Running Internal Investigations in Canada
Internal investigations help Canadian organizations respond to allegations of fraud, corruption or misconduct, but they must be structured carefully. Privilege, employee interview warnings, privacy-compliant data collection, cross-border coordination and decisions about reporting to boards and regulators determine whether an investigation helps or harms the organization.

Key takeaways
- Independent oversight is essential where senior management may be implicated.
- Commission investigations through counsel to protect solicitor-client and litigation privilege.
- Facts and business records remain producible even when communications are privileged.
- Give interviewees clear warnings that counsel represents the organization.
- Privacy laws allow investigative collection without consent in limited circumstances.
- Self-reporting decisions affect cooperation credit and remediation agreements.
When internal investigations are needed
Internal investigations are fact-finding exercises that an organization undertakes when it receives credible allegations or discovers indications of fraud, corruption, harassment, financial misstatement, sanctions or export violations, competition law breaches, or other misconduct. Done well, they let boards and management understand what happened, stop ongoing wrongdoing, meet legal reporting obligations, discipline those responsible and decide whether to self-report to authorities. Done badly, they waste privilege, alert wrongdoers, breach privacy and employment law, and create documents that can be used against the organization.
In Canada, internal investigations operate without a statutory framework of their own. They are shaped by solicitor-client and litigation privilege, employment law, privacy legislation, securities and regulatory reporting obligations, and the expectations of prosecutors who may later assess the organization's cooperation, for example in deciding whether to offer a remediation agreement.

This insight explains how to scope and structure internal investigations, protect privilege, conduct employee interviews, collect data lawfully, coordinate across borders and report to boards and regulators. It is general information, not legal advice.
Triage and scoping
Every investigation starts with triage. The organization should assess the source and credibility of the allegation, its seriousness, who may be implicated, the potential legal exposure, and whether any immediate steps are required, such as preserving evidence, suspending payments or restricting system access. Scoping then defines the questions the investigation must answer, the time period, the business units and individuals involved, the evidence to be gathered and the reporting line.
The reporting line is critical. Where senior management may be implicated, the investigation should report to a special committee of independent directors or the audit committee, not to management. Scope can expand as facts emerge, but expansions should be documented and approved.
| Decision | Options | Key considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Who oversees | Management, legal department, audit committee, special committee | Independence from those implicated |
| Who investigates | In-house team, external counsel, forensic accountants | Privilege, expertise, credibility with regulators |
| Scope | Narrow allegation-focused review or broader compliance review | Proportionality and regulator expectations |
| Reporting | Oral briefings, written report, summary of findings | Privilege waiver risk and disclosure obligations |
Structuring internal investigations for privilege
Solicitor-client privilege protects confidential communications between a client and its lawyer made for the purpose of seeking or giving legal advice. The Supreme Court of Canada has described it as a principle of fundamental justice and close to absolute, and has held that legislation does not override it without clear and explicit language (Alberta (Information and Privacy Commissioner) v. University of Calgary, 2016 SCC 53). Litigation privilege protects documents and communications whose dominant purpose is preparing for litigation that is ongoing or reasonably contemplated (Lizotte v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2016 SCC 52).
To maximize protection, investigations should be commissioned in writing by counsel for the purpose of providing legal advice to the organization, with forensic accountants and other experts retained by counsel to assist. Communications should be marked privileged and circulated narrowly. Facts are not privileged, however, and underlying business records remain producible. Sharing investigation findings with auditors, regulators or third parties can waive privilege, so the form and content of any disclosure should be planned, with limited-waiver or common-interest arrangements where available.
Decide at the outset whether a written report will be produced and who will see it. Many organizations receive oral reports or a short summary of findings and remedial actions, which reduces waiver risk if information must later be shared with regulators or auditors.
Employee interviews and warnings
Interviews are often the most important source of evidence. Before interviewing, investigators should explain that they act for the organization, not the employee; that the conversation is privileged but the privilege belongs to the organization, which may decide to waive it and share information with authorities; and that the employee should keep the interview confidential. These explanations, sometimes called corporate or "Upjohn"-style warnings, avoid later claims that the employee believed investigators represented them personally.
Employees generally have a duty to cooperate with reasonable workplace investigations, and refusal can be a disciplinary matter, but employers must act fairly and in good faith. Unionized employees may have rights to union representation under the collective agreement. Where an employee faces potential criminal exposure, the organization should consider whether they need independent counsel, and whether the organization will advance legal fees under its by-laws or indemnification agreements. Interview notes should record facts rather than investigators' opinions.
Data collection and privacy
Investigations usually require collecting emails, chat messages, documents, phone records and financial data. Organizations must comply with privacy law while doing so. Under the federal Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) and provincial private-sector laws in Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec, organizations can generally collect and use employee personal information without consent where reasonable for purposes such as investigating a breach of an agreement or a contravention of law, subject to conditions. Employment policies that set expectations about monitoring and the use of company systems strengthen the organization's position.
Practical safeguards include forensic imaging by qualified specialists to preserve chain of custody, targeted searches using agreed terms, limits on access to personal information unrelated to the investigation, and secure storage. Personal devices used for work, messaging apps and cloud accounts raise additional consent and access questions that should be addressed in bring-your-own-device policies.
Workplace harassment and human rights complaints
Not all internal investigations concern financial misconduct. Occupational health and safety statutes in several provinces, including Ontario, require employers to investigate incidents and complaints of workplace harassment and to inform the complainant and the alleged harasser of the results. Federally regulated employers have prescribed requirements under the Canada Labour Code and its harassment and violence regulations. Human rights complaints may also follow. These investigations require trained, impartial investigators, procedural fairness for the respondent, and confidentiality, and their reports may be disclosed in later proceedings, so privilege planning is different from fraud investigations. See our page on workplace investigations and human rights.
Regulated sectors
Financial institutions, securities registrants, reporting issuers and other regulated organizations face added obligations. They may need to report certain incidents or misconduct to OSFI, securities regulators, self-regulatory organizations or FINTRAC within set periods, and regulators may expect to be informed of significant investigations even before they are complete. Suspicious transaction reporting under anti-money laundering law cannot be delayed for an internal investigation. Reporting issuers must also consider insider trading restrictions while undisclosed investigation findings are known within the company.
Timing, budget and proportionality
Investigations should be proportionate to the allegation and the risk. A narrow complaint about expense claims does not need the same resources as allegations of systemic bribery. Setting an initial budget and timeline, with checkpoints for the oversight body to approve expansions, keeps the work focused. Speed matters too: delays allow evidence to disappear and may be criticized later by regulators, while premature conclusions can be wrong. Interim findings and remedial steps can be taken before the investigation ends where risks are ongoing.
Cross-border coordination
Many internal investigations involve conduct, people or data in several countries. Privilege rules differ: some jurisdictions do not protect communications with in-house counsel, and foreign regulators may not respect Canadian privilege. Data transfer rules, including Quebec's requirements for assessments before personal information is communicated outside Quebec, and foreign blocking or secrecy laws can restrict moving data. Ontario's Business Records Protection Act and similar statutes limit removal of business records from a province under foreign process in some circumstances. Coordination with foreign counsel and, where relevant, with foreign authorities avoids inconsistent positions.
Reporting to boards, auditors and regulators
Findings must reach the people who need to act on them. The board or special committee should receive regular updates and a final report on facts, root causes, responsibility and remediation. External auditors may need information to assess financial statement impact; reporting issuers must consider whether the matter is a material fact or material change requiring disclosure. Regulated entities may have mandatory reporting obligations, such as to securities regulators, FINTRAC, OSFI or privacy commissioners.
Self-reporting to law enforcement or regulators is often voluntary but can be decisive in obtaining cooperation credit, a remediation agreement under Part XXII.1 of the Criminal Code or reduced sanctions; see our insights on remediation agreements and securities enforcement. The decision should be made with counsel after the facts are understood.
Handling whistleblowers during internal investigations
Many investigations start with a whistleblower. Organizations must protect whistleblowers from retaliation, which is prohibited under several statutes, including securities and competition legislation, and keep their identity confidential as far as possible. Investigators should keep the whistleblower informed at an appropriate level, avoid steps that reveal their identity, and document that any later employment decisions affecting them are unrelated to the report. See our insight on whistleblower protections.
Remediation and discipline
Investigations should end with action. Remediation typically includes disciplining or terminating those responsible, strengthening controls, training, recovering losses and, where appropriate, compensating victims. Discipline must respect employment law: terminating for just cause requires clear evidence and a proportionate response, and a failed just cause allegation can lead to damages for wrongful dismissal. Documenting remediation also matters for any later regulatory or prosecutorial assessment.
Documentation standards
Every step of an investigation may later be scrutinized by a court, regulator, arbitrator or labour board. Investigators should keep a chronology of steps taken, records of evidence collected and its chain of custody, interview notes or memoranda prepared promptly after each interview, and a record of decisions on scope and reporting. Draft conclusions should be shared narrowly. Consistent, factual documentation protects the credibility of the findings and of the people who acted on them, and helps the organization show that it took the allegations seriously.
Common mistakes in internal investigations
- Starting interviews before preserving documents and data, which allows evidence to be deleted or altered.
- Interviewing key witnesses before reviewing their documents, which makes it harder to test their accounts.
- Allowing implicated managers to direct, staff or influence the investigation.
- Creating non-privileged written records of preliminary or speculative conclusions.
- Failing to give clear warnings to interviewees about whom counsel represents.
- Collecting personal information beyond what the investigation reasonably needs.
- Delaying decisions on disclosure until they are forced by external events.
- Neglecting to protect the whistleblower or complainant from retaliation during the process.
Each of these steps should be documented as the investigation proceeds.
How TRW & Co helps
We conduct and advise on internal investigations in Canada for boards, special committees and management. Our work includes triage and scoping, privilege structuring, coordinating forensic accountants and data specialists, employee interviews, privacy-compliant data collection, cross-border coordination, reporting to boards and auditors, and decisions about self-reporting and remediation. Where court proceedings or regulatory appearances require counsel licensed in a province, we work with locally licensed counsel. See our anti-corruption and corporate investigations page or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Are internal investigation reports privileged?
They can be, if the investigation is conducted by or at the direction of counsel for the purpose of giving legal advice, or predominantly for litigation that is reasonably contemplated. Facts and pre-existing business records are not privileged, and sharing findings with third parties can waive privilege.
Must employees cooperate with an internal investigation?
Generally, employees must cooperate with reasonable workplace investigations, and refusal can lead to discipline. Employers must act fairly and respect collective agreements. Employees facing personal exposure may need independent counsel.
Can we review employees' emails?
Usually, if the systems belong to the organization, policies set expectations, and the review is reasonable for investigating a breach of agreement or contravention of law under applicable privacy law. Keep searches targeted and protect unrelated personal information.
Should we report the findings to authorities?
Some reporting is mandatory, for example for certain regulated entities. Voluntary self-reporting can lead to cooperation credit or a remediation agreement. Decide with counsel after the facts are understood and weigh civil litigation consequences.
Who should oversee the investigation?
Someone independent of those potentially implicated. Where senior executives may be involved, a special committee of independent directors or the audit committee should oversee the investigation and receive reports.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


