Skip to content

Guide · Tax

Transfer Pricing in Canada: Section 247 and CRA Practice

Canada rewrote its transfer pricing rules in 2026. Section 247 of the Income Tax Act now turns on "arm's length conditions" read with the OECD Guidelines, and documentation must reach the CRA within 30 days of a request. This page explains the current rules, the penalty, advance pricing arrangements, the mutual agreement procedure and the leading cases.

10 min read Updated
ENFR

Key takeaways

  • Section 247 ITA, as amended by S.C. 2026, c. 3, adjusts related-party amounts to what arm's length conditions would have produced.
  • The OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines as adopted on 7 January 2022 are written into the definition of Transfer Pricing Guidelines.
  • A 10% penalty applies where net adjustments exceed the lesser of 10% of gross revenue and CAD 10 million.
  • Contemporaneous documentation must be provided within 30 days of a written CRA request.
  • Downward adjustments require the Minister's opinion; challenges to a refusal go to the Federal Court (Dow Chemical, 2024 SCC 23).

How transfer pricing works in Canada

Transfer pricing rules decide how much profit a multinational group reports in Canada. Under s. 247 of the Income Tax Act (ITA), when a Canadian taxpayer and a non-arm's-length non-resident take part in a transaction or series of transactions whose "actual conditions" differ from "arm's length conditions", the amounts used for tax purposes are adjusted to the "quantum or nature" they would have had if arm's length conditions had applied. The rule covers sales of goods, services, licences of intangible property, cost-sharing, guarantees and intercompany financing.

Intercompany agreements and benchmarking analysis prepared for transfer pricing documentation in Canada
Canadian pricing files now need to show the actual conduct of each party, not only the intercompany contract.

The section was substantially amended by the Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1 (S.C. 2026, c. 3), which received royal assent on 26 March 2026. The consolidated text current to 19 October 2026 shows the old "arm's length transfer price" and "arm's length allocation" definitions as repealed and replaced by a conditions-based framework. Taxpayers should check the transitional rules in the amending Act to confirm which taxation years the new text governs; files for earlier years continue to be assessed under the previous wording.

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) runs these audits through specialized international tax teams. Adjustments often run to tens of millions of dollars and trigger knock-on effects: penalties, Part XIII withholding tax on deemed dividends, and double taxation unless a treaty partner provides relief.

The amended section 247: arm's length conditions and the OECD Guidelines

The 2026 amendments align Canadian law more closely with the OECD approach. The key features of the current text are:

  • Arm's length conditions. The comparison is between the conditions actually present and those that would have applied had the participants been dealing at arm's length in comparable circumstances.
  • Delineation. Under s. 247(1.1), a transaction or series is analyzed "with reference to the economically relevant characteristics" of the transaction, which allows the CRA to look beyond the legal form to the parties' actual functions, assets and risks.
  • Broad meaning of conditions. Section 247(1.2) says "conditions" is to be interpreted broadly and includes price, rate, gross margin, net margin, division of profit and contributions to costs.
  • Missing conditions. Section 247(2.01) deems a transaction to include non-arm's-length conditions where a condition that arm's length parties would have agreed on does not exist.
  • OECD Guidelines. "Transfer Pricing Guidelines" are defined as the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations as adopted on 7 January 2022, unless another text is prescribed, and s. 247(2.03) directs how they are to be used in applying the section.

In practice, the amended rules weaken arguments that rest only on the legal form of intercompany contracts. A Canadian subsidiary described as a "low-risk distributor" in its agreement but that in fact controls marketing strategy, bears inventory risk and develops customer relationships can expect the CRA to delineate the transaction according to that conduct. Conversely, a Canadian entity that genuinely performs only routine functions should document that reality in detail, because the burden of showing reasonable efforts sits with the taxpayer.

ElementCurrent rule (s. 247 ITA)Practical consequence
StandardArm's length conditions, broadly definedAll terms of the arrangement, not only price, can be adjusted
Interpretive guideOECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (January 2022 version)Guideline methods and comparability analysis carry statutory weight
Documentation deadlineMade or obtained by the documentation-due date (generally the filing-due date); provided within 30 days of a written requestFiles must be complete before the return is filed
Penalty thresholdLesser of 10% of gross revenue and CAD 10 millionMid-size groups can reach the threshold on a single transaction
Penalty rate10% of net adjustments above the thresholdNot deductible; applies in addition to tax and interest
Downward adjustmentsOnly if the Minister considers it appropriate (s. 247(10))Refusals are reviewed by judicial review, not in the Tax Court

Contemporaneous transfer pricing documentation

Section 247(4) sets out what a taxpayer must prepare to show it made reasonable efforts to determine and use amounts based on arm's length conditions. Records or documents must be made or obtained by the "documentation-due date", which for a corporation is its filing-due date for the year, and must give a description that is complete and accurate in all material respects of:

  1. the property or services involved;
  2. the contractual terms and their relationship to other relevant transactions within the multinational group;
  3. the identity of the participants and their relationship;
  4. the functions performed by each participant, based on their actual conduct, taking into account assets used and risks assumed, how the functions relate to value creation in the wider group, the surrounding circumstances and industry practices;
  5. the data and methods considered and the analysis performed to select and apply the most appropriate method in accordance with the Guidelines; and
  6. the economic circumstances, assumptions, policies and business strategies that influenced the determination.

For each later year in which the transaction continues, the taxpayer must document each material change. The records must be provided to the Minister within 30 days after service of a written request. Section 247(4.1) allows simplification measures for taxpayers that meet prescribed conditions and provide prescribed documentation, so smaller groups should watch for the regulations that give that provision effect.

Practical point

Thirty days is not enough time to build a transfer pricing file from scratch. Treat the report as part of the annual tax return process: finalize the functional analysis and benchmarking before the filing-due date, keep the intercompany agreements signed and current, and store a version ready to send the day a request arrives.

Transfer pricing penalties

The penalty in s. 247(3) is 10% of the net transfer pricing adjustments for the year, to the extent they exceed the lesser of 10% of the taxpayer's gross revenue and CAD 10 million. Adjustments relating to transactions for which the taxpayer made reasonable efforts to determine and use arm's length amounts are excluded from the calculation, as are those relating to qualifying cost contribution arrangements. Because a taxpayer is deemed not to have made reasonable efforts unless it meets the documentation requirements in s. 247(4), the documentation file is the main defence.

Illustration (hypothetical): a Canadian distributor with gross revenue of CAD 300 million is reassessed for three intercompany transactions, producing a net income adjustment of CAD 45 million. The threshold is the lesser of CAD 30 million (10% of gross revenue) and CAD 10 million, so CAD 10 million. If the distributor had no adequate documentation for any of the transactions, the penalty would be 10% of the CAD 35 million excess, or CAD 3.5 million, on top of the tax and interest on the adjustment. If complete documentation existed for transactions accounting for CAD 40 million of the adjustment, only CAD 5 million would count, which is below the threshold, and no penalty would apply.

The CRA usually issues a proposal letter before reassessing, and that is the moment to make written submissions on reasonable efforts, with the documentation attached and a clear explanation of how it meets each element of s. 247(4). Once a penalty is assessed, it can be challenged by objection and appeal like any other assessment, but the factual record will largely have been set at the audit stage. The penalty is not deductible and applies in addition to tax and interest on the underlying adjustment.

Secondary adjustments and downward adjustments

An adjustment under s. 247 does more than increase Canadian income. Under s. 247(12), where a Canadian corporation has an upward adjustment in transactions with a non-arm's-length non-resident, an amount is deemed to be a dividend paid to the non-resident for Part XIII purposes, attracting withholding tax at 25% or the treaty rate. The CRA may agree to reduce the deemed dividend if the non-resident repatriates the amount to Canada, which is why repatriation agreements are a common part of settlements.

Downward adjustments, which reduce Canadian income, are available only if the Minister considers them appropriate under s. 247(10). In Dow Chemical Canada ULC v. Canada, 2024 SCC 23, decided on 28 June 2024, the Supreme Court held that a taxpayer challenging the Minister's refusal to make a downward adjustment must seek judicial review in the Federal Court; the Tax Court does not have jurisdiction to review that discretionary decision. Groups whose Canadian entity has overpaid, for example after a foreign audit increased profits elsewhere, should therefore ask for the adjustment early and build a record that will support judicial review if needed.

APAs, the mutual agreement procedure and the case law

Advance pricing arrangements

An advance pricing arrangement (APA) is an agreement with the CRA, and often with a treaty partner's tax authority, on the method for pricing specified transactions for future years. Bilateral APAs give the most certainty because both countries agree to the outcome, but they take time and require full disclosure. They suit material, recurring transactions where the method is genuinely uncertain, such as contract manufacturing, intangibles or complex service charges.

Mutual agreement procedure

When the CRA's adjustment produces double taxation, Canada's tax treaties allow the taxpayer to ask the competent authorities to negotiate relief under the mutual agreement procedure (MAP). Treaty time limits for a MAP request vary and are often counted from the first notification of the action giving rise to taxation not in accordance with the treaty. Some of Canada's treaties provide for mandatory arbitration if competent authorities cannot agree. Taxpayers usually need to protect their domestic appeal rights by filing a notice of objection while MAP proceeds.

Leading case law

In Canada v. GlaxoSmithKline Inc., 2012 SCC 52, decided on 18 October 2012, the Supreme Court held that the reasonable amount that would have been paid at arm's length must take account of all relevant circumstances, including other transactions such as a licence agreement linked to the purchase. It treated the OECD Guidelines as helpful but "not controlling as if they were a Canadian statute". The 2026 amendments now give the Guidelines a defined statutory role, which is likely to change how courts use them. Earlier appeals in which the Crown attempted to recharacterize transactions under the former wording should be read with care for years governed by the new text.

Intercompany financing and practical steps

Intercompany loans, guarantees and cash pools attract close attention. The interest rate, the amount of debt, the guarantee fee and even whether a loan would have been made at all are "conditions" that can be adjusted. Section 247 interacts here with thin capitalization, the EIFEL interest limitation and the hybrid mismatch rules, so the arm's length rate is only one of several tests a financing must pass. Credit ratings for the borrower, implicit group support and the terms of the facility should be documented.

Where CRA audits focus

Certain patterns recur in Canadian audits. Management fees and head-office charges are tested for benefit and duplication: the Canadian entity must show it received services it would have paid for at arm's length, rather than shareholder activities performed for the parent's own benefit. Transfers of intangibles, including migrations of IP developed in Canada with SR&ED support, are examined for whether the Canadian entity was paid for what it gave up. Business restructurings that convert full-fledged Canadian distributors or manufacturers into limited-risk entities raise questions about compensation for the functions and risks transferred. Losses incurred over several years by a supposedly routine Canadian entity also invite scrutiny, since an arm's length service provider would not usually accept persistent losses.

For each of these areas, the amended s. 247 makes the parties' actual conduct central. Emails, board papers, organization charts and approval matrices often reveal where decisions are really made, and the CRA can request them under its general audit powers. Groups should make sure their pricing narrative and their internal documents tell the same story.

Practical steps for groups with Canadian operations:

  • Map every intercompany flow involving a Canadian entity and confirm that each has a written agreement consistent with actual conduct.
  • Refresh functional analyses for restructurings, new IP arrangements and changes in headcount or decision-making.
  • Benchmark annually where margins move materially, and record why the selected method is the most appropriate.
  • Diarize the documentation-due date and keep a production-ready version of each report.
  • Consider an APA for high-value recurring transactions, and preserve objection rights while pursuing MAP.

Finally, align the tax position with customs and indirect tax. Year-end adjustments that change the price of imported goods can affect the value for duty reported to the Canada Border Services Agency and the GST paid at the border, and the two regimes have their own correction procedures and deadlines.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise multinational groups and Canadian companies on transfer pricing policy, documentation and disputes. We review intercompany agreements against actual conduct, coordinate functional analyses and benchmarking with economists, prepare documentation that meets s. 247(4), and respond to CRA audits, penalty proposals and requirements for information. We also help clients pursue APAs and competent authority relief, and assess judicial review options where the Minister declines a downward adjustment. We work with Canadian chartered professional accountants and, for Tax Court or Federal Court proceedings, with Canadian-licensed counsel. This page is general information, not advice on any particular arrangement. To discuss a transfer pricing question, contact us, or see our pages on corporate and international tax and tax disputes.

Frequently asked questions

What changed in Canada's transfer pricing rules in 2026?

The Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1 (S.C. 2026, c. 3) amended s. 247 ITA. The rules now compare actual conditions with arm's length conditions, delineate transactions by their economically relevant characteristics, incorporate the January 2022 OECD Guidelines, set the penalty threshold at the lesser of 10% of gross revenue and CAD 10 million, and require documentation within 30 days of a request.

When is a transfer pricing penalty charged in Canada?

When net transfer pricing adjustments, excluding those for transactions where the taxpayer made reasonable efforts, exceed the lesser of 10% of gross revenue and CAD 10 million. The penalty is 10% of the excess. A taxpayer is deemed not to have made reasonable efforts unless it has the contemporaneous documentation described in s. 247(4).

How quickly must transfer pricing documentation be given to the CRA?

Within 30 days after service of a written request, under s. 247(4)(c). The documentation itself must already have been made or obtained by the documentation-due date, which for a corporation is its filing-due date for the year. In practice the file should be complete when the return is filed.

Can I appeal a refusal of a downward transfer pricing adjustment to the Tax Court?

No. In Dow Chemical Canada ULC v. Canada, 2024 SCC 23, the Supreme Court held that the Minister's refusal to make a downward adjustment under s. 247(10) is reviewable by judicial review in the Federal Court, not by appeal to the Tax Court of Canada.

Do intercompany loans need transfer pricing support?

Yes. The interest rate, the amount lent, guarantee fees and other terms are conditions that s. 247 can adjust. Financing also has to satisfy the thin capitalization rule, the EIFEL limitation and the hybrid mismatch rules, so each loan should be documented and tested against all of them.

Sources

  1. Income Tax Act, s. 247 (consolidated to 2026-10-19)
  2. Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1 (S.C. 2026, c. 3)
  3. Supreme Court of Canada: Dow Chemical Canada ULC v. Canada, 2024 SCC 23 (Case in Brief)
  4. Canada v. GlaxoSmithKline Inc., 2012 SCC 52

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.