Canada v Loblaw: FAPI and the Regulated Bank Exception
In Canada v Loblaw, the Supreme Court held that a parent's capital and oversight do not make a foreign bank's business one conducted with non-arm's length persons. The text-first ruling saved Loblaw Financial from FAPI on its Barbados bank, but the exception now carries stricter statutory conditions.

Key takeaways
- Canada v. Loblaw Financial Holdings Inc., 2021 SCC 51, was decided unanimously on 3 December 2021.
- Funding and managing a foreign bank is not 'doing business' with it for the arm's length test.
- The Court read the detailed FAPI definition according to its ordinary words, not a broad policy purpose.
- Section 95(2.11) ITA now requires the Canadian group itself to be a regulated financial institution.
- Non-financial groups will rarely fit offshore bank income within the exception under current law.
What Canada v Loblaw decided
In Canada v. Loblaw Financial Holdings Inc., 2021 SCC 51, the Supreme Court of Canada unanimously held that income earned by a Barbados bank owned by Loblaw Financial Holdings Inc. was not foreign accrual property income (FAPI), because the bank's business was conducted principally with arm's length persons. Canada v Loblaw turned on a narrow question: does a Canadian parent "do business" with its foreign bank when it funds and oversees it? The Court said no, reading the Income Tax Act (ITA) according to its ordinary words.

The decision, released on 3 December 2021 with reasons by Justice Côté, matters well beyond the grocery sector. It is a leading statement on how Canadian courts read detailed, rules-based tax provisions, and on the limits of reading purpose into text when the Minister of National Revenue dislikes the result. It also shows how a statutory exception can shift after litigation: the regulated foreign bank exception in the Act today contains gatekeeping conditions that bear directly on structures like the one at issue. This note covers the facts, the holding, the statutory framework, the current rules and practical points for groups with foreign financial affiliates. It is general information, not legal advice.
The facts and the path through the courts
Loblaw Financial Holdings Inc. (Loblaw Financial), part of the Loblaw group of companies, opened a bank in Barbados in 1992 called Glenhuron Bank Limited (Glenhuron). Glenhuron carried on corporate banking activities: it invested and managed funds, much of which came from the Loblaw group itself. Between 1992 and 2000 the group and Loblaw Financial injected money into Glenhuron, and the bank was wound up in 2013.
For its 2001 to 2005, 2008 and 2010 taxation years, Loblaw Financial did not include Glenhuron's income as FAPI, taking the position that the income came from an active business and fell within the exception for regulated foreign banks. The Minister reassessed. The Tax Court of Canada agreed with the Minister, finding that the exception did not apply. The Federal Court of Appeal allowed Loblaw Financial's appeal, and the Supreme Court dismissed the Crown's further appeal, restoring the taxpayer's filing position for the years in issue.
| Court | Outcome | Key reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Tax Court of Canada | Minister succeeds | The exception did not apply; the bank was treated as dealing principally with non-arm's length persons |
| Federal Court of Appeal | Taxpayer succeeds | The arm's length condition was met on a proper reading of the definition |
| Supreme Court of Canada (2021 SCC 51) | Crown appeal dismissed, unanimous | Capital contributions and management by the parent are not "business conducted" with it |
The FAPI rules and the regulated foreign bank exception
Canada taxes a Canadian shareholder on certain passive income earned by its controlled foreign affiliates as it is earned, whether or not it is distributed. That income is FAPI. Income from an "investment business" is FAPI, and the definition of investment business in s. 95(1) ITA captures a business whose principal purpose is to derive income from property, such as interest and dividends, or profits from disposing of investment property.
The definition then carves out certain regulated financial businesses. In broad terms, a business is excluded if it is carried on by the affiliate as a foreign bank, trust company, credit union, insurance corporation or securities dealer whose activities are regulated under the relevant foreign laws, provided the affiliate employs more than five full-time employees (or the equivalent) in the active conduct of the business. Critically, the exclusion applies only to a business "other than any business conducted principally with persons with whom the affiliate does not deal at arm's length". That parenthetical became the battleground in Canada v Loblaw.
The Minister argued that Glenhuron's business was conducted principally with its non-arm's length parent, because the parent supplied the capital the bank invested and exercised oversight of its operations. On that view, the bank's activities served the group rather than outside customers, and the income should be taxed in Canada as FAPI.
The holding in Canada v Loblaw: text first
Justice Côté accepted that the FAPI regime is one of the most complicated in Canadian law, but framed the question as a simple one: is a corporation doing business with its affiliate when it provides capital and management to it? Reading the arm's length requirement in its grammatical and ordinary sense, the Court said no. The relevant inquiry is with whom the foreign bank does business, meaning its counterparties in the transactions that generate its income, not who funds or supervises it.
As a corporate bank, Glenhuron carried out its banking and investment transactions principally with companies that were not related to it. Loblaw Financial's capital injections and its oversight were not themselves "business conducted" with the bank. The arm's length condition was therefore met, the exception applied, and the income was not FAPI for the years in question.
The Court also cautioned against using broad purposive arguments to override a carefully drafted provision. Where Parliament has written detailed, precise rules, the words carry particular weight, and policy concerns about a perceived gap are for Parliament to address. That reasoning echoes a long line of tax cases that put text, context and purpose together but give the text dominant weight where it is clear.
Canada v Loblaw is a statutory interpretation case, not a general licence for offshore treasury structures. The FAPI exception now has additional statutory conditions, and the general anti-avoidance rule, transfer pricing rules and foreign affiliate dumping rules all operate alongside it. Any structure relying on the decision should be tested against the current version of the Act for the year in question.
The exception after Canada v Loblaw: tighter statutory conditions
The current consolidation of the ITA contains a further gate in s. 95(2.11). A taxpayer or foreign affiliate is deemed not to have established that it meets the regulated-business condition in the investment business definition unless, throughout the relevant period, the Canadian taxpayer itself is part of a regulated Canadian financial group. In summary, the conditions now include the following:
- the taxpayer is (or is controlled by, or wholly owned within a chain leading to) a Canadian-resident bank listed in Schedule I to the Bank Act, trust company, credit union, insurance corporation or registered securities dealer whose business is supervised by OSFI or a comparable provincial regulator; and
- either that regulated corporation has, or is deemed to have, CAD 2 billion or more of equity under the Bank Act, the Trust and Loan Companies Act or the Insurance Companies Act, or more than 50% of the taxable capital employed in Canada of the taxpayer and its affiliated Canadian corporations is attributable to a regulated business carried on in Canada.
The practical effect is that a non-financial group, such as a retailer, manufacturer or resources company, will generally find it far harder to bring the income of an offshore bank or treasury company within the regulated foreign bank exception. For such groups, income of this kind is now more likely to be FAPI regardless of how the arm's length question would have been answered on the facts in Canada v Loblaw.
| Question | As decided in Canada v Loblaw | Under the current Act (s. 95(2.11)) |
|---|---|---|
| Who must be regulated? | The foreign affiliate carrying on the banking business | The foreign affiliate and, in addition, the Canadian taxpayer's group |
| Size or activity test for the Canadian group | None in the provision applied | CAD 2 billion equity, or more than 50% of taxable capital employed in Canada in a regulated business |
| Arm's length requirement | Measured by the bank's counterparties, not its funders | Same wording remains in the definition |
| Who is likely to qualify | A wider range of groups, depending on facts | Mainly Canadian regulated financial institutions and their groups |
Why the decision still matters for businesses in Canada
First, Canada v Loblaw remains a leading authority on the interpretive approach to the ITA. Where a provision is detailed and its words are clear, courts will not stretch it to catch a result the Crown considers inconsistent with the policy behind it. Taxpayers can plan with reasonable confidence around the ordinary meaning of carefully drafted rules, subject to the general anti-avoidance rule (GAAR).
Second, the decision illustrates a recurring pattern in Canadian tax law: litigation exposes a perceived gap, and Parliament responds with targeted amendments. The GAAR amendments in force for transactions from 1 January 2024, discussed in our note on the 2024 GAAR changes, reflect the same dynamic after decisions such as Alta Energy. Planning that relies on a favourable judgment needs to track later legislative responses.
Third, the case is a reminder that the arm's length inquiry is fact-specific. Glenhuron could show who its counterparties were and how its investment activities were carried on. Groups with foreign financial affiliates should keep transaction-level records that identify counterparties, the regulator, employee headcount and the functions performed, because the burden is on the taxpayer or affiliate to establish the exception.
Practical steps for groups with foreign financial affiliates
- Map the affiliates. Identify every controlled foreign affiliate that earns interest, dividends, insurance or trading income and confirm which years are open for reassessment.
- Apply the current definition. Test the investment business definition and s. 95(2.11) for each year, including the five-employee condition and the regulatory requirements in each relevant country.
- Document counterparties. Record the arm's length status of the parties with whom each business is principally conducted, separately from funding and governance arrangements.
- Coordinate with transfer pricing. Intra-group funding, guarantees and services must also be priced on arm's length terms under s. 247; see our transfer pricing page.
- Consider global minimum tax. For large groups, the Global Minimum Tax Act may impose top-up tax on low-taxed foreign entities regardless of the FAPI result.
- Review disclosure. Consider whether any arrangement is a reportable or notifiable transaction under the mandatory disclosure rules before filing.
Illustration
Illustration (hypothetical): a Canadian manufacturing group capitalizes a licensed bank in a foreign jurisdiction, which employs eight staff and lends to unrelated regional businesses. On the reasoning in the 2021 decision, the parent's funding would not by itself make the bank's lending business one conducted with non-arm's length persons. But under the current Act, the group would also need to satisfy s. 95(2.11). A manufacturer is not a Schedule I bank, trust company, credit union, insurer or registered dealer, so the bank's interest income would likely be FAPI, taxable in Canada as earned, subject to the deduction for foreign accrual tax paid on that income.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise Canadian and international groups on Canadian corporate and international tax, including the foreign affiliate and FAPI rules, the regulated financial institution conditions in s. 95, treaty positions and the interaction with transfer pricing and the GAAR. We review existing offshore treasury, captive insurance and finance structures against the current law, prepare the factual record a taxpayer needs to support its filing position, and help in-house teams respond to CRA queries and audits. Where a dispute reaches the Tax Court of Canada, we work with Canadian-licensed litigation counsel as required. Learn more about our corporate and international tax work, or contact us to discuss a specific structure.
Sources: Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Canada v. Loblaw Financial Holdings Inc.; full reasons, 2021 SCC 51.
Frequently asked questions
What is FAPI?
Foreign accrual property income is passive income, such as income from an investment business, earned by a controlled foreign affiliate of a Canadian taxpayer. The Canadian shareholder includes its share of FAPI in income as it is earned, even if nothing is paid up to Canada. The rules sit mainly in s. 91 and s. 95 of the Income Tax Act.
Why did Loblaw Financial win?
The Supreme Court held that the regulated foreign bank exception's arm's length condition looks at the parties with whom the bank actually does business, its counterparties. The parent's capital injections and oversight were not business conducted with the bank. Because Glenhuron dealt principally with unrelated parties and the other conditions were met, its income was not FAPI for the years in issue.
Can a non-financial group still rely on the regulated foreign bank exception?
Under the current Act, it is much harder. Section 95(2.11) deems the exception's regulatory condition unmet unless the Canadian taxpayer belongs to a regulated Canadian financial group meeting either a CAD 2 billion equity test or a test based on taxable capital employed in a regulated Canadian business. Each year must be tested under the version of the law that applies to it.
Did the GAAR play a role in the decision?
The Supreme Court decided the appeal on the meaning of the investment business definition, and its reasoning focused on the text of that provision. The general anti-avoidance rule is a separate tool, and the 2024 amendments to it, which apply to transactions from 1 January 2024, make it a more significant consideration for any planning that relies on a narrow reading of a rule.
What records should a group keep for a foreign financial affiliate?
Keep evidence of the affiliate's regulator and licence in each country, employee headcount and functions, the identity and arm's length status of counterparties, and how capital and governance are provided. The taxpayer bears the burden of establishing the exception, so contemporaneous documentation is critical in an audit or appeal.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


