Skip to content
Banking, Finance & Fintech

Intercreditor Agreements Under Canadian Law

Intercreditor agreements decide who controls enforcement and who is paid first when a Canadian borrower has more than one lender. This note covers first-lien/second-lien and ABL/term structures, standstills and waterfalls, DIP and CCAA provisions, unitranche agreements among lenders, and Quebec hypothec considerations.

Senior and junior lenders negotiating intercreditor agreements for a Canadian borrower

Key takeaways

  • Canadian courts generally enforce intercreditor agreements between sophisticated lenders as contracts.
  • The PPSAs let a secured party subordinate its security by agreement, overriding registration order.
  • CCAA s. 11.2 lets courts grant DIP charges ranking ahead of existing secured creditors.
  • Statutory priorities, including Crown deemed trusts and wage and pension charges, cannot be contracted away.
  • Quebec ranking depends on publication of hypothecs; cessions of rank should also be published.

What intercreditor agreements do under Canadian law

Intercreditor agreements set the rules between lenders that share a borrower. They decide who is paid first, who controls enforcement, what each lender may do without the other's consent, and how the lenders will behave if the borrower files for creditor protection. Canadian law gives lenders wide freedom to agree on these matters, and courts will generally enforce intercreditor agreements as contracts between sophisticated parties. But they operate against a statutory background that differs from the United States: provincial Personal Property Security Acts (PPSAs), Quebec's hypothec regime, the federal Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) and Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), and a set of statutory and Crown claims that no contract can subordinate.

Senior and junior lenders negotiating intercreditor agreements for a Canadian borrower
Intercreditor agreements allocate priority, enforcement control and insolvency rights among lenders to the same borrower.

Many Canadian intercreditor agreements are modelled on US forms, especially in cross-border deals where a Canadian borrower is part of a US-led credit group. That is workable, but provisions drafted around Chapter 11 of the US Bankruptcy Code need careful adaptation to the CCAA, which gives a supervising judge broad discretion, and to the BIA proposal regime.

Common structures: first lien/second lien and ABL/term

StructureTypical collateral splitMain intercreditor issues
First lien / second lienBoth lenders share all collateral; second lien ranks behindLien subordination, standstill, release of second-lien security on first-lien sale, DIP and plan voting
ABL / term loan (split collateral)ABL first on receivables and inventory; term lender first on fixed assets, IP and sharesAccess and use rights to premises and IP, proceeds tracing, cross-default and enforcement coordination
Senior / mezzanineMezzanine often at holdco, sometimes with second-ranking securityPayment blockage, cure and purchase rights, holdco share pledge enforcement
Unitranche with agreement among lendersSingle lien and single loan to the borrower"First-out/last-out" waterfall between lenders, voting, buyout rights

A first lien/second lien deal usually provides for lien subordination, not payment subordination: the second-lien lender ranks behind as to collateral proceeds but may receive scheduled interest and principal until a default. In a senior/subordinated or mezzanine deal, the subordinated lender also agrees to payment subordination, accepting that payments to it are blocked once a senior default occurs, and that any amounts received in breach are held in trust for the senior lender.

Split-collateral ABL/term structures need precise definitions of each lender's priority collateral and rules for identifiable proceeds, because sales of inventory and collection of receivables continuously convert one class of collateral into another. The ABL lender will also want a licence to use the borrower's intellectual property and access to real property to complete the sale of inventory after enforcement.

Core terms of intercreditor agreements

Priority and the PPSA

Under the PPSAs, priority between registered security interests generally follows the order of registration, and s. 39 of the Ontario Personal Property Security Act confirms that a secured party may subordinate its security interest to another interest by agreement. Intercreditor agreements rely on this to set contractual priority regardless of registration order. The agreement should also deal with future advances, increases in the senior debt (a "senior debt cap" is common), refinancing and the treatment of hedging and cash management obligations.

Standstills and enforcement

The junior lender typically agrees to a standstill period, often several months after notice of a default, during which it may not enforce its security, start insolvency proceedings or take steps against the collateral. The senior lender controls enforcement. Exceptions usually allow the junior to file proofs of claim, vote, and take protective steps such as preserving its security.

Waterfalls and turnover

An enforcement waterfall sets the order in which proceeds are applied: enforcement costs, senior debt, then junior debt. A turnover clause requires a lender that receives proceeds out of order to hold them in trust and pay them over. Release provisions oblige the junior lender to release its security when the senior lender sells collateral on enforcement.

Amendments, refinancing and information

Senior lenders want freedom to amend and refinance their facilities without junior consent; junior lenders want limits on increases in principal, pricing and maturity changes that push value away from them. The compromise is usually a list of prohibited amendments and a cap on senior debt, often expressed as a percentage cushion above the closing amount. The agreement should say whether a refinancing lender automatically inherits the senior position and must sign a joinder.

Information covenants matter too. Each lender should be required to give notice of defaults, acceleration and enforcement steps, and the agreement should allow sharing of borrower information subject to confidentiality. A clear notice mechanism avoids later arguments about when a standstill period started.

Purchase and cure rights

Junior lenders commonly negotiate an option to buy out the senior debt at par after an enforcement trigger, and sometimes a right to cure financial covenant defaults. These rights are often the junior lender's most valuable protection. The purchase price, the timing window, whether the junior must buy all senior obligations including hedging and cash management claims, and whether make-whole or prepayment premiums are payable on the purchase all need to be negotiated, because they determine whether the option can be exercised in a real distress scenario.

DIP financing and CCAA provisions in intercreditor agreements

The CCAA allows a court to grant an interim financing (DIP) charge. Under s. 11.2, on notice to secured creditors likely to be affected, the court may declare that all or part of the debtor's property is subject to a charge in favour of an interim lender, and may order that the charge rank in priority over the claim of any secured creditor. The charge may not secure obligations that existed before the order. Similar powers exist in BIA proposals. Courts also grant administration charges and directors' charges with priority over existing security.

In Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a CCAA court may order such court-ordered charges to rank ahead of the Crown's deemed trust for unremitted employee source deductions. Lenders cannot assume that their contractual priority will survive a CCAA filing intact.

Intercreditor agreements therefore usually provide that:

  • the junior lender will consent to, or not oppose, a DIP facility and DIP charge approved by the senior lender, within a cap;
  • the junior lender will not propose a competing DIP without senior consent;
  • the junior lender will not oppose a sale of collateral supported by the senior lender, including a sale under s. 36 of the CCAA or a credit bid;
  • voting and plan rights are allocated, although courts may scrutinize provisions that purport to assign the junior lender's vote in a CCAA plan; and
  • the agreement remains effective in any insolvency proceeding.

CCAA judges have broad discretion, and intercreditor agreements cannot override court orders or statutory priorities. They nonetheless shape how lenders behave in court, and judges have generally respected agreed subordination between sophisticated parties when approving distributions.

Practical point

Do not assume a US-form intercreditor agreement will work in a Canadian insolvency. Check that DIP, sale and voting provisions refer to the CCAA and BIA as well as US law, that the agreement addresses court-ordered priority charges and Crown claims, and that Quebec collateral is covered by the hypothec ranking provisions.

Statutory priorities that intercreditor agreements cannot change

No intercreditor agreement can subordinate the claims of non-parties. Several statutory claims can rank ahead of all lenders, whatever their agreement says:

  • Crown deemed trusts for unremitted source deductions (income tax, Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance), which generally survive bankruptcy;
  • wage and pension claims secured by statutory charges in bankruptcy and receivership under ss. 81.3 to 81.6 of the BIA;
  • court-ordered administration, DIP and directors' charges in CCAA and BIA proceedings;
  • certain provincial liens and deemed trusts, such as construction liens, repair and storage liens and some provincial tax claims.

Their size is often uncertain until a filing occurs. Lenders allocate these risks through reserves (especially in borrowing base facilities), covenants and the waterfall. The intercreditor agreement should state which lender bears the cost of priority claims that erode the shared collateral.

Unitranche agreements among lenders and Quebec considerations

In a unitranche facility, the borrower sees a single loan with one set of security, but the lenders split it internally into "first-out" and "last-out" tranches under an agreement among lenders (AAL). The borrower is usually not a party to the AAL and may not even see it. Canadian private credit funds use unitranche structures for mid-market buyouts. The AAL deals with payment waterfalls before and after default, voting thresholds, the last-out lenders' buyout rights and how the tranches will vote in an insolvency. Because the borrower is not party, there are open questions about how a CCAA court would treat the first-out and last-out lenders when classifying creditors for voting; drafting should anticipate that the court may treat them as one class.

Where collateral is in Quebec, security is created by hypothecs under the Civil Code of Québec (C.C.Q.), and ranking among hypothecs is determined by the date and time of publication in the Register of Personal and Movable Real Rights or the land register. Lenders can agree to a cession of rank, which should itself be published so it can be set up against third parties. Quebec law also requires a hypothecary representative (the "fondé de pouvoir") for bond-type structures with multiple creditors, and enforcement follows prior notice periods under the Code. Intercreditor agreements for Canadian borrowers with Quebec assets should include Quebec-specific provisions and, often, separate cession-of-rank documents.

Illustration (hypothetical): a Canadian manufacturer has an ABL facility from a bank secured first on receivables and inventory, and a term loan from a private credit fund secured first on equipment, real property and IP. The intercreditor agreement gives the ABL lender a 180-day licence to use the IP and access the plants to finish and sell inventory after enforcement, sets a cap on the ABL's priority debt, and provides that the term lender will not oppose a DIP facility from the ABL lender up to an agreed amount in a CCAA filing.

How TRW & Co helps with intercreditor agreements

We advise senior and junior lenders, private credit funds, sponsors and borrowers on intercreditor agreements in Canadian and cross-border financings. We draft and negotiate first lien/second lien, ABL/term and senior/mezzanine intercreditor agreements and agreements among lenders, adapt US forms to the CCAA and BIA, and advise on enforcement and insolvency strategy. Where Quebec hypothecs or a court filing require a Canadian-licensed lawyer or notary, we coordinate with licensed counsel. Our lending and acquisition finance and CCAA restructuring work covers related issues; see also our notes on private credit and asset-based lending. To discuss a financing, contact us. This note is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Are intercreditor agreements enforceable in a CCAA proceeding?

Generally yes, as contracts among the lenders. Courts tend to respect agreed subordination between sophisticated parties. But the agreement cannot bind non-parties or override court orders, such as DIP, administration and directors' charges, or statutory priorities, and provisions assigning a junior lender's plan vote may be scrutinized.

What is the difference between lien and payment subordination?

Lien subordination ranks the junior lender behind the senior lender only as to collateral and its proceeds; the junior can still receive scheduled payments until a default. Payment subordination also blocks payments to the junior lender after a senior default and requires amounts received in breach to be turned over.

Can a court prime existing secured lenders with a DIP charge?

Yes. Under s. 11.2 of the CCAA, on notice to affected secured creditors, a court may grant an interim financing charge and order that it rank ahead of any secured creditor. The charge cannot secure pre-filing obligations. Intercreditor agreements usually govern whether the junior lender may oppose a DIP.

How do unitranche agreements among lenders work?

The borrower gets one loan and one security package, while the lenders divide it into first-out and last-out tranches under an agreement among lenders, to which the borrower is usually not a party. The agreement covers waterfalls, voting and buyout rights; insolvency treatment of the tranches remains a drafting risk.

What changes when collateral is in Quebec?

Quebec uses hypothecs under the Civil Code of Québec rather than PPSA security interests. Ranking depends on publication, cessions of rank should be published to be set up against third parties, and multi-lender structures often use a hypothecary representative. Quebec-specific provisions and documents are needed.

Sources

  1. Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, s. 11.2 (interim financing)
  2. SCC Case in Brief: Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30
  3. Personal Property Security Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.10 (Ontario)
  4. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3
  5. Civil Code of Québec (hypothecs)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.