Skip to content
Banking, Finance & Fintech

Private Credit in Canada: Direct Lending Structures

Private credit funds now finance much of the Canadian mid-market. This note explains how direct lenders structure unitranche and holdco loans, why most arm's length interest paid to foreign lenders is free of withholding tax, how EIFEL and the criminal interest rate affect pricing, and how enforcement differs from bank lending.

Private credit fund team reviewing a unitranche term sheet for a Canadian mid-market borrower

Key takeaways

  • Arm's length, non-participating interest paid to non-resident lenders is generally exempt from Part XIII tax.
  • EIFEL limits most borrowers' net interest deductions to 30% of adjusted taxable income.
  • The criminal rate is now an APR above 35%, with exemptions for business loans to non-individuals.
  • Commercial loans above CAD 500,000 to non-individuals are exempt from s. 347 entirely.
  • CCAA courts can prime existing security with DIP and administration charges.

How private credit funds lend to Canadian borrowers

Private credit in Canada means loans made by non-bank lenders, mainly private debt funds, pension plans, insurers and business development lenders, directly to companies rather than through syndicated bank facilities or public bond markets. Direct lenders now finance a large share of Canadian mid-market buyouts, growth companies, real estate and infrastructure. The legal framework is largely the same as for bank lending, since loan agreements, security and guarantees are governed by provincial law and enforced under the same federal insolvency statutes. But private credit transactions raise distinct issues: non-resident lender withholding tax, the borrower's interest deductibility under the excessive interest and financing expenses limitation (EIFEL) rules, the criminal interest rate, and enforcement strategies that differ from those of regulated banks.

Private credit fund team reviewing a unitranche term sheet for a Canadian mid-market borrower
Direct lenders offer speed and flexibility, but the Canadian tax, criminal interest and insolvency rules shape every private credit structure.

Most private credit lenders in Canada are not federally regulated financial institutions, so they are not subject to the Bank Act or supervision by the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI). Commercial lending to businesses generally does not require a provincial licence either, although mortgage lending, consumer lending and certain fund activities can trigger licensing or securities law requirements. Funds raising capital from Canadian investors must also comply with securities law on the fund side.

Unitranche, holdco and other structures

StructureDescriptionKey Canadian issues
UnitrancheSingle senior secured term loan blending senior and junior risk at one priceAgreement among lenders, first-out/last-out waterfall, CCAA voting classes
Unitranche with super-senior revolverBank provides a revolver ranking ahead in the waterfall; fund provides the term loanIntercreditor or AAL terms, ABL-style collateral if borrowing base
Holdco PIK or mezzanineStructurally subordinated loan to a holding company, often payment-in-kindShare pledge enforcement, criminal interest analysis for PIK and fees, EIFEL at holdco
Asset-based or specialty financeLending against receivables, inventory, equipment or royaltiesPPSA perfection, priority payables reserves, true sale questions
NAV and fund financeLending to funds against investment portfolios or commitmentsFund documents, investor consents, securities account control

Unitranche facilities are popular because a sponsor negotiates with one lender group, documentation is shorter and execution is faster. The lenders divide the economics internally through an agreement among lenders. Holdco loans sit above an operating company's senior debt and are repaid from dividends or a sale, so the lender's real collateral is a pledge of the operating company's shares.

Documentation generally follows North American market forms adapted to Canadian law: a credit agreement governed by Ontario or another provincial law (or New York law for cross-border deals with Canadian security governed locally), general security agreements registered under each relevant Personal Property Security Act, Quebec hypothecs where needed, guarantees from material subsidiaries and share pledges with control.

Due diligence points specific to Canada

Private credit diligence on a Canadian borrower should cover a few items that foreign lenders sometimes miss:

  • Priority payables. Unremitted source deductions, GST/HST, provincial sales taxes, wages, vacation pay and pension contributions can rank ahead of the lender. Ask for remittance evidence and consider reserves.
  • Pension plans. A defined benefit plan deficit can become a significant claim in a liquidation, and provincial pension statutes create deemed trusts for some contributions.
  • Environmental liabilities. Following the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Orphan Well Association v. Grant Thornton Ltd., 2019 SCC 5, regulatory end-of-life obligations can reduce what is available to secured creditors in a bankruptcy.
  • Foreign investment and sanctions. Taking security over, or later enforcing against, shares of a Canadian business can raise Investment Canada Act questions if the lender or its investors are non-Canadian and the business is sensitive.
  • Quebec assets. Collateral located in Quebec requires hypothecs and Quebec-law formalities, including a specific sum for each hypothec.

Lenders also need to know the borrower's PPSA location for intangibles, any existing registrations that must be discharged at closing, and the change of control terms in material contracts that could be triggered by enforcement.

Non-resident lenders and withholding tax

Many private credit funds lending into Canada are organized outside Canada. Under s. 212(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act (ITA), Part XIII withholding tax (25% before treaty relief) applies to interest paid to a non-resident only if the interest is paid to a non-arm's length person, is paid in respect of a debt owed to a non-arm's length person, or is "participating debt interest". Interest paid by a Canadian borrower to an arm's length foreign lender on ordinary, non-participating debt is therefore generally exempt from withholding tax, whatever the lender's country.

Three points need attention in private credit deals:

  • Arm's length status. A lender that also holds equity, warrants or board rights may not deal at arm's length with the borrower, especially in sponsor-affiliated or co-invest structures.
  • Participating debt interest. Interest computed by reference to revenue, profit, cash flow, commodity price or dividends can be participating. Equity kickers and profit-linked fees should be structured carefully.
  • Back-to-back rules. Anti-avoidance rules can recharacterize arrangements where an intermediary lender stands between the borrower and a non-arm's length funder.

Treaty relief matters mainly where withholding does apply, for example on participating interest or non-arm's length loans. Credit agreements should include a tax gross-up limited to changes in law and exclude lenders that fail to provide required tax forms or become non-arm's length. Fees paid to non-residents, such as standby fees and guarantee fees, may be deemed interest for withholding purposes, so they should be reviewed separately.

EIFEL and thin capitalization effects on borrowers

The borrower's ability to deduct interest is part of the pricing of private credit. Under the EIFEL rules in s. 18.2 ITA, for taxation years beginning on or after 1 January 2024, a taxpayer's net interest and financing expenses are generally deductible only up to 30% of its adjusted taxable income (a tax version of EBITDA). Excluded entities, such as small Canadian-controlled private corporations and groups with modest net interest expense, are outside the rules, but leveraged buyout targets often are not. Denied amounts can be carried forward, and groups can transfer unused capacity in some cases.

The older thin capitalization rules in s. 18(4) ITA limit interest deductions on debt owed to specified non-residents (broadly, significant shareholders and their non-arm's length parties) to a 1.5:1 debt-to-equity ratio. They rarely affect a pure third-party fund loan, but can apply where a foreign sponsor lends alongside or guarantees the debt. Excess interest under thin cap is also treated as a deemed dividend subject to withholding.

For lenders, the practical effect is that highly leveraged borrowers may pay more cash tax than their models assumed, reducing debt service capacity. PIK interest and capitalized fees are still financing expenses for EIFEL purposes even though no cash is paid, so PIK-heavy holdco structures can run into EIFEL limits on deductions even though no cash interest is being paid by the group. Financial covenants and cash flow projections should reflect EIFEL limits.

The criminal interest rate and private credit

Section 347 of the Criminal Code makes it an offence to enter into an agreement to receive interest at a "criminal rate", now defined as an annual percentage rate that exceeds 35% on the credit advanced. "Interest" is defined broadly to include fees, fines, penalties and commissions, so original issue discount, upfront fees, prepayment premiums, PIK interest and default interest all count. High-yield private credit can approach the limit in stress scenarios, especially when a loan is repaid early and fees are spread over a short period.

The Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, in force 1 January 2025, exempt loans where the borrower is not a natural person, the borrowing is for a business or commercial purpose, and either the credit advanced exceeds CAD 500,000, or it is more than CAD 10,000 and up to CAD 500,000 and the annual percentage rate does not exceed 48%. Most institutional private credit loans to corporate borrowers therefore fall outside s. 347, but loans to individuals, small loans and loans where a guarantor or co-borrower is an individual require care. Many credit agreements still include a savings clause reducing interest to the maximum lawful rate.

Practical point

When a private credit deal includes an individual borrower or co-obligor, or a credit amount near the CAD 500,000 threshold, run a criminal interest calculation that includes all fees, premiums and default scenarios. Keep the calculation on file, and draft the savings clause to reduce amounts in a defined order so that a court is more likely to give effect to it.

Enforcement differences from bank lending

Private credit lenders enforce through the same tools as banks: demand, a notice under s. 244 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), private or court-appointed receivership, and participation in CCAA or BIA proposal proceedings. Several differences show up in practice:

  • Appetite for ownership. Funds are often willing to take the keys through a credit bid or debt-for-equity exchange, while banks usually prefer a sale to a third party.
  • Speed and flexibility. Direct lenders can amend, extend and add capital quickly, which can avoid formal proceedings.
  • Super-priority risk. In a CCAA proceeding, a court may grant interim financing, administration and directors' charges ranking ahead of existing security under s. 11.2 and related provisions. A fund that wants control should be ready to offer the DIP facility itself.
  • Holdco loans. Enforcement against a share pledge requires a commercially reasonable sale process and careful handling of change of control provisions in the operating company's contracts.
  • Statutory claims. Crown deemed trusts, wage and pension charges and environmental obligations can erode collateral value, whatever the lender's contractual priority.

Illustration (hypothetical): a US private credit fund provides a CAD 120 million unitranche loan to finance a sponsor's acquisition of an Ontario manufacturer. The fund deals at arm's length and the interest is not participating, so no withholding tax applies. EIFEL limits the borrower's deductions to 30% of adjusted taxable income, which the model reflects. The loan exceeds CAD 500,000 and the borrower is a corporation borrowing for business purposes, so the criminal interest rate does not apply. A bank provides a super-senior revolver under an agreement among lenders.

How TRW & Co helps with private credit

We advise private credit funds, institutional lenders, sponsors and borrowers on direct lending in Canada. That includes structuring unitranche, holdco and specialty finance facilities, reviewing withholding tax, EIFEL and criminal interest exposure, negotiating credit and intercreditor documentation, and planning enforcement and restructuring strategy. Where a security filing, Quebec hypothec, tax opinion or court proceeding requires a Canadian-licensed lawyer or notary, we work with licensed counsel. Our lending and acquisition finance, private equity and CCAA restructuring work covers related issues; see also our notes on intercreditor agreements and the criminal interest rate. To discuss a financing, contact us. This note is general information, not legal or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

Do foreign private credit funds pay withholding tax on Canadian interest?

Generally not, if the fund deals at arm's length with the borrower and the interest is not participating debt interest. Section 212(1)(b) ITA limits withholding on interest to non-arm's length and participating debt interest. Equity kickers, board rights and profit-linked returns can change the analysis.

Does the 35% criminal interest rate apply to private credit loans?

Usually not for institutional loans. The Criminal Interest Rate Regulations exempt business loans to non-individuals above CAD 500,000, and those between CAD 10,000 and CAD 500,000 with an APR up to 48%. Loans to individuals or small loans remain subject to the 35% APR limit, which counts fees and premiums.

How does EIFEL affect a leveraged borrower?

For taxation years beginning on or after 1 January 2024, EIFEL generally limits deductible net interest and financing expenses to 30% of adjusted taxable income. Highly leveraged borrowers may lose deductions and pay more cash tax, reducing debt service capacity. Excluded entities and some group elections can reduce the effect.

Do private lenders need a licence to lend to Canadian businesses?

Commercial lending to businesses generally does not require a federal or provincial licence. Mortgage lending, consumer lending and some other activities are licensed provincially, and funds raising money from Canadian investors must comply with securities law. Lenders should confirm the position for each product and province.

How do private credit lenders enforce in Canada?

Through demand, a BIA s. 244 notice, receivership or participation in CCAA and BIA proceedings, like banks. Funds are often more willing to credit bid or take equity. In a CCAA case, court-ordered charges can rank ahead of existing security, so lenders seeking control often offer DIP financing.

Sources

  1. Income Tax Act, s. 212 (Part XIII withholding)
  2. Income Tax Act, s. 18.2 (EIFEL)
  3. Criminal Code, s. 347 (criminal interest rate)
  4. Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, SOR/2024-114
  5. Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, s. 11.2

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.