Peoples v Wise: Director Duties Near Insolvency
Peoples v Wise is the Supreme Court of Canada's leading case on directors' duties near insolvency. It held that directors owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation, not to creditors, but that creditors can rely on the objective duty of care, while courts defer to reasonable, informed business decisions.

Key takeaways
- Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, was decided on 29 October 2004.
- Directors owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation, even as insolvency approaches.
- The duty of care is objective, and creditors can rely on it.
- Courts defer to decisions made prudently and on a reasonably informed basis.
- Creditors also have the oppression remedy and insolvency-law tools.
What Peoples v Wise decided
Peoples v Wise, formally Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, is the Supreme Court of Canada's foundational decision on directors' duties when a company approaches insolvency. The Court held that directors do not owe a fiduciary duty directly to creditors, even when the company is in financial difficulty; that the statutory duty of care is an objective standard that creditors can invoke; and that courts will defer to reasonable business decisions made on an informed basis. On the facts, the directors were not liable. The judgment was delivered on 29 October 2004, according to the Supreme Court docket.

Read together with the later BCE decision, Peoples v Wise defines the architecture of Canadian directors' duties: a fiduciary duty owed to the corporation, a duty of care with a broader reach, and the oppression remedy as the main tool for stakeholders who claim unfair treatment.
The facts: an integrated inventory policy that failed
Wise Stores Inc., a Quebec retailer controlled by three brothers, acquired Peoples Department Stores from Marks & Spencer Canada in 1992 in a leveraged transaction and merged its operations with its own. The Wise brothers were the only directors of Peoples. The combined business struggled, and in early 1994 management proposed, and the directors approved, a joint inventory procurement policy: Peoples would buy inventory from North American suppliers for both companies, Wise would buy from overseas suppliers, and each would charge the other for goods transferred.
In practice, Peoples ended up buying most of the inventory and extending substantial trade credit to Wise, which was in a weaker financial position. Both companies went bankrupt in December 1994. Peoples' trustee in bankruptcy sued the Wise brothers, alleging that they had breached their fiduciary duty and their duty of care under s. 122(1) of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) by favouring Wise to the detriment of Peoples' creditors.
The trial judge found the directors liable. The Quebec Court of Appeal reversed. The Supreme Court, in joint reasons by Major and Deschamps JJ., dismissed the trustee's appeal.
Peoples v Wise and the fiduciary duty
The trustee's central argument was that, as a company nears insolvency, directors' fiduciary duty shifts toward creditors. The Court rejected it. At all times, directors and officers owe their fiduciary obligation to the corporation, and the interests of the corporation are not to be confused with those of creditors or any other stakeholder.
At the same time, the Court explained that "the best interests of the corporation" is not the same as the best interests of the shareholders. In determining what is in the corporation's best interests, directors may legitimately consider "the interests of shareholders, employees, suppliers, creditors, consumers, governments and the environment". Parliament codified a similar list in s. 122(1.1) CBCA in 2019.
The fiduciary duty is a duty of loyalty and good faith. The directors in Peoples v Wise had not acted for personal benefit or in bad faith: the policy aimed to solve a genuine and urgent inventory problem facing both companies. There was therefore no breach of the fiduciary duty.
The duty of care and the business judgment rule
The duty of care in s. 122(1)(b) CBCA requires directors and officers to exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in comparable circumstances. The Court described this as an objective standard, while noting that the circumstances in which the decision was made remain relevant.
Unlike the fiduciary duty, the duty of care is not expressed as owed only to the corporation. The Court held that creditors can rely on it: in Quebec, through the general civil liability rule in art. 1457 of the Civil Code; in the common-law provinces, through the law of negligence where its requirements are met. That gives creditors a direct route against directors whose decisions fall below the standard.
The Court paired that holding with strong deference to business decisions. Directors will not be in breach of the duty of care if they act prudently and on a reasonably informed basis. Courts are, in the Court's words, "ill-suited and should be reluctant to second-guess the application of business expertise", and "perfection is not demanded". Applying that standard, the Court found that the joint procurement policy was a reasonable business decision made to address a serious and urgent problem, even though it turned out badly.
| Duty | Owed to | Standard | Who can enforce it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fiduciary duty, s. 122(1)(a) CBCA | The corporation | Honesty, good faith and loyalty to the corporation's best interests | The corporation, or stakeholders through a derivative action with leave |
| Duty of care, s. 122(1)(b) CBCA | Not limited to the corporation | Objective: care, diligence and skill of a reasonably prudent person in comparable circumstances | The corporation and, per Peoples v Wise, creditors and others under general civil or tort law |
| Oppression remedy, s. 241 CBCA | Security holders, creditors, directors and officers whose interests are unfairly treated | Reasonable expectations defeated by oppressive or unfairly prejudicial conduct | Complainants, including creditors granted complainant status |
Oppression and other routes for creditors
The Court emphasized that creditors are not without protection. The oppression remedy under s. 241 CBCA gives Canadian creditors broad rights compared with other common-law jurisdictions; a creditor who is not a security holder can apply for leave as a "complainant" under s. 238. Insolvency legislation adds further tools, including the trustee's ability to challenge transfers at undervalue under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. In Peoples v Wise, the trustee's challenge under the BIA also failed because the transactions were not conspicuously below fair market value.
The decision also addressed the statutory defence for reliance on reports. At the time, the CBCA allowed directors to rely in good faith on reports of professionals such as lawyers and accountants. The Court held that reliance on the advice of an internal finance executive who was not a member of a listed profession did not fall within that defence. Parliament has since broadened the defences: s. 123(4) CBCA now provides a due diligence defence where a director exercised the care of a reasonably prudent person, including good-faith reliance on financial statements and professional reports, and s. 123(5) provides a good-faith reliance defence for the fiduciary duty.
The Quebec civil-law angle
Peoples was a Quebec case decided under a federal statute, and the Court's reasoning on creditors' recourse draws directly on the Civil Code of Québec. Article 1457 C.C.Q. imposes on every person a duty to abide by the rules of conduct incumbent on them so as not to cause injury to another. Because the CBCA duty of care sets a rule of conduct for directors, a creditor injured by a director's breach of that standard can, in principle, seek reparation under art. 1457, subject to proving fault, injury and causation.
The Civil Code also contains its own duties for directors of legal persons. Article 322 C.C.Q. requires a director to act with prudence and diligence, and with honesty and loyalty in the interest of the legal person; art. 323 prohibits mingling the legal person's property with the director's own or using its property or information for personal profit without authorization. For companies incorporated under Quebec's Business Corporations Act, these provisions operate alongside the statute. Directors of Quebec subsidiaries of foreign groups should therefore treat intra-group dealings with particular care. Our page on the Quebec civil law of contracts explains how the Civil Code interacts with corporate statutes.
Questions a distressed board should ask
- Do we have reliable, current information on liquidity, covenants and creditor exposure, and how often are we receiving it?
- Which decisions on the agenda shift risk from shareholders to creditors, such as distributions, new debt or asset transfers?
- Are any transactions with affiliates, shareholders or insiders on commercial terms, and are conflicted directors abstaining?
- Have we obtained independent advice, and do the minutes show that we considered it and the alternatives?
- Have we assessed formal and informal restructuring options in time for them to be useful?
- Are statutory liabilities for wages, source deductions and sales taxes being paid or ring-fenced?
- Is our directors' and officers' insurance adequate, and do we understand its insolvency exclusions and run-off options?
- Who will communicate with lenders, key suppliers and employees, and are those communications accurate and consistent?
How Peoples v Wise guides distressed board decisions today
In practice, Peoples v Wise tells boards that the zone of insolvency does not change to whom the duty is owed, but it does change what a prudent board must think about. When the company's ability to pay its debts is in doubt, creditors bear much of the downside of risky decisions, and a reasonable board will give their interests real weight. Directors of distressed companies typically:
- meet more often, with current cash-flow forecasts and liquidity analysis;
- obtain independent financial and legal advice, and record that they considered it;
- scrutinize related-party and intra-group transactions, which were at the heart of Peoples v Wise;
- consider restructuring options early, including proposals under the BIA and filings under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA);
- track statutory exposures that apply regardless of fiduciary analysis, such as unpaid wages under s. 119 CBCA and source deductions and sales taxes under tax statutes.
The business judgment rule protects process, not outcomes. The Wise brothers succeeded because their decision responded to a real problem and was reasonable when made. A board that cannot show what information it had, what alternatives it weighed and why it chose its course will find little shelter in Peoples v Wise when the company fails.
Illustration: a hypothetical Canadian subsidiary of a foreign group is running short of cash and is asked to extend more credit to an affiliate. Its directors, mindful of Peoples v Wise, ask for the affiliate's financial information, consider whether security or guarantees can be obtained, take independent advice and minute their reasons. If they approve the credit on commercial terms for a legitimate business purpose, they are well placed; if they approve it without information simply because the parent asked, they risk claims under the duty of care, oppression and insolvency law. Our insight on directors' duties in the zone of insolvency and our page on CCAA restructuring develop these points.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise boards, special committees, officers and investors on directors' duties in Canada, including in distressed situations. We help directors structure decision-making, document deliberations, evaluate intra-group transactions and restructuring options, and assess exposure to creditor, oppression and statutory claims. We also act for creditors and trustees evaluating claims against directors, working with litigation counsel and licensed insolvency trustees where required. This article is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a board or creditor issue, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Do directors owe fiduciary duties to creditors when a company is insolvent?
No. Peoples v Wise held that directors owe their fiduciary duty to the corporation at all times, including near insolvency. They may consider creditors' interests in deciding what is in the corporation's best interests, and a prudent board will give those interests real weight when solvency is in doubt, but the duty does not shift to creditors.
Can creditors sue directors after Peoples v Wise?
Yes, in some circumstances. The Court held that the statutory duty of care is not limited to the corporation, so creditors may rely on it through general civil liability in Quebec or negligence law elsewhere. Creditors can also seek leave to bring an oppression claim, and trustees may use insolvency-law remedies against transactions at undervalue.
What is the business judgment rule in Canada?
It is the principle that courts will not second-guess business decisions made honestly, prudently and on a reasonably informed basis, even if they turn out badly. Peoples v Wise affirmed it, stating that perfection is not demanded. The rule protects a sound decision-making process rather than a particular outcome.
Why were the Wise brothers not liable?
The Court found that the joint inventory procurement policy was a reasonable business decision made in good faith to address a serious and urgent problem. The directors did not act for personal benefit, so there was no breach of fiduciary duty, and the decision met the objective standard of care despite its poor results.
What defences do CBCA directors have today?
Section 123(4) CBCA provides a due diligence defence for certain liabilities and the duty in s. 122(2) where a director exercised the care of a reasonably prudent person, including good-faith reliance on financial statements and professional reports. Section 123(5) protects directors who relied in good faith on such documents with respect to their s. 122(1) duties.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


