Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Start-Up Employment Law Essentials

Start-up employment law decisions made in the first year follow a company into every financing round and exit. This guide sets out what Canadian founders need in place: enforceable contracts, IP assignments, option terms that survive termination, contractor and intern rules, remote hires across provinces and how to avoid early dismissal liability.

Founders reviewing start-up employment law documents for their first hires at a Canadian tech company

Key takeaways

  • Sign written contracts with ESA-compliant termination clauses before employees start.
  • One defective termination clause can void all of them (Waksdale, 2020 ONCA 391).
  • Get IP assignments and moral rights waivers from founders, employees and contractors.
  • Option plans must clearly address vesting on termination (Matthews, 2020 SCC 26).
  • Unpaid internships and employee non-competes are largely prohibited in Ontario.

Why start-up employment law matters from the first hire

Start-up employment law is mostly about avoiding a handful of expensive, predictable mistakes in the first year: hiring without a written contract, leaving intellectual property with the people who created it, promising equity loosely, treating employees as contractors, taking on unpaid interns and hiring across provincial lines without checking which rules apply. Each mistake is cheap to prevent at the offer stage and costly to fix in a dismissal, a financing round or an acquisition, when investors and buyers will ask to see the paperwork.

Founders reviewing start-up employment law documents for their first hires at a Canadian tech company
Start-up employment law issues are easiest to fix before the first offer letter is signed.

Employment in Canada is provincially regulated for most businesses. A Toronto start-up is governed by Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA); a Vancouver one by British Columbia's legislation; a Montreal one by Quebec's Act respecting labour standards and the Civil Code. Federal rules under the Canada Labour Code apply only to federally regulated sectors such as banking, telecommunications and interprovincial transport, which few early-stage companies enter. The examples below use Ontario law, with differences flagged where they matter.

Offer letters and employment contracts

An offer letter is a contract. If it states salary, title and start date but says nothing about termination, a court will imply "reasonable notice" at common law, which for a mid-career employee can reach many months of pay. A properly drafted termination clause can limit entitlements to the ESA minimums, which in Ontario start at one week of notice after three months' service and rise by roughly a week per year of service to a maximum of eight weeks (ss. 54 and 57 ESA), plus severance pay for larger employers.

Drafting matters more than founders expect. In Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that if any termination provision in a contract (including a "for cause" clause) breaches the ESA, all the termination provisions fall, even if the clause actually relied on was compliant. Section 5(1) ESA makes any contracting out of an employment standard void. Template clauses copied from the internet often fail this test.

  • Sign the contract before the employee starts; terms imposed after the first day may fail for lack of fresh consideration.
  • Include a termination clause reviewed for current ESA compliance, and refresh it when the law changes.
  • Address probation accurately: the ESA does not require notice in the first three months, but a contractual "probation" that purports to remove all notice later can be unenforceable.
  • Keep the ability to change duties and work location within reason, to reduce constructive dismissal risk as the company pivots.

Intellectual property and confidentiality

For a technology start-up, the IP is the company. Canadian law gives employers partial protection by default. Under s. 13(3) of the Copyright Act, where an employee creates a work in the course of employment under a contract of service, the employer is the first owner of the copyright "in the absence of any agreement to the contrary". That default does not help with:

  • Founders who wrote code before incorporation or before signing anything;
  • Contractors and freelancers, who own what they create unless they assign it in writing;
  • Inventions, because the Patent Act has no general employer-ownership rule and ownership turns on the facts and the contract;
  • Moral rights, which under s. 14.1(2) of the Copyright Act may not be assigned but may be waived.

Every founder, employee and contractor should sign an invention and IP assignment agreement with a moral rights waiver and confidentiality obligations. Founders should also assign pre-incorporation work to the company. Investors' counsel will look for these documents in due diligence, and gaps can delay a closing or reduce valuation. Restrictive covenants need care too: Ontario's ESA (s. 67.2) prohibits non-compete agreements with employees, subject to exceptions for the sale of a business and for executives, as the Ontario guide to the ESA explains. Narrow non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses remain available.

Equity for employees: options and termination

Stock options are a core start-up employment law issue because they combine contract, corporate and tax rules. The plan, the grant agreement and the employment contract must say the same thing about vesting, exercise windows and what happens on termination. The Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26 held that a dismissed employee can claim damages for incentive compensation that would have vested during the reasonable notice period unless the contract or plan clearly removes that right. Generic wording that ties payment to being an employee on the payment or vesting date may not be clear enough on its own.

Practical steps include a board-approved option plan with a clear termination section, grant letters that cross-refer to it, a capitalization table that matches signed grants, and a process for handling ex-employees' options. The tax treatment of employee options under s. 7 of the Income Tax Act, including the different rules for Canadian-controlled private corporations, should be explained in plain terms to employees at grant.

Contractors, interns and remote hires

Early-stage companies often prefer contractors for flexibility. The label in the contract does not decide status; courts and agencies look at control, ownership of tools, chance of profit and risk of loss, and integration into the business. A full-time "contractor" who works only for the start-up, on its schedule and with its equipment, is likely an employee for employment standards, tax and payroll purposes. Our insight on contractor misclassification explains the tests in more detail.

Unpaid internships are mostly unlawful in Ontario. The ESA applies to anyone performing work for an employer, and s. 3(5) excludes only specific groups, such as secondary school students in board-approved work experience programs and individuals working under a program approved by a college or university. A graduate "intern" doing real work must be paid at least minimum wage.

Remote hiring adds a layer of start-up employment law complexity. As a rule, the employment standards of the province where the employee physically works apply, not the province of the head office. Hiring a developer in Quebec brings Quebec labour standards, French-language obligations for employment documents and Quebec payroll deductions. Each new province may also require workers' compensation registration and provincial payroll accounts.

IssueDefault positionWhat founders should do
Termination entitlementsCommon law reasonable notice if no valid clauseESA-compliant termination clause signed before start
Copyright in employee workEmployer owns if made in the course of employment (Copyright Act s. 13(3))Written IP assignment and moral rights waiver anyway
Contractor IPContractor ownsAssignment clause in every contractor agreement
Non-compete for employees (Ontario)Prohibited, subject to limited exceptions (ESA s. 67.2)Use confidentiality and non-solicit clauses
Unpaid interns (Ontario)ESA applies unless an s. 3(5) exclusion fitsPay at least minimum wage or use a qualifying school program
Options on terminationDamages for lost vesting unless the plan clearly excludes them (Matthews)Clear plan and grant language
Practical point

Before a seed or Series A round, run a one-day employment audit: signed contracts for every employee, IP assignments from founders and contractors, option grants that match the cap table, and a list of anyone working outside the home province. Fixing gaps before the investor's diligence request is far cheaper than negotiating around them in the closing documents.

Avoiding early termination liability

Start-ups dismiss people for performance, fit or cash reasons, often within the first two years. Without a valid termination clause, even a short-service employee can claim several months of common law notice, and senior hires recruited from secure jobs can claim more. Inducement, where a start-up lures an employee away from long-term employment, can lengthen the notice period further. Three habits limit exposure: an enforceable termination clause, documented performance management for cause-type concerns, and a careful approach to changing terms such as pay cuts or role changes, which can amount to constructive dismissal.

Illustration: a hypothetical Ottawa start-up hires a VP Sales away from a large employer with an offer letter that contains no termination clause and promises options "vesting over four years". Fourteen months later, after a missed revenue target, the company terminates. The VP claims many months of reasonable notice, aggravated by inducement, plus damages for options that would have vested during that period. A one-paragraph ESA-compliant termination clause and plan language addressing vesting on termination would have narrowed both claims considerably. Getting start-up employment law basics right is, in practice, a cash-preservation exercise.

Founders should also remember the statutory steps around any dismissal: final pay and vacation pay within ESA timelines, a Record of Employment, continuation of benefits during the statutory notice period, and, where the employee is on leave or has recently raised a complaint, an assessment of human rights and reprisal risk before acting.

A first-year start-up employment law checklist

The list below turns the points above into a sequence founders can work through as the team grows from two people to twenty. It is deliberately short; most items take an afternoon once the templates exist.

  1. Before the first hire: incorporate, have founders sign IP assignments covering pre-incorporation work, and adopt a founder share vesting arrangement (see our insight on founder vesting).
  2. At each offer: a written employment agreement with an ESA-compliant termination clause, confidentiality and IP assignment, and any equity promise expressed as "subject to the plan and board approval".
  3. At registration: payroll accounts with the Canada Revenue Agency, workers' compensation registration in each province where staff work, and the mandatory employment standards poster or information sheet.
  4. At the first option grant: a board-approved plan, individual grant agreements and an updated capitalization table.
  5. At 25 employees in Ontario: a written electronic monitoring policy, and job postings that comply with Ontario's pay range, AI-disclosure and vacancy rules for employers of that size.
  6. Every year: review templates against legislative changes, confirm contractor relationships still look like contracting, and check that remote employees' provinces are known and registered.

Policies matter as headcount grows. Ontario employers must have workplace violence and harassment policies under the Occupational Health and Safety Act, and a human-rights-compliant accommodation process is needed from the first employee. A short handbook covering these, plus expense, leave and remote-work rules, also gives managers a consistent script and reduces the risk that informal practices become implied contract terms that are hard to change later.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise founders and venture-backed companies on employment law and on the corporate side of venture capital and emerging companies. For start-up employment law, we prepare offer letter and contract templates with ESA-compliant termination clauses, IP assignment and confidentiality agreements, contractor agreements and option plan documentation; run pre-financing employment audits; advise on hiring in other provinces; and help manage terminations to limit exposure. Where a court or tribunal appearance requires Canadian-licensed counsel, we coordinate with them. This page is general information rather than legal advice. To discuss your hiring plan, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Does a start-up need written employment contracts?

Not legally, but it should have them. Without a written contract containing an enforceable termination clause, employees are entitled to common law reasonable notice, which is usually far longer than the statutory minimums. A written contract also documents IP ownership, confidentiality and equity terms that investors will review.

Who owns code written by a start-up's employees?

Under s. 13(3) of the Copyright Act, the employer is generally the first owner of copyright in works created by employees in the course of employment, absent a contrary agreement. Founders, contractors and inventions are not reliably covered by that rule, so written assignment agreements and moral rights waivers are standard practice.

Can an Ontario start-up use non-compete clauses?

Generally not with employees. Section 67.2 of Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 prohibits non-compete agreements, with exceptions for the sale of a business and for certain executives. Confidentiality and reasonable non-solicitation clauses remain available and are usually the better tool.

Can a start-up offer unpaid internships?

In Ontario, only in narrow cases. The ESA excludes secondary school work experience programs and work under programs approved by a college or university, among a few others. Otherwise, an intern who performs work is an employee entitled to at least minimum wage and other ESA protections.

Which province's law applies to a remote employee?

As a general rule, the employment standards of the province where the employee physically works apply. A Toronto company with a developer working from Quebec must comply with Quebec labour standards, payroll and language requirements for that employee, and may need workers' compensation registration there.

Sources

  1. Employment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41 (e-Laws)
  2. Copyright Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-42, ss. 13–14.1
  3. Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391
  4. Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26 (case in brief)
  5. Ontario: Your guide to the ESA – non-compete agreements

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.