Private Company Governance: Boards, Records and Informal Risk
Private company governance in owner-managed Canadian companies often lives in handshakes rather than minute books. This guide explains the records and resolutions the CBCA requires, how courts treat informal arrangements and undocumented equity promises, oppression exposure, and when to add independent directors.

Key takeaways
- The CBCA requires specific records, including registers and minutes, kept in Canada.
- Written resolutions are valid only if signed by all directors or shareholders entitled to vote.
- Informal promises can shape shareholders' reasonable expectations in oppression claims.
- Mennillo, 2016 SCC 51, shows records matter, but so do the facts behind them.
- Independent directors help at key moments: investment, debt, succession or founder conflict.
Why private company governance matters
Private company governance is often treated as paperwork: an annual resolution signed in a hurry, a minute book updated before a financing. In owner-managed Canadian companies, the real decisions happen in conversations, emails and handshakes. That works until something changes: a founder leaves, a family relationship breaks down, an investor arrives, a lender asks questions, or a buyer starts due diligence. At that point, informal arrangements are tested against the corporate records and the governing statute, and the gaps become disputes.

Good private company governance is not about copying public company practice. It is about doing the small number of things the statute requires, documenting the decisions that matter, and making sure that what the shareholders believe about their rights matches what the documents say. This guide uses the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) as its reference point; provincial statutes impose broadly similar obligations.
Minute books, registers and resolutions
Under s. 20(1) of the CBCA, a corporation must keep, at its registered office or another place in Canada designated by the directors, its articles and by-laws and any unanimous shareholder agreement, minutes of meetings and resolutions of shareholders, copies of director notices, and a securities register. It must also keep adequate accounting records and minutes of directors' meetings and resolutions (s. 20(2)). Federal corporations must additionally maintain a register of individuals with significant control and, since January 2024, file ISC information with Corporations Canada, as the Corporations Canada ISC page explains.
Most private companies act by written resolution rather than meetings. A resolution in writing signed by all directors entitled to vote is as valid as if passed at a meeting (s. 117(1)), and a written resolution signed by all shareholders entitled to vote is valid as a shareholders' resolution, with a written resolution dealing with all matters required at an annual meeting satisfying the annual meeting requirement (s. 142(1)). The key word is "all": a resolution missing one signature is not a valid written resolution.
| Annual task | Who acts | CBCA reference |
|---|---|---|
| Approve financial statements | Directors; placed before shareholders | ss. 155, 158 |
| Annual meeting or written resolution in lieu | Shareholders | ss. 133, 142 |
| Elect directors | Shareholders | s. 106 |
| Appoint auditor or resolve not to appoint (non-distributing, unanimous) | Shareholders | ss. 162, 163 |
| Review ISC register and file | Corporation | ss. 21.1, 21.21 |
| File annual return | Corporation | Corporations Canada |
Directors must call an annual meeting not later than 18 months after incorporation and then not later than 15 months after the last annual meeting and no later than six months after the end of the preceding financial year (s. 133(1)). Shareholders of a non-distributing corporation may resolve not to appoint an auditor, but only with the consent of all shareholders, including those not otherwise entitled to vote, and only until the next annual meeting (s. 163).
Director elections and who really runs the company
In many private companies, the people who make decisions are not the people listed as directors. A founder may have stepped off the board for personal reasons but still controls strategy; a spouse may be a director in name only; an investor may have informal approval rights. Each mismatch creates risk. Directors carry statutory duties and liabilities regardless of their actual involvement, while people who control decisions without being directors may be treated as de facto directors or, in some contexts, as individuals with significant control.
Private company governance should therefore start with an honest map: who are the directors and officers of record, who makes which decisions in practice, and whether the two match. Where they do not, the options are to change the board, to formalize decision-making in a unanimous shareholder agreement, or to document delegations and approval processes so that responsibility is clear.
Informal side arrangements and undocumented equity promises
Two kinds of informal arrangement cause most disputes. The first is the side agreement: a promise between shareholders about dividends, employment, buy-outs or decision-making that never made it into the articles or a shareholders' agreement. The second is the undocumented equity promise: an early employee or adviser was told they would "get 5%", but no shares or options were ever issued.
Courts deal with these in different ways. A clear promise supported by consideration may be enforced as a contract. Even where a contract cannot be proved, the promise may shape the "reasonable expectations" of a shareholder in an oppression claim. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the Supreme Court explained that the oppression remedy protects reasonable expectations, assessed objectively in light of factors such as commercial practice, the nature of the corporation, the relationship between the parties and past practice. Informal arrangements in a small company can therefore matter more than the formal documents suggest.
The opposite can also be true. In Mennillo v. Intramodal inc., 2016 SCC 51, a co-founder argued that he had been oppressed because his shares were transferred without the corporate formalities being observed. The Supreme Court held that the claim failed: on the trial judge's findings he had wanted to stop being a shareholder, so he could have no reasonable expectation of being treated as one. The corporation's failure was in not observing formalities when carrying out his own wishes, not in acting oppressively. The case shows both the risk of poor records and the importance of the facts behind them.
Run an annual "promises audit": ask the founders and managers whether anyone has been promised equity, a bonus tied to a sale, a board seat or a buy-out right. Either document each promise properly or confirm in writing that it does not exist. Undocumented promises surface most often during a sale, when they are most expensive to resolve.
Oppression exposure in private companies
Section 241 of the CBCA allows a court to make any interim or final order it thinks fit where an act or omission of the corporation effects a result, its business or affairs have been carried on, or the directors' powers have been exercised, in a manner that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to or that unfairly disregards the interests of a security holder, creditor, director or officer. In private companies, typical triggers include:
- excluding a minority shareholder from management or information after a falling-out;
- paying excessive compensation to controlling shareholders instead of dividends;
- issuing shares to dilute a minority without a legitimate business purpose;
- diverting opportunities to another company owned by the majority;
- refusing to honour an informal buy-out arrangement.
The remedy is flexible: courts can order a buy-out, set aside transactions, regulate the company's affairs, or in some cases make orders against directors personally. Private company governance that documents decisions, gives minority holders appropriate information and avoids self-dealing reduces the risk of a claim and improves the company's position if one is brought.
When to add independent directors
Few private companies need a majority-independent board, but many benefit from one or two independent directors at the right moment. Common triggers include a first institutional investor, significant debt financing, preparation for sale or succession, a family business moving to the next generation, and persistent disagreement among founders. An independent director can chair the board, lead conflict decisions, and bring discipline to budgeting and risk management.
- Define the role: advisory board member or full director with fiduciary duties and liabilities.
- Confirm D&O insurance and indemnification are in place before the appointment.
- Agree information flows, meeting frequency and the matters the board will decide.
- Set compensation and term, and review performance annually.
Advisory boards are a useful halfway house. Their members do not have statutory director duties, but they also have no power to bind the company, and the line between advising and directing should be kept clear.
Private company governance as the business grows
Governance needs change with the business. A two-founder start-up can run on a shareholders' agreement and annual written resolutions. A company with outside investors, a growing management team and bank debt needs more: regular board meetings with an agenda and pre-read materials, an approved budget, delegations of authority that say who can sign which contracts, and a process for approving related-party transactions.
| Stage | Typical governance features |
|---|---|
| Founders only | USA or shareholders' agreement, annual written resolutions, simple cap table |
| Early outside capital | Investor director or observer, information rights, option plan, protective provisions |
| Bank debt and growth | Quarterly board meetings, budget approval, delegation of authority, covenant compliance reporting |
| Pre-sale or succession | Independent director or chair, clean minute book, documented policies, data room readiness |
Each step up should be deliberate. Adding formality for its own sake wastes management time, but failing to adjust governance as the company grows leaves directors exposed and makes the next transaction harder. A short annual review of the board's composition, meeting rhythm and key policies is usually enough to keep pace.
Conflicts of interest deserve particular attention in owner-managed companies, where directors often have business dealings with the corporation. Section 120 of the CBCA requires directors and officers to disclose, in writing or by entry in the minutes, the nature and extent of their interest in material contracts or transactions with the corporation, and restricts their participation in the vote. Recording those disclosures in the minutes protects both the director and the validity of the transaction. Where every director is conflicted, shareholder approval may be the safer route.
Private company governance checklist
- Minute book complete: articles, by-laws, registers, resolutions and USA in one place.
- Securities register matches the cap table and option ledger.
- Annual resolutions signed by every director and shareholder entitled to vote.
- ISC register reviewed and filed on time.
- Shareholders' agreement or USA reflects current ownership and expectations.
- Equity promises documented or expressly withdrawn.
- Related-party transactions approved and disclosed under the statute.
- Directors' remittance controls for payroll and sales tax in place.
Illustration (hypothetical): Three founders run a CBCA software company. Only two sign the annual written resolutions because the third has moved abroad. Years later, during a sale, the buyer discovers that several years of director elections and financial statement approvals were never validly passed, and that an early employee was promised 3% of the company in an email. Rectifying the records, ratifying past acts and settling the employee's claim delays closing by two months and reduces the price.
How TRW & Co helps
We help owner-managed and family companies strengthen private company governance: reviewing and rectifying minute books, preparing annual resolutions, drafting shareholders' agreements and USAs, documenting equity promises and option plans, maintaining ISC registers, and advising boards on adding independent directors. When disputes arise, we advise on oppression risk and settlement strategy, working with Canadian counsel where a provincial licence is required. See also corporate governance and corporate structuring, and our insights on unanimous shareholder agreements, the oppression remedy and minority investor protections. To review your governance, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Does a private company have to hold an annual meeting?
Under the CBCA, directors must call annual meetings within the statutory time limits, but a written resolution signed by all shareholders entitled to vote that deals with all matters required at an annual meeting satisfies the requirement. Most private companies use this route.
Can a private company skip the audit?
Under s. 163 CBCA, shareholders of a non-distributing corporation may resolve not to appoint an auditor, but only if all shareholders consent, including those whose shares do not otherwise carry voting rights, and the resolution lasts only until the next annual meeting.
Are verbal equity promises enforceable?
Sometimes. A clear promise supported by consideration may be enforced as a contract, and even an unenforceable promise can influence a shareholder's reasonable expectations in an oppression claim. Companies should document or expressly withdraw any equity promises before a financing or sale.
What is the risk of poor minute books?
Invalid resolutions, unclear share ownership and disputes over who are the directors and shareholders. Problems usually surface in due diligence for a financing or sale, when rectification and ratification are slower and more expensive than routine maintenance would have been.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


