Skip to content
Competition & Foreign Investment

Substantiating Environmental Claims Under the Competition Act

Environmental claims substantiation rules in Canada require adequate and proper testing for product claims and adequate and proper substantiation for business-level claims. In 2026, Parliament removed the internationally recognized methodology requirement and excluded business-level claims from private access, and the Bureau issued updated guidance. This note explains what businesses must do now.

Sustainability report and product label reviewed for environmental claims substantiation in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Product environmental claims must rest on an adequate and proper test (s. 74.01(1)(b.1)).
  • Business-level claims need adequate and proper substantiation (s. 74.01(1)(b.2)).
  • The 2026 amendments removed the internationally recognized methodology requirement.
  • Private applicants cannot bring cases based on s. 74.01(1)(b.2).
  • The Bureau's updated guidance of 23 October 2026 sets out six compliance principles.

Environmental claims substantiation rules in 2026

Canada's environmental claims substantiation rules are set out in the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act. Since the June 2024 amendments, two specific requirements apply on top of the general prohibition on false or misleading representations. Under s. 74.01(1)(b.1), a statement, warranty or guarantee about a product's benefits for protecting or restoring the environment or mitigating the environmental, social and ecological causes or effects of climate change must be based on an adequate and proper test.

Sustainability report and product label reviewed for environmental claims substantiation in Canada
Environmental claims substantiation in Canada requires adequate and proper testing for product claims and adequate and proper substantiation for business-level claims.

Under s. 74.01(1)(b.2), a representation about the benefits of a business or business activity for protecting or restoring the environment or mitigating the environmental and ecological causes or effects of climate change must be based on adequate and proper substantiation. In both cases, the proof lies on the person making the claim.

The rules changed again in 2026. The Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, which received royal assent on 26 March 2026, removed the requirement that business-level claims be substantiated "in accordance with internationally recognized methodology", excluded s. 74.01(1)(b.2) from private applications to the Competition Tribunal and barred the Tribunal from considering leave applications based on it. The Competition Bureau published updated guidance, Environmental claims and the Competition Act, dated 23 October 2026, replacing its June 2025 guidance.

What the 2026 changes mean in practice

The former wording left businesses to work out which "internationally recognized methodology" would satisfy the Bureau or a court, a question the statute did not answer and that was never settled by the Tribunal before the requirement was removed. Under the amended text, a business can choose a substantiation approach suited to its claim, provided the substantiation is adequate and proper. Recognized standards and verification remain useful evidence, and many businesses will continue to use them, but they are no longer a statutory precondition.

The exclusion of business-level claims from private access means that only the Commissioner can bring civil proceedings based on s. 74.01(1)(b.2). Product claims, and any environmental claim that is false or misleading under the general provision, remain open to private applicants with public interest leave. Businesses should therefore not read the 2026 amendments as a general relaxation: product claims are untouched, the burden of proof still lies on the business, and the penalties are unchanged.

Product claims: adequate and proper testing

Claims about a product's environmental benefits, such as "recyclable", "compostable", "lower emissions", "plastic-free" or "uses 30% less energy", must be supported by an adequate and proper test conducted before the claim is made. What counts as adequate and proper depends on the claim: the test must be relevant to the specific benefit claimed, reflect the conditions under which consumers will use the product, and produce results that support the general impression the claim creates. A recyclability claim, for example, may need evidence not only that the material is technically recyclable but that recycling facilities accepting it are available to the consumers to whom it is marketed.

The Bureau's updated guidance sets out six principles: claims should be truthful and not false or misleading; environmental benefits of products and performance claims should be adequately and properly tested; comparative claims should be specific about what is compared; claims should avoid exaggeration; claims should be clear and specific rather than vague; and claims about the future should be supported by substantiation and a clear plan.

Type of claimStatutory standardPrivate access?
Product environmental benefit (s. 74.01(1)(b.1))Adequate and proper testYes, with public interest leave
Business or business activity benefit (s. 74.01(1)(b.2))Adequate and proper substantiation (methodology wording removed in 2026)No (ss. 74.01(1.01), 103.1(6.2))
Any environmental claim that is false or misleading (s. 74.01(1)(a))General impression testYes, with public interest leave
Knowing or reckless false claims (s. 52)Criminal standardCivil damages under s. 36

Business-level claims: adequate and proper substantiation

Business-level claims include statements about a company's operations, strategy or targets, such as "we are carbon neutral", "our operations are powered by renewable energy" or "we are committed to net-zero by 2050". These require adequate and proper substantiation. After the 2026 amendments, the statute no longer specifies that substantiation must follow an internationally recognized methodology, which gives businesses more flexibility in choosing how to support their claims. It does not lower the bar to nothing: the substantiation must still be adequate and proper for the claim actually made, and the general prohibition on misleading claims in s. 74.01(1)(a) continues to apply.

Future-oriented claims are the area of greatest risk. The Bureau's guidance explains that claims about future environmental performance, such as being carbon-neutral by a certain date, should be supported by substantiation and a clear plan. A target announced without an implementation plan, interim milestones, resources and a way to measure progress is vulnerable to challenge. Claims relying on carbon offsets should explain the role offsets play and be supported by evidence of the offsets' quality.

Net-zero and carbon-neutral claims

Net-zero and carbon-neutral claims combine every difficult element of environmental claims substantiation: future performance, measurement across complex operations and value chains, and reliance on offsets or removals. Businesses making such claims should be able to show the scope of emissions covered, the baseline, the reduction pathway with interim targets, the investments committed, the governance overseeing the plan, and how any residual emissions will be addressed. They should avoid unqualified statements where the claim applies only to part of the business or depends on uncertain future technologies. Where the claim is in a regulatory filing, securities law disclosure obligations may also apply.

Practical point

Build a substantiation file before publishing any environmental claim: the exact wording, the general impression it creates, the tests or data supporting it, who reviewed it and when it will be re-validated. If you cannot assemble the file, revise or withdraw the claim. The burden of proof is on the business, not the Bureau.

Common problem claims and how to fix them

Certain claims cause trouble repeatedly. Vague terms such as "eco-friendly", "green", "sustainable" or "natural" create a broad general impression of environmental benefit that is difficult to test or substantiate; the safer course is to replace them with specific, supported statements about what the benefit is and how it was measured. Claims that a product is "recyclable" or "compostable" need evidence that the product can actually be processed through facilities available to consumers in the markets where it is sold, not just in laboratory conditions. Claims of "zero waste", "carbon negative" or "climate positive" are especially demanding because they suggest an absolute outcome.

Comparative claims, such as "50% less plastic", must make clear what is being compared: the previous version of the product, a competitor's product or an industry average, and over what period. Claims based on certifications or eco-labels should identify the certifying body and what the certification actually covers, and should not imply a broader endorsement. Images matter too: pictures of forests, leaves or the globe can contribute to a general impression of environmental benefit that the business must be able to support. Effective environmental claims substantiation therefore starts with the wording and imagery, not just the underlying data.

Governance for environmental claims substantiation

Because environmental claims appear in so many places, from packaging and advertising to annual reports and executive speeches, businesses need a governance process. The most effective programs designate an owner for environmental claims, require legal and technical review before publication, maintain a central register of approved claims with their substantiation, set review dates so that claims are re-validated when products, suppliers or operations change, and train marketing and communications staff on the Bureau's principles. Boards should receive periodic reports on environmental claims risk, particularly for high-profile targets such as net-zero commitments.

A good environmental claims substantiation file also helps beyond the Competition Act. It supports responses to investor questions, provides a defence to consumer complaints and class actions, and reduces the risk that a well-intended announcement becomes a reputational problem. Businesses that adopt the discipline now will be better placed if Canadian rules on sustainability disclosure become more prescriptive.

Enforcement and penalties

The Bureau can apply to the Competition Tribunal or a court for orders under s. 74.1, including orders to stop making the claim, publish corrective notices, pay restitution and pay administrative monetary penalties. For corporations, the maximum penalty is the greater of CAD 10 million (CAD 15 million for subsequent orders) and three times the value of the benefit derived from the deceptive conduct, or, if that cannot reasonably be determined, 3% of annual worldwide gross revenues.

Knowingly or recklessly false claims can also be prosecuted under s. 52. Private parties can seek leave in the public interest to bring applications about product claims and other misleading environmental representations, but not about business-level claims under s. 74.01(1)(b.2).

Interaction with securities, consumer and labelling laws

Environmental claims often appear in sustainability reports, investor presentations and regulatory filings as well as in advertising. Securities law requires material climate risks to be disclosed and prohibits misrepresentations, and provincial consumer protection statutes prohibit misleading representations to consumers. Specific labelling rules may also apply to products. The Competition Act applies to representations made to promote a product or a business interest "by any means whatever", so investor-facing statements can be within scope. Companies should coordinate review of environmental statements across marketing, sustainability, investor relations and legal teams. See our page on environmental and climate law.

Environmental claims substantiation checklist

  1. Identify every environmental claim across advertising, packaging, websites, reports and social media.
  2. Classify each one as a product claim, business-level claim or general representation.
  3. For product claims, confirm adequate and proper testing exists before the claim is made.
  4. For business-level and future claims, confirm substantiation and a clear, resourced plan.
  5. Remove vague terms such as "eco-friendly" or "green" unless they are clearly qualified and supported.
  6. Review comparative claims for a clear and disclosed basis of comparison.
  7. Keep substantiation files and re-validate claims periodically, especially after product, supplier or operational changes.
  8. Coordinate advertising claims with sustainability reports and investor disclosure.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise companies, brands, retailers, energy and resource businesses and investors on environmental claims substantiation under the amended Competition Act. Our work includes claim audits, substantiation files, review of net-zero and carbon-neutral statements, coordination with securities disclosure, and responses to Bureau inquiries and private applications. See our pages on deceptive marketing and greenwashing and our note on Product of Canada claims. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss your claims, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What changed for environmental claims in 2026?

The Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, which received royal assent on 26 March 2026, removed the requirement that business-level environmental claims be substantiated in accordance with an internationally recognized methodology. It also made s. 74.01(1)(b.2) unavailable for private applications to the Competition Tribunal. The Bureau updated its guidance on 23 October 2026.

What is the standard for product environmental claims?

Under s. 74.01(1)(b.1), a statement, warranty or guarantee about a product's benefits for the environment or for mitigating climate change must be based on an adequate and proper test, with the burden of proof on the person making the claim. The test must be relevant to the benefit claimed and support the claim's general impression.

Can private parties challenge greenwashing?

Partly. With public interest leave, private parties can bring applications about product environmental claims and other misleading representations. They cannot bring applications based on business-level claims under s. 74.01(1)(b.2), and the Tribunal may not consider leave applications based on that paragraph.

How should a company support a net-zero claim?

With substantiation and a clear plan, as the Bureau's guidance on future claims explains: defined scope and baseline, interim targets, committed resources, governance and measurement, and transparency about any reliance on offsets. Unqualified net-zero statements without a plan are vulnerable.

Sources

  1. Competition Act, ss. 74.01, 74.1, 103.1
  2. Competition Bureau: Environmental claims and the Competition Act (23 October 2026)
  3. Competition Bureau: archived guidance (June 2025) with note on 2026 amendments
  4. Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, S.C. 2026, c. 3

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.