Guide · Energy, Mining and Environment
Energy Regulatory
Energy regulatory law in Canada is applied by independent regulators that set rates, approve infrastructure and oversee markets. This guide explains the Canada Energy Regulator and the main provincial commissions, how rate cases and facility approvals work, how decisions are reviewed by the courts, and how to participate effectively.
Key takeaways
- The CER regulates federal pipelines, international power lines and energy exports.
- Provincial commissions such as the AUC, OEB and BCUC set utility rates and approve facilities.
- CER tolls must be just and reasonable under s. 230 of the CER Act.
- Appeals from the CER Commission go to the Federal Court of Appeal with leave sought within 30 days.
- The evidentiary record before the regulator usually decides the outcome.
Energy regulatory law in Canada: the basics
Energy regulatory law in Canada is administered mainly by independent, quasi-judicial regulators. At the federal level, the Canada Energy Regulator (CER) oversees interprovincial and international pipelines, international power lines, offshore renewable energy in some areas and energy exports. In the provinces, utilities commissions set rates and approve facilities for electricity and natural gas utilities, and separate regulators may handle upstream oil and gas. The main provincial bodies include the Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC), the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER), the Ontario Energy Board (OEB), the British Columbia Utilities Commission (BCUC) and the Régie de l'énergie in Quebec.

These regulators decide matters worth billions of dollars: the rates customers pay, the returns utilities earn, whether a pipeline or transmission line is built, and the rules that govern competitive markets. Their proceedings have their own procedures and evidentiary practices, and their decisions are reviewed by the courts only on limited grounds. This page explains how energy regulatory proceedings work in practice and what participants need to do to be effective.
| Regulator | Main responsibilities | Route to court |
|---|---|---|
| Canada Energy Regulator (Commission) | Federal pipelines and power lines, tolls and tariffs, export licences, safety and abandonment | Appeal on law or jurisdiction to the Federal Court of Appeal with leave, applied for within 30 days (CER Act, s. 72) |
| Alberta Utilities Commission | Utility rates, power plant and transmission approvals, market oversight matters | Appeal to the Court of Appeal of Alberta with permission, on law or jurisdiction |
| Ontario Energy Board | Electricity and gas rates, licensing, leave to construct, market rules review | Appeal to the Divisional Court on law or jurisdiction |
| BC Utilities Commission | Utility rates and certificates, energy supply contracts, reliability standards | Appeal to the Court of Appeal for British Columbia with leave |
| Régie de l'énergie (Quebec) | Rates for electricity transmission and distribution and natural gas, supply plans | Review and judicial review under Quebec law |
The Canada Energy Regulator
The CER was created in 2019 by the Canadian Energy Regulator Act, replacing the National Energy Board. Adjudicative decisions are made by a Commission of independent commissioners, while a board of directors oversees governance and a chief executive officer manages operations. The Commission hears applications for pipeline certificates, tolls and tariffs, export licences and abandonment, and the CER enforces safety, environmental protection and emergency management requirements over the life cycle of federally regulated infrastructure.
For new major pipelines, the Commission reports to the Minister with a recommendation within a time limit of no more than 450 days after a complete application, subject to excluded periods, and the federal Cabinet decides whether the certificate should be issued. Smaller facilities may be approved by the Commission directly. Section 230 requires all tolls to be just and reasonable and charged equally in substantially similar circumstances, and the Commission can approve negotiated toll settlements between pipelines and shippers, which have become the norm.
Lands and landowners
The CER Act contains a land acquisition and compensation regime for federally regulated pipelines. Companies must serve notices on landowners, negotiate land acquisition agreements and may apply for right-of-entry orders if agreement cannot be reached. Landowners have specific rights, including compensation for damages and protection against non-compliant agreements. Proponents should manage land relations carefully, because landowner objections can affect route approval and timelines.
Provincial utilities commissions
Provincial energy regulatory work centres on utility rates and facility approvals. Utilities that are natural monopolies, such as electricity distribution and transmission companies and natural gas distributors, must charge rates that the regulator approves as just and reasonable. The regulator determines the utility's revenue requirement, including operating costs, depreciation, taxes and a fair return on the capital invested, and then allocates costs among customer classes and designs rates.
Alberta
The AUC regulates utility rates and approves power plants, substations and transmission lines, and it has a role in market surveillance and enforcement matters together with the Market Surveillance Administrator. The Alberta Electric System Operator plans the transmission system and operates the wholesale market under rules that the AUC can review. The province's ongoing restructuring of its electricity market has made AUC proceedings and market rule changes central to investment decisions.
Ontario
The OEB sets rates for electricity distributors and transmitters, for Ontario Power Generation's regulated assets and for natural gas utilities, licenses market participants and approves certain facilities through leave-to-construct applications. Distributors file rate applications under incentive rate-making frameworks, with cost-of-service reviews at intervals. The Independent Electricity System Operator runs the wholesale market and procurements, with market rules subject to review by the OEB.
British Columbia and Quebec
The BCUC regulates BC Hydro, FortisBC and other utilities, issues certificates of public convenience and necessity for new facilities and reviews energy supply contracts. In Quebec, the Régie de l'énergie fixes rates for Hydro-Québec's transmission and distribution activities and for natural gas distributors, and approves supply plans, while the province's legislation shapes how Hydro-Québec procures new supply.
Rate cases and cost recovery
Rate cases are the core of energy regulatory practice. A utility files evidence supporting its proposed revenue requirement and rates, interveners such as consumer groups, industrial customers and other utilities file evidence and information requests, and the regulator holds a written or oral hearing. The regulator then decides which costs are prudent and recoverable, what return on equity and capital structure are appropriate, and how costs are allocated.
The Supreme Court has addressed key principles. In ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd. v. Alberta (Energy and Utilities Board), 2006 SCC 4, the Court held that a regulator could not allocate the proceeds of a sale of utility assets to customers, because the regulator's powers did not extend that far. In Ontario (Energy Board) v. Ontario Power Generation Inc., 2015 SCC 44, the Court held that the OEB was not bound to apply a particular prudence test to committed costs and that its decision to disallow certain compensation costs was reasonable. These cases show both the breadth of regulatory discretion and its statutory limits.
Deferral and variance accounts
Regulators often allow utilities to record costs or revenues that are uncertain or outside their control in deferral and variance accounts for later disposition. These accounts can be significant, for example for storm costs, commodity price variances or policy changes. Investors and lenders should understand which accounts exist and the likelihood of recovery, because a large balance that is later disallowed can result in a write-off and affect credit metrics.
Facility approvals and market rules
New energy infrastructure needs approval from the regulator with jurisdiction. Federally, that means CER certificates or orders for pipelines and international power lines. Provincially, it may mean approval of a power plant or transmission line by the AUC, a leave-to-construct order from the OEB for certain lines and pipelines, or a certificate of public convenience and necessity from the BCUC. Approval proceedings consider need, routing, environmental and land impacts, Indigenous consultation and cost.
In competitive markets, market rules set by the system operator determine how generators are dispatched, how prices are formed and how capacity is procured. Changes to market rules can shift value among participants, so generators, storage developers and large consumers should participate in stakeholder processes and, where necessary, seek regulatory review of rule changes.
Regulators decide on the evidentiary record. If an issue matters to your business, file evidence, ask information requests and test the utility's case during the hearing. Arguments raised for the first time on appeal, or without evidence, rarely succeed.
Energy regulatory decisions and the courts
Most energy regulatory statutes provide a statutory appeal on questions of law or jurisdiction, often requiring leave. Under the CER Act, an appeal from a Commission decision lies to the Federal Court of Appeal on any question of law or jurisdiction with leave, and leave must be sought within 30 days after the decision, unless extended in exceptional circumstances. Provincial statutes provide similar routes. Cabinet decisions on pipeline certificates are challenged by judicial review.
Since Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65, courts hearing statutory appeals apply appellate standards of review: correctness on questions of law and palpable and overriding error on questions of fact or mixed fact and law within the scope of the appeal. On judicial review, the presumptive standard is reasonableness. Many regulatory decisions turn on issues of fact, policy and expertise that fall outside the appeal right, so the hearing before the regulator is usually the decisive stage.
Review and variance applications
Most regulators also allow a party to ask the regulator itself to review and vary a decision, for example where there is an error of fact or law or new evidence. These applications are often quicker and cheaper than court appeals, and some statutes require them before an appeal. Deadlines are short, so parties must decide quickly after a decision how to proceed, and should preserve their appeal rights while a review application is pending.
Participating effectively in energy regulatory proceedings
Participants in energy regulatory proceedings include utilities and pipeline companies, shippers and customers, generators, Indigenous communities, landowners, municipalities and public interest groups. Each needs a strategy. Utilities should build a record that justifies their costs and plans. Customers and interveners should focus on issues where they can add evidence. Developers should engage early with the regulator and the system operator to understand connection, approval and market issues.
- Monitor regulator notices and stakeholder processes that affect your business.
- Apply for intervener status early and comply with procedural orders.
- Coordinate expert evidence on finance, engineering and economics.
- Consider negotiated settlements, which regulators often encourage and approve.
- Track compliance obligations attached to approvals and licences.
Energy regulatory issues in transactions
Energy regulatory approvals affect mergers and acquisitions of utilities, pipelines and generators. Transfers of regulated assets or changes of control may require regulatory approval, such as the OEB's approval of certain distributor consolidations or CER approval of pipeline transfers, and regulators may impose conditions to protect customers. Licences and approvals must be transferred or amended. Buyers should assess rate risk, deferral account balances, pending proceedings and compliance history, as well as Investment Canada Act and Competition Act requirements. Our oil, gas and LNG and power and renewables pages cover sector-specific issues.
Policy direction and government influence
Energy regulators are independent in their adjudicative functions, but governments shape their work. Provincial governments can issue directives or regulations that require regulators to implement policies, such as procurement of particular resources, rate mitigation programmes or support for specific infrastructure. In Ontario, ministerial directives to the OEB and the IESO are a regular feature of the system. In Alberta, legislation and regulations are driving the restructuring of the electricity market. Federally, Cabinet makes the final decision on major pipeline certificates and can send recommendations back to the Commission for reconsideration.
Intergovernmental agreements can also change the regulatory landscape. The 2025 Canada–Alberta memorandum of understanding, for example, addressed clean electricity regulation, industrial carbon pricing, data centre policy and interties, all of which feed into Alberta's regulatory proceedings. Participants should monitor policy announcements as closely as regulatory dockets, because policy often determines the questions the regulator is asked to decide.
Compliance and enforcement
Regulated companies carry continuing obligations once an approval is granted. Federally, the CER monitors compliance with certificate conditions, safety and security requirements, emergency management programmes and environmental protection measures through inspections, audits and incident reporting. It can issue orders, impose administrative monetary penalties and, in serious cases, refer matters for prosecution. Provincial regulators have comparable tools, including licence conditions, compliance orders and penalties, and some have dedicated market surveillance bodies that investigate market manipulation and rule breaches in electricity markets.
Compliance programmes should track every condition attached to an approval, assign responsibility for each, and record how each has been met. Conditions often require filings at specific project milestones, such as before construction starts or before operations begin, and missing one can delay a project or lead to enforcement. For companies operating across several provinces, a central register of approvals and conditions helps avoid gaps.
Reliability standards and cybersecurity
Electricity transmission owners and operators must comply with mandatory reliability standards, largely based on North American standards adopted or approved by provincial authorities. These include critical infrastructure protection standards for cybersecurity. Non-compliance can lead to penalties, and cyber incidents can trigger reporting obligations to regulators and, for some entities, federal authorities. Federal cyber security legislation for critical infrastructure has been reintroduced in Parliament as Bill C-8 and had not received royal assent as of the latest parliamentary record. Energy companies should treat reliability and cyber compliance as part of their regulatory strategy, not a separate technical issue.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise utilities, pipeline companies, generators, developers, large energy users, investors and Indigenous communities on energy regulatory matters in Canada. We help clients plan regulatory strategy, prepare applications and evidence, participate as interveners, negotiate settlements, and assess regulatory risk in transactions. Where a proceeding requires counsel licensed in the province, or appearances before the courts, we coordinate with local counsel. See also our energy, mining and environment overview and our energy and utilities sector page. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a regulatory matter, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the CER and provincial regulators?
The Canada Energy Regulator oversees infrastructure and trade that crosses provincial or national borders, such as interprovincial pipelines and energy exports. Provincial regulators handle utilities, facilities and resource development within the province, including electricity and gas distribution rates and most power plant approvals.
How are utility rates set in Canada?
The utility files evidence of its costs and proposed rates, interveners test the evidence, and the regulator decides what revenue requirement and rates are just and reasonable, including a fair return on capital. Many regulators use incentive rate-making frameworks with periodic cost-of-service reviews.
Can I appeal a CER decision?
An appeal from a decision of the CER Commission lies to the Federal Court of Appeal on questions of law or jurisdiction, with leave. Leave must be sought within 30 days after the decision, unless extended in exceptional circumstances. Cabinet decisions on certificates are challenged by judicial review.
Do I need regulatory approval to buy a utility?
Often, yes. Transfers of regulated assets or changes of control may require approval from the relevant regulator, which can impose conditions to protect customers. Licences may need to be transferred, and Investment Canada Act and Competition Act requirements may also apply.
Who can intervene in an energy regulatory proceeding?
Regulators generally allow persons with a substantial interest to intervene, including customers, industry associations, Indigenous communities, landowners and public interest groups. Interveners must apply early, comply with procedural orders and focus on issues where their evidence will help the regulator.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.