Skip to content
Energy, Mining & Environment

UNDRIP and Free, Prior and Informed Consent

Free prior and informed consent is UNDRIP’s standard for decisions affecting Indigenous peoples, and both Ottawa and British Columbia have legislated to implement the Declaration. Yet in October 2026 the Federal Court of Appeal held that the federal Act does not immediately implement UNDRIP’s articles. Here is where the law stands and what it means for projects.

Indigenous community meeting with project representatives, illustrating free prior and informed consent under UNDRIP

Key takeaways

  • The federal UNDRIP Act received royal assent on 21 June 2021 and requires consistency measures and an action plan.
  • In 2025 FC 319 the Federal Court said FPIC is not a veto but requires a robust process.
  • In 2026 FCA 174 the Federal Court of Appeal held the UNDA does not immediately implement UNDRIP’s articles.
  • BC’s DRIPA allows consent-based decision-making agreements for specific projects.
  • The constitutional duty to consult remains the primary enforceable standard for approvals.

What free prior and informed consent means in Canadian law today

Free prior and informed consent (FPIC) is the standard set by the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) for state decisions affecting Indigenous peoples, their lands and resources. Canada has endorsed UNDRIP and enacted federal legislation to implement it, and British Columbia has its own statute. But FPIC has not been turned into a general legal veto over projects.

As of November 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal has held that the federal UNDRIP Act does not immediately implement the Declaration's articles, so regulators continue to apply the established duty-to-consult case law. In British Columbia, the courts are working through how the provincial statute interacts with existing law. For project proponents, the practical consequence is that FPIC shapes expectations, negotiations and timelines more than it changes the formal approval test.

Indigenous community meeting with project representatives, illustrating free prior and informed consent under UNDRIP
Free prior and informed consent informs consultation and agreements in Canada, but courts have not treated it as a stand-alone veto.

This note sets out the legislative framework, the leading recent decisions and what the current state of the law means for project timelines and agreements. It is general information and not legal advice.

What UNDRIP says about consent

Several articles of UNDRIP refer to consent. Article 19 provides that states shall consult and cooperate in good faith with Indigenous peoples through their own representative institutions to obtain their free, prior and informed consent before adopting and implementing legislative or administrative measures that may affect them. Article 32(2) applies a similar standard to the approval of projects affecting their lands, territories and other resources, particularly in connection with the development of mineral, water or other resources. Article 29(2) addresses storage or disposal of hazardous materials, and Article 10 addresses relocation.

The wording is "consult and cooperate ... in order to obtain" consent. Much of the Canadian debate turns on whether that language requires consent before a decision, or a process aimed at consent. Canadian courts and governments have generally adopted the second reading, while emphasizing that the process must be robust and in good faith.

The federal UNDRIP Act and action plan

The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (UNDA) received royal assent on 21 June 2021. It affirms the Declaration as a universal international human rights instrument "with application in Canadian law" (s. 4(a)) and provides a framework for federal implementation (s. 4(b)). Section 5 requires the Government of Canada, in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples, to take all measures necessary to ensure federal laws are consistent with the Declaration. Section 6 requires an action plan, prepared within two years, and s. 7 requires annual reports to Parliament. The federal government released its action plan in 2023.

The annual reports under s. 7 are useful to proponents because they describe which federal laws and policies the government is reviewing for consistency with the Declaration, giving early notice of possible changes to permitting regimes, environmental statutes and resource legislation that may affect long-term projects.

The Act is a framework statute. It does not amend other federal laws directly, and it does not by its own terms create a consent requirement for permits. Its effect comes through the consistency review in s. 5, the action plan, and the interpretive weight courts give to UNDRIP when reading other legislation.

InstrumentKey provisionCurrent legal effect (Nov 2026)
UNDRIP (2007)Arts. 19 and 32(2): consult and cooperate to obtain free, prior and informed consentInternational instrument; interpretive weight in Canadian law
Federal UNDA (S.C. 2021, c. 14)Ss. 4–7: affirmation, consistency measures, action plan, annual reportsFramework for implementation; FCA in 2026 FCA 174 held it does not immediately implement UNDRIP's articles
BC Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (2019)Alignment of laws; agreements with Indigenous governing bodies, including consent-based decision-makingAgreements in use for specific projects; appellate litigation on its broader effect
Duty to consult (s. 35, Constitution Act, 1982)Consultation and accommodation proportionate to claim strength and impactPrimary enforceable standard applied by regulators and courts

Kebaowek: the Federal Court and the Federal Court of Appeal

The most important federal litigation concerned the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission's authorization of a near-surface disposal facility for low-level radioactive waste at Chalk River, Ontario. In Kebaowek First Nation v. Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, 2025 FC 319 (19 February 2025), the Federal Court held that the Commission should have considered UNDRIP, including the FPIC standard, in its consultation, and ordered further consultation. The Court also stated that FPIC does not give Indigenous Nations a veto power over proposals within their territories, describing it instead as a requirement for a robust process.

On appeal, in Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation, 2026 FCA 174 (16 October 2026), the Federal Court of Appeal reversed. It held that the UNDA does not immediately implement UNDRIP's articles; it provides a framework and process for resolving inconsistencies through consultation and cooperation. The Commission therefore did not err in following existing duty-to-consult jurisprudence rather than deciding for itself how to implement UNDRIP. Further appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada is possible, so the position may change.

British Columbia's DRIPA and consent-based agreements

British Columbia enacted its Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act in 2019. It commits the province to bring its laws into alignment with UNDRIP and authorizes agreements with Indigenous governing bodies, including agreements under which decisions about land and resources are made jointly or require the consent of the Indigenous governing body. Such consent-based decision-making agreements have been used for specific mining projects, and they give the participating Nation a defined, contractual role in statutory decisions.

BC courts are also considering DRIPA's broader legal effect. The Gitxaala litigation over the province's mineral tenure regime, discussed in our note on mineral tenure reform, led the province to adopt a consultation framework before registering mineral claims, and the Court of Appeal issued a decision on DRIPA's effect in December 2025. Because the appellate position may be subject to further review, proponents in British Columbia should obtain up-to-date advice on how DRIPA affects the approvals they need.

Practical point

Whatever the formal legal standard, regulators, lenders and investors increasingly ask whether affected Nations support a project. Treat free prior and informed consent as a design objective: involve Nations before key decisions, share information early and in usable form, and document how concerns changed the project.

How FPIC interacts with the duty to consult

The constitutional duty to consult, developed in Haida Nation and later cases, remains the enforceable standard for most decisions. It requires consultation proportionate to the strength of the claim and the seriousness of the potential impact, and, where appropriate, accommodation. It does not require agreement, but at the deep end of the spectrum it can require significant changes to a project. The Supreme Court's 2024 and 2025 decisions on honour of the Crown and consultation, such as Quebec (AG) v. Pekuakamiulnuatsh Takuhikan, 2024 SCC 39, and Saskatchewan (Environment) v. Métis Nation‑Saskatchewan, 2025 SCC 4, show that courts continue to enforce these obligations rigorously.

In practice, free prior and informed consent and the duty to consult converge. A consultation process designed to seek consent, with early engagement, capacity funding, access to information and willingness to change the project, will usually satisfy the duty to consult and reduce litigation risk, whatever view courts ultimately take of UNDRIP's direct effect.

What free prior and informed consent means for project timelines

For proponents, the main effect of FPIC is on timing and sequencing. Seeking consent takes longer at the front end, because Nations need time and resources to assess a project and to make decisions according to their own governance processes. But it can shorten the overall timeline by reducing opposition, judicial review and delay at the permitting stage. Investors increasingly price this risk: a project with documented support from affected Nations is easier to finance than one facing active opposition.

Agreements are the main tool. Impact benefit agreements, equity partnerships and, in British Columbia, consent-based decision-making agreements can record a Nation's support and set out how it will participate in monitoring and decision-making. Our notes on impact benefit agreements and Indigenous equity ownership explain those structures.

FPIC in other federal statutes and processes

Even without direct implementation, UNDRIP language appears throughout recent federal legislation. Statutes enacted since 2019 often include preambles or purpose clauses referring to the Declaration, and several require decision-makers to consider Indigenous knowledge, the impacts on Indigenous peoples and their rights, and agreements with Indigenous governing bodies. The Impact Assessment Act, for example, requires assessments to take into account the impact on any Indigenous group and on s. 35 rights, Indigenous knowledge and assessments carried out by Indigenous governing bodies. These provisions create procedural hooks through which consent-oriented principles can influence decisions and through which inadequate engagement can be challenged.

Federal fast-tracking legislation for projects of national interest also requires consultation with Indigenous peoples before projects are designated, and the government has emphasized partnership and equity participation in nation-building projects. Whether these measures are applied in a way consistent with free prior and informed consent is likely to be a recurring issue in litigation over designated projects.

What investors and lenders look for

Financial institutions have their own standards. Many lenders follow international frameworks such as the Equator Principles, which refer to free prior and informed consent for projects with significant adverse impacts on Indigenous peoples, and institutional investors increasingly ask about community support in due diligence. In practice they look for evidence of early engagement, agreements with affected Nations, grievance mechanisms and monitoring arrangements. A proponent that cannot show this may face higher financing costs or conditions, even if it has met the minimum legal requirements for permits.

For listed companies, the status of relationships with Indigenous Nations can also be a material fact for securities disclosure, particularly where opposition could delay or prevent a project. Boards should ensure that disclosure reflects the real state of engagement and the legal risks described above.

Practical checklist

  • Identify affected Nations early, including overlapping territories, and their decision-making processes.
  • Fund independent advisers and allow time for community decision-making.
  • Share project information early, in usable form, and record how concerns changed the design.
  • Track federal and BC litigation, including any appeal from 2026 FCA 174.
  • Use agreements to document support, participation and monitoring roles.
  • Build realistic engagement timelines into financing and construction schedules.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise project proponents, investors and Indigenous Nations on UNDRIP, free prior and informed consent and the duty to consult. We design engagement strategies, review consultation records, negotiate benefit, partnership and consent-based agreements and assess litigation risk for approvals. Where a matter requires a lawyer licensed in a particular province, we work with local counsel. To discuss a project, contact us; our Indigenous law page provides more background.

Frequently asked questions

Does free prior and informed consent give Indigenous Nations a veto in Canada?

Canadian courts have not treated it as a veto. The Federal Court in 2025 FC 319 described FPIC as requiring a robust process rather than a veto, and the Federal Court of Appeal in 2026 FCA 174 held that the federal UNDRIP Act does not immediately implement UNDRIP’s articles. The duty to consult remains the enforceable standard.

What does the federal UNDRIP Act require?

It affirms the Declaration as having application in Canadian law, requires the federal government to take measures, in consultation and cooperation with Indigenous peoples, to make federal laws consistent with the Declaration, requires an action plan within two years and requires annual reports to Parliament. It is a framework statute rather than a direct consent requirement.

What did the Federal Court of Appeal decide in Kebaowek?

In Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation, 2026 FCA 174, the court held that the UNDA provides a framework and process rather than immediately implementing UNDRIP’s articles, and that the CNSC did not err in applying existing duty-to-consult case law. It reversed the Federal Court’s order for further consultation.

What are consent-based decision-making agreements in BC?

Under British Columbia’s Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, the province can enter into agreements with Indigenous governing bodies under which certain statutory decisions are made jointly or require the Indigenous governing body’s consent. They have been used for specific resource projects and give the Nation a defined role in decisions.

How should proponents factor FPIC into project planning?

Proponents should engage affected Nations early, fund independent advice, share information in usable form, allow time for community decision-making and use agreements to document support and participation. A consent-oriented process usually satisfies the duty to consult and reduces the risk of delays from opposition or judicial review.

Sources

  1. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (S.C. 2021, c. 14)
  2. Kebaowek First Nation v. Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, 2025 FC 319
  3. Canadian Nuclear Laboratories Ltd. v. Kebaowek First Nation, 2026 FCA 174
  4. Province of British Columbia — Mineral Claims Consultation Framework

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.