Skip to content
Restructuring & Insolvency

Forbearance Agreements and Out-of-Court Workouts in Canada

Forbearance agreements give a distressed borrower time while improving the lender's position. They typically include acknowledgments of debt and default, releases, consent to early enforcement and receivership, milestones and fees. This note explains each term under Canadian law, the limits set by the BIA and the Interest Act, and when a workout beats a formal proceeding.

Lender and borrower negotiating forbearance agreements during a Canadian workout

Key takeaways

  • Acknowledgments of debt, default and security reduce later disputes and can restart limitation periods.
  • Consent to early enforcement cannot be obtained before the BIA s. 244 notice is sent.
  • Consent receivership orders speed enforcement but the court still decides.
  • Interest Act s. 8 limits default rates on mortgage arrears.
  • Workouts suit simple capital structures; formal proceedings bind holdouts and allow priming DIPs.

What forbearance agreements do

Forbearance agreements are standstills: a lender agrees not to enforce its rights for a defined period despite existing defaults, and the borrower agrees to conditions that improve the lender's position while the parties work toward a solution. They are the most common first step in a Canadian workout. A well-drafted forbearance gives a viable business time to refinance, sell assets or recapitalize without the cost and publicity of a formal insolvency proceeding. It also gives the lender acknowledgments, information, fees and, often, pre-agreed enforcement rights if the plan fails. Because forbearance agreements shift leverage significantly, borrowers, guarantors and other creditors need to understand what they are signing.

Lender and borrower negotiating forbearance agreements during a Canadian workout
Forbearance agreements trade lender patience for acknowledgments, milestones, fees and stronger enforcement rights.

This note covers the standard terms of forbearance agreements in Canada: acknowledgments of debt and default, releases, consent to receivership and early enforcement, milestones, fees and interest, and the strategic question of when an out-of-court workout is better than a formal proceeding under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) or the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA).

Acknowledgments of debt and default

Almost every forbearance agreement begins with acknowledgments. The borrower and guarantors confirm the amount owing, that specified events of default have occurred and are continuing, that the lender's security is valid, enforceable and properly perfected, and that they have no defences, set-off or counterclaims. These acknowledgments are valuable to the lender: they reduce the scope for later disputes over the debt, the default and the security, and they can restart or extend limitation periods under provincial limitations legislation.

Borrowers and guarantors should review the acknowledgments carefully. Agreeing that the security is valid and enforceable may waive arguments about defective registrations or missing guarantees that could matter in a later insolvency. Where there are genuine disputes, the borrower should carve them out or negotiate a mutual reservation of rights rather than sign a blanket acknowledgment.

Releases

Lenders usually require a release from the borrower and guarantors of claims against the lender relating to the loan and its administration up to the date of the agreement. The release protects the lender from lender-liability claims, such as allegations that it acted in bad faith, gave insufficient notice or interfered with the business. Borrowers sometimes negotiate for a mutual release or to exclude specific known claims, but in a distressed situation the lender usually holds the leverage. In a later insolvency, a trustee or monitor may scrutinize releases given by an insolvent borrower shortly before filing, particularly if they released valuable claims for no consideration.

Many forbearance agreements include the borrower's consent to the appointment of a receiver, and a draft consent receivership order, to be used if the forbearance terminates. Lenders also seek to shorten or eliminate the ten-day waiting period that applies after a notice of intention to enforce security under s. 244 of the BIA. The statute limits that strategy in one important respect: consent to earlier enforcement may not be obtained before the s. 244 notice is sent (s. 244(2.1)). Lenders therefore commonly deliver the s. 244 notice at the time the forbearance agreement is signed, and the borrower then consents to early enforcement in the agreement itself.

A consent receivership order makes enforcement faster, but it does not bind the court. A judge must still be satisfied that appointing a receiver is just or convenient, and other stakeholders may oppose it. Consents are nonetheless persuasive, and courts frequently grant receiverships where the borrower agreed to one in a forbearance agreement and failed to meet its conditions.

TermLender objectiveBorrower or guarantor concern
Acknowledgment of debt and defaultAvoid later disputes; restart limitation periodsDo not waive genuine defences without need
Release of lenderEliminate lender-liability claimsMutuality; carve-outs for known claims
BIA s. 244 notice and consent to early enforcementRemove the ten-day waitConsent only after notice is sent (s. 244(2.1))
Consent receivership orderRapid enforcement if forbearance endsCourt still decides; consider CCAA alternative
MilestonesKeep process moving; define failureAchievable dates; cure periods
Fees and default interestCompensation for risk and timeInterest Act s. 8 on mortgages; criminal rate limits

Milestones, reporting and additional security

The forbearance period is usually short, often 30 to 120 days, and tied to milestones. Typical milestones include engaging a financial adviser or chief restructuring officer acceptable to the lender, delivering a 13-week cash-flow forecast and business plan, launching a refinancing or sale process by a set date, obtaining letters of intent or signed agreements by later dates, and closing by the end of the period. Missing a milestone terminates the forbearance, usually without further notice.

Lenders also commonly require weekly cash-flow reporting with variance testing, access for the lender's financial adviser, restrictions on payments to shareholders and related parties, cash dominion, and additional security or guarantees from entities that were not previously obligors. Borrowers should be aware that new security given for existing debt in the months before an insolvency can be challenged as a preference, especially if the lender is not at arm's length, so lenders often pair additional security with new money or other consideration.

Practical point

Negotiate milestones the business can actually meet, with short cure periods and a clear process for extensions. A forbearance agreement that fails on day 31 because a letter of intent arrived a week late usually leaves the borrower with less leverage than if it had never signed.

Fees and interest in forbearance agreements

Forbearance agreements usually include a forbearance fee, increased interest or default interest, and reimbursement of the lender's legal and advisory costs. Canadian law places two limits on these terms. First, for loans secured by mortgages on real property, s. 8 of the Interest Act prohibits any fine, penalty or rate of interest on arrears that increases the charge on the arrears beyond the rate payable on principal not in arrears; a default rate that applies only to arrears on a mortgage can be unenforceable.

Second, the criminal interest rate in s. 347 of the Criminal Code counts fees and charges as interest; most commercial loans over CAD 500,000 to non-individuals are exempt under the Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, but smaller facilities need care. Courts may also refuse to enforce fees that operate as penalties rather than a genuine pre-estimate of the lender's costs or compensation for additional risk, so fee clauses should explain what the fee is for and how it was calculated.

Forbearance agreements with syndicates and multiple lenders

When a borrower has a syndicate of lenders, or several layers of debt, the forbearance becomes a multi-party negotiation. Syndicated credit agreements usually allow the agent to grant waivers and forbearances with the consent of the required lenders, often a simple or two-thirds majority, but certain changes, such as extending maturity, reducing principal or releasing material collateral, need every affected lender's consent. A forbearance that is drafted as a pure standstill, without amending economic terms, is easier to approve than one that resets pricing or covenants.

Where there is senior and junior debt, the intercreditor agreement will control who can forbear and who can enforce. Junior lenders are often subject to standstill periods that begin when they give notice of default, and they may have purchase options allowing them to buy out the senior debt at par. A senior forbearance can therefore trigger strategic decisions by junior lenders, who may prefer to buy the senior position rather than wait. Equipment lessors, landlords and suppliers are not bound by a bank's forbearance, so the borrower may need separate standstill arrangements with them to avoid enforcement on another front.

Information sharing is the practical glue. Lenders in a forbearance usually require access to the borrower's financial adviser, regular lender calls and a data room for the refinancing or sale process. Borrowers should agree confidentiality terms, especially where lenders trade their positions, and should anticipate that information given to lenders may later be used in a formal proceeding.

Documents and timeline of a typical workout

A typical Canadian workout follows a familiar sequence: a reservation of rights letter from the lender after the first default; delivery of financial information and appointment of a lender-approved adviser; negotiation of a term sheet; signing of the forbearance agreement, often with the s. 244 notice and consent; a refinancing or sale process run during the forbearance period; and then either closing, an amendment and extension, or a formal proceeding. Each step generates documents that will matter later, so both sides should assume that a court may eventually read them and should write accordingly.

When out-of-court workouts beat formal proceedings

Forbearance agreements and consensual workouts work best when the capital structure is simple (one lender or a small, cooperative group), the business is fundamentally viable, trade creditors can be paid in the ordinary course, and the problem can be solved by time, an asset sale or new equity. They preserve customer and supplier confidence and avoid court costs, monitor fees and unwanted public filings in court.

Formal proceedings are better when holdout creditors must be bound, contracts or leases must be disclaimed, priming interim financing is needed, a broad stay is required to stop enforcement by multiple creditors, or a sale must be completed free and clear with a vesting order. Many workouts start with a forbearance and end in a pre-negotiated CCAA filing or receivership, with the forbearance agreement having set up the terms. Our notes on DIP financing and CBCA restructurings discuss those routes.

Guarantors, junior lenders and directors

Guarantors are usually parties to forbearance agreements and give their own acknowledgments, releases and sometimes additional collateral. They should check whether the forbearance changes the guaranteed obligations in a way that requires their consent, and whether they are waiving defences that would otherwise arise from changes to the principal debt.

Junior lenders may be bound by standstills in intercreditor agreements and need to know whether the senior lender's forbearance affects their own enforcement windows. Directors, meanwhile, must consider whether entering into the forbearance is in the corporation's best interests, given the acknowledgments and consents involved, and should document their reasons. Our note on directors' duties in the zone of insolvency covers that analysis.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise lenders, private credit funds, borrowers, sponsors and guarantors on forbearance agreements and workouts in Canada. Our work includes negotiating forbearance terms, milestones and fees, s. 244 notices and consent receivership orders, additional security and preference risk, and planning the transition to a CCAA, BIA proposal or receivership where needed. We work with Canadian litigation counsel and licensed insolvency trustees where those roles are required. See our pages on receiverships and enforcement and lending and acquisition finance. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a workout, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can a borrower waive the BIA ten-day notice period in advance?

No. Section 244(2.1) of the BIA provides that consent to earlier enforcement may not be obtained before the notice of intention to enforce security is sent. Lenders therefore usually deliver the s. 244 notice when the forbearance agreement is signed, and the borrower consents to early enforcement in the agreement.

Is a consent receivership order binding on the court?

No. The court must still be satisfied that appointing a receiver is just or convenient, and other stakeholders can oppose. In practice, a borrower's prior consent is persuasive, and courts often appoint receivers where borrowers agreed to it in a forbearance agreement and then failed to meet its conditions.

Can a lender charge default interest under a forbearance agreement?

Often yes, but with limits. For mortgages on real property, s. 8 of the Interest Act bars any penalty or rate on arrears that exceeds the rate on principal not in arrears. Fees and default interest also count toward the criminal interest rate in s. 347 of the Criminal Code, subject to the commercial loan exemptions.

What should a borrower negotiate in a forbearance agreement?

Achievable milestones with cure periods, a realistic forbearance period, limited acknowledgments that preserve genuine defences, a mutual or carved-out release, reasonable fees, and clarity on what happens at the end of the period. The borrower should also consider whether a formal proceeding would better protect the business.

Sources

  1. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, ss. 243–244
  2. Interest Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-15, s. 8
  3. Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, SOR/2024-114

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.