Equity Claims and Subordination in CCAA and BIA Proceedings
Equity claims rank behind every other claim in Canadian insolvency. The statutory definition captures dividends, redemptions, securities misrepresentation damages and related contribution or indemnity claims. This note explains CCAA s. 6(8) and BIA s. 140.1, the treatment of claims by directors, auditors and underwriters, classification and voting, and common characterization disputes.

Key takeaways
- No CCAA plan may pay equity claims unless all other claims are paid in full (s. 6(8)).
- Under BIA s. 140.1, equity claimants get no dividend until other claims are satisfied.
- Securities misrepresentation damages are equity claims as losses from buying shares.
- Contribution and indemnity claims in respect of equity claims are also subordinated.
- Equity claimants form one class and do not vote unless the court orders otherwise (s. 22.1).
Why equity claims rank last
In Canadian insolvency law, equity claims rank behind every other claim. Under amendments enacted in 2005 and 2007, the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) provides that a court may not sanction a plan that pays an equity claim unless all claims that are not equity claims are paid in full first (s. 6(8)), and the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) provides that a creditor with an equity claim receives no dividend until all other claims are satisfied (s. 140.1).

The rule reflects a basic principle of corporate finance: shareholders take the residual risk and reward of the business, so they should not compete with creditors when the business fails. What makes the rule powerful in practice is the breadth of the definition, which captures not just shareholders' claims for dividends or return of capital but also damages claims for securities misrepresentation and related indemnity claims.
This note explains the statutory definition, how it applies to securities class actions and to indemnity claims by directors, officers, auditors and underwriters, how equity claims are classified and voted in plans, and what investors and professionals can do to manage the risk.
The statutory definition of equity claim
Both statutes use the same definitions. An "equity claim" is a claim in respect of an equity interest, including a claim for, among others:
- a dividend or similar payment;
- a return of capital;
- a redemption or retraction obligation;
- a monetary loss resulting from the ownership, purchase or sale of an equity interest, or from the rescission (in Quebec, annulment) of a purchase or sale of an equity interest; or
- contribution or indemnity in respect of any of those claims.
An "equity interest" is a share in the company, or a warrant, option or other right to acquire a share, other than one derived from convertible debt; for income trusts, a unit or a right to acquire one. Holders of convertible debentures therefore remain creditors for the debt, even though their conversion right relates to shares.
| Claim | Equity claim? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Unpaid declared dividend | Yes | Para. (a): dividend or similar payment |
| Redemption price for retractable preferred shares | Yes | Para. (c): redemption or retraction obligation |
| Shareholder's damages for prospectus or secondary market misrepresentation | Yes | Para. (d): monetary loss from purchase of an equity interest |
| Auditor's or underwriter's indemnity claim for those damages | Generally yes | Para. (e): contribution or indemnity in respect of (a)–(d) claims |
| Convertible debenture principal and interest | No | Rights derived from convertible debt are excluded from "equity interest" |
| Employee's claim for unpaid salary | No | Not in respect of an equity interest, even if the employee is a shareholder |
Securities misrepresentation claims
The most consequential application of the definition is to securities class actions. Shareholders who bought shares in reliance on misleading disclosure may sue the company under provincial securities statutes for primary or secondary market misrepresentation, or in negligence and contract. If the company then files for CCAA protection, their claims against the company are "monetary loss resulting from the ownership, purchase or sale of an equity interest" and are therefore equity claims. They rank behind trade creditors, lenders and bondholders and, in most insolvent restructurings, recover nothing from the company.
That outcome is not affected by the merits of the claim. The Supreme Court of Canada's 2025 decision in Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich (2025 SCC 39), which gave a broad reading to "material change" in secondary market disclosure claims, may make such claims easier to pursue against solvent issuers, but it does not change their subordination if the issuer is insolvent. Investors' practical recourse in an insolvency is usually against other defendants, such as directors, officers, auditors and underwriters, and against insurance.
Timing affects the size of that recourse. Statutory secondary market liability regimes in provincial securities laws cap damages for some defendants and require leave of the court to proceed, so plaintiffs often need to move quickly to preserve claims while the issuer's restructuring unfolds. Insurance towers may also be shared among the issuer, its directors and officers, which makes early negotiation over the allocation of policy limits an important part of any global resolution. Plaintiffs who wait until a plan is filed may find that the available insurance has already been reduced by defence costs.
Indemnity claims by directors, auditors and underwriters
Securities plaintiffs routinely sue individual directors and officers, auditors and underwriters alongside the issuer. Those defendants then claim contribution or indemnity from the issuer, under indemnity agreements, underwriting agreements or the law of contribution. Paragraph (e) of the definition subordinates contribution and indemnity claims "in respect of" equity claims. Ontario appellate authority arising from a major securities fraud restructuring has applied that paragraph to auditors' and underwriters' indemnity claims connected to shareholder misrepresentation claims, treating them as equity claims even though the auditors and underwriters were never shareholders.
The result is that professionals sued by shareholders cannot shift that loss onto the insolvent issuer's creditors. For directors and officers, the practical protection lies in D&O insurance and, during a CCAA proceeding, the court-ordered D&O charge, which covers post-filing obligations rather than pre-filing securities claims. For auditors and underwriters, it lies in their own insurance and in the terms of any global settlement negotiated in the restructuring.
Classification and voting of equity claims in plans
Section 22.1 of the CCAA provides that creditors with equity claims are to be in the same class in relation to those claims, unless the court orders otherwise, and may not vote at any meeting unless the court orders otherwise. In practice, equity claimants usually do not vote, and plans release or extinguish equity claims against the company because there is no value available for them.
Plans in securities fraud restructurings often go further, establishing settlement frameworks that channel claims against third parties (directors, auditors, underwriters) into court-approved settlements funded by those parties and their insurers, combined with releases. Courts approve such frameworks where the releases are connected to the restructuring, the settlements are fair and reasonable, and class members have notice and an opportunity to object, often with coordination between the CCAA court and the class action court.
Shareholder plaintiffs should name and preserve claims against solvent defendants and insurers early, because the issuer's insolvency will leave their claim against it subordinated. Professionals and directors should check that their insurance responds to securities claims and that policy limits are not eroded by the issuer's own defence costs.
Equity claims in practice: characterization disputes
Characterization disputes arise at the edges of the definition. Examples include claims under share purchase agreements where a vendor sold shares to the company and was to be paid over time, claims by holders of shares with fixed redemption dates, earn-out payments to former shareholders, and claims by employees for equity-based compensation. Courts look at the substance of the claim: whether it arises from the claimant's position as an investor in the company's equity, or from a separate debtor-creditor relationship. A promissory note issued for the purchase of shares may be treated differently from an unpaid retraction price on shares still held, depending on the facts.
For investors structuring hybrid instruments, the line between debt and equity is therefore critical. Preferred shares, even with mandatory redemption, will usually generate equity claims; subordinated debt, even if deeply junior, will usually not. Our note on CBCA restructurings explains how equity is treated in solvent arrangements, where shareholders may still vote.
Subordination in bankruptcy, receivership and proposals
The same subordination applies outside the CCAA. In a bankruptcy, s. 140.1 of the BIA means the trustee pays secured creditors, preferred claims and ordinary unsecured claims before any dividend on a shareholder's damages claim or redemption claim. In BIA proposals, s. 60(1.7) contains a parallel rule: no proposal that provides for payment of an equity claim may be approved unless all claims that are not equity claims are to be paid in full first, and shareholders' claims are classed separately from those of ordinary creditors. Receiverships typically end with a distribution under court order or a bankruptcy, so the same ranking applies in substance.
The practical question in each forum is timing. Shareholder plaintiffs often have certified class actions under way when the issuer becomes insolvent. The stay of proceedings stops the action against the issuer, and the claims process requires class members, often through class counsel, to prove their claims. Because those claims will be subordinated, class counsel usually focus on resolving claims against co-defendants within the insolvency process, where a global settlement can bind all class members through a combination of the class action settlement approval and the plan or court order.
Courts have also had to decide whether claims by former shareholders who sold their shares to the company in exchange for a promissory note are "in respect of an equity interest". The answer depends on the terms and timing: a completed sale that left the vendor as an ordinary creditor may produce a debt claim, while an unpaid redemption or retraction obligation on shares the holder still owns is a classic equity claim.
Structuring capital with subordination in mind
Investors in growth companies and private equity portfolio companies often use instruments that sit between debt and equity: preferred shares with redemption rights, shareholder loans, convertible notes, warrants and earn-outs. The insolvency outcome for each depends on its legal form. Preferred shares, however debt-like their economics, generate equity claims; a properly documented shareholder loan or convertible note generates a debt claim, subject to the preference and transfer-at-undervalue rules if it is repaid or secured shortly before an insolvency.
Investors who want creditor status should therefore lend rather than subscribe, document the loan on arm's-length terms, and consider security registered in the ordinary way. Those who choose preferred shares for tax or governance reasons should accept that, in an insolvency, they will rank with common shareholders behind every creditor. Directors approving redemptions or dividends should also remember the solvency tests in corporate law and the personal liability that can follow if those tests are not met.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise creditors, investors, directors, auditors' and underwriters' counsel teams and plan sponsors on equity claims in CCAA and BIA proceedings. Our work includes characterization of claims and instruments, classification and voting strategy, global settlements of securities claims with releases, and structuring hybrid capital to reflect intended priority. We coordinate with Canadian securities and class action counsel where needed. See our pages on CCAA restructuring and securities litigation, and our note on directors' duties in the zone of insolvency. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss an equity claims issue, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What is an equity claim?
Under the CCAA and BIA, it is a claim in respect of an equity interest, including claims for dividends, return of capital, redemption or retraction obligations, monetary loss from owning, buying or selling shares or rescinding such a purchase, and contribution or indemnity in respect of any of those claims. Rights derived from convertible debt are excluded.
Are securities class action claims against an insolvent issuer equity claims?
Yes. Claims for losses from buying shares in reliance on misrepresentations are monetary losses resulting from the purchase of an equity interest. They rank behind all other claims, so in most insolvent restructurings they recover nothing from the issuer. Claimants usually look to directors, auditors, underwriters and insurers.
Can an auditor claim indemnity from the insolvent issuer?
Contribution or indemnity claims in respect of equity claims are themselves equity claims. Ontario appellate authority has applied this to auditors' and underwriters' indemnity claims tied to shareholder misrepresentation claims, so those claims are subordinated to creditors' claims.
Do equity claimants vote on a CCAA plan?
Under s. 22.1 of the CCAA, creditors with equity claims are placed in a single class for those claims unless the court orders otherwise, and they may not vote unless the court orders otherwise. Plans commonly extinguish equity claims against the company where no value is available.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


