Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Occupational Health and Safety: Director and Officer Exposure

Occupational health and safety laws place duties on corporations and on the individuals who run them. Directors and officers can be prosecuted personally under provincial statutes and, in serious cases, under the Criminal Code. Ontario has raised maximum fines sharply, and regulators are paying more attention to psychosocial hazards such as harassment.

Safety officer and executives inspecting a site to meet occupational health and safety duties

Key takeaways

  • Every Canadian jurisdiction imposes occupational health and safety duties on employers, supervisors and workers.
  • Ontario directors and officers must take all reasonable care to ensure corporate compliance.
  • Ontario's maximum fine for a corporation is now CAD 2 million; directors and officers face up to CAD 1.5 million.
  • Criminal Code s. 217.1 imposes a legal duty on those who direct work to prevent bodily harm.
  • Workplace harassment and violence are occupational health and safety hazards with specific obligations.
  • A documented due diligence program is the main defence for corporations and individuals.

The occupational health and safety framework

Occupational health and safety is regulated mainly by the provinces and territories, each with its own statute and regulations. Federally regulated workplaces, such as banks, airlines, ports and interprovincial transport, are governed by Part II of the Canada Labour Code. All of these regimes impose an internal responsibility system: employers, supervisors and workers each have defined duties, with joint health and safety committees or representatives in larger workplaces and inspectors with powers to investigate and issue orders.

Safety officer and executives inspecting a site to meet occupational health and safety duties
Occupational health and safety duties reach the boardroom as well as the worksite.

Most occupational health and safety offences are strict liability offences. The Crown does not need to prove intent; it must prove the prohibited act, and the accused can then avoid conviction by proving due diligence on a balance of probabilities, as the Supreme Court explained in R. v. Sault Ste. Marie, [1978] 2 SCR 1299. That allocation makes the quality of a company's safety program, and the evidence of it, central to any prosecution.

Prosecutions often follow serious injuries or deaths, but inspectors also issue orders and, in some provinces, administrative penalties for non-compliance without an incident. Repeat findings and poor cooperation increase the likelihood of charges.

Sentencing principles emphasize deterrence. Courts consider the gravity of the harm, the size and resources of the corporation, prior convictions, the degree of departure from industry standards and any remedial steps taken after the incident. Large corporations should expect fines that are significant relative to their size, not nominal amounts, and individuals who were directly responsible may face jail in the worst cases.

Ontario's duties for directors and officers

Section 32 of Ontario's Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) requires every director and every officer of a corporation to take all reasonable care to ensure that the corporation complies with the Act, the regulations and orders and requirements of inspectors and directors. The duty is personal. A director who fails to take reasonable care can be convicted even if they did not know of the specific hazard, if they failed to put in place and oversee a system that would reasonably have ensured compliance.

OffenderMaximum penalty under the Ontario OHSA
CorporationFine of up to CAD 2,000,000; minimum CAD 500,000 for a second or subsequent offence causing death or serious injury within two years
Director or officer who fails to comply with s. 32Fine of up to CAD 1,500,000, imprisonment of up to 12 months, or both
Other individuals (e.g., supervisors)Fine of up to CAD 500,000, imprisonment of up to 12 months, or both

The corporate maximum was increased to CAD 2,000,000 by amendments in 2024, and the director and officer maximum to CAD 1,500,000 by amendments in 2022. Courts also impose victim fine surcharges, and repeated or aggravated offences attract higher sentences.

Who is an employer: Greater Sudbury

In R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28, the Supreme Court considered whether a city that hired a contractor to repair a water main, and sent its own inspectors to the site, was an "employer" under the Ontario OHSA when a pedestrian was killed.

The appeal was dismissed, leaving in place the Court of Appeal's conclusion that the city was an employer because it employed inspectors at the project and therefore owed the employer's duties, subject to a due diligence defence. The case confirms that owners who place their own workers at a project, even for quality control, may carry employer duties, and must rely on due diligence to defend charges. Owners, developers and municipalities should therefore structure and supervise construction projects with worker safety in mind.

Criminal liability: the Westray amendments

After the 1992 Westray mine explosion in Nova Scotia, Parliament amended the Criminal Code in 2004. Section 217.1 provides that everyone who undertakes, or has the authority, to direct how another person does work or performs a task is under a legal duty to take reasonable steps to prevent bodily harm to that person or any other person arising from that work. Breach of that duty can ground criminal negligence charges. Sections 22.1 and 22.2 set out how organizations become liable for offences committed by their "representatives" and "senior officers", making it easier to convict corporations.

In R. v. Metron Construction Corporation, 2013 ONCA 541, the Court of Appeal for Ontario increased the fine imposed on a corporation convicted of criminal negligence causing death after four workers died when a swing stage collapsed, emphasizing deterrence. Individual supervisors and project managers have also been convicted and imprisoned in other cases. Criminal prosecutions remain less common than regulatory charges but are a real risk where there is wanton or reckless disregard for safety.

Because the criminal standard requires a marked and substantial departure from what a reasonable person would do, the same facts can support both regulatory and criminal proceedings, and police and inspectors may investigate in parallel. Companies should coordinate their responses, recognizing that statements and documents provided in one process may be used in the other, and that individual employees may need separate advice when their own conduct is under scrutiny.

Practical point

Board oversight is evidence. Directors should receive regular safety reports with leading and lagging indicators, ask about serious incidents and near misses, approve the safety policy and program, and record their questions and decisions in minutes. When charges are laid, those records often decide whether a due diligence defence succeeds.

Harassment, violence and psychosocial hazards

Safety laws increasingly treat workplace harassment and violence as hazards. Ontario's OHSA requires employers to have workplace violence and harassment policies and programs, to assess risks of violence, to investigate incidents and complaints of harassment appropriately, and to inform workers of the results. Federally, the Work Place Harassment and Violence Prevention Regulations under the Canada Labour Code require workplace assessments, prevention policies, a resolution process, training and support measures. Several provinces have also addressed psychological safety more broadly. Directors' reasonable care duties extend to these programs.

Investigations of harassment complaints must be appropriate in the circumstances: impartial, timely and thorough, with results communicated to the complainant and the alleged harasser. Inspectors can order an employer to retain an independent investigator at its own expense where an internal investigation is inadequate, which is costly and reputationally damaging. A well-designed complaint process, trained investigators and clear timelines reduce that risk.

Remote work extends the scope: harassment through digital channels is workplace harassment, and employers must address it.

Occupational health and safety in other jurisdictions

Every province imposes comparable duties, with variations. Some statutes, such as those in British Columbia and Alberta, impose duties on directors and officers to ensure compliance, and many use administrative penalties alongside prosecutions. The Canada Labour Code imposes duties on federally regulated employers and has its own enforcement and penalty regime. Quebec's regime, modernized in recent years, requires prevention programs and participation mechanisms, including for psychosocial risks. National employers should map duties province by province and maintain a consistent baseline program.

Building a due diligence program

  1. Policy and leadership. A board-approved occupational health and safety policy and clear accountability at senior management level.
  2. Hazard identification. Regular risk assessments, including psychosocial risks and contractor activities.
  3. Procedures and training. Written safe work procedures, competent supervisors and documented training.
  4. Monitoring. Inspections, audits, incident and near-miss reporting, and corrective action tracking.
  5. Contractor management. Prequalification, coordination and oversight on multi-employer sites.
  6. Board reporting. Regular reports with metrics and narrative, and follow-up on actions.

After a serious incident

A fatal or critical injury triggers immediate reporting and scene-preservation duties, inspector attendance and, often, a parallel police investigation. Companies should have an incident protocol that covers notifications, cooperation with inspectors, preservation of evidence, internal investigation under legal privilege where appropriate, communications with families and employees, and support for affected workers. Statements given to inspectors can be used in prosecutions, so employees should understand their rights and obligations. Limitation periods for regulatory charges are typically one or two years from the incident or from the inspector's knowledge, depending on the statute.

Supervisors and the internal responsibility system

Many prosecutions focus on supervisors as well as corporations. A supervisor, under the Ontario OHSA, is a person who has charge of a workplace or authority over a worker, and must ensure workers comply with the Act and use required equipment, advise workers of hazards, and take every precaution reasonable in the circumstances to protect them. Supervisors must be competent, meaning qualified by knowledge, training and experience. Appointing supervisors without training, or giving them responsibility without authority, undermines the internal responsibility system and weakens the employer's defence.

Workers also have duties and rights, including the right to refuse unsafe work and protection from reprisal. Reprisal complaints can be filed with the labour relations board, and employers found to have disciplined a worker for raising safety concerns face orders and penalties. Directors should ensure that the organization's culture encourages reporting rather than discouraging it.

Contractors, constructors and multi-employer sites

Construction and industrial projects with several employers on site raise questions about who is responsible for what. Ontario's OHSA designates a "constructor" with overall responsibility on construction projects, and owners may become constructors if they retain multiple contractors without assigning that role. Greater Sudbury shows that owners who put their own staff on site can also be employers. Contracts should allocate safety roles expressly, prequalify contractors on safety performance, require site-specific safety plans, and give the owner audit and stop-work rights. The allocation does not remove statutory duties, but it supports due diligence.

Insurance and indemnities

Fines for regulatory safety offences are generally not insurable, and indemnification of directors for fines may be restricted by corporate law and public policy. Defence costs may be covered under directors' and officers' liability insurance or indemnification agreements, subject to policy terms and conduct exclusions. Directors should understand the scope of their indemnities and insurance before an incident occurs, and should confirm that coverage extends to safety investigations and prosecutions. Early notice to insurers after an incident avoids coverage disputes later.

Directors joining a board should ask specific questions: what the company's serious incident history is, whether any orders or charges are outstanding, how contractor safety is managed, and what the board receives in its regular safety reporting. Those questions are part of taking reasonable care, and the answers show where the program needs attention.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise boards, executives and safety teams on occupational health and safety governance, due diligence programs, contractor management and harassment programs, and we act on incident response, investigations and defence of regulatory and criminal charges. Our employment law and corporate governance teams work together on these mandates, and see our insights on workers' compensation and corporate criminal liability. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your program.

Frequently asked questions

Can directors be personally liable for safety violations?

Yes. In Ontario, s. 32 of the OHSA requires directors and officers to take all reasonable care to ensure corporate compliance, with fines of up to CAD 1,500,000 and up to 12 months' imprisonment. Other provinces impose similar duties, and the Criminal Code can apply in serious cases.

What are Ontario's maximum OHSA fines?

For a corporation, up to CAD 2,000,000, with a minimum of CAD 500,000 for a second or subsequent offence causing death or serious injury within two years. Directors and officers face up to CAD 1,500,000, and other individuals up to CAD 500,000, with possible imprisonment.

What is the Westray law?

The 2004 Criminal Code amendments that created s. 217.1, a legal duty on those who direct work to take reasonable steps to prevent bodily harm, and revised ss. 22.1 and 22.2 on organizational liability. Breach can support criminal negligence charges against individuals and organizations.

Is an owner an employer if it hires a contractor?

It can be. In R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28, the Supreme Court dismissed the city's appeal, leaving in place the finding that a city which placed its own inspectors on a contractor's project was an employer under the Ontario OHSA, subject to a due diligence defence.

What is a due diligence defence?

For strict liability offences, the accused avoids conviction by proving on a balance of probabilities that it took all reasonable care to prevent the offence, as described in R. v. Sault Ste. Marie. Documented policies, training, supervision, monitoring and board oversight are the evidence.

Sources

  1. Occupational Health and Safety Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1 (Ontario)
  2. Criminal Code, ss. 22.1, 22.2, 217.1
  3. R. v. Greater Sudbury (City), 2023 SCC 28

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.