Tax Treaty Benefits and the Principal Purpose Test
Since the Multilateral Instrument took effect, most of Canada's tax treaties contain a principal purpose test that can deny treaty benefits where obtaining them was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement. For foreign investors relying on reduced withholding or gains exemptions, the test now sits alongside the GAAR and beneficial ownership as a central treaty risk.

Key takeaways
- The MLI was implemented in Canada by S.C. 2019, c. 12, assented to on 21 June 2019.
- The principal purpose test denies treaty benefits if obtaining them was one of the principal purposes of an arrangement.
- The benefit is preserved if granting it accords with the object and purpose of the treaty provision.
- Alta Energy, 2021 SCC 49, rejected a GAAR challenge to treaty shopping under the Canada-Luxembourg treaty.
- The Canada-US treaty is not covered by the MLI and relies on its own limitation on benefits article.
- Substance, commercial rationale and documentation are the best defences for holding structures.
What the principal purpose test says
The principal purpose test (PPT) is an anti-abuse rule developed in Action 6 of the OECD/G20 project on base erosion and profit shifting.
It was inserted into Canada's tax treaties through the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent BEPS (the MLI), which Canada implemented by the Multilateral Instrument in Respect of Tax Conventions Act, S.C. 2019, c. 12, assented to on 21 June 2019. Article 7(1) of the MLI provides that a treaty benefit "shall not be granted" if it is reasonable to conclude, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining it was one of the principal purposes of any arrangement or transaction that resulted directly or indirectly in that benefit, unless granting it would be in accordance with the object and purpose of the relevant treaty provisions.

The test applies only to "covered tax agreements": Canadian treaties with partner jurisdictions that have also ratified the MLI and listed the treaty. Many of Canada's treaties with European and Asian partners are covered, but coverage depends on both countries' MLI positions and must be confirmed treaty by treaty. The Canada-United States treaty is not a covered agreement; it relies on its own limitation on benefits article in Article XXIX-A. For each investment, the first step is therefore to check whether the relevant treaty has been modified by the MLI and from which date.
The test is deliberately broad. Unlike a limitation on benefits clause, which applies objective ownership and activity tests, the principal purpose test is a judgment about purpose based on all the facts. That makes outcomes harder to predict but allows genuine business structures to succeed even where they would fail a mechanical test.
For withholding taxes, the MLI generally has effect for amounts paid or credited on or after the first day of the calendar year following the later of the dates on which it entered into force for the two countries. For Canada and many partners, that means amounts paid from 1 January 2020 or later.
How the principal purpose test operates
The test has two limbs. First, the tax authority must show that it is reasonable to conclude that obtaining the benefit was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement. It does not need to be the only or dominant purpose. Second, even if that limb is met, the benefit is still granted if the taxpayer establishes that doing so accords with the object and purpose of the relevant provisions. The second limb gives the PPT a built-in safe harbour for arrangements that use a treaty as intended.
The OECD Commentary on Article 29(9) of the Model Tax Convention, which reproduces the PPT, gives examples. A company that establishes a regional holding or financing entity in a treaty country for genuine business reasons, with real activities, is expected to retain treaty benefits. A conduit company set up solely to route income through a favourable treaty is not. The Commentary is not binding law in Canada, but courts consider it when interpreting treaties.
| Tool | Source | What it targets |
|---|---|---|
| Principal purpose test | MLI Article 7 in covered agreements | Arrangements where obtaining treaty benefits was one of the principal purposes |
| Beneficial ownership | Dividend, interest and royalty articles | Recipients that are not the beneficial owners of the income |
| General anti-avoidance rule | ITA s. 245, applied to treaties through the Income Tax Conventions Interpretation Act | Abusive avoidance transactions, including misuse of treaties |
| Limitation on benefits | Canada-US treaty Article XXIX-A | Residents that fail objective ownership and activity tests |
Alta Energy and treaty shopping
In Canada v. Alta Energy Luxembourg S.A.R.L., 2021 SCC 49, the Supreme Court of Canada considered a Luxembourg company, owned by US investors, that sold shares of a Canadian oil and gas subsidiary and claimed the Canada-Luxembourg treaty exemption for gains on shares deriving value from immovable property used in the business. The Crown argued that the GAAR applied because the Luxembourg company had no economic connection to Luxembourg. The majority held that the treaty's residence provisions did not require more than residence for tax purposes, that the treaty partners had anticipated that conduit companies could claim benefits, and that the GAAR did not apply.
The case concerned years before the MLI, and the majority noted that Canada and other countries had since adopted the principal purpose test to address treaty shopping. The practical lesson is that Alta Energy limits the use of the GAAR against structures that comply with the text of pre-MLI treaties, but the PPT now provides the CRA with a treaty-based tool designed for exactly those cases. The GAAR itself was strengthened in 2024 with an economic substance factor and a penalty, which further shifts risk to holding structures without commercial substance.
Beneficial ownership
Reduced treaty rates on dividends, interest and royalties are available only to a resident of the treaty country that is the beneficial owner of the income. In Prévost Car Inc. v. Canada, 2009 FCA 57, the Federal Court of Appeal held that a Dutch holding company was the beneficial owner of dividends it received, because it had possession, use, risk and control of the dividends and was not a mere conduit obliged to pass them on. Beneficial ownership is assessed on the facts, including any legal or practical obligation to pay the income onward. The principal purpose test adds a purposive layer on top: a holding company that is the beneficial owner may still lose treaty benefits if obtaining them was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement.
Holding company substance
Substance does not guarantee treaty benefits, but it is the most persuasive evidence of non-tax purposes. Relevant factors include:
- directors resident in the treaty country who make real decisions, with board meetings held and minuted there;
- employees, premises and functions appropriate to the entity's role, such as regional management, treasury or IP management;
- multiple investments or activities rather than a single Canadian asset;
- capital and risk borne by the entity, and funding not simply passed through;
- a credible commercial reason for the location, such as investor base, regulation, financing access or proximity to markets.
Structures that existed before the MLI and that were driven by non-tax reasons, such as a fund's established European platform, are in a stronger position than entities inserted shortly before a Canadian investment or exit.
Prepare a contemporaneous memo explaining why each intermediate holding company exists, what it does and why it is located where it is, signed off by its board. If the CRA later challenges the claim, that record, rather than an after-the-fact explanation, is what will carry weight.
CRA audit practice
The CRA reviews treaty claims through Part XIII withholding audits, s. 116 clearance certificate requests on sales of taxable Canadian property, and transfer pricing and international audits. Payers who apply reduced treaty rates must obtain declarations of eligibility, using Forms NR301, NR302 or NR303, and can be liable for under-withheld tax if the claim fails. Requests for information typically cover the ownership chain up to ultimate investors, the purpose and history of each entity, board minutes, employees and premises, and the flow of funds after payment.
Disputes under the PPT are likely to turn on evidence of purpose. Taxpayers can object and appeal to the Tax Court of Canada. Where double taxation results, the mutual agreement procedure under the treaty, strengthened by the MLI's dispute resolution provisions and, for some treaties, arbitration, may provide relief.
Investment funds and pension investors
Collective investment vehicles raise particular questions. A fund organized as a partnership or transparent entity may not itself be a treaty resident, so investors claim benefits based on their own residence, which requires look-through documentation. Where a fund invests through a holding company in a treaty country, the CRA will want to know whether the holding company's location reflects the investor base and the fund's established platform or was chosen to access a particular treaty. The OECD Commentary includes examples involving regulated funds and pension funds that are generally expected to qualify, and those examples are a useful benchmark.
Foreign pension funds and sovereign investors may also have domestic exemptions or treaty provisions specific to them, which can make treaty shopping concerns less relevant. Each investor class should be analyzed on its own terms rather than through a single structure-wide assumption.
Interest, royalties and financing structures
Canada does not withhold tax on most arm's length interest, but non-arm's length interest and participating debt interest remain subject to Part XIII, as do royalties and rents. Intra-group financing routed through a treaty country to reduce withholding on non-arm's length interest is a classic target for the PPT and beneficial ownership analysis. Back-to-back loan and royalty rules in the ITA, which look through intermediaries to the ultimate lender or licensor, can produce similar results even without the treaty test. Financing structures should be reviewed against all three: back-to-back rules, beneficial ownership and purpose.
What foreign investors should do
- Confirm whether each relevant treaty is a covered agreement and when the MLI took effect.
- Map the ownership chain and the business purpose of each entity.
- Review beneficial ownership: is there any obligation to pass income onward?
- Document substance and decision-making in the treaty jurisdiction.
- Consider whether the Canada-US limitation on benefits article, rather than the principal purpose test, governs US-owned structures.
- Collect NR301 declarations and refresh them on changes in ownership.
- Revisit the analysis before any exit, refinancing or reorganization, since purpose is tested arrangement by arrangement.
- Coordinate the Canadian position with the treaty partner's view, especially where double taxation could arise.
The principal purpose test on exits
Exits are a pressure point. Gains on shares of Canadian companies whose value derives principally from Canadian real property or resource property are taxable in Canada under most treaties, but some treaties, as in Alta Energy, exempt gains where the property is used in the company's business. The principal purpose test can deny that exemption where a holding company was interposed to access it. Buyers withholding under s. 116 face their own risk if they rely on a vendor's treaty claim, so they often require clearance certificates or increased escrows. Budget 2026 proposes lower withholding rates for corporate vendors of taxable Canadian property, which would change cash-flow but not the treaty analysis.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise funds, multinationals and family offices on treaty eligibility under the principal purpose test, beneficial ownership and the GAAR: structuring and documenting holding entities, withholding and clearance certificate processes, CRA audits and appeals. We work with our corporate and international tax and tax disputes practices, and see our insights on Part XIII withholding and the 2024 GAAR amendments. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review a structure.
Frequently asked questions
Does the principal purpose test apply to all Canadian treaties?
No. It applies to covered tax agreements, meaning treaties with partners that ratified the MLI and listed the treaty with Canada. The Canada-US treaty is not covered and relies on its own limitation on benefits article. Each treaty's MLI status and effective date should be checked.
What must the CRA show to apply the PPT?
It must be reasonable to conclude, having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances, that obtaining the treaty benefit was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement or transaction. The taxpayer can still keep the benefit by establishing that granting it accords with the object and purpose of the relevant treaty provisions.
Did Alta Energy allow treaty shopping?
In Canada v. Alta Energy Luxembourg S.A.R.L., 2021 SCC 49, the Supreme Court held that the GAAR did not apply to a Luxembourg company's use of the Canada-Luxembourg treaty exemption for pre-MLI years. The Court noted that the principal purpose test was later adopted to address treaty shopping.
Is substance enough to satisfy the PPT?
Not by itself, but it is the most persuasive evidence that the entity has non-tax purposes. Directors who make real decisions in the treaty country, employees, premises, multiple investments and a credible commercial rationale all support treaty claims.
How does beneficial ownership interact with the PPT?
Reduced rates on dividends, interest and royalties require the recipient to be the beneficial owner, as discussed in Prévost Car, 2009 FCA 57. The PPT is an additional test: a beneficial owner can still be denied benefits if obtaining them was one of the principal purposes of the arrangement.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


