Skip to content
Competition & Foreign Investment

No-Poach and Wage-Fixing Agreements Under the Competition Act

No poach agreements and wage-fixing between unaffiliated employers have been criminal in Canada since 23 June 2023, with penalties of up to 14 years' imprisonment. This note explains what s. 45(1.1) prohibits, how legacy clauses are treated, the ancillary restraints defence, franchise and outsourcing issues, HR practices and compliance steps.

HR leaders reviewing contracts for no poach agreements under Canada's Competition Act

Key takeaways

  • Section 45(1.1) criminalizes wage-fixing and no-poach agreements between unaffiliated employers.
  • The offence applies whether or not the employers compete in product markets.
  • Pre-2023 clauses are a concern if reaffirmed or implemented after 23 June 2023.
  • Ancillary restraints tied to a legitimate transaction can be defended under s. 45(4).
  • Penalties: up to 14 years' imprisonment and fines in the court's discretion.

The criminal prohibition on no poach agreements

Since 23 June 2023, wage-fixing and no poach agreements between unaffiliated employers have been criminal offences in Canada. Section 45(1.1) of the Competition Act provides that every employer commits an offence who, with another employer that is not affiliated with it, conspires, agrees or arranges to fix, maintain, decrease or control salaries, wages or terms and conditions of employment, or not to solicit or hire each other's employees. The offence is per se: the prosecution does not need to prove any effect on competition. Conviction can lead to imprisonment of up to 14 years, a fine in the discretion of the court, or both (s. 45(2)).

HR leaders reviewing contracts for no poach agreements under Canada's Competition Act
Wage-fixing and no poach agreements between unaffiliated employers have been criminal offences in Canada since 23 June 2023.

The offence applies whether or not the employers compete to sell products. Two businesses in different industries that hire the same kinds of workers, such as software engineers, nurses or truck drivers, can commit the offence if they agree not to poach each other's staff. The Competition Bureau's Enforcement Guidelines on Wage-Fixing and No-Poaching Agreements explain how it applies the provision, including the defences and the treatment of franchise and outsourcing relationships.

What is prohibited and what is not

The provision captures two kinds of agreements:

  • Wage-fixing agreements: agreements to fix, maintain, decrease or control salaries, wages or terms and conditions of employment, which can include benefits, hours, signing bonuses and other non-wage terms.
  • No poach agreements: reciprocal or one-way agreements not to solicit or not to hire each other's employees. The Bureau's guidelines describe non-solicit and no-hire agreements together as "no-poaching agreements".

The provision does not prohibit unilateral decisions, such as a company's own policy not to hire a competitor's staff, or individual non-competition and non-solicitation clauses between an employer and its employee, which are governed by employment law and, in Ontario, by the statutory ban on most non-competes. It also does not apply to agreements between affiliated companies. What matters is an agreement between two or more unaffiliated employers.

Provincial employment law sits alongside the federal offence. Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 has prohibited most employee non-compete agreements since 25 October 2021, with exceptions for the sale of a business and certain executives, and other provinces have considered or adopted similar measures. Those rules govern the employer-employee relationship, while s. 45(1.1) governs agreements between employers. A compliance review should cover both, because an employer that cannot restrict a departing employee directly may be tempted to seek the same result through an agreement with the employee's next employer, which is exactly what the federal offence prohibits.

ArrangementRisk under s. 45(1.1)Comment
Two employers agree not to hire each other's engineersHighClassic no-poach agreement; per se illegal
Employers agree on maximum wage increasesHighWage-fixing
Company adopts its own policy not to recruit from a clientLow (unilateral)Must not be reciprocal or agreed
Non-solicit in a share purchase agreement for a limited periodUsually defensibleAncillary restraints defence may apply (s. 45(4))
Franchise agreement barring franchisees from hiring each other's staffRequires analysisGuidelines discuss franchise examples; affiliation and ancillarity matter
Agreement between parent and wholly owned subsidiaryNot caughtAffiliated employers

Timing and pre-existing agreements

The guidelines state that s. 45(1.1) applies to agreements made on or after 23 June 2023, and to conduct that reaffirms or implements agreements made before that date. The Bureau has said it is unlikely to find a pre-existing agreement problematic where the parties take no steps to reaffirm or implement it on or after that date, and that at least two parties must reaffirm or implement the restraint to establish the required meeting of the minds. Employers with legacy clauses in outsourcing, consulting, franchise or joint venture agreements should review and, where necessary, remove or narrow them, and avoid enforcing them.

The ancillary restraints defence

Section 45(4) provides a defence where the restraint is ancillary to a broader or separate agreement that includes the same parties, is directly related to and reasonably necessary for giving effect to the objective of that broader agreement, and the broader agreement does not itself contravene s. 45. The guidelines distinguish between naked restraints, which are prohibited, and ancillary restraints, which can be defended. Typical examples of potentially ancillary no poach agreements include:

  • non-solicitation covenants in the sale of a business, protecting the buyer's investment in the workforce for a reasonable period;
  • restrictions in outsourcing or staffing agreements that prevent the client from hiring the provider's staff assigned to the project, for the duration of the project;
  • restrictions in joint ventures or research collaborations that protect personnel committed to the collaboration.

To rely on the defence, the restraint should be tailored in scope (the employees covered), duration and geography to what the legitimate transaction requires, and the reason should be documented. Blanket, industry-wide or indefinite restraints are hard to defend.

Practical point

Inventory every contract that contains a non-solicit or no-hire clause involving another employer's staff: M&A agreements, outsourcing and staffing contracts, consulting agreements, franchise agreements and joint ventures. For each clause, record the broader agreement it serves and why its scope and duration are necessary. Narrow or remove those you cannot justify.

Franchise systems and outsourcing arrangements

Franchise systems pose particular questions. A franchisor and its franchisees, or franchisees among themselves, may not be affiliates, so a clause preventing franchisees from hiring each other's employees can fall within s. 45(1.1). The guidelines include a franchise example and consider whether the restraint is ancillary to the franchise system's legitimate objectives, such as protecting training investments, and whether it is reasonably tailored. Franchisors reviewing their systems should consider whether a no-hire clause is genuinely needed to protect training investments, whether a shorter or narrower clause would serve the same purpose, and whether the clause has actually been enforced since June 2023. Where it is not needed, removing it at the next renewal is usually the simplest course.

Outsourcing and staffing arrangements are another common source of no-hire clauses. A narrowly drawn restriction limited to staff actually assigned to the client, lasting for the engagement and a short period after, is more likely to be ancillary than a broad prohibition on hiring any of the provider's staff for years.

HR policies, compensation surveys and information sharing

Most wage-fixing risk arises informally. Human resources leaders talk to counterparts at other employers, attend industry roundtables and participate in compensation surveys. Agreeing on salary freezes, maximum increases, standard benefits or "not stealing each other's people" in those settings can amount to an offence even without a written contract. The guidelines also address information sharing: sharing wage information is not in itself prohibited, but it can be evidence of an agreement, and under s. 45(3) a court may infer an agreement from circumstantial evidence. Compensation surveys should be run by independent third parties, use historical and aggregated data and avoid forward-looking plans. See our note on information sharing between competitors.

No poach agreements in mergers, investments and joint ventures

Transactions are where most legitimate no poach agreements are found, and where drafting discipline matters most. In a share or asset purchase, the buyer pays for the workforce as part of the business and may reasonably ask the seller not to solicit transferred employees for a limited period. In confidentiality agreements signed at the start of a sale process, bidders are often asked not to solicit the target's employees they meet during due diligence. Both are commonly defended as ancillary restraints, but only if they are proportionate. A two-year non-solicit covering employees the buyer actually acquires is far easier to justify than an indefinite no-hire covering every employee of the seller's group, including businesses not being sold.

Private equity raises additional questions. A sponsor's portfolio companies may or may not be affiliated with each other depending on control, and agreements between portfolio companies not to hire each other's staff can be caught if they are not affiliates. Sponsors should also be careful about informal guidance from deal teams to portfolio companies on compensation or recruiting, which can look like coordination between independent employers.

Joint ventures and research collaborations often include restrictions on hiring personnel seconded to the venture. These can be ancillary if they protect the collaboration's investment in people and know-how and are limited to the staff involved and the life of the project, with a short tail. Restrictions that extend to the partners' entire workforces for long periods invite scrutiny.

How investigations unfold

The Bureau learns of wage-fixing and no poach agreements from complainants, often employees or recruiters who hear that candidates are off limits, from immunity applicants and from documents obtained in other investigations. It can use search warrants and court orders to obtain emails, messages and HR records. Evidence frequently consists of informal communications: a message between HR leaders agreeing to "keep raises in line", or a note that a recruiter was told to avoid a partner's staff. Because the court may infer an agreement from circumstantial evidence, consistent patterns of conduct combined with communications can be enough. Employers should preserve documents and seek advice immediately if they learn of an investigation or of conduct that may be problematic.

Penalties, immunity and civil exposure

Penalties for no poach agreements and wage-fixing are the same as for price-fixing: up to 14 years' imprisonment and fines in the court's discretion. Individuals, including HR and business executives, can be prosecuted personally. The Bureau's Immunity and Leniency Programs apply to these offences, so the first employer to come forward with evidence may obtain immunity, subject to cooperation obligations. Employees harmed by an unlawful agreement may also bring civil damages claims under s. 36 of the Act, often as class actions on behalf of affected workers.

In merger contexts, pre-closing coordination on wages and hiring between the parties can raise the same issues. Our note on gun jumping covers that risk.

Compliance checklist

  1. Review and remediate contracts with no-hire or non-solicit clauses involving other employers.
  2. Train HR, recruiting and senior management on s. 45(1.1) and informal communications.
  3. Set rules for compensation surveys and industry HR forums.
  4. Document the business rationale for any ancillary restraint.
  5. Keep unilateral recruiting policies genuinely unilateral.
  6. Escalate any suspected agreement to counsel promptly, considering immunity options.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise employers, franchisors, staffing firms, private equity sponsors and investors on wage-fixing and no poach agreements under Canadian competition law. Our work includes contract audits and remediation, ancillary restraint drafting in M&A and outsourcing, compliance programs and training, HR survey design and responses to Bureau investigations. See our pages on cartels and criminal enforcement and employment law. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss your contracts and practices, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Are no-poach agreements illegal in Canada?

Yes, between unaffiliated employers. Since 23 June 2023, s. 45(1.1) of the Competition Act makes it an offence to agree with another unaffiliated employer not to solicit or hire each other's employees, or to fix or control wages or terms of employment. It is a per se offence with penalties of up to 14 years' imprisonment and fines in the court's discretion.

Do employee non-solicitation clauses fall under the offence?

No. Clauses between an employer and its own employee are governed by employment law, not s. 45(1.1). The offence targets agreements between two or more unaffiliated employers. Unilateral hiring policies are also outside it, provided they are not agreed with another employer.

Can a share purchase agreement include a non-solicit of employees?

Usually, if the restraint is ancillary to the transaction. Section 45(4) provides a defence where the restraint is directly related to and reasonably necessary for the broader agreement, and the broader agreement is lawful. Scope and duration should be limited to what protecting the purchased business requires.

What about agreements made before June 2023?

The Bureau's guidelines say s. 45(1.1) applies to agreements made on or after 23 June 2023 and to conduct reaffirming or implementing older agreements. The Bureau is unlikely to pursue pre-existing agreements that the parties do not reaffirm or implement after that date, but employers should review and narrow legacy clauses.

Sources

  1. Competition Act, s. 45
  2. Competition Bureau: Enforcement Guidelines on Wage-Fixing and No-Poaching Agreements
  3. Competition Bureau: Competitor Collaboration Guidelines

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.