Designated Projects Under the Impact Assessment Act
Only designated projects enter the federal impact assessment process, and the list has shrunk. After the Supreme Court's 2023 reference, the 2024 amendments and the September 2026 removal of CER-regulated pipelines and other project types, this note explains how to tell if a project is caught, how substitution works and what timelines apply.

Key takeaways
- Designated projects are those on the Physical Activities Regulations or designated by ministerial order under s. 9.
- Since 2024, assessment turns on adverse effects within federal jurisdiction and direct or incidental effects.
- SOR/2026-185 removed interprovincial pipelines, transmission lines and fossil fuel power plants from the Project List on 3 September 2026.
- The Agency must issue a notice of commencement within 180 days; its report is due within 300 days of the s. 19(4) notice.
- Provinces can request substitution under s. 31, but the federal decision remains with the Minister.
When designated projects trigger federal assessment
A project needs a federal impact assessment only if it is one of the designated projects under the Impact Assessment Act (IAA) and the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada then decides an assessment is required. Section 2 defines a "designated project" as physical activities carried out in Canada or on federal lands that are either listed in the Physical Activities Regulations (the Project List) or designated by the Minister by order under s. 9(1). Being a designated project starts a planning phase; it does not guarantee a full assessment. Since 2024 the Act has been narrower, and on 3 September 2026 the Project List itself was cut back.

This note explains how to tell whether a project is caught, what changed after the Supreme Court's 2023 reference opinion and the 2024 amendments, the September 2026 Project List amendments, substitution and cooperation with provinces, and the statutory timelines. It reflects the IAA and the Regulations as consolidated to 19 October 2026.
The Project List
The Physical Activities Regulations (SOR/2019-285) set out classes of physical activities by type and size. Examples from the current schedule include:
| Project type | Threshold in the Project List |
|---|---|
| New metal mine (other than rare earth, placer or uranium) | Ore production capacity of 5,000 t/day or more |
| New rare earth element mine | Ore production capacity of 2,500 t/day or more |
| New coal or diamond mine | Production capacity of 5,000 t/day or more |
| New oil sands mine | Bitumen production capacity of 10,000 m³/day or more |
| New LNG liquefaction, storage or regasification facility | Processing capacity of 3,000 t/day or more, or storage of 136,000 m³ or more |
| New offshore wind facility (offshore area or boundary water) | 10 or more turbines |
| New all-season public highway | 75 km or more of new right of way |
| New marine terminal | Designed for ships larger than 25,000 DWT |
Expansions are generally caught where they increase capacity or area by 50% or more and the total after expansion meets the threshold. The Regulations also catch certain activities in national parks and other protected areas regardless of size. Thresholds must be read carefully: definitions such as "new right of way" and the treatment of incidental activities often decide close cases.
Ministerial designation under s. 9
Projects below the Project List thresholds are not automatically safe. On request or on the Minister's own initiative, s. 9(1) allows the Minister to designate a physical activity by order if it may cause adverse effects within federal jurisdiction or direct or incidental adverse effects. In deciding, the Minister may consider public concerns about those effects and adverse impacts on the rights of Indigenous peoples, among other factors. Designation requests are often made by community groups or Indigenous nations once a project becomes public, so proponents of large but unlisted projects should be ready to explain why existing federal and provincial regimes already address the relevant effects.
The September 2026 Project List amendments
The Regulations Amending the Physical Activities Regulations (SOR/2026-185), registered and in force on 3 September 2026, removed several project types from the Project List. According to the accompanying Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement, these projects are no longer subject to the IAA:
- international and interprovincial pipelines;
- international and interprovincial electrical transmission lines;
- offshore renewable energy projects regulated under the Canadian Energy Regulator Act (CERA);
- oil and gas pipelines and facilities in national parks and protected areas regulated under the CERA;
- oil and gas facilities functionally integrated into a CER-regulated federal work or undertaking;
- in situ oil sands facilities of 2,000 m³/day or more in a province without legislation limiting oil sands greenhouse gas emissions; and
- fossil fuel-fired power generating facilities.
The stated aim is that CER-regulated projects are assessed by a single life-cycle regulator under the CERA, or under the Building Canada Act if listed as national interest projects. Further Project List changes following the 2024 Project List review are expected to be proposed later. For pipelines, see our note on pipeline approvals at the CER.
The 2023 reference and the 2024 amendments
In Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23 (13 October 2023), the Supreme Court held that the designated projects scheme was largely unconstitutional because it was not confined to effects within federal jurisdiction and allowed decisions to rest on matters outside federal authority; the provisions on federal projects on federal lands (ss. 81–91) were upheld. Parliament responded with amendments in S.C. 2024, c. 17, in force 20 June 2024. Key changes include:
- Narrower effects: the Act now turns on "adverse effects within federal jurisdiction" — non-negligible adverse changes to fish and fish habitat, aquatic species, migratory birds and other listed components, to the environment on federal lands, transboundary and interprovincial pollution, and certain impacts on Indigenous peoples — and on "direct or incidental adverse effects" linked to a federal authority's decisions or funding.
- Screening: under s. 16(2.1), the Agency may require an assessment only if satisfied the project may cause such effects, and under s. 16(2)(f.1) it must consider whether another jurisdiction has a means to address them.
- Decision-making: the Minister determines whether effects within federal jurisdiction are likely to be significant and, if so, whether they are justified in the public interest (s. 60), considering the factors in s. 63.
- Prohibition: under s. 7(1), a proponent must not do anything in connection with a designated project that may cause adverse effects within federal jurisdiction until the Agency decides no assessment is required or a decision statement allows it.
Designated projects: planning phase and timelines
| Step | Rule | IAA |
|---|---|---|
| Initial project description | Proponent files description; Agency posts it and consults | ss. 10–15 |
| Screening decision | Agency decides whether an assessment is required, considering s. 16(2) factors | s. 16 |
| Notice of commencement | Within 180 days after posting the initial description, with tailored guidelines and plans | s. 18(1) |
| Proponent's studies | Within three years after notice, extendable | s. 19 |
| Agency report | Final report to the Minister within 300 days after the s. 19(4) notice | s. 28(2) |
| Review panel | Minister may refer within 45 days; panel time limits capped at 600 days in total, subject to extension | ss. 36–37 |
Time limits can be extended or suspended in defined circumstances, so actual durations are often longer. Proponents of designated projects control a significant part of the schedule through the quality and timing of their studies.
Before filing an initial project description, test whether the project is still on the Project List after the September 2026 amendments, whether a provincial process could address the federal effects, and whether a substitution or cooperation request is realistic. A well-supported argument at the screening stage that no federal assessment is needed can save years.
Substitution and cooperation with provinces
Under s. 31, at the request of a province or other listed jurisdiction and before the s. 18(1) time limit expires, the Minister may approve substituting the jurisdiction's assessment process for the federal impact assessment if it would be an appropriate substitute, or allow a combination of the provincial process and federal activities. The final federal decision on effects within federal jurisdiction remains with the Minister (s. 60(1)). Since 2024 the Act places greater emphasis on cooperation with provinces, reflected in the screening factor in s. 16(2)(f.1).
In practice, "one project, one assessment" is achieved through cooperation agreements and substitution decisions, joint information requirements and aligned timelines. Proponents in provinces with cooperation arrangements should plan a single evidentiary record that meets both provincial and federal needs. Where a project is listed as a national interest project, s. 19 of the Building Canada Act deems an assessment required and removes the planning phase provisions (ss. 9–17 IAA), so the assessment informs the conditions document rather than a go/no-go decision.
Decision statements, conditions and projects on federal lands
At the end of an assessment of designated projects, the Minister issues a decision statement under s. 65 that sets out the determinations and reasons, the conditions the proponent must meet, and the period within which the project must be substantially begun. Conditions are enforceable, and the Minister may later amend a decision statement, including its conditions, but may not change the decision itself (s. 68(1)). Under s. 70, a decision statement expires if the project is not substantially begun within the period set, unless extended. Lenders and investors should therefore track both the conditions and the start-up deadline as financing milestones.
Separate rules apply to projects on federal lands and outside Canada, which the Supreme Court upheld. Under s. 82, an authority must not carry out a project on federal lands, issue an authorization for one or fund it unless it determines that the project is not likely to cause significant adverse environmental effects, or the Governor in Council decides that such effects are justified. Projects at ports, airports, on reserve lands and on other federal property, such as port terminals, airport expansions and infrastructure financed by federal programs, often fall into this stream even when they are not designated projects.
Judicial review of screening decisions, decision statements and federal lands determinations lies to the Federal Court. Recent reforms emphasize reasons and transparency, so a well-documented record of how federal effects were identified and addressed is the best protection against challenge.
Practical steps for proponents of designated projects
- Classify each component of the project against the current Project List, including expansions and incidental activities.
- Check for ministerial designation risk under s. 9 if the project is close to a threshold or controversial.
- Map adverse effects within federal jurisdiction and the federal authorizations that will be needed regardless (Fisheries Act, Species at Risk Act, navigable waters).
- Engage the relevant province early on substitution or cooperation.
- Begin Indigenous engagement before the initial project description; Indigenous impacts are central to screening and decision-making.
- Build the baseline studies and schedule into financing and offtake timelines.
Illustration: a company plans a new copper mine with ore production of 6,000 t/day in Ontario. It is a designated project. The proponent files an initial project description and argues, with a provincial assessment plan and fish habitat offsetting proposal, that the province's process can address most federal effects. The Agency may still require an assessment, but the province may request substitution under s. 31, leaving the federal decision on effects within federal jurisdiction to the Minister.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise proponents, investors and lenders on whether designated projects trigger the IAA and how to manage the process. We assess Project List coverage after the 2024 and 2026 changes, prepare screening strategies, advise on substitution and cooperation, and review decision statements and conditions for financing. We coordinate with technical consultants, provincial counsel and Canadian-licensed litigation counsel where judicial review arises. This work connects with our environmental and climate and mining and critical minerals practices and our note on national interest projects. To discuss a project, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What are designated projects under the Impact Assessment Act?
Physical activities carried out in Canada or on federal lands that are listed in the Physical Activities Regulations or designated by the Minister by order under s. 9(1), including incidental activities. A designated project enters the planning phase, and the Agency then decides whether an impact assessment is required.
Are interprovincial pipelines still subject to the IAA?
No longer. SOR/2026-185, in force on 3 September 2026, removed international and interprovincial pipelines and transmission lines and other CER-regulated project types from the Project List. They are reviewed by the Canada Energy Regulator under the CER Act, or under the Building Canada Act if listed as national interest projects.
What did the Supreme Court decide about the IAA?
In Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23, the Court found the designated projects scheme largely ultra vires because it was not confined to effects within federal jurisdiction, while upholding the provisions on federal projects on federal lands. Parliament amended the Act in June 2024 to narrow the scheme.
Can a provincial assessment replace the federal one?
Under s. 31, at a province's request and before the 180-day time limit expires, the Minister may approve substituting the provincial process if it is an appropriate substitute, or combining it with federal activities. The Minister still makes the federal decision on effects within federal jurisdiction.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


