set age.
- Conversion and continuation. Limited rights to convert life coverage and to continue health coverage.
- Pre-existing conditions and evidence of insurability. Restrictions on new or increased coverage.
- Administrative obligations. Accurate enrollment and timely premium payment; errors can leave employees uninsured.
Administration errors
Many employer liabilities arise from administrative mistakes: failing to enrol an eligible employee, failing to submit evidence of insurability for optional life coverage, terminating coverage too early, or miscommunicating conversion rights. Where an employee or beneficiary loses benefits because of such errors, the employer may be liable for the amount the insurer would have paid. Regular audits of enrollment data and clear processes for terminations, leaves and age milestones reduce that risk.
Communication errors are just as costly. HR staff who tell a departing employee that coverage continues, when the insurer has terminated it, or who fail to explain conversion deadlines, can create liability. Standard termination letters should state precisely when each coverage ends, what continuation or conversion options exist, and the deadlines for exercising them, with the insurer's materials attached.
Insured and self-insured group benefits plans
Group benefits plans can be fully insured, where the insurer bears the claims risk in exchange for premiums, or administered on an administrative-services-only (ASO) basis, where the employer funds claims and the insurer or administrator processes them. Many employers combine the two, insuring life and long-term disability while self-funding health and dental. Self-insured long-term disability creates significant employer exposure, since the employer must pay claims that may last decades, and in an insolvency employees may be left unprotected. Several regulators and legislatures have addressed self-insured disability plans because of past insolvency cases. Employers using ASO arrangements should understand stop-loss coverage, claims adjudication practices and how disputes with claimants are handled.
Health spending accounts and flexible group benefits plans
Health spending accounts and flexible benefits plans let employees allocate a fixed employer credit across coverage options or reimburse eligible medical expenses. They help control costs and respond to diverse employee needs, but they must be structured to satisfy the Income Tax Act's requirements for a private health services plan if reimbursements are to be non-taxable. Unused credits, carry-forward rules and the tax treatment of any taxable allowances should be clearly explained. Wellness and lifestyle spending accounts, which cover items such as gym memberships, are generally taxable benefits and should be communicated as such.
Mental health coverage
Coverage for psychological services has grown in importance, and many group benefits plans have increased annual maximums. Employers should consider how mental health coverage interacts with disability management and accommodation, and whether employee assistance programs, paramedical coverage and short-term disability work together. Coverage decisions affecting particular conditions should be reviewed for human rights implications, particularly where they exclude or cap benefits for mental health conditions differently from physical conditions.
Mergers and acquisitions
In transactions, buyers should review benefit plans for retiree commitments, self-insured exposures, pending disability claims and inconsistencies between booklets and policies. In asset deals, employees moving to the buyer may need replacement coverage without gaps, and disabled employees who do not transfer remain with the seller's insurer. Transition services agreements can bridge coverage during integration. Our insight on pension issues in M&A covers related plan issues.
Group benefits checklist
- Compare employment contracts, booklets and insurance policies for consistency on eligibility, age limits and termination of coverage.
- Set a termination protocol that addresses benefits continuation, conversion rights and disability risk.
- Review treatment of employees on leave and those approaching 65.
- Audit enrollment data and evidence of insurability submissions annually.
- Document any reserved rights to amend benefits, including for retirees.
- Monitor federal and provincial public coverage changes, including pharmacare agreements.
- Review self-insured exposures and stop-loss arrangements.
Illustration: an employer terminates a 58-year-old employee without cause and stops all benefits after the eight-week statutory notice period, although a court later finds reasonable notice to be 16 months. Six months after termination, the employee is diagnosed with a serious illness that prevents work. Because long-term disability coverage would have continued during the notice period, the employer may be liable for the disability benefits the insurer would have paid, potentially until age 65. Continuing coverage, or pricing the risk into a settlement with a release, would have avoided that exposure.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise employers on group benefits plans: plan design and redesign, alignment of booklets, contracts and policies, terminations and leaves, retiree benefit changes, insurer disputes and transactions. Our pensions and benefits practice works with our employment law team. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your plans.
Frequently asked questions
Must employers continue benefits after termination?
During the statutory notice period, yes, under employment standards legislation such as Ontario's ESA. At common law, damages include the value of benefits during the reasonable notice period, and employers can be liable for uninsured losses if an employee becomes disabled or dies during that period without coverage.
Can benefits end at age 65?
Some jurisdictions have allowed benefit plans to distinguish based on age for employees 65 and older, but these distinctions are under scrutiny since mandatory retirement was abolished. Employers should review jurisdiction-specific rules and justify any reductions with cost data.
Can an employer reduce retiree benefits?
It depends on what was promised. If documents and communications consistently reserved the right to amend or terminate, prospective changes are usually possible. If benefits were promised for life without reservation, or vested under a collective agreement, retirees may have enforceable rights.
How does the Pharmacare Act affect employer plans?
The Pharmacare Act, S.C. 2024, c. 24, supports a first phase of public coverage for contraception and diabetes medications through agreements with provinces and territories. Where public coverage applies, employer plans may become secondary for those drugs, affecting costs and design.
Who is liable for benefits lost through administration errors?
Often the employer. If an employee loses coverage because the employer failed to enrol them, submit required evidence, or terminated coverage too early, the employer may be liable for what the insurer would have paid.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


