Skip to content
Corporate & M&A

Limitation of Liability and Indemnity Clauses Under Canadian Law

A limitation of liability clause between commercial parties is generally enforceable in Canada, but only for the claims its words actually cover. This guide explains the Tercon test, how to draft caps and consequential loss exclusions, carve-outs for fraud and data breaches, the link to insurance, and when indemnities add little.

Contract clause showing a limitation of liability cap and carve-outs under Canadian law

Key takeaways

  • Tercon, 2010 SCC 4, replaced fundamental breach with a three-step interpretation, unconscionability and public policy test.
  • Most disputes turn on whether the clause, properly interpreted, covers the claim.
  • Lost profits can be direct losses; exclude them expressly if that is intended.
  • Data breach carve-outs and super-caps should be aligned with cyber insurance.
  • Quebec law bars excluding liability for intentional or gross fault and bodily or moral injury.

Are limitation of liability clauses enforceable in Canada?

Yes. In Canada's common-law provinces, a limitation of liability clause negotiated between commercial parties will generally be enforced according to its terms. The Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Tercon Contractors Ltd. v. British Columbia (Transportation and Highways), 2010 SCC 4, replaced the old doctrine of "fundamental breach" with a three-step test that starts from the wording and gives courts only narrow grounds to refuse enforcement. The real risks lie in drafting: clauses that do not cover the claim that actually arises, consequential loss wording that means less than the parties assumed, and indemnities that interact badly with caps.

Contract clause showing a limitation of liability cap and carve-outs under Canadian law
A limitation of liability clause works only if its cap, exclusions and carve-outs match the claims the parties expect.

This note covers the Tercon test, drafting caps and exclusions, consequential loss, carve-outs for fraud and data breaches, the interaction with insurance and indemnities, and the different rules in Quebec. It is written for in-house counsel negotiating supply, services, technology and M&A agreements.

The Tercon three-step test

In Tercon, 2010 SCC 4, decided on 12 February 2010, the Supreme Court held that the doctrine of fundamental breach should be laid to rest and set out the following analysis for exclusion and limitation clauses:

  1. Interpretation. Does the clause, properly interpreted, apply to the circumstances established in evidence? If not, the analysis ends.
  2. Unconscionability. If it applies, was the clause unconscionable at the time the contract was made, for example because of an inequality of bargaining power?
  3. Overriding public policy. If it was valid when made, should the court nevertheless refuse to enforce it because of an overriding public policy, the burden of proof being on the party seeking to avoid it? Examples include conduct approaching serious criminality or egregious fraud.

In Tercon itself, a majority found that the exclusion clause, read in context, did not cover the claim, so the contractor recovered. The case is therefore also a reminder that step one, interpretation, is where most limitation of liability disputes are won and lost. Canadian courts read contracts as a whole, in light of the surrounding circumstances known to both parties, and resolve genuine ambiguity in exclusion clauses against the party relying on them.

Drafting limitation of liability caps and exclusions

A limitation of liability clause usually combines three elements: a cap on the amount recoverable, an exclusion of certain heads of loss, and carve-outs from both. Drafting choices that matter:

ElementCommon approachDrafting watch points
Cap amountFees paid or payable in the prior 12 months, a fixed amount, or a multiple of feesAggregate or per claim; what happens in year one; whether paid or payable
Scope of cap"All claims arising under or in connection with this agreement, whether in contract, tort (including negligence) or otherwise"Expressly cover negligence and statutory claims if intended
Excluded lossesIndirect, consequential, special and punitive damages; lost profits, revenue, dataLost profits may be direct; define whether they are excluded regardless of characterization
Carve-outsFraud, wilful misconduct, confidentiality breaches, IP indemnities, data breaches, bodily injuryUncapped versus "super-cap"; overlap between carve-outs
MutualityUsually mutual, but customers' payment obligations are excluded from the capAvoid capping fees owed

Precision matters because courts give effect to the words chosen. A cap described as applying to "damages" may not limit claims for debt, restitution or specific performance. An exclusion of "liability for negligence" is clearer than a general exclusion that never mentions negligence.

Consequential loss wording

Exclusions of "indirect or consequential loss" are standard, but their meaning is often misunderstood. In Canadian law, the distinction tracks the two limbs of the classic remoteness rule: losses arising naturally from the breach (direct) versus losses that arise from special circumstances within the parties' contemplation (consequential). Lost profits can fall into either category. A supplier that assumes "consequential loss" excludes all lost profits may find that the customer's lost profits on resale were direct losses that the exclusion does not reach.

The safer approach is to list the excluded categories expressly, for example "loss of profits, revenue, business, goodwill or anticipated savings, whether direct or indirect", and to say whether the exclusion applies to indemnified third-party claims. Parties should also think about what they do not want excluded: costs of procuring replacement services, regulatory fines (where lawfully recoverable), and costs of restoring data are frequently negotiated as recoverable direct losses.

Carve-outs for fraud, wilful misconduct and data breaches

Even without an express carve-out, a party is unlikely to be able to rely on a limitation of liability clause to escape the consequences of its own fraud: under Tercon's third step, courts can refuse to enforce a clause on grounds of overriding public policy. The Supreme Court has also held, in Bhasin v. Hrynew, that the duty of honest performance is a general doctrine of contract law that parties cannot exclude, although they may relax its requirements in some respects; see our note on honest contractual performance.

Data breaches are now the most negotiated carve-out in technology and outsourcing deals. Customers want breach costs (notification, credit monitoring, forensics, regulatory penalties where recoverable, third-party claims) outside the general cap; suppliers want them inside, or subject to a separate "super-cap" tied to their cyber insurance. Common compromises include:

  • a separate cap for data protection breaches, typically a multiple of the general cap;
  • uncapped liability only for breaches caused by the supplier's failure to meet specified security obligations;
  • a list of recoverable breach costs, so that disputes about direct versus consequential loss do not arise.

Our note on service provider agreements and privacy covers the related privacy law obligations.

Practical point

Before agreeing a cap, check the other party's insurance. A cap above its available coverage gives a theoretical remedy; a cap aligned with coverage and an obligation to maintain that coverage gives a practical one.

Interaction with insurance

Limitation of liability clauses and insurance should be designed together. Points to coordinate include whether the cap equals or exceeds required policy limits; whether the clause could prejudice an insurer's subrogation rights (and whether the policy permits pre-loss waivers); waivers of subrogation in favour of the other party; and whether carve-outs are insurable at all. Professional liability and cyber policies often exclude contractual liability assumed beyond what the insured would have at law, so an uncapped indemnity may be uninsured.

Insurance requirements should also be specific: the types of coverage, minimum limits, whether the other party must be named as an additional insured, notice of cancellation, and evidence of coverage. A clause that simply requires "adequate insurance" gives little protection when a claim arises.

When indemnities add little to ordinary damages

Indemnities are often negotiated as though they were a separate, superior remedy. Sometimes they are, particularly for third-party claims, where an indemnity can shift defence costs and settlement control and avoid arguments about remoteness. But a broad "first-party" indemnity for losses arising from breach may add little beyond ordinary damages, while creating uncertainty about whether caps, exclusions and mitigation principles apply. Indemnities should state:

  • whether they cover only third-party claims or also direct losses between the parties;
  • whether the general cap and exclusions apply, and if not, what limits do;
  • notice, defence and settlement procedures; and
  • whether the indemnity is the sole remedy for the matters it covers.

In M&A agreements, the indemnity package usually is the sole remedy, with baskets, caps and survival periods replacing the general law. In commercial agreements, clarity about how the indemnity and the limitation of liability clause interact is essential.

Sale of goods, consumer law and statutory limits

Statutes can limit freedom of contract. Provincial sale of goods legislation implies conditions of merchantable quality and fitness for purpose into sales of goods, which can be excluded in commercial contracts only with sufficiently clear language. In Earthco Soil Mixtures Inc. v. Pine Valley Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 20, the Supreme Court addressed what is needed to contract out of those implied conditions.

The majority held that an exclusion clause qualifies as the required express agreement if, read according to ordinary principles of contractual interpretation, it sets out an agreement to negative or vary the implied right, and it restored the trial judgment enforcing the seller's exclusion clauses. Consumer protection statutes go further: many prohibit or limit exclusions of liability in consumer contracts altogether. Businesses selling to consumers should not assume that a business-to-business template will work.

Quebec: different rules under the Civil Code

In Quebec, the Civil Code of Québec governs. A party cannot exclude or limit its liability for material injury caused through an intentional or gross fault, and it cannot exclude or limit liability for bodily or moral injury caused to another. Contracts of adhesion and consumer contracts face additional controls on abusive clauses. A limitation of liability clause drafted for Ontario may therefore be partly unenforceable in Quebec. Our note on liability clauses under Quebec law explains the rules.

Negotiating limitation of liability in practice

Limitation of liability terms are often left to the end of a negotiation and settled under time pressure. A more disciplined approach starts with the risk profile of the deal. Which failures are most likely, which would be most costly, and who is best placed to prevent or insure them? The answers usually point to a structure in which ordinary performance failures sit under a general cap, specific high-severity risks sit under separate caps or indemnities, and a short list of conduct (fraud, wilful misconduct, wilful abandonment) is uncapped.

A practical checklist for reviewing a draft:

  1. Does the clause cover every cause of action, including negligence, misrepresentation and statutory claims?
  2. Is the cap aggregate or per claim, and how is it calculated in the first year of the contract?
  3. Are payment obligations, such as fees owed, excluded from the cap?
  4. Are lost profits, lost data and wasted expenditure dealt with expressly?
  5. Do carve-outs overlap, and does any carve-out swallow the rule?
  6. Do indemnities sit inside or outside the cap, and is that stated?
  7. Is the clause consistent with the insurance each party carries?
  8. Does it work under each governing law that may apply, including Quebec?

Contract templates often carry clauses copied from other jurisdictions. A US-style "in no event" clause or an English-style "consequential loss" exclusion can produce different results under Canadian law, so templates should be checked against Canadian principles before they are used on a Canadian deal.

How TRW & Co helps

We draft and negotiate limitation of liability, exclusion and indemnity provisions in commercial, technology, outsourcing and M&A agreements, align them with insurance programmes, and advise on enforceability under common-law and Quebec rules. When disputes arise, we assess how clauses are likely to be interpreted and work with litigation counsel on strategy. See our corporations and commercial structuring page and our technology transactions page. This note is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a contract, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Tercon test?

From Tercon Contractors v. British Columbia, 2010 SCC 4: first, does the clause, properly interpreted, apply to the circumstances? Second, if so, was it unconscionable when made? Third, if valid, should the court refuse to enforce it because of an overriding public policy? The party seeking to avoid the clause bears the burden at the third step.

Does excluding consequential loss exclude lost profits?

Not necessarily. Lost profits can be direct losses if they arise naturally from the breach. To exclude them in all cases, the clause should list loss of profits, revenue and similar heads expressly, whether direct or indirect.

Can a party limit liability for its own fraud?

Practically, no. Under Tercon's third step, courts can refuse to enforce an exclusion clause on grounds of overriding public policy, such as fraud. The duty of honest performance recognized in Bhasin v. Hrynew also cannot be excluded entirely. Most agreements carve fraud and wilful misconduct out expressly.

Should indemnities be subject to the liability cap?

It depends on the indemnity. Third-party IP and data breach indemnities are often uncapped or subject to a higher super-cap; broad first-party indemnities are usually capped. Whatever is agreed should be stated expressly, because unclear drafting invites disputes about whether caps and exclusions apply.

Do limitation clauses work the same way in Quebec?

No. Under the Civil Code of Québec, a party cannot exclude or limit liability for material injury caused by intentional or gross fault, or for bodily or moral injury. Abusive clauses in adhesion and consumer contracts can also be struck down, so Quebec-specific drafting is needed.

Sources

  1. SCC case information: Tercon Contractors Ltd. v. British Columbia (docket 32460), 2010 SCC 4
  2. SCC Case in Brief: Earthco Soil Mixtures Inc. v. Pine Valley Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 20
  3. Supreme Court of Canada: judgment notice for Tercon, 2010 SCC 4 (12 February 2010)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.