Personal Health Information: PHIPA, HIA and Digital Health
Personal health information is governed by provincial statutes such as Ontario's PHIPA and Alberta's HIA, which regulate custodians and the agents, affiliates and vendors that act for them. Implied consent within the circle of care, electronic health records, AI scribes and strict breach reporting to commissioners shape compliance for providers and digital health companies.

Key takeaways
- PHIPA and the HIA regulate custodians and those who act on their behalf.
- PHIPA s. 20(2) allows certain custodians to assume implied consent for providing health care.
- PHIPA requires notice to individuals at the first reasonable opportunity after theft, loss or unauthorized use.
- Alberta's HIA s. 60.1 requires notice to the Commissioner, Minister and individual where there is a risk of harm.
- PHIPA offences carry fines up to $200,000 for individuals and $1,000,000 for organizations.
- AI scribes call for privacy impact assessments and careful vendor terms.
Personal health information and the provincial health privacy statutes
Health information is governed in Canada by a patchwork of provincial statutes that sit alongside general privacy laws. Ontario's Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004 (PHIPA) and Alberta's Health Information Act (HIA) are two of the most detailed. They apply to hospitals, physicians, pharmacies, laboratories, long-term care homes and other custodians, and through them to the technology vendors, clinics and service providers that handle personal health information on their behalf.

This insight explains the custodian model, consent and the circle of care, electronic health records, AI scribes and other digital tools, and breach reporting to commissioners. It focuses on Ontario and Alberta, with notes on how other laws interact. It is general information, not legal advice.
The custodian and agent model
Health privacy statutes are built around the health information custodian: the person or organization with custody or control of health information as a result of providing health care. In Ontario, custodians include health care practitioners, hospitals, long-term care homes, pharmacies, laboratories and others listed in PHIPA. A custodian remains responsible for the information, and anyone who acts on its behalf, such as an employee, contractor or volunteer, is an "agent" who may only collect, use and disclose personal health information as the custodian permits and as PHIPA allows.
Alberta's HIA uses the term "affiliate" for individuals and organizations that act for a custodian, such as employees, volunteers and contractors, and separately regulates information managers that provide information technology services to custodians. In both provinces, technology providers that supply electronic records systems or other services typically fall within these frameworks and must meet statutory and contractual requirements.
Which law applies
| Context | Typical governing law |
|---|---|
| Ontario custodians and their agents | PHIPA |
| Alberta custodians and their affiliates | HIA |
| Commercial organizations outside health statutes (for example, some wellness apps) | PIPEDA or provincial private-sector law |
| Quebec health and social services bodies | Quebec's health information statute and access legislation |
| Employers holding employee health information | Depends on the employer and province |
Several other provinces have similar health information statutes, and PIPEDA applies to commercial activities involving personal health information where no substantially similar provincial law applies. Mapping which law governs each data flow is the first step in any health privacy project.
Consent and the circle of care
PHIPA requires consent for the collection, use and disclosure of personal health information unless the Act permits otherwise. Consent may be express or implied in many cases.
Under subsection 20(2), certain custodians that receive information from the individual, a substitute decision-maker or another custodian for the purpose of providing health care are entitled to assume implied consent to collect, use or disclose it for providing health care to that individual, unless they know the individual has expressly withheld or withdrawn consent. The phrase "circle of care", used widely in practice and by the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, describes this group of custodians providing care. It is not a defined statutory term.
Disclosures outside the circle of care, such as to insurers, employers or researchers, or for marketing, generally require express consent or a specific statutory authority. Individuals can also place restrictions, often called a "lockbox", on the use or disclosure of their information for health care, and custodians must respect those instructions subject to the Act. Alberta's HIA takes a different approach, permitting many collections, uses and disclosures among custodians for providing health services without consent while emphasizing the duty to use the least amount of information necessary.
Electronic health records and interoperability
Both provinces operate province-wide electronic health records. PHIPA contains a dedicated Part on the electronic health record developed and maintained by a prescribed organization, setting out rules on access, directives and logging. Amendments made by S.O. 2025, c. 7, Schedule 6 extend aspects of the Act, including access and correction rights, to records accessible through the provincial electronic health record and to digital health identifier records maintained by the prescribed organization. Alberta's provincial electronic health record operates under the HIA.
Interoperability initiatives, including patient portals, shared care records and application programming interfaces, are expanding the flow of personal health information between hospitals, primary care and patients. Each new connection should be supported by agreements that define roles, permitted uses, logging and audit, breach cooperation and the handling of individual access requests.
When you connect a new application to an electronic health record or patient portal, confirm who is the custodian for each record, whether the vendor is acting as an agent or affiliate, and how access logs will be kept and reviewed. Unclear roles are a common source of compliance gaps and disputes after incidents.
AI scribes and digital health tools
AI scribes, which record clinical encounters and generate draft notes, are spreading rapidly across Canadian primary care and hospitals. They raise several privacy questions:
- whether patients are told the encounter is being recorded and how the recording is processed;
- whether the vendor is acting as an agent or affiliate under health privacy law, and on what contractual terms;
- where audio and transcripts are processed and stored, and for how long;
- whether the vendor uses recordings or transcripts to train or improve its models;
- accuracy, clinician review of drafts, and integration with the clinical record; and
- safeguards, including encryption, access controls and deletion of raw audio.
Custodians should run a privacy impact assessment before deployment, review vendor terms carefully, and provide patients with clear information. See our insight on software as a medical device.
Safeguards, logging and snooping
Health privacy statutes require custodians to take reasonable steps to protect personal health information against theft, loss and unauthorized use or disclosure. Unauthorized access by employees, often called snooping, is a recurring source of breaches in hospitals and clinics. Effective controls include role-based access, audit logging and proactive log review, confidentiality agreements, training and prompt discipline; see our cybersecurity practice. PHIPA makes wilful collection, use or disclosure in contravention of the Act an offence.
Breach reporting to commissioners
Under PHIPA subsection 12(2), if personal health information in a custodian's custody or control is stolen, lost or used or disclosed without authority, the custodian must notify the individual at the first reasonable opportunity and tell them they may complain to the Commissioner. Under subsection 12(3), the custodian must also notify the Commissioner where the circumstances meet requirements prescribed by regulation.
Under section 60.1 of Alberta's HIA, an affiliate must notify the custodian as soon as practicable of any loss of, or unauthorized access to or disclosure of, individually identifying health information. The custodian must then, as soon as practicable, notify the Commissioner, the Minister and the affected individual if there is a risk of harm, considering all relevant factors including those prescribed by regulation. A custodian may decide not to notify an individual where notice could reasonably be expected to harm the individual's mental or physical health, but must then notify the Commissioner of that decision and its reasons.
Penalties and enforcement
PHIPA has some of the strongest enforcement tools of any Canadian privacy law. The Information and Privacy Commissioner can investigate and make orders.
It can also, under section 61.1, issue administrative penalties to encourage compliance or prevent a person from benefiting from a contravention, with amounts determined under the regulations. Under section 72, offences such as wilfully collecting, using or disclosing personal health information in contravention of the Act carry fines of up to $200,000 or up to one year of imprisonment, or both, for individuals and up to $1,000,000 for organizations. Alberta's HIA also contains offences and penalties, and the Alberta Commissioner can order a custodian to notify individuals.
Contracts with vendors and agents
Custodians rely on electronic medical record vendors, cloud hosting providers, transcription and AI services, billing services and IT support. Agreements should define the vendor's status, limit its use of personal health information to the services, set safeguards and logging requirements, require prompt notice of incidents so the custodian can meet its notification duties, address data location and retention, and provide for return or destruction at the end of the relationship. Alberta's HIA requires custodians to enter into a written agreement with an information manager in accordance with the regulations. See our insight on service provider agreements.
Patient access and correction rights
Patients have a statutory right to access records of their health information, subject to limited exceptions, and to request corrections. Under PHIPA, a custodian must respond to an access request as soon as possible in the circumstances and no later than 30 days after receiving it. It may extend that period once, by up to 30 more days, where meeting the deadline would unreasonably interfere with its operations or where consultations are needed, and it must give the patient written notice of the extension and the reasons. Correction requests must also be answered within 30 days.
Custodians should have a clear intake process, templates for responses, and a way to search all systems where records are kept, including those hosted by vendors. Patient portals can satisfy many requests efficiently, but they do not replace the formal statutory process when a patient invokes it.
Research and secondary use
Health data is valuable for research, quality improvement and health system planning. Both PHIPA and the HIA permit some disclosures for research subject to conditions, including research ethics board approval of a research plan and agreements with researchers. Commercial secondary uses, such as product development or analytics by vendors, require careful analysis: de-identification standards, contractual limits and, where required, consent.
For digital health companies
Start-ups and technology companies entering the health sector need to determine early whether they will act for custodians, as agents, affiliates or information managers, or offer services directly to consumers under general privacy law. The answer shapes consent models, contracts, data residency expectations and breach duties. Many hospital and clinic customers will require privacy impact assessments, security certifications and Canadian data residency as conditions of procurement.
A compliance checklist for personal health information
- Identify the applicable statute for each data flow and each party's role.
- Document consent models, including implied consent for health care and express consent for other uses.
- Implement role-based access, audit logging and proactive monitoring.
- Run privacy impact assessments for new systems, including AI scribes and portals.
- Put compliant agreements in place with agents, affiliates and information managers.
- Prepare breach procedures that meet provincial notification rules and timelines.
- Train staff and enforce consequences for unauthorized access.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise health care organizations, digital health companies and their vendors on PHIPA, the HIA and other health privacy laws. Our work includes role and applicability analysis, privacy impact assessments for AI scribes and digital tools, agent and information manager agreements, breach response and commissioner reporting, and responses to investigations. See our privacy and data protection page or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What is the circle of care?
A practical term, not defined in PHIPA, describing custodians that provide or assist in providing health care to an individual. PHIPA subsection 20(2) allows certain custodians in that context to assume implied consent unless the individual has expressly withheld or withdrawn it.
Is a software vendor bound by PHIPA?
Vendors acting on behalf of a custodian are generally agents and may only handle personal health information as the custodian permits and PHIPA allows. Some providers have additional obligations under the regulations.
When must an Ontario custodian report a breach?
It must notify affected individuals at the first reasonable opportunity after theft, loss or unauthorized use or disclosure, and notify the Commissioner where the prescribed circumstances are met.
What does Alberta's HIA require after a breach?
Affiliates must notify the custodian as soon as practicable. If there is a risk of harm, the custodian must notify the Commissioner, the Minister and the affected individual.
Can we use an AI scribe?
Possibly, but custodians should complete a privacy impact assessment, inform patients, confirm the vendor's role and data practices, restrict training on patient data and ensure clinician review of drafts.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


