Interest Act Traps: Sections 4, 8 and 10 Explained
The federal Interest Act is brief, but its rules on stating annual rates, default interest on mortgages and five-year prepayment still decide real disputes. This note explains ss. 4, 8 and 10, the Supreme Court's substance-over-form approach in Krayzel, and a drafting checklist for Canadian loan and mortgage documents.

Key takeaways
- Section 4 caps interest at 5% a year unless the yearly equivalent of a sub-annual rate is stated.
- Section 8 bars any rate or penalty that increases the charge on mortgage arrears.
- Krayzel, 2016 SCC 18, applies s. 8 to substance, not labels such as discounts.
- Section 10 lets non-corporate mortgagors prepay after five years with three months' interest.
- The Act applies to commercial loans across Canada, including Quebec.
Why the Interest Act still matters
The federal Interest Act (R.S.C. 1985, c. I-15) is short, old and easy to overlook, but it still catches lenders. Parliament has exclusive jurisdiction over interest under s. 91(19) of the Constitution Act, 1867, so the Interest Act applies across Canada, including Quebec, to loans by banks, credit unions, private lenders and funds alike. Three provisions cause most of the trouble: s. 4, which requires an annual rate to be stated when interest is expressed for a shorter period; s. 8, which prohibits higher rates on arrears of mortgage debt; and s. 10, which gives certain mortgagors a right to prepay after five years. Breaching these rules can reduce the lender's recovery to a statutory rate, or let the borrower recover amounts paid.

The Interest Act sits alongside the Criminal Code limit on the cost of credit, provincial consumer protection and mortgage brokerage laws, and the cost of borrowing disclosure rules for federally regulated lenders. Unlike those regimes, it applies to commercial loans between sophisticated parties, so even large syndicated facilities need Interest Act wording.
Foreign lenders are often surprised by this. A New York or English-law credit agreement lending to a Canadian borrower cannot safely assume that a foreign governing law clause takes it outside the Interest Act if the obligation is enforced in a Canadian court, which is why Canadian counsel routinely add an Interest Act clause to such agreements. Borrowers, for their part, sometimes raise the Act defensively in enforcement proceedings, so lenders should treat compliance as part of their enforcement planning rather than a drafting nicety.
Section 4 of the Interest Act: stating the annual rate
Section 4 provides that, except for mortgages on real property or hypothecs on immovables, when interest under a written contract is payable at a rate per day, week or month, or for any period less than a year, no interest exceeding 5% per annum is chargeable, payable or recoverable unless the contract contains an express statement of the yearly rate to which the other rate is equivalent. Under s. 5, any amount paid on account of interest that is not recoverable under s. 4 may be recovered back or deducted from principal or interest.
The consequence is severe: a lender that charges "2% per month" without stating the equivalent annual rate may be limited to 5% a year. Courts have applied s. 4 to rates expressed by reference to periods shorter than a year, including per diem rates and some formula-based rates, but not where the contract states an annual rate even if interest is calculated daily. The analysis turns on the wording of each contract.
360-day and 365-day conventions
Many credit agreements, particularly those based on US forms, compute interest on the basis of a 360-day year. That is a rate for a period of less than a year in substance, so Canadian practice is to include an "Interest Act (Canada)" clause stating that, for the purposes of the Act, whenever interest is calculated on the basis of a 360-day or 365-day year, the yearly rate to which it is equivalent is the stated rate multiplied by the actual number of days in the calendar year and divided by 360 or 365. Lenders should also confirm that fees expressed as percentages over short periods, such as monthly standby or monitoring fees, are not characterized as interest without an annual equivalent.
| Provision | Applies to | Rule | Consequence of breach |
|---|---|---|---|
| s. 4 | Written contracts other than real property mortgages and immovable hypothecs | State the yearly equivalent of rates for periods under a year | Interest capped at 5% a year; excess recoverable (s. 5) |
| s. 6 | Blended-payment or sinking fund mortgages | Mortgage must state principal and annual or half-yearly rate, not in advance | No interest recoverable unless the statement is made |
| s. 8 | Arrears secured by real property mortgage or immovable hypothec | No fine, penalty or rate that increases the charge on arrears beyond the rate on non-arrears | Excess recoverable or deductible (s. 9) |
| s. 10 | Mortgages with terms over five years, other than corporate mortgagors | Right to repay after five years with three months' interest | Prepayment cannot be refused |
Section 8: no higher rates on mortgage arrears
Section 8(1) provides that no fine, penalty or rate of interest may be stipulated for, taken, reserved or exacted on arrears of principal or interest secured by a mortgage on real property or a hypothec on immovables that has the effect of increasing the charge on the arrears beyond the rate payable on principal not in arrears. Section 8(2) clarifies that interest on arrears is allowed at a rate no greater than the rate on principal not in arrears. Amounts paid in breach can be recovered or deducted under s. 9.
Section 8 protects all mortgagors, including corporations, and applies to commercial mortgages. It catches the obvious, such as a default rate 3% above the contract rate on a mortgage loan, and the disguised. In Krayzel Corp. v. Equitable Trust Co., 2016 SCC 18, the Supreme Court of Canada held that s. 8 looks at substance, not form: a structure that states a higher rate but allows a lower rate so long as the borrower is not in default can still have the prohibited effect of increasing the charge on arrears. Lenders cannot avoid s. 8 by calling the lower rate a discount or a reward for prompt payment.
What lenders can still do
Section 8 does not prevent compound interest on arrears at the contract rate, reasonable administration fees reflecting actual costs of handling a default, enforcement costs, or legitimate fees for a new agreement such as an extension or renewal negotiated at arm's length. The line between a renewal at a new rate and a penalty for default is fact-specific, and post-maturity "holdover" rates attract scrutiny. Where a facility is secured by both real property and other assets, lenders should consider whether default interest provisions can be confined to obligations not secured by the mortgage, recognizing that courts look at what the mortgage actually secures.
Commercial loan agreements often carry a default rate of 2% above the contract rate. If the loan is secured by a mortgage or hypothec on real property, that default rate is likely unenforceable as against mortgage arrears under s. 8 of the Interest Act. Review default interest, late fees, exit fees and post-maturity rates in every real estate financing before closing, not after a default.
Section 10: the five-year prepayment right
Under s. 10(1), when principal or interest secured by a mortgage on real property or a hypothec on immovables is not payable until more than five years after the date of the mortgage, any person liable to pay or entitled to redeem may, at any time after five years, tender the principal and interest due plus three months' further interest in lieu of notice, and no further interest is then chargeable. In effect, the borrower can prepay a long-term mortgage after year five with a three-month interest penalty, whatever the mortgage says.
Section 10(2) excludes mortgages given by a joint stock company or any other corporation, and debentures secured by such mortgages, as well as prescribed mortgages of prescribed entities. The right is therefore mainly relevant to individuals, partnerships and trusts that are not corporations. Whether an amendment, renewal or extension restarts the five-year period depends on how it is documented and on the case law, so lenders and borrowers should analyse carefully the date from which five years runs before relying on, or resisting, a prepayment tender.
For corporate borrowers, prepayment rights and yield maintenance clauses are matters of contract. For individual borrowers on long-term commercial or residential mortgages, s. 10 limits the lender's ability to lock in yield beyond year five.
Other Interest Act provisions and related rules
Section 6 requires a mortgage on real property with blended payments, a sinking fund plan or similar structure to state the principal and the rate of interest, calculated yearly or half-yearly, not in advance. If it does not, no interest is recoverable. Section 7 then limits the lender to the stated rate if other provisions would produce more. These rules explain why Canadian residential mortgages describe rates as "compounded semi-annually, not in advance".
The Interest Act also interacts with:
- the Criminal Code limit on the cost of credit, which since 1 January 2025 is a 35% annual percentage rate, with exemptions for many commercial loans;
- the Bank Act cost of borrowing regulations for federally regulated lenders;
- provincial consumer protection, mortgage brokerage and cost of credit disclosure laws; and
- in Quebec, the Civil Code of Québec rules on hypothecs and on penal clauses, as well as the Consumer Protection Act for consumer credit.
Illustration (hypothetical): a private lender makes a CAD 3 million two-year loan to a property developer, secured by a first mortgage on Ontario land, at 9% a year with a default rate of 14%. The developer misses two payments. Under s. 8, the lender can charge 9% on the arrears, including compound interest at 9%, but not 14%. If the loan agreement had also expressed a monthly extension fee as "1% per month" without an annual equivalent, s. 4 would not apply to the mortgage itself, but the lender should still state annual equivalents for non-mortgage obligations in the agreement.
Interest Act drafting checklist
- Express every interest rate and every interest-like fee as an annual rate, or state the annual equivalent.
- Include an Interest Act (Canada) clause for 360-day and 365-day calculations.
- For mortgage-secured debt, remove or confine default rates and penalties that increase the charge on arrears.
- Check post-maturity, holdover and extension rates against s. 8 and the Krayzel substance test.
- Identify whether any mortgagor is an individual or other non-corporate person, and whether s. 10 applies.
- For blended-payment mortgages, state principal and the rate calculated yearly or half-yearly, not in advance.
- Run a separate criminal interest rate test for loans to individuals and smaller commercial loans.
How TRW & Co helps with the Interest Act
We advise lenders, borrowers, private credit funds and real estate investors on the Interest Act and related cost-of-credit rules. We review and draft interest, default and prepayment provisions, adapt US and English-law forms for Canadian borrowers, assess exposure on existing portfolios, and advise on disputes over default interest and prepayment. Where a mortgage registration, Quebec hypothec or court proceeding requires a Canadian-licensed lawyer or notary, we coordinate with licensed counsel. Our lending and acquisition finance and real estate work covers related issues; see also our notes on the criminal interest rate and mortgage brokering and private lending. To discuss your documents, contact us. This note is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Does section 4 of the Interest Act apply to commercial loans?
Yes. Section 4 applies to any written contract, other than mortgages on real property and hypothecs on immovables, that makes interest payable at a rate for a period of less than a year. Unless the contract states the equivalent yearly rate, interest above 5% a year is not recoverable, and amounts paid can be recovered under s. 5.
Can a mortgage loan have a default interest rate?
Not one that increases the charge on arrears. Section 8 prohibits any fine, penalty or rate on arrears secured by a real property mortgage or immovable hypothec that exceeds the rate on principal not in arrears. Interest on arrears at the ordinary contract rate, including compounding, is permitted.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Krayzel?
In Krayzel Corp. v. Equitable Trust Co., 2016 SCC 18, the Court held that s. 8 is applied according to substance rather than form. A mortgage that sets a higher rate but allows a lower rate while the borrower is not in default can offend s. 8 if, in effect, it increases the charge on arrears.
Who can rely on the five-year prepayment right in section 10?
Persons liable on, or entitled to redeem, a real property mortgage or immovable hypothec with a term longer than five years, other than mortgages given by corporations and certain prescribed mortgages. After five years they can repay principal and interest plus three months' further interest.
Does the Interest Act apply in Quebec?
Yes. Interest is within exclusive federal jurisdiction, so the Interest Act applies across Canada. The Act refers expressly to hypothecs on immovables. Quebec loans are also subject to Civil Code of Québec rules, including on penal clauses, and to Quebec consumer protection legislation for consumer credit.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


