Skip to content
Leading Court Decisions

Matthews v Ocean Nutrition: Bonuses on Termination

Matthews v Ocean Nutrition decides whether dismissed employees keep bonuses and incentives that would have paid out during their notice period. The Supreme Court held they do unless the plan unambiguously says otherwise, and awarded a constructively dismissed chemist about $1 million under a long-term incentive plan.

Executive reviewing a long-term incentive plan, the issue in Matthews v Ocean Nutrition

Key takeaways

  • Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, was decided unanimously on 9 October 2020.
  • Notice damages include bonuses and incentives that would have been earned during reasonable notice.
  • Plan language must clearly and unambiguously remove that entitlement.
  • "Full-time employee" and "with or without cause" wording was not enough.
  • The Court accepted that the employer was dishonest but awarded no separate damages.

What Matthews v Ocean Nutrition decided

Matthews v Ocean Nutrition, formally Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, decided on 9 October 2020, is the Supreme Court of Canada's leading decision on whether a dismissed employee is entitled to bonuses and incentive payments that would have been earned during the reasonable notice period. In a unanimous judgment by Kasirer J., the Court held that a constructively dismissed employee was entitled to a long-term incentive payment of about $1 million, triggered by the sale of the company within his 15-month notice period, because nothing in the incentive plan clearly and unambiguously removed that entitlement.

Executive reviewing a long-term incentive plan, the issue in Matthews v Ocean Nutrition
Matthews v Ocean Nutrition requires unambiguous language before an incentive plan can cut off payments during the notice period.

For employers, Matthews v Ocean Nutrition is primarily a drafting decision. Many bonus, long-term incentive, equity and commission plans contain language requiring "active employment" or providing that entitlements end on termination "with or without cause". The Court held that such language may not be enough to defeat a claim for damages covering the reasonable notice period.

The facts: a chemist, a hostile executive and a sale

According to the Supreme Court's Case in Brief, Mr. Matthews was a chemist and senior employee at Ocean Nutrition, a Nova Scotia company that became successful in omega-3 products. In 2007, a new chief operating officer arrived. Over the following years, he removed responsibilities and team members from Mr. Matthews, lied to him and told the board there was no place for him in the company. Mr. Matthews had stayed partly because of a long-term incentive plan that would pay a large amount if the company was sold.

Eventually, finding his position untenable, Mr. Matthews resigned. Just over a year later, Ocean Nutrition was sold for more than half a billion dollars. The company refused to pay him under the incentive plan because he was no longer employed. The trial judge found that he had been constructively dismissed, set reasonable notice at 15 months, and held that he would have received the incentive payment had he remained employed through the notice period, since the sale occurred within it. The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal majority agreed that he had been constructively dismissed and that 15 months was the right notice period, but held that he had no right to the incentive payment after leaving the company. The Supreme Court restored the award.

The two-step test from Matthews v Ocean Nutrition

An employee dismissed without cause or reasonable notice is entitled to damages placing them in the position they would have been in had the employer given proper notice. Those damages include the compensation the employee would have received during the notice period. The Court framed the analysis of bonus and incentive entitlements in two steps:

  1. Entitlement during the notice period. Would the employee have been entitled to the bonus or incentive as part of their compensation during the reasonable notice period? Here the answer was yes: the sale occurred within 15 months of the dismissal.
  2. Removal by the contract. If so, do the terms of the employment contract or incentive plan unambiguously take away or limit that common-law right? Here the answer was no.

The Court emphasized that the second step concerns the employee's right to damages for the employer's failure to give reasonable notice, not the employee's right to the bonus as such. Clauses aimed at employees who have actually left the company are not necessarily drafted to exclude damages for a period during which the employee should still have been employed.

Plan languageEffect after Matthews v Ocean Nutrition
"Must be a full-time employee" or "actively employed" on the payment dateNot enough on its own; the employee would have been employed during reasonable notice
Forfeiture on termination "with or without cause"Not enough if the termination was unlawful because notice was not given
Language expressly excluding entitlement during any period of reasonable notice or pay in lieu, beyond the statutory minimumMore likely to be effective, subject to employment standards minimums and to fair disclosure
No forfeiture languageBonus or incentive included in notice damages if it would have been earned

Why Ocean Nutrition's plan language failed

Ocean Nutrition's plan required the employee to be a full-time employee of the company when the triggering event occurred, and stated that it would not apply where employment ended, whether with or without cause. The Court held that neither provision was sufficient. A clause requiring "full-time employment" when the payment is triggered does not clearly address the period of reasonable notice during which the employee should have been employed. A clause referring to termination "with or without cause" does not cover an unlawful termination, that is, one made without the reasonable notice the law requires.

The lesson is that forfeiture language drafted with voluntary resignations or lawful terminations in mind does not automatically reach an unlawful dismissal. The more valuable the entitlement, the more clearly the plan must speak to the notice period if the employer intends to exclude it.

Applying the test to different types of plans

The two-step test applies across compensation structures, but the first step, whether the employee would have received the payment during the notice period, plays out differently for each:

  • Annual bonuses. Where a bonus is an integral part of compensation and has been paid regularly, courts often include it in notice damages even if the plan describes it as discretionary. A truly discretionary bonus, not regularly paid, is harder to claim.
  • Commissions. Damages usually reflect average commission earnings over a representative period, since the employee would have continued selling during the notice period.
  • Long-term incentives tied to events. As in Matthews v Ocean Nutrition itself, the question is whether the triggering event, such as a sale or IPO, occurred within the notice period.
  • Restricted share units and options. Awards that would have vested during the notice period are commonly claimed. Plan terms that end vesting on the "termination date" must define that date clearly enough to exclude the notice period.
  • Retention and deferred bonuses. These are often designed precisely to require continued service, so drafting that addresses unlawful termination is especially important.

The second step, whether the plan unambiguously removes the entitlement, is assessed on the wording actually communicated to the employee. Courts have been reluctant to enforce terms that were buried in plan documents the employee never received, or that were introduced without notice or consideration. A careful onboarding and award process, with signed acknowledgements, is as important as the wording itself.

Good faith and honesty in the employment relationship

Mr. Matthews also argued that Ocean Nutrition breached a duty of good faith, invoking Bhasin v. Hrynew, 2014 SCC 71. The Court accepted that the employer had not been honest with him about his future with the company. However, because he claimed only the incentive payment, which he recovered through the reasonable notice analysis, the Court did not award separate damages. It left open how broadly a duty of good faith in the course of employment might extend, while noting that the duty of honest performance applies to employment contracts as to others. Employers should assume that dishonest treatment in the period leading up to a dismissal can support additional damages in an appropriate case. The Bhasin docket sets out the earlier judgment's disposition.

Practical point

Courts read incentive plans against the employer that drafted them. If the business intends that an employee terminated without cause receive nothing beyond the statutory minimum under a bonus, long-term incentive or equity plan, the plan must say so in clear terms that specifically address the notice period and pay in lieu, and the employee must have been given the plan when the entitlement was offered.

Drafting incentive plans after Matthews v Ocean Nutrition

Since the decision, Canadian courts have regularly applied the two-step test to annual bonuses, long-term incentive plans, stock options, restricted share units and commission plans. Employers can reduce the risk of unplanned liabilities by:

  • Addressing the notice period expressly. State that no entitlement accrues or vests during any period of notice, pay in lieu of notice or severance, other than what employment standards legislation requires.
  • Defining termination broadly. Define the termination date as the last day of active work, whether or not notice is given, and whether termination is lawful or unlawful.
  • Respecting statutory minimums. Provisions that purport to remove entitlements during the statutory notice period risk being void and may taint the clause. In Ontario, for example, employment standards rights cannot be contracted out of, and courts look closely at any clause that might do so; see our page on employment law.
  • Aligning documents. Ensure the employment agreement, plan text, award agreements and offer letters use consistent language, and that the employee receives and accepts the governing terms.
  • Using fresh consideration for changes. Introducing forfeiture language mid-employment may require consideration to bind existing employees.
  • Reviewing equity plans. Plans governed by foreign law or drafted for other jurisdictions often use "active employment" wording that may not achieve the intended result in Canada; our insight on equity award forfeiture clauses discusses this.

Employer checklist and illustration

  1. Inventory every bonus, commission, incentive and equity plan applying to Canadian employees.
  2. Check each for language addressing the reasonable notice period and pay in lieu.
  3. Compare that language with employment standards minimums in each province.
  4. Confirm employees received and accepted the plan terms, and identify any who did not.
  5. Model the cost of terminations of senior employees during expected liquidity events or bonus cycles.
  6. Avoid conduct, such as stripping responsibilities, that could support a constructive dismissal claim while a liquidity event is pending.
  7. Factor potential incentive claims into transaction documents, including purchase price adjustments and indemnities for pre-closing terminations.

Illustration: a hypothetical technology company plans a sale within a year and has a retention plan paying key staff on closing if they are "employed on the closing date". It dismisses a vice-president without cause six months before closing, giving only statutory notice. Under Matthews v Ocean Nutrition, a court is likely to find that the vice-president would have been employed on closing had reasonable notice been given, and that "employed on the closing date" does not unambiguously exclude damages, so the retention payment forms part of the notice damages. A buyer conducting due diligence should identify that exposure before signing and allocate it in the purchase agreement. See also our insights on constructive dismissal and enforceable termination clauses.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise employers, boards and compensation committees on incentive and equity plan design and on terminations of senior employees in Canada. We review plans and employment agreements in light of Matthews v Ocean Nutrition, model exposure ahead of transactions and restructurings, and advise on negotiated exits and litigation risk, working with counsel in the relevant province where required. This article is general information, not legal advice. To review your plans, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Are bonuses part of reasonable notice damages in Canada?

Generally yes. Under Matthews v Ocean Nutrition, damages for wrongful dismissal include bonuses and incentive payments the employee would have received during the reasonable notice period, unless the employment contract or plan unambiguously removes or limits that entitlement.

Does an "active employment" clause defeat a bonus claim?

Often not. The Court held that wording requiring the employee to be a full-time employee when the payment is triggered, or ending entitlement on termination with or without cause, did not unambiguously exclude damages for the notice period. Clauses should expressly address the notice period and pay in lieu.

How much did Mr. Matthews receive?

The Supreme Court restored the trial judge's award of the long-term incentive payment, which the Court's summary describes as about $1 million. The payment was triggered by the sale of Ocean Nutrition within the 15-month reasonable notice period.

Can employers exclude bonuses during the statutory notice period?

No. Employment standards legislation sets minimum entitlements that cannot be waived by contract, and courts scrutinize clauses that could breach them. Drafting usually distinguishes the statutory notice period, during which minimum entitlements continue, from any longer common-law notice period.

Did the Court award damages for dishonesty?

No. The Court accepted that Ocean Nutrition had not been honest with Mr. Matthews about his future, but because he claimed only the incentive payment, which he recovered through the notice analysis, no additional damages were awarded. Dishonest conduct may support further damages in other cases.

Sources

  1. Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26 (full text)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd.
  3. Supreme Court of Canada, case 35380 (Bhasin v. Hrynew), docket and judgment entries

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.