Skip to content
Leading Court Decisions

Reference re Impact Assessment Act: What the Supreme Court Held

The Reference re Impact Assessment Act held that most of Canada's federal impact assessment regime for designated projects exceeded Parliament's jurisdiction. Sections 81 to 91 survived, Parliament amended the Act in 2024, and proponents of mines, pipelines and industrial projects now face a narrower but still significant federal review.

Open-pit mine and river in Canada, the type of project addressed in the Reference re Impact Assessment Act

Key takeaways

  • Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23, was released on 13 October 2023.
  • The designated projects scheme was ultra vires; ss. 81 to 91 were upheld.
  • Federal decisions were not driven by effects within federal jurisdiction, and that term was overbroad.
  • Amendments in force 20 June 2024 refocus review on non-negligible adverse federal effects.
  • The Building Canada Act adds a separate national-interest project stream from 2025.

Reference re Impact Assessment Act: what the Court held

In Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23, released on 13 October 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the federal impact assessment regime for "designated projects" was largely unconstitutional because it reached beyond Parliament's legislative authority. The part of the Impact Assessment Act (IAA) dealing with projects carried out or financed by federal authorities on federal lands or outside Canada, ss. 81 to 91, was valid. The rest of the scheme, which made listed projects subject to automatic federal review, was ultra vires. The Reference re Impact Assessment Act is now the leading statement on the limits of federal environmental assessment of major resource and infrastructure projects.

Open-pit mine and river in Canada, the type of project addressed in the Reference re Impact Assessment Act
The 2023 reference reshaped how far federal impact assessment can reach into provincially regulated projects.

For project proponents, investors and lenders, the decision and Parliament's response determine when a mine, pipeline, LNG facility, transmission line or industrial plant will face a federal assessment, what that assessment can consider, and how federal and provincial reviews fit together.

Background: the 2019 Act and Alberta's reference

Parliament enacted the IAA in 2019, replacing the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act, 2012. The Act and its project-list regulations created two regimes. The first required federal authorities to consider the environmental effects of projects they carried out or financed on federal lands or abroad (ss. 81 to 91). The second, the designated projects scheme, required proponents of listed projects, such as large mines, energy facilities and pipelines, to give notice to the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, which could require a full impact assessment. A final decision on whether the project could proceed rested with the Minister or the Governor in Council, based on whether adverse effects were in the public interest.

Alberta referred the constitutionality of the Act and the regulations to the Court of Appeal of Alberta, a majority of which found both unconstitutional in their entirety. Because provincial reference opinions can be appealed to the Supreme Court as of right, the Attorney General of Canada appealed, as the Case in Brief explains.

The majority's reasoning

Writing for a five-judge majority, Wagner C.J. accepted that the environment is not a single head of power. Both Parliament and the provinces can legislate in relation to it, and Parliament may enact an environmental assessment scheme, provided the scheme is tethered to matters within federal jurisdiction. The designated projects scheme failed that test for two overarching reasons:

  1. Decision-making was not driven by federal effects. The scheme's key decisions, the screening decision on whether a full assessment was required and the final public interest decision, were not focused on "effects within federal jurisdiction" as the Act defined them. Decision-makers could weigh a wide range of effects, including on matters within provincial jurisdiction, effectively allowing federal regulation of projects that are otherwise provincial.
  2. The definition was overbroad. The defined term "effects within federal jurisdiction" did not align with federal legislative jurisdiction. That overbreadth compounded the constitutional problems in the decision-making functions.

The Chief Justice emphasized that environmental protection is among today's most pressing challenges and that Parliament has the power to enact a scheme of environmental assessment, but also "the duty ... to act within the enduring division of powers framework". He encouraged both levels of government to exercise their powers harmoniously in a spirit of cooperative federalism.

Karakatsanis and Jamal JJ. dissented in part. They would have held the Act and the regulations valid in their entirety.

Part of the 2019 schemeResult in the Reference re Impact Assessment Act
Sections 81 to 91 (federal projects on federal lands or outside Canada)Constitutional
Designated projects scheme (screening, assessment and public interest decision)Ultra vires Parliament
Project-list regulationsUltra vires, as part of the designated projects scheme
Federal power to assess environmental effects generallyAffirmed, if tied to matters within federal jurisdiction

The federalism principles behind the decision

The Reference re Impact Assessment Act is as much a federalism decision as an environmental one. The majority's approach rests on three principles that will shape future federal climate and resource legislation.

The environment is a shared field. Neither level of government owns "the environment" as a subject. Each legislates in relation to it through its own heads of power: Parliament through matters such as fisheries, navigation, federal lands, interprovincial undertakings and criminal law; the provinces through property and civil rights, natural resources and local works. A federal environmental law is valid only if, in pith and substance, it relates to a federal head of power.

Process can be substance. A scheme that is framed as information gathering can still regulate. Because the IAA gave federal decision-makers the power to decide whether a project could proceed, based on effects that included matters within provincial jurisdiction, the Court treated the scheme as regulating those projects, not merely studying them.

Federal backstops need clear limits. Read together with the earlier carbon pricing reference, which upheld a federal minimum standard for greenhouse gas pricing under the national concern branch, the decision shows the Court accepting federal action on genuinely national environmental problems while insisting that it be precisely defined. A broad, open-ended federal power to approve or refuse provincial projects did not meet that standard.

These principles also guide how proponents read the amended Act. When the Agency or the Minister considers a project, the reasons should show that the decision turns on adverse effects within federal jurisdiction. Reasons that rely heavily on provincial matters, such as general economic or land-use considerations unconnected to federal effects, may be open to challenge on the basis of the Reference re Impact Assessment Act.

Parliament's 2024 amendments

Parliament responded within months. Amendments in S.C. 2024, c. 17, in force on 20 June 2024 according to the IAA amendment history, rewrote the core of the designated projects scheme. As the consolidated Act now reads (current to 19 October 2026):

  • "effects within federal jurisdiction" are defined as non-negligible adverse changes to listed federal components of the environment, such as fish and fish habitat, aquatic species and migratory birds, and to the environment on federal lands, among other categories;
  • in deciding whether an impact assessment is required, the Agency must consider the "adverse effects within federal jurisdiction" and the direct or incidental adverse effects of the project (s. 16(2));
  • at the decision stage, the Minister must determine whether those adverse effects are likely to be, to some extent, significant and, if so, to what extent (s. 60(1)(a)), before deciding whether they are justified in the public interest;
  • the factors for the public interest determination in s. 63 are tied to the effects likely to be caused by the project.

Further amendments followed in 2024 and 2025, and regulatory changes were made in 2026, as the amendment history shows. Whether the amended scheme fully cures the defects identified by the Court has not, as far as we have been able to confirm, been tested before the Supreme Court. Proponents should assume that provincial governments and other parties may continue to scrutinize the scheme's reach.

Practical point

The amended Act focuses federal review on adverse effects within federal jurisdiction, but the list of such effects remains broad. A project that affects fish habitat, migratory birds, federal lands or Indigenous peoples can still face a federal assessment. Early analysis of which federal effects a project could cause, and how they can be avoided or mitigated, is the best way to manage scope and timelines.

Interaction with the Building Canada Act and other federal approvals

Federal environmental oversight of projects does not depend on the IAA alone. Specific statutes such as the Fisheries Act, the Species at Risk Act, the Canadian Navigable Waters Act and the Canadian Energy Regulator Act continue to require federal permits for particular activities. In 2025, Parliament also enacted the Building Canada Act as part of the One Canadian Economy Act (S.C. 2025, c. 2), which allows the Governor in Council to list national-interest projects in a schedule, after notice and consultation; for listed projects, certain federal authorizations are deemed to be favourable determinations.

For projects in the national-interest stream, the practical role of the IAA may therefore differ significantly from that for other designated projects. Our insight on designated projects under the Impact Assessment Act covers the process in more detail, and our page on environmental and climate law explains the wider federal and provincial permitting landscape.

What the Reference re Impact Assessment Act means for proponents

The decision matters for business in three practical ways:

  • Scope of federal review. Federal assessment must be linked to effects within federal jurisdiction. Proponents can and should challenge attempts to extend assessments into matters of purely provincial concern.
  • Coordination with provinces. The decision encourages cooperative federalism. Substitution and cooperation arrangements, under which one assessment serves both levels of government, are more important than ever to avoid duplication.
  • Litigation risk. Federal decisions under the amended Act can be challenged on administrative law grounds under the Vavilov framework, as well as on constitutional grounds where a decision reaches beyond federal effects.

Illustration: a hypothetical proponent plans an open-pit mine in a province with its own robust environmental assessment process. The mine would cross fish-bearing streams and affect migratory bird habitat. Under the amended IAA, those effects could trigger a federal assessment, but federal decision-making should focus on them, not on the mine's economic or provincial land-use impacts. The proponent seeks a cooperation arrangement so that one process informs both decisions, and designs mitigation for the federal effects from the outset. Our page on mining and critical minerals describes related approvals.

Diligence points for investors and lenders

For acquirers, investors and lenders evaluating Canadian projects, the decision and the 2024 amendments add specific questions to permitting diligence:

  1. Is the project, or any expansion, of a type listed for federal designation, and has the Agency decided whether an impact assessment is required?
  2. Which adverse effects within federal jurisdiction could the project cause, and are mitigation measures and offsetting plans credible?
  3. Were any federal decisions made under the pre-2024 provisions, and could their validity or conditions be questioned?
  4. Is there a cooperation or substitution arrangement with the province, and how are timelines aligned?
  5. Has the Crown's duty to consult affected Indigenous groups been addressed in both processes?
  6. Do financing documents treat a delayed or conditioned federal decision as a default, a condition precedent or a risk the sponsor must manage?

How TRW & Co helps

We advise project proponents, investors and lenders on federal and provincial impact assessment, the constitutional limits identified in the Reference re Impact Assessment Act, and the interaction between the amended IAA, sector permits and the Building Canada Act. We help scope federal triggers, plan coordinated assessments, review permitting risk in transactions and assess challenges to federal decisions, working with litigation counsel where required. This article is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a project, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Did the Supreme Court strike down the whole Impact Assessment Act?

No. The Court held that ss. 81 to 91, which govern projects carried out or financed by federal authorities on federal lands or outside Canada, are constitutional. The designated projects scheme, including the project-list regulations, was held to exceed Parliament's jurisdiction.

Why was the designated projects scheme unconstitutional?

The majority gave two reasons. The scheme's screening and final decisions were not driven by effects within federal jurisdiction, allowing decision-makers to weigh matters within provincial authority, and the Act's definition of effects within federal jurisdiction was broader than federal legislative jurisdiction.

How did Parliament respond?

Amendments enacted in S.C. 2024, c. 17 came into force on 20 June 2024. They redefine effects within federal jurisdiction as non-negligible adverse changes to listed federal matters and refocus the screening and decision stages on adverse effects within federal jurisdiction. Further amendments followed in 2024 to 2026.

Is the amended Act constitutional?

The Supreme Court has not, as far as we have confirmed as of November 2026, ruled on the amended scheme. The amendments were designed to address the Court's concerns, but proponents and provinces may still challenge particular decisions or provisions that reach beyond federal effects.

Does the Building Canada Act replace impact assessment?

Not generally. The Building Canada Act creates a separate process for national-interest projects listed in its schedule, for which certain federal authorizations are deemed favourable. Other designated projects remain subject to the amended Impact Assessment Act and sector-specific federal permits.

Sources

  1. Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23 (full text)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Reference re Impact Assessment Act
  3. Impact Assessment Act, S.C. 2019, c. 28, s. 1 (consolidated, current to 2026-10-19)
  4. Impact Assessment Act: amendment history
  5. One Canadian Economy Act, S.C. 2025, c. 2 (Building Canada Act)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.