Skip to content
Leading Court Decisions

Bhasin v Hrynew: The Duty of Honest Performance

Bhasin v Hrynew created the duty of honest performance, a rule that applies to every contract governed by Canadian common law. Parties may pursue their own interests, but they must not lie or knowingly mislead each other about the contract's performance, and they cannot contract out of that duty.

Business partners reviewing a dealer agreement, reflecting the duty of honest performance from Bhasin

Key takeaways

  • Bhasin v. Hrynew, 2014 SCC 71, was decided on 13 November 2014 by a unanimous Court.
  • Good faith is an organizing principle of Canadian common-law contract law.
  • The duty of honest performance bars lying or knowingly misleading about contract performance.
  • It is not a duty of loyalty or disclosure, and it cannot be excluded by contract.
  • Can-Am was liable for $87,000, the value of the business Mr. Bhasin lost.

Bhasin v Hrynew and the duty of honest performance

Bhasin v. Hrynew, 2014 SCC 71, is the Supreme Court of Canada decision that introduced the duty of honest performance into Canadian common law. In a unanimous judgment written by Cromwell J., the Court recognized good faith as an "organizing principle" of contract law and, as a specific manifestation of it, a general duty on every contracting party not to lie or otherwise knowingly mislead the other about matters directly linked to the performance of the contract. The duty applies to all contracts, regardless of the parties' intentions, and cannot simply be excluded by agreement.

Business partners reviewing a dealer agreement, reflecting the duty of honest performance from Bhasin
Since Bhasin, every contract governed by Canadian common law carries a duty not to lie or knowingly mislead about its performance.

The Supreme Court docket records that judgment was rendered on 13 November 2014. The appeal was allowed against the corporate defendant, with damages set at $87,000 plus interest, and dismissed against the individual defendant, Mr. Hrynew. A decade later, Bhasin has been extended and refined by a series of decisions, and the honesty duty has become a standard feature of commercial litigation in the common-law provinces.

The facts: a dealer agreement, a rival and a non-renewal

Mr. Bhasin was an enrolment director selling education savings plans for Canadian American Financial Corp. (Can-Am) under a dealer agreement. The agreement ran for three years and renewed automatically unless either party gave six months' notice of non-renewal. Mr. Hrynew was another enrolment director and a competitor of Mr. Bhasin who wanted to take over his business.

Can-Am, under pressure from the Alberta Securities Commission to appoint a provincial trading officer to review its enrolment directors for compliance, appointed Mr. Hrynew to that role. Mr. Bhasin objected to a competitor reviewing his confidential business records. Can-Am was not honest with him about its plans: it had been discussing a restructuring under which Mr. Hrynew would take over Mr. Bhasin's agency, and it equivocated when Mr. Bhasin asked whether that outcome had already been decided. When Mr. Bhasin refused the audit, Can-Am gave notice of non-renewal. Mr. Bhasin lost the value of his business, and most of his sales agents went to work for Mr. Hrynew's agency.

The trial judge found that Can-Am had breached an implied term of good faith. The Alberta Court of Appeal reversed, holding that no such term could be implied given the agreement's entire-agreement clause and its clear non-renewal provision. The Supreme Court restored liability against Can-Am on a different basis.

Good faith as an organizing principle

Before Bhasin, Canadian common law recognized good faith only in specific settings, such as employment, insurance and tendering, and through particular doctrines. Cromwell J. described the law as piecemeal and unsettled. The Court took two incremental steps to bring coherence to it.

First, it held that there is an organizing principle of good faith underlying many contractual doctrines: parties generally must perform their contractual duties honestly and reasonably and not capriciously or arbitrarily. An organizing principle is not a free-standing rule; it is a standard that underpins and manifests itself in more specific doctrines, and it helps courts develop the law incrementally.

Second, the Court recognized a new common-law duty applying to all contracts as a manifestation of that principle: the duty of honest performance. The organizing principle has since grown through other doctrines, most notably the duty to exercise contractual discretion in good faith confirmed in the Wastech decision.

The scope of the duty of honest performance

The Court defined the duty with care, emphasizing what it does not require as much as what it does. Its key features are summarized below.

FeatureWhat Bhasin held
ContentParties must not lie or otherwise knowingly mislead each other about matters directly linked to the performance of the contract
Not a duty of loyaltyA party may pursue its own self-interest and need not put the other's interests first
Not a duty of disclosureThere is no general obligation to volunteer information, including an intention not to renew
SourceA general doctrine of contract law, not an implied term, so it applies regardless of the parties' intentions
ExclusionIt cannot be excluded entirely; parties may relax its requirements in some contexts if the core of honest performance is respected
RemedyDamages on the expectation measure for breach of contract

Because the duty of honest performance is a doctrine of law rather than an implied term, the entire-agreement clause in Can-Am's agreement did not exclude it. That was the decisive answer to the Court of Appeal's reasoning. The Court noted that parties may define the content of honest performance in a way suited to their context, for example in commercial settings where certain kinds of posturing are expected, but they cannot contract out of the requirement to be honest.

Application to Can-Am and the measure of damages

The Court found that Can-Am breached the duty of honest performance by misleading Mr. Bhasin about its intentions and about the arrangements with Mr. Hrynew in the period leading up to the non-renewal. It did not have to give reasons for not renewing, and it was entitled to choose not to renew; what it could not do was deceive Mr. Bhasin about matters directly linked to its performance of the agreement, including the exercise of the non-renewal right.

Damages were assessed on the expectation measure: the position Mr. Bhasin would have been in had Can-Am performed honestly. The Court reasoned that, had he known the truth, he could have taken steps to preserve the value of his agency before the agreement ended. It valued that loss at $87,000, the figure the trial judge had found as the value of his business. The claim against Mr. Hrynew failed; the Court found no basis for his personal liability on the pleaded causes of action.

Practical point

A party that has decided not to renew, or to terminate, does not have to announce the decision early. But once it speaks about the future of the relationship, it must not say things that are false or misleading. Silence is safer than reassurance; and, as Callow later confirmed, half-truths can be as dangerous as lies.

How the duty has developed since 2014

Three later Supreme Court decisions have shaped the duty of honest performance and the organizing principle of good faith:

  • C.M. Callow Inc. v. Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45. The duty applies to the exercise of a termination right and can be breached by active deception, including half-truths, misleading conduct and, in some circumstances, silence. The Case in Brief notes that the majority found the condominium corporations had actively misled the contractor into believing the contract would continue.
  • Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7. A separate duty requires contractual discretion to be exercised in good faith, meaning reasonably and for the purposes for which it was granted (Case in Brief).
  • Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26. In the employment context, the Court noted that the employer had not been honest with the employee about his future, while deciding the case on the bonus entitlement (Case in Brief).

Together these cases confirm that good faith in Canadian common law is real but bounded. It polices honesty and the purposes for which contractual powers are used. It does not impose fiduciary-style loyalty or a general duty to disclose, and it does not permit courts to rewrite bargains they consider unfair.

Where honesty claims arise in practice

Allegations of dishonest performance now appear in a wide range of commercial disputes. They tend to cluster in a few recurring situations:

  • Non-renewal and termination of long-term relationships, such as distribution, franchise, agency and services agreements, where the terminating party gave reassurances while planning to exit.
  • Earnouts and deferred consideration, where a seller alleges the buyer misrepresented how the business was being run or how a metric was calculated.
  • Construction and procurement, where an owner is alleged to have misled a contractor about site conditions, change orders or payment intentions during performance.
  • Lending and forbearance, where a borrower claims a lender misled it about whether it would continue to support the business.
  • Employment, where employees allege that an employer misled them about their future, their role or their incentive entitlements.

The claim is usually pleaded alongside breach of express terms and, where a discretion is involved, the Wastech duty. Its value lies in reaching conduct that complies with the letter of a contract but involves deception about how it is being performed. Its limit is that it requires something more than a hard bargain: the claimant must show a misleading statement or conduct, knowledge, and a direct link to performance. Courts have rejected attempts to use the duty as a general fairness standard or to imply a duty to disclose information a party was entitled to keep to itself.

Practical guidance for businesses

The duty of honest performance applies to every contract, from long-term supply and distribution agreements to franchise, licensing and services contracts. Businesses can manage the risk with straightforward discipline:

  1. Control communications around renewal and termination. Decide who speaks to the counterparty when a non-renewal or termination is under consideration, and avoid reassuring statements that are untrue.
  2. Do not use audits or compliance rights as pretexts. Using a contractual right to obtain information for an undisclosed competitive purpose invites claims.
  3. Train relationship managers. Sales and account teams often make the statements that later become evidence of deception.
  4. Review entire-agreement and good-faith clauses. They cannot exclude the duty of honest performance, though they can shape expectations about negotiation and posturing.
  5. Document legitimate reasons. Although no reasons are required for non-renewal, a record of honest business reasons helps rebut allegations of a hidden agenda.

Illustration: a hypothetical manufacturer decides in March to end a distribution agreement at its December expiry and to appoint a new distributor. In June, the incumbent distributor asks whether it should invest in a new warehouse to support next year's sales, and the manufacturer's sales director says the relationship is "solid for the long term". That statement risks breaching the honesty duty, and the distributor's wasted investment and lost opportunity to find another supplier could found a damages claim. The manufacturer could have declined to comment on renewal, or told the truth.

Quebec reaches similar results through the Civil Code's general requirement of good faith in the performance and termination of contracts; see our page on Quebec civil law contracts.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise businesses on the duty of honest performance and the wider law of good faith in Canadian contracts. We review distribution, franchise, supply and services agreements, plan non-renewal and termination communications, and assess good-faith claims and defences in disputes, working with litigation counsel in the relevant province where required. This article is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a contract relationship or dispute, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the duty of honest performance?

It is a general duty, recognized in Bhasin v. Hrynew, that requires contracting parties not to lie or otherwise knowingly mislead each other about matters directly linked to the performance of the contract. It applies to all contracts governed by Canadian common law, whatever the parties intended.

Can the duty of honest performance be excluded by an entire-agreement clause?

No. Because it is a doctrine of contract law rather than an implied term, an entire-agreement clause does not displace it. Parties may relax some aspects in particular contexts, provided the core requirement of honesty is respected, but they cannot contract out of the duty entirely.

Does the duty require disclosure of a decision not to renew?

No. Bhasin made clear that the duty is not a duty of disclosure, so a party need not volunteer that it will not renew. But it must not mislead the other party. Later, Callow v. Zollinger held that half-truths and misleading conduct, and sometimes silence, can amount to active deception.

How are damages measured?

On the expectation measure, as for any breach of contract: the claimant is put in the position it would have been in had the other party performed honestly. In Bhasin, the Court found Mr. Bhasin would have been able to preserve the value of his business, assessed at $87,000.

Does Bhasin apply in Quebec?

Bhasin is a common-law decision. Quebec has long recognized good faith in contracts through the Civil Code, which requires good faith when obligations arise, are performed and are extinguished. The Supreme Court in Callow drew on Quebec civil-law concepts to illustrate the common-law duty.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Canada, case 35380 (Bhasin v. Hrynew), docket and judgment entries
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: C.M. Callow Inc. v. Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45
  3. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7
  4. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.