The General Anti-Avoidance Rule After the 2024 Amendments
The general anti avoidance rule was overhauled for transactions from 1 January 2024: a new preamble, a lower purpose threshold, an economic substance factor, a 25% penalty and a longer reassessment period for undisclosed transactions. This note explains each change, how disclosure works, and how courts approach GAAR after Deans Knight.

Key takeaways
- The 2024 GAAR amendments apply to transactions on or after 1 January 2024.
- An avoidance transaction now exists where tax is "one of the main purposes".
- Significant lack of economic substance tends to indicate misuse or abuse.
- Undisclosed transactions face a 25% penalty and a three-year longer reassessment period.
- Voluntary GAAR disclosure under s. 237.3(12.1) avoids the penalty and extension.
- Deans Knight, 2023 SCC 16, confirmed a functional approach to abuse.
The general anti avoidance rule after 2024: the short answer
The general anti avoidance rule (GAAR) in s. 245 of the Income Tax Act (ITA) was substantially amended in 2024 for transactions entered into on or after 1 January 2024. The amendments added a preamble describing GAAR's purpose, lowered the threshold for an "avoidance transaction" from a transaction undertaken primarily for tax purposes to one where obtaining a tax benefit is "one of the main purposes", made a significant lack of economic substance an important indicator of abuse, introduced a penalty of 25% of the tax benefit unless the transaction was disclosed to the CRA, and extended the reassessment period by three years for undisclosed transactions.
Together with the Supreme Court's decision in Deans Knight in 2023, the changes make GAAR a much more potent tool for the CRA.

The amendments were enacted by S.C. 2024, c. 15, which received royal assent on 20 June 2024. For tax directors and advisers, the practical consequences are a lower bar for the CRA to reach the abuse analysis, greater weight on whether a transaction has real economic effects, and a strong incentive to disclose aggressive transactions voluntarily to avoid the penalty and the extended reassessment period.
The three-step test and what changed
GAAR still applies in three steps, as established in Canada Trustco Mortgage Co. v. Canada, 2005 SCC 54: there must be a tax benefit, an avoidance transaction, and a misuse or abuse of the provisions relied on. The 2024 amendments change each stage in some way.
| Element | Before 2024 | After the 2024 amendments |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose of GAAR | Not stated in the statute | Preamble in s. 245(0.1): GAAR denies tax benefits from transactions that misuse provisions or abuse them read as a whole, while not preventing benefits Parliament contemplated, and balances protection of the tax base with taxpayers' need for certainty |
| Avoidance transaction | Transaction not undertaken "primarily" for bona fide non-tax purposes | Transaction where it cannot reasonably be considered that obtaining the tax benefit is not "one of the main purposes" (s. 245(3)) |
| Tax benefit | Reduction, avoidance or deferral of tax | Expressly includes a reduction, increase or preservation of a tax attribute that could later be relevant (s. 245(1)) |
| Misuse or abuse | Purposive analysis of provisions relied on | Same, plus economic substance: a significant lack of it "tends to indicate" misuse or abuse (s. 245(4.1)-(4.2)) |
| Consequences | Tax benefit denied | Tax benefit denied, plus a 25% penalty for undisclosed transactions (s. 245(5.1)) and a reassessment period extended by three years (s. 152(4)(b)(viii)) |
The "one of the main purposes" threshold
Under the former s. 245(3), a transaction was an avoidance transaction unless it could reasonably be considered to have been undertaken primarily for bona fide purposes other than obtaining the tax benefit. Under the amended rule, a transaction (or a transaction in a series) that results in a tax benefit is an avoidance transaction unless it may reasonably be considered that obtaining the tax benefit is not one of the main purposes for undertaking or arranging it.
A commercially driven transaction structured in a tax-efficient way may now meet the avoidance-transaction test if tax savings were one of its main purposes. The protection for taxpayers lies mainly at the third step: GAAR applies only if the transaction also results in a misuse or abuse. In practice, many disputes under the former rule were won or lost at the second step on evidence of commercial purpose; under the new wording, more cases will turn on the purposive analysis of the provisions relied on, and on the economic substance indicators.
The same "one of the main purposes" language appears in the principal purpose test in Canada's treaties as modified by the Multilateral Instrument. See our note on the principal purpose test.
Series of transactions
The avoidance-transaction test applies to each transaction in a series. Under the case law, a series includes transactions completed in contemplation of the series, before or after it, and the Supreme Court has interpreted that extension broadly. A single step with a non-tax purpose can therefore still be an avoidance transaction if it forms part of a series that produces a tax benefit and obtaining that benefit was one of the main purposes of the step. Tax directors should assume that the CRA will look at the whole arrangement, including later steps that were planned only in general terms when the first transaction occurred.
Economic substance under the general anti avoidance rule
New s. 245(4.1) provides that if an avoidance transaction, or a series that includes it, is significantly lacking in economic substance, that is "an important consideration that tends to indicate" misuse or abuse. Section 245(4.2) lists non-exhaustive indicators:
- all or substantially all of the taxpayer's (and non-arm's-length parties') opportunity for gain or profit and risk of loss remains unchanged, including because of circular flows of funds, offsetting financial positions, the timing between steps or the use of an accommodation party;
- the expected value of the tax benefit exceeded the expected non-tax economic return at the time; and
- the entire, or almost entire, purpose of the transaction or series was to obtain the tax benefit.
Economic substance is not a separate test, and a transaction lacking economic substance is not automatically abusive. But it shifts the practical burden. Taxpayers relying on transactions with circular funds, short-lived steps or accommodation parties should expect the CRA to rely on s. 245(4.1), and should be ready to show why the provisions relied on contemplate the result regardless of economic effect.
The 25% penalty, disclosure and extended reassessment
Where GAAR applies to a transaction that was not disclosed under s. 237.3 (reportable transactions) or s. 237.4 (notifiable transactions), the taxpayer is liable to a penalty equal to 25% of the tax benefit, broadly the additional tax and reduced refundable credits, less any gross negligence penalty already imposed for the same transaction (s. 245(5.1)). The penalty does not apply if the taxpayer shows it was reasonable to conclude that GAAR would not apply because the transaction was identical or almost identical to one addressed in published administrative guidance or court decisions (s. 245(5.2)).
Section 237.3(12.1) allows a taxpayer to file a voluntary GAAR disclosure for a transaction that is not otherwise reportable. A disclosure made by the reportable-transaction deadline avoids both the penalty and the three-year extension of the reassessment period. A late disclosure, up to one year after the deadline, avoids the penalty and reduces the extension to one year (s. 237.3(12.2)). For significant planning, a deliberate decision on whether to disclose is now part of the transaction checklist. See our note on mandatory disclosure rules.
Decide on GAAR disclosure when the transaction is planned, not at audit. Weigh the 25% penalty and the three-year extension against the cost of drawing CRA attention. For well-supported transactions with real economic effects, disclosure can be a low-cost insurance policy. Record the decision and the reasons in the transaction file.
How courts apply GAAR after Deans Knight
In Deans Knight Income Corp. v. Canada, 2023 SCC 16, decided on 26 May 2023, the Supreme Court applied GAAR to deny the use of non-capital losses after a transaction designed to avoid the acquisition-of-control restriction in s. 111(5) without technically triggering it. The Court held that the object, spirit and purpose of s. 111(5) is to prevent corporations from being acquired by unrelated parties in order to deduct unused losses against income from another business, and that the transactions achieved functionally what the provision was meant to prevent.
The decision confirmed that the abuse analysis looks at a provision's rationale, can consider the outcome functionally rather than formally, and does not require a gap in the provision to be filled by express words.
By contrast, in Canada v. Alta Energy Luxembourg S.A.R.L., 2021 SCC 49, the Court declined to apply GAAR to treaty shopping under the Canada-Luxembourg treaty, finding that the treaty did not require substantive economic connections to the residence state. The amended GAAR now refers expressly to tax treaties as provisions that can be misused (s. 245(4)(a)(iv)), and the principal purpose test in the Multilateral Instrument applies to many treaties, so the result in Alta Energy is less likely to be repeated. See our notes on Deans Knight and Alta Energy.
Decisions applying the amended s. 245 to post-2023 transactions will take several years to reach the courts, because reassessments, objections and Tax Court appeals typically take years to resolve. In the meantime, the CRA's GAAR committee continues to review proposed assessments, and taxpayers should expect it to rely on both the preamble and the economic substance provisions.
Planning under the amended general anti avoidance rule
The amended general anti avoidance rule does not prohibit tax planning, and the preamble expressly preserves tax benefits that Parliament contemplated. What it does is raise the cost of being wrong. Practical steps for groups and advisers include:
- Identify the provisions relied on. For each step that produces a tax benefit, state which provision provides it and why the result is consistent with its object, spirit and purpose.
- Test economic substance. Ask whether the taxpayer's risk of loss and opportunity for gain actually change, whether funds move in a circle, and whether any party is an accommodation party.
- Record non-tax purposes. Contemporaneous board papers, financing documents and business plans are the best evidence of commercial purpose, even under the lower threshold.
- Consider disclosure. Decide whether to make a reportable, notifiable or voluntary GAAR disclosure, and diarize the 90-day deadline.
- Check specific anti-avoidance rules. Many outcomes are now governed by targeted rules, such as the hybrid mismatch, EIFEL and acquisition-of-control provisions, and the CRA may plead GAAR in the alternative.
Which transactions are most exposed
Based on the statute and recent case law, the general anti avoidance rule is most likely to be raised against loss-trading and attribute-preservation structures, surplus stripping, circular or self-cancelling financing, treaty shopping, and transactions that rely on technical gaps in rules designed to prevent the very outcome achieved. Ordinary reorganizations, estate freezes and acquisition structures that use provisions as intended remain available, but the file should show why.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise corporations, private groups and investors on the general anti avoidance rule as amended in 2024. We review planning for avoidance-transaction and economic-substance risk, advise on reportable and notifiable transaction filings and voluntary GAAR disclosures, assess penalty and reassessment-period exposure, and respond to GAAR proposals and assessments. We work with our corporate and international tax and tax disputes teams. This note is general information, not legal advice. To review a transaction, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
When did the GAAR amendments take effect?
The amendments to s. 245 were enacted by S.C. 2024, c. 15, which received royal assent on 20 June 2024. They generally apply to transactions that occur on or after 1 January 2024.
What is the GAAR penalty?
If GAAR applies to a transaction that was not disclosed under s. 237.3 or 237.4, the taxpayer is liable to a penalty of 25% of the tax benefit, reduced by any gross negligence penalty for the same transaction. The penalty does not apply where reliance on published guidance or case law about an identical or almost identical transaction made it reasonable to conclude GAAR would not apply.
Does a lack of economic substance mean GAAR applies?
Not automatically. Under s. 245(4.1), a significant lack of economic substance is an important consideration that tends to indicate misuse or abuse, but the CRA must still show abuse of the provisions relied on. The statute lists indicators such as unchanged risk of loss and circular flows of funds.
How can taxpayers avoid the extended reassessment period?
By disclosing the transaction to the CRA on time, either because it is a reportable or notifiable transaction or through the voluntary GAAR disclosure in s. 237.3(12.1). A disclosure filed up to one year late still avoids the penalty and limits the extension to one year.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


